Sustainable Renovation Comfort Inn Boston / Logan Airport
Presentation Overview Team Project Goals Obstacles Outcome
Team Group One Partners, Incorporated Harry Wheeler, Mary Faria, Carrie Nielsen USGBC corporate member Architecture / Design / Purchasing Group One Partners, Inc. Saunders Hotel Group Long term hospitality owner Family organization High interest in sustainability EcoLogical Solutions, Inc. Provide the most cost effective and innovative environmental solutions for hotels Callahan Construction Full service construction firm Specializes in construction management and preconstruction
Property Overview Built in 2000 High rise construction block and plank Site was a Brownfield site requiring remediation Close to public transportation Originally built with sustainable initiatives High efficiency heat pumps Motion sensors and door switched for t-stats Fluorescent lighting Low e insulated windows Light colored roofing Low flow plumbing fixtures Ozone system for laundry HVACs central control system tied into hotel PMS system
Renovation Scope-BEFORE pics Renovate guest rooms and bathrooms Create an upscale feel and environment Be sensitive to environmental issues Utilize sustainable materials Design is the primary focus Sustainability is a key factor
Design Process Update and Refresh with sustainable materials in mind Modernize with the use of spa like bathroom features and color scheme Working with a team to achieve the design vision Keep Recycled content in mind
Team approach How we determined the priority items to be replaced (i.e. casegoods, lighting, bedding, etc) with hotel staff and ownership G1 provided a base budget for this scope based on FF&E and construction costs Team identified items that should specifically be targeted for sustainability Team was held by designer to dates to maintain schedule
Decision process Clear that we would not be able to evaluate all design aspects in a very simple format G1P developed design / sustainability matrix It was key to involve hotel, ownership, Procurement Company and Contractor in the decision process which was led by the design team Some design aspects that were reviewed Low VOC Minimizing waste and reusing existing materials in new ways (mirrors) Recycled content in carpet (put in elevators to test durability) Worked with local manufacturer to reuse existing plumbing valves Fluorescent decorative lighting (formerly incandescent lamps) Longevity and durability of materials
Mock up Three(3) mock up rooms were developed ranging from the least invasive (lowest cost) to the most invasive (higher cost) Each of these options had different aspects of green design that needed to be acknowledged The team met on site several occasions to evaluate the mock-ups At the end it was a blending of pieces of each room that won out for the best overall comprehensive design, green and budget. From this point the final specs were compiled and documents were completed
Implementation Group One Partners, Inc. Purchasing Final buyout bidding about 16 weeks Delivery was sent to a warehouse for processing Removal of existing furniture pieces (liquidation) Programs to send FF&E for reuse. Installation Shipping of goods to minimize trucking Recycling of all boxes and materials Construction Noise / dust control was maintained by GC Carpet recycling program was handled by GC General construction recycling program by the GC Protection of HVAC equipment was maintained by GC Caulking materials were all low VOC Adhesives and ventilation Delivery of completed rooms back to the hotel Expediting punch list Limited rooms out of commission Limited and controlled disruption
Obstacles Time and Budget evaluating the benefits of the product with regards to lead time availability and value Sustainable fabrics Limited designs and patterns Availability and cost CAL 133 Fire Code Requirements Further restricting design options due to fire rating Construction Noise and access within the operating property Maintaining schedule and room turnover back to hotel
Outcome New fresh upgrade interior Clean spa like finishes in the guest baths Upheld the sustainability standards of the client Provided new opportunities for green initiatives Met and or exceeded client expectations Maintained project budget and schedule
Additional hotel programs and the future Currently planning lobby and public space renovation that will have the same goals for sustainability Post renovation Enhanced weekly Preventative Maintenance visits In room recycling Ongoing initiatives - http://www.comfortinnboston.com/environmentalleadership.htm Saunders Hotel Group Green team Eco Checks Employee fun facts Xeriscape landscaping Paperless audits
Summary Design has to be approached in a different manner Having the contractor and procurement group on board early on is crucial to maintain schedule and budget To truly be successful in any renovation project, especially one based on sustainability a team approach is critical.
Thank you for your time Group One Partners, Incorporated Architecture Interior Design Purchasing