The Tenth National HIPAA Summit Baltimore, Maryland April 6-8, 2005 Streamlining New Jersey Hospital Inpatient/Outpatient Data Reporting Using EDI and HIPAA Standards Mark S. Gordon Senior Fellow/Director of Healthcare Information Networks & Technologies (HINT) Thomas Edison State College 609-777-4351, ext. 4275 mgordon@tesc.edu 1
Data Intermediary Project Team New Jersey Department of Health and Senior Services (NJDHSS) Initiates a major re-engineering project to improve the data intermediary reporting system by using current technology to reduce costs and improve the accuracy, timeliness and accessibility of hospital data. Thomas Edison State College Project Administrator - Assisted in development of and issued RFP for Data intermediary. On behalf of NJDHSS, award and monitor contracts for Deloitte Consulting and QuadraMed Corporation. Deloitte Consulting Professional consultant and technical assistance for RFP and QuadraMed Corporation design and implementation of new data intermediary system. QuadraMed Corporation Based on a public bid, vendor selected to design, implement and maintain new data intermediary system. 2
Background Medical Incident Data System (MIDS) had collected inpatient discharge data information from acute care hospitals by New Jersey Department of Health and Senior Services (NJDHSS) since the early-1980 s. Horizon Blue Cross/Blue Shield of New Jersey, as the MIDS data intermediary, collected 1.5 million inpatient and same-day surgery discharge data information annually on behalf of NJDHSS. The Data Intermediary Project is an outgrowth of the Health Information Networks & Technologies (HINT) study requested by the State Legislature and the Governor to reduce healthcare administrative costs in the state. The HINT study was a collaborative effort between Thomas Edison State College (TESC) and New Jersey Institute of Technology (NJIT). The HINT study found that EDI technology and national healthcare transmission standards could achieve $760 million in annual cost savings to New Jersey. 3
Background (cont d) HINT study recommended several pilot projects and legislation to implement the HINT goals. The Data Intermediary Project, formally referred to as the New Jersey Discharge Data Collection System (NJDDCS), is one of those projects. Thomas Edison State College as Project Administrator, on behalf of NJDHSS, issued a public request for proposal, (RFP) to streamline the current inpatient discharge data processing system. QuadraMed awarded contract. In addition, New Jersey enacted the HINT Law on July 1, 1999 (Chapter 154, Public Law of 1999). This law promotes the use of EDI technology and national healthcare standards, to achieve administrative simplification and cost efficiencies for the public and private sectors in New Jersey. 4
HINT Study Findings Annual Healthcare Expenditure Costs & Claims Processed National New Jersey Total Costs $1 Trillion $30 Billion Administrative Costs $183 Billion $ 5 Billion Claims Processed 4.6 Billion 150 Million 5
HINT Study Findings (cont d) Annual administrative cost savings using electronic data interchange (EDI) and national healthcare transmission standards. EDI Claims Processing Reducing Claims rejection with EDI Verification of Insurance with EDI Decreasing Accounts Receivable with EDI Other EDI Applications $267.0 Million $ 23.6 Million $ 7.0 Million $102.0 Million $360.4 Million TOTAL SAVINGS WITH EDI $760.0 MILLION 6
NJDHSS Specific Project Goals Overall simplification of the current Medical Incident Data System (MIDS) Use existing EDI claims processing and telecommunications technologies using national standards to collect hospital inpatient data Significantly reduce the per record hospital transaction cost Provide annual savings for hospitals over the current system Improve the timeliness, accuracy, and availability of the hospital data Improve completeness of data by starting to collect outpatient information in the next couple of years 7
NJDHSS Major Objectives Daily submission by hospital of patient discharge data vs. monthly submissions Utilize an electronic process consistent with claims submission to Medicare and other payers Engage the data intermediary vendor as the NJDHSS agent in an electronic commerce transaction. NJDHSS is the same as a payer, except DHSS does not make payments on the billing information. Enhance the hospital s ability to submit a clean UB-92 ANSI 837 format to DHSS, resulting in the hospital to comply with the HIPAA claim transaction requirements. Significantly reduce the $1.26 per transaction record cost to the hospital. Issue the ANSI 837 implementation guide addendum. 8
