Simultaneous integration of urban heat island mitigation technologies in the existing urban fabric in Athens, Greece

Similar documents
Influence of Urban Morphology on Outdoor Thermal Comfort in Summer: A Study in Tunis, Tunisia

Watts in a comfort index:

Passive Cooling Design Options to Improve Thermal Comfort in an Urban District of Rome, Under Hot Summer Conditions

Assessment of Thermal Comfort in Respect to Building Height in a High-Density City in the Tropics

Urban Climate. Prof. Dr. Lutz Katzschner Environmental Meteorology Department Faculty of Architecture and Planning University Kassel / Germany

The influence of the surrounding environment on the building s energy performance

Human thermal comfort below the canopy of street trees on a typical Central European summer day

Urban microclimate and thermal comfort evaluation

Trees Configuration Model for Hot Humid Tropic Urban Parks

SPATIAL URBAN CLIMATE AND URBAN PLANNING UNDER CONSIDERATION OF GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGE. Prof. Dr. Lutz Katzschner University Kassel Germany

Bioclimatic approaches of modern residential architecture in Cyprus,

Cool spots in hot climates: a means to achieve pedestrian comfort in hot climates

Thermal Comfort in Architecture

Volume 8, ISSN (Online), Published at:

Street Design and Urban Microclimate: Analyzing the Effects of Street Geometry and Orientation on Airflow and Solar Access in Urban Canyons

Impact of Vegetation on Urban Microclimates

Validation of ENVI-met PMV values by in-situ measurements

Workshop: Architecture-Tradition and Modernization. Climate Responsive Urban Design

Assessing The Microclimate of Green and Less-Green Tropical Landscape Environment

Towards green design guidelines for thermally comfortable streets

Microclimate Effects of Urban Geometry on Outdoor Thermal Comfort in the Brazilian Tropical Semi-arid Climate

Activity report Simulation survey (Villaggio Artigiano)

Impact of increasing the depth of urban street canyons on building heating and cooling loads in Tel Aviv, Israel

ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION

Adaptive Thermal Comfort in Warm Dry Climate: Economical dwellings in Mexico

Using passive solutions to improve thermal summer comfort in timber framed houses in South-west France

Outdoor Thermal Comfort in the Hot Arid Climate The effect of socio-economic background and cultural differences

Case Study: Bio-Climatic Building Design for Tropical Climates

Environmental Impacts of Urban Heat Islands and their Countermeasures - Experiences of Japanese dense cities-

Thermal comfort and psychological adaptation as a guide for designing urban spaces

Designing Air-Distribution Systems To Maximize Comfort

BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOT AND HUMID CLIMATES IMPLICATIONS ON THERMAL COMFORT AND ENERGY EFFICIENCY. Dr Mirek Piechowski 1, Adrian Rowe 1

Optimizing Indoor Environments for Occupant Satisfaction. Presented by: Kelli Goldstone April 2016

Influence of trees on the air temperature in outdoor spaces according to planting parameters: the case of the city of Aix-en-Provence in France

Heating, Cooling, Lighting: Sustainable Design Methods for Architects

SUSTAINABLE BY PASSIVE ARCHITECTURE, USING COURTYARDS IN NON-DOMESTIC BUILDINGS IN SOUTHEAST QUEENSLAND

Mitigating and adapting thermal stress with urban green - Quantification with measurements and micro scale models. Andreas Matzarakis

POST OCCUPANCY DESIGN INERVENTION TO IMPROVE COMFORT AND ENERGY PERFORMANCE IN A DESERT HOUSE

Modelling Analysis of Thermal Performance of Internal Shading Devices for a Commercial Atrium Building in Tropical Climates

DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONS FOR NEW COURTYARD BUILDINGS

ENERGY AND THERMAL COMFORT EVALUATION FOR DIFFERENT PASSIVE SOLUTIONS IN A KINDERGARTEN IN SUMMER CONDITIONS.

Macro and Micro Climate Climate

ScienceDirect. Influence of the balcony glazing construction on thermal comfort of apartments in retrofitted large panel buildings

PALM TREE RESIDENTIAL AREA / Hanoi, Vietnam

Vegetation effects on urban street microclimate and thermal comfort during overheated period under hot and dry climatic conditions

A Field Study of the Thermal Environment in Residential Buildings in Harbin

Advances in building energy simulation tools and integration of microclimate issues

Energy and Thermal Comfort Management in a Kindergarten School Building in the South of Portugal in Winter Conditions

! #! %%%%&%%% &( &% )) + # +,% #.!. # 0! 1 2! ,%,% 0 # 0! 1 2! ,4&,) 5,%

Whole Building Energy Analysis using BIM

The Effects of Set-Points and Dead-Bands of the HVAC System on the Energy Consumption and Occupant Thermal Comfort

OPERATION AND CONTROL OF THERMALLY ACTIVATED SLAB HEATING AND COOLING SYSTEMS

MODELLING THE URBAN MICROCLIMATE AND ITS INFLUENCE ON BUILDING ENERGY DEMANDS OF AN URBAN NEIGHBOURHOOD

Effect of Rotation Speed of a Rotary Thermal Wheel on Ventilation Supply Rates of Wind Tower System

Integrated BIPV performance assessment for tropical regions: a case study for Bangalore

Natural Ventilation Approached on Circular Courtyard Building in Hot Humid Climate

Work Package 2: Performance of naturally ventilated buildings

Thermal Comfort Evaluation of HDB flats

External Environment and Indoor Microclimate

IMPLICATIONS OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND OCCUPANT BEHAVIOUR ON FUTURE ENERGY DEMAND IN A ZERO CARBON HOUSE

A STUDY ON THE COOLING EFFECTS OF GREENING FOR IMPROVING THE OUTDOOR THERMAL ENVIRONMENT IN PENANG, MALAYSIA

Available online at ScienceDirect. Energy Procedia 78 (2015 )

Bio-climatic Chart for Different Climatic Zones of Northeast India

Local Climate Change and Urban Mitigation Techniques to Counterbalance it. Mat Santamouris

Building and Environment

Work environment. Microclimate - definition. Main microclimate elements. Core temperature. Microclimate

Building Groups Design Strategies in Hot-humid Climate: A Dense Residential Planning in Bandung, Indonesia

Field investigation on indoor thermal environment of a high-rise condominium in hot-humid climate of Bangkok, Thailand

The utilization of first derivatives and violinplots of meteorological parameters for the evaluation of thermal behavior of small urban sites.

681: Environmentally Responsive Architecture; Passive Design for School in Southern India

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF CAR COCKPIT HEATING DURING WINTER 1

Performance-Risk Methodology for the Design of High-Performance Affordable Homes

Optimization of air tightness and night ventilation for Passive houses in Italian climates under Fanger and Adaptive comfort models

Adapting Cities to Climate Change Scenarios for the City of Essen J. Alexander Schmidt University Duisburg-Essen Germany

Healthy Buildings 2017 Europe July 2-5, 2017, Lublin, Poland. Research on indoor thermal environment of stilted buildings in Chongqing, China

Design Strategies and Guide lines for Tropical Coast of Pakistan, Using Climate Consultant

Passive Cooling Strategies in Greening Existing Residential Building in Hot Dry Climate: Case Study in Bahrain

Assessment of shading devices with integrated PV for efficient energy use

HEAT LOSS REDUCTION OF ENERGY-EFFICIENT HOME BY BUFFER AREAS. Alexander Dvoretsky, KseniaKlevets

Available online at ScienceDirect. Procedia Engineering 121 (2015 )

Great Ocean Rd Ice Creamery

Available online at ScienceDirect. Procedia Engineering 145 (2016 ) 18 25

4.2 PHYSIOLOGICALLY EQUIVALENT TEMPERATURE AND CLIMATE CHANGE IN FREIBURG

Stage 6 & 7 Design Guidelines

EXPLORING THE IMPLICATIONS OF VARIANCE IN URBAN MICROCLIMATE FOR BUILDINGS ENERGY PERFORMANCE: A SIMULATION BASED APPROACH

GREEK TRADITIONAL BIOCLIMATIC ARCHITECTURE

ASSESSMENT OF AIR CHANGE RATE AND CONTRIBUTION RATIO IN IDEALIZED URBAN CANOPY LAYERS BY TRACER GAS SIMULATIONS

Designing carbon neutral schools: The Victor Miller Building, a critical review

Central Arizona-Phoenix Long-Term Ecological Research Project

Bioclimatic Design Approach Integration into Architectural Design: a Library Case Study

OFFICE DE CONSULTATION PUBLIQUE DE MONTRÉAL

Daylight, Solar Gains and Overheating Studies in a Glazed Office Building

Investigation of a Solar active glass facade

The Urban Environment and Climate Change

Available online at ScienceDirect. Energy Procedia 78 (2015 )

Thermal Characteristics and Energy Performance of Double Skin. Façade System in the Hot Summer and Cold Winter Zone

IMPACT OF COLUMNS AND BEAMS ON THE THERMAL RESISTANCE OF THE BUILDING ENVELOPE

125BEPM - Building energy performance modeling. Lecture handouts

Use of a mobile platform for assessing urban heat stress in Rotterdam

Transcription:

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258093327 Simultaneous integration of urban heat island mitigation technologies in the existing urban fabric in Athens, Greece Conference Paper September 2013 CITATIONS 0 READS 59 2 authors, including: Stelios C. Zerefos Hellenic Open University 39 PUBLICATIONS 346 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects: Human-centric Lighting View project Methodology for the Lighting Design of Historical Buildings View project All content following this page was uploaded by Stelios C. Zerefos on 31 October 2015. The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

SIMULTANEOUS INTEGRATION OF URBAN HEAT ISLAND MITIGATION TECHNOLOGIES IN THE EXISTING URBAN FABRIC OF ATHENS, GREECE Elli A. Calokerinou, Stylianos C. Zerefos* Hellenic Open University School of Applied Arts Parodos Aristotelous 18, 26 335, Patra, Greece *Corresponding author email: zerefos@eap.gr tel.: +30 6974 964979 ABSTRACT This research studies the possibility of introducing combinations of specific mitigation techniques for the urban heat island effect (UHI) in Athens, Greece. Advanced mitigation techniques have been applied in many urban rehabilitation projects around the globe and have succeeded in improving the local microclimate. However, each mitigation measure is often being implemented as an individual element. The focus of this study is to define their relationship and the actual feasibility for their simultaneous integration into the urban environment. To this end this study proposes the development of a methodology for the optimal simultaneous architectural integration of high performance UHI mitigation technologies. The methodology can be applied at city block or neighbourhood level and is based on the geometric characteristics and the orientation of the site, but also on the microclimatic conditions of the site. In order to achieve this, a small typical neighbourhood in Athens, typical in terms of orientation, building height, road width etc., is analysed as a case study. After recording each feature that describes the urban cityscape, the study presents feedback, regarding the feasibility for the integration of UHI mitigation technologies. Finally, the study presents how the above mentioned factors reduce air temperature at street level, affect the UHI and provide good air quality at the neighbourhood scale, whereas at the same time analyse possible problems or merits for their simultaneous integration. KEYWORDS Urban heat island, Mitigation Techniques, Thermal comfort, Urban microclimate, Advanced materials 1 INTRODUCTION Rapidly developed urban areas, such as Athens, Greece, have a major negative impact on the outdoor environment. Urban geometry is a major factor in the urban heat island effect (UHI), as it affects airflow and mean radiant temperatures (Oke 1987, Golden 2004). Past research has focused on distinct environmental problems, such as high temperatures, wind distribution and speed in urban canyons (Oke, 1988). There are various physical and climatic factors that affect human thermal comfort in different scales, thus there is a strong need for interdisciplinary work between urban climatology, urban design and architecture (Ali- Toudert, 2005). Mitigation techniques can contribute highly to improve the urban thermal environment and to decrease urban air temperatures. Advanced mitigation techniques have been applied quite recently in many urban rehabilitation projects around the globe (Ito et al, 2004, Slosberg

et al, 2006) and have succeeded in improving the local microclimate significantly. However, each mitigation measure is often being implemented in its own as a unique individual element. The focus of this research is to study their relationship and the feasibility of their simultaneous integration into the urban environment. This research studies the possibility of introducing combinations of specific mitigation techniques for the urban heat island effect (UHI) in Athens, Greece. A variety of factors, such as surface cover, traffic density, anthropogenic heat release and urban characteristics including geographic features and climate conditions, interact with each other to create UHI, which is becoming increasingly evident also due to the changing climate. In the region that we investigate in this work, man made climate change is expected to increase the duration of hot spells and the frequency of heat waves, thus making the mitigation of the UHI a necessity (Climate Change Impacts Study Committee, 2011). The study focuses on urban architectural dynamics and the development of a methodology for the optimal simultaneous integration of high performance heat-island mitigation technologies in the urban fabric. 2 LITERATURE REVIEW One of the great challenges for cities is the mitigation of the urban heat island effect (UHI). In the past years, interesting research has been presented, recognizing the root of the problem and the effects of the UHI on the urban environment (Golden, 2004, Kartalis, 1999). The strong relationship between air pollution, anthropogenic heat, urban geometry, urban fabric and UHI density has been analyzed, introducing ways to mitigate the UHI without altering city planning (Che-Ani, 2009, Yamamoto, 2006). The most important formative elements on the urban environment are buildings. Buildings surround urban open spaces, creating urban canyons with high temperatures. Temperature is associated with the UHI, which in turn increases the intensity of heat waves, that often expose humans to extreme thermal conditions within their cities (Tan et al. 2009). There is a strong interest on the quality of open urban spaces and the relationship with various physical and climatic factors, such as surface temperatures, irradiation of canyon surfaces and wind flow at street level, decisive features that affect the microclimate of a neighbourhood. The height-to-width (H/W) ratio and street orientation were found to be the most important factors affecting thermal comfort at street level (Ali-Toudert F., 2005). Surface materials were also found to affect the thermal behaviour of an urban canyon (Ali-Toudert F., 2005). However, the number of interdisciplinary studies is limited (Pearlmutter et al, 1999). The variation of the urban spaces can generate significant modifications of microclimatic parameters. Those modifications can have an influence on thermal comfort at street level. Thermal comfort can be described as that condition of mind that expresses satisfaction with the thermal environment (ASHRAE, 2010). Thermal sensation has been defined as the Actual Sensation Vote (ASV) (Nikolopoulou et al, 2003). Based on the ASV developed by the RUROS project (Nikolopoulou, 2004), ASV=0.034Tair_met +0.0001Sol_met 0.086V_met 0.001RH_met 0.412 (r=0.27), (1)

there is an indication concerning the contribution of wind and temperature data. Analysing the data, it has been possible to examine correlations between microclimatic parameters and the ASV. Through RUROS, it is becoming clear that a purely physiological approach is inadequate to characterise thermal comfort conditions outdoors. ASV has an inverse relation to wind speed. For example a case study area in Athens - which we will focus on section 4 of this paper - during the summer period, records typical values of Tair_met=33 o C, Sol_met=1000W/m², V_met=1m/s and RH_met=30%. This provides us with the result ASV=0.60, in between the comfortable categories -1=ASV=+1 (varying from «very cold» at - 1 to «very hot» at 1). Lack of shading has a -14% impact on this value (Nikolopoulou, 2004). The ASV is relevant only to particular meteorological factors. Figure 1: PMV calculation, (PMV calculation programme. Håkan Nilsson (2005), Department of Technology and Built Environment, Laboratory of ventilation and air quality, University of Gavle) www.atecyr.org/ Accordingly, many studies have been carried out to reveal the relationships between human thermal comfort sensation and physical environment variables in order to meet the needs of these people (Kim, 2010). Fanger (1970) produced the Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) for assessing the thermal comfort. According to Kwon (2009), the PMV is an index which predicts the thermal sensation of people based on a seven point scale (+3 hot, +2 warm, +1 slightly warm, 0 neutral, -1 slightly cool, -2 cool, -3 cold) considering the comfort zone to be -0.50=PMV=+0.50. The subjective data collected from interviews on the field of the case study can be compared with the thermal index PMV which is another method of predicting thermal comfort that takes into account the mean objective environmental parameters recorded for the duration of an interview, clothing levels and metabolic rate, using the ASHRAE thermal sensation scale. Figure 1, shows an empirical relationship between the percentage of dissatisfied people (PPD) with a thermal environment as a function of PMV (Brandemuehl, 2005). PPD=100-95*exp(-0.03353*PMV 4-0.2179PMV 2 ) (2) Comparing the PMV with the corresponding ASV, a great discrepancy was revealed between the two sets of data for the same area in Athens. The PMV was calculated above +3 (hot) for over 90% of dissatisfied people (LTPEP, 2013), when the ASV fell within comfortable limits. Therefore, we conclude to the assumption that the prediction of human thermal comfort on the outdoor environment requires a combined model.

3 METHODOLOGY The outdoor environment is hard to quantify as it includes a multitude of factors that affect thermal comfort at pedestrian level. Critical factors for outdoor comfort include air temperature, relative humidity, air movement and mean radiant temperature. Furthermore, there are numerous unquantifiable factors affecting outdoor comfort, such as the critical importance of urban geometry, vegetation and shading. Therefore, there is a need for a quantitative assessment method for assessing the effects of climate on the urban environment and a proper implementation tool that will guide urban designers to evaluate and propose coordinated UHI mitigation techniques. Architectural and urban design process is itself very complicated. During the design process, there are some problems that architects face and for designing a successful and adaptive model it is best to be aware of all the different factors that interact with each other. This research has utilized the research of RUROS (Nikolopoulou, 2004) and published research (Ali-Toudert et al. 2006, Koutsourakis 2010, Yamamura 2009, Zambrano 2006) on thermal comfort and different factors that affect the UHI, always referring to the street level. Through a combined critical approach, our work uses a simple tool, which takes into consideration climatic and environmental factors, as well as issues and environmental problems, applicable to a wide range of Greek city typologies, adequate to guide designers and architects understand the thermal qualities and measures that create UHI. This tool has been developed through research in the urban characteristics of Greek cities and their potential to include UHI mitigation techniques used in cities around the globe. The referenced tool was created in response to the need for a detailed subjective analysis for case studies. This tool should be easy to use, in contrast to most urban environment simulation programs that require more detailed technical knowledge in order to operate. Givoni (1998) states that the difference between urban and rural temperatures is affected by two types of parameters. Recording the meteorological and the urban parameters should be the first step to a proper subjective analysis in terms of integrated urban design. The meteorological parameters are air temperature, solar radiation, relative humidity and wind speed. Those factors can be obtained by meteorological data stations. Various features of the urban structure, such as the density of the built-up areas, and the ratio of the height of the buildings to the distances between them, create small special microclimates that are hard to define. It is not easy to obtain exact climatic conditions near buildings. Therefore, it is important to acknowledge each element effecting urban microclimate and the importance through the design process. By simply applying the meteorological factors on a site and recording the urban elements as shown in Table 1, one can inspect the general characteristics for the corresponding area. All possible features can react or contradict with the restrictions of the urban geometry, thus a complete site analysis is able to provide us with the concentrated information we need to proceed with the proposal of appropriate UHI mitigation techniques.

meteorological parameters urban parameters Table 1: Site analysis -Meteorological & Urban parameters factors neighbourhood building street surface cover air temperature (Tair_met) o C solar radiation (Sol_met) W/m² wind speed (at roof level)(v_h) m/s Relative humidity (RH_met) % ASV (Actual Sensation Vote) land use 0.034(Tair_met-2)+0.0001(0.2*Sol_met)- 0.086(0.4*V_met)-0.001RH_met-0.412 mixed use (residential-commercial) strictly residential strictly commercial industrial conflicting land use (residential-indastrial) Urban geometry complex organised (with a pattern) no pattern density of built area <40% 40%-70% >70% free space (%) <5% 5%-15% 15%-25% 25%-50% >50% characteristics pilotis atrium skylight roof type flat roof roof terracing street orientation N-S E-W NE-SW NW-SE linear street length <90 >90 road classification primary secondary pedestrian area height to width ratio (H/W) <0.5 0.5-1 1 to 2 2 to 3 >3 linear street length to height ratio (L/H) low <3 medium =5 high >7 limit to street no extra space canopy gallery garden patch street canyon symmetrical assymetrical sky view factor ( 0-1) vegetation low high linear / individual trees group of trees wind speed (at street level)(v_h) m/s albedo (solar reflectance) <0.1 0.1-0.3 0.3-0.5 >0.5 thermal emission <0.30 0.30-0.50 0.50-0.70 >0.70 The tool proposed in this paper is based on a database that we have developed through past research on specific UHI mitigation techniques and their implementation within the urban environment in relation to specific meteorological factors. This database is an attempt to record all possible UHI mitigation techniques and their relation to most possible urban parameters. The critical approach on their interaction is the step towards their optimal simultaneous architectural integration in the urban fabric of Greek cities.

To set the database, all available mitigation techniques have been collected and categorized. A tree-diagram, as shown in Figure 2, can explain the three categories, according to the aim of the application. In detail, the different techniques were divided in: the reduction of anthropogenic heat release the improvement of artificial surface covers the improvement of city air ventilation Mitigation techniques Reduction of anthropogenic heat release Improvement of artificial surface cover Improvement of city air ventilation Figure 2: The three categories of mitigation techniques that were used in this research Through literature and relative research all mitigation techniques were decoded and categorized according to these three groups. It is important for architects to understand the scale of implementation of the design tools. Thus, a theoretical attempt was made to analyse each technique and set the range of implementation effectiveness to street, building and neighbourhood scale, creating an up-to-date model that suggests a 5 point scale of importance, from 1 (not important) to 5 (very important), combining urban parameters and meteorological factors and considering the analytical sensation of thermal comfort. Table 2 shows the outline of the tool, which has a tree structure that concludes to the scale of its implementation and a subjective account on the degree of effect, all considering the properties of Greek cities. Until this point of the paper, Table 1 provides a proper site potential analysis and Table 2 a categorized database that suggests possible design solutions. The aim is to create a combined model that will understand the site meteorological parameters, use urban characteristics to understand the microclimate parameters and interact with each other, providing the architect or the urban designer with design solutions. For example, if the case is a small neighbourhood with hot street canyons and high radiation temperature at street level, the proposed tool should be adequate to eliminate techniques relevant only to buildings, such as green roofs, from the table. Therefore, the outcome of the process can inform architects and urban designers on the feasibility and performance for applying each proposed mitigation technique at a certain site or neighbourhood, in terms of thermal comfort at street level. To this end the methodology proposed consists of five stages as shown in Figure 3: Figure 3: Outline of analysis

Table 2: Mitigation technique model outline scale of implementation degree of effect MITIGATION TECHNIQUE reduction in anthropogenic heat release improvement of artificial surface covers improvement control of air conditioning systems control of land use optimal operation of air conditioning systems neighbourhood Buildings proper placing of outdor units Buildings 2 use of cooling towers Buildings 5 greening of building surfaces and adoption of waterretentive materials improvement in the reflectivity of walls and roofing materials use of cool materials traffic management improve reflectivity of walls and roofing improve reflectivity of paving materials PCM Phase change materials buildings/street Buildings streets /neighbourhood streets /neighbourhood water retentive pavement streets /neighbourhood 5 buildings & streets 1 1 5 5 4 5 1 improvement of city air ventilation greening shading windbreaks street greenery low vegetation streets /neighbourhood row of trees 2 green roof Buildings 5 green walls Buildings pockets parks neighbourhood 3 artificial Street 1 greenery 3 use of cooling towers Buildings 5 cold sinks City 3 water & green areas neighbourhood 3 artificial neighbourhood 1 greenery 1 4 3 4 CASE STUDY The city of Athens, is dealing with the lack of green spaces and pedestrian activities, as the city centre is a vehicular environment with exposed concrete sidewalks. The present study focuses on the relation between street design, building characteristics and outdoor thermal comfort. In order to achieve the aim of the study, five city blocks representative to the city centre in terms of orientation, building height, road width were selected. The case study covers the district area of approximately 20.000 square meters. This district is a high density area (>70%) of mainly residential and office use. Most of the buildings are multi-storey concrete volumes (>6 floors) with flat roofs and recesses