Data Intermediary Project Benefits Collect on a daily basis health care inpatient discharge data on 1.5 million patients treated in New Jersey hospitals, and to yield accurate, up-to-date and comprehensive data. Expand data collection to include outpatient data on an additional 14.5 million patients annually. Expected to save the hospital industry millions of dollars. Based on QuadraMed bid, the hospital transaction costs alone will decrease by 60%. New system provides hospital with up-front edits and electronic submissions to the data intermediary on a daily basis, versus current monthly mailed tape. Use 128-bit encryption for data transmissions over the Internet which meet the HIPAA security requirement. Uses ANSI X12N - 837 Version 4010i format required by HIPAA. 9
Current MIDS process NJ DHSS/QuadraMed process The hospital s MIDS coordinator edits the records based on the turn around documents and the process repeats until all records are deemed clean. The host system creates a monthly tape for submission to Blue Cross (by mail) Tape The host system creates a daily file and downloads it to a network server accessible by the QEDI data collection pc An edit template is applied to the daily file at the hospital by the QEDI software to indicate claims in error. These claims are corrected in a timely fashion ANSI 837 format Blue Cross applies edits to the data and produces turn around documents highlighting claims in error. Blue Cross Turn around document Only clean claims are transmitted to the QuadraMed Claims Network Center (via Internet or analog transmission). QuadraMed accepts the clean claims and makes them available for reporting over the Internet to both NJDHSS and hospitals Clean Claims Internet QuadraMed Claims Network Center 10
Current MIDS process NJ DHSS/QuadraMed process Blue Cross then sends tape by mail to NJ DHSS. NJ DHSS sends tape to NJ State Office of Information and Technology(OIT). OIT processes tape and then generates error report and tape. Tape The host system creates a daily file and downloads it to a network server accessible by the QEDI data collection pc An edit template is applied to the daily file at the hospital by the QEDI software to indicate claims in error. These claims are corrected in a timely fashion ANSI 837 format OIT sends error report and tape to Blue Cross for hospital corrections. Hospital corrections sent to Blue Cross and forwarded to DHSS. Blue Cross Only clean claims are transmitted to the QuadraMed Claims Network Center (via Internet or analog transmission). Clean Claims Internet Turn around document QuadraMed accepts the clean claims and makes them available for reporting over the Internet to both DHSS and hospitals. QuadraMed Claims Network Center 11
NJ DHSS/QuadraMed process The host system creates a daily file and downloads it to a network server accessible by the QEDI data collection pc An edit template is applied to the daily file at the hospital by the QEDI software to indicate claims in error. These claims are corrected in a timely fashion ANSI 837 format Uses HIPPA transaction standard 837 version 4010i Online upfront edit Only clean claims are transmitted to the QuadraMed Claims Network Center (via Internet or analog transmission). QuadraMed accepts the clean claims and makes them available for reporting over the Internet Clean Claims Internet Eliminates need for turn around documents Utilizes Internet technology for data transmissions and access using 128 bit encryption. Meets HIPAA security standard QuadraMed Claims Network Center 12
NJDHSS Pilot Evaluation Process A post implementation report was prepared by the NJDHSS project team. The success of the pilot was measured in 4 specific areas (1) System Evaluation (2) Cost (3) Process Improvement (4) Customer Satisfaction 13
NJ Regulations for Collection of UB-92 Data Description Reporting requirement to submit a final bill to the data intermediary Existing 30 days after discharge Same New NJDDCS Hospital data submission to the data intermediary Time limit for hospitals to correct edit rejects from data intermediary Time limit for data intermediary to submit to DHSS Notification of database closure Earliest database can be closed Penalty for records submitted after database closure Various weekly, monthly 5 working days Within 90 days of end of quarter for all discharges during quarter 30 days notice of intent to close database must be provided by DHSS Within 90 days after calendar year end $10.00 per record Daily discharge billed previous day 2 working days 5 days after end of month for all patients billed previous month Same No sooner than 90 days after calendar year end $1.00 per record per day 14
Summary of NJDDCS and MIDS System Comparisons NJDDCS Modified UB and 837 4010i file formats for data streams (industry standards) Edit report available daily at the client desktop User friendly, PC based editing software using latest EDI software. Data transmitted via Internet or direct dial. Data available to the hospital within 24-48 hours of transmission. Data available to the State within 24-48 hours of transmission. $0.50 per record cost for submission. MIDS Proprietary MIDS file format. Edits only available on turnaround documents sent via US Mail after data submissions. Mainframe terminal based editing software. Data sent on mainframe tapes and cartridges via US Mail. Data available one week or more after submission Data available to the State 90 days after Quarter ends. $1.26 per record cost for submission. Data is available to hospitals on 3480 cartridges, CD-ROM, and for free via Internet. Data is available only on mainframe tapes or cartridges. 15
Expand System To Collect Outpatient Data The RFP called for NJDHSS to start collecting outpatient data which is estimated to be 80-90% of the encounter data in New Jersey, after the in-patient pilot is deemed a success. NJDHSS created an outpatient industry workgroup to discuss the outpatient data to be collected. The variables would be a subset of the inpatient data. The emergency department is the first outpatient area of collection. In March 2002, outpatient system design approved. An outpatient pilot program with 5 hospitals participating was completed February 2003 prior to full State roll-out in January 2004. 16
Emergency Room Data Collection NJDHSS received approval October 2003 to expand data collection to include emergency department (ED) electronic data collection. Emergency Room Data Collection expanded to include identification of potential bioterrorism cases. Phase I included generation of automatic nightly email for notification to the DHSS based on identification of specific codes in the patient data. Phase II included a data base query tool which includes access to all cases rather than specific diagnoses. Reporting accomplished through an automated secure file transfer protocol (FTP) connection during Summer 2004. ED outpatient data collection more than doubles the amount of inpatient data collected by DHSS (2.4 million ED vs. 1.5 million inpatient). 17
Data Intermediary Project Summary Five pilot hospitals participated. All reported process and system improvements along with reduced costs. State data intermediary regulation changes proposed on March 16, 2000; regulations approved by State Health Board Advisory Council on July 20, 2000. Regulations adopted on August 21, 2000 in New Jersey Register. Roll-out includes pre-implementation meeting; file certification; user training; installation; and data transmission. New NJDDCS is installed at all 89 NJ acute care hospitals; complete installation by 6/31/01. Project is meeting HIPAA requirements; also on time and within budget. 18
Data Intermediary Project Summary (cont d.) Achieved major objectives of the data intermediary project: Use EDI to daily transmit hospital data w/upfront edit Eliminate turnaround documents Accurate, timely, and accessible hospital data via Internet Closeout NJDHSS calendar year end hospital data base within 5 months instead of current 12-18 months Hospital transmission costs reduced 60% to $0.50, savings of $1.5 million annually In January 2000 first state project in the nation to have ANSI X12N-837 version 4010i, a HIPAA standard, certified as compliant by the Electronic Health Network Accreditation Commission (EHNAC) 19
Biography Mark S. Gordon Mark S. Gordon, Senior Fellow/Director of Healthcare Information Networks & Technologies (HINT) at Thomas Edison State College (Trenton, NJ), is the College s team leader for the Healthcare Information Networks and Technologies (HINT) study and implementation efforts. Under his leadership, the first statewide healthcare survey in the nation was conducted on the use of current information technologies, associated costs, and barriers to the use of information technology. Based on the HINT study recommendations, New Jersey legislation has been signed into law [P.L. 1999, Chapter 154] on July 1, 1999 to promote healthcare EDI and administrative simplification using HIPAA standards. Mark has over twenty years of senior level public sector experience and has served on various boards, commissions, and workgroups at the local, state and national levels. The New Jersey HINT Study is available by sending a $30 check payable to Thomas Edison State College to the address on PowerPoint title page. 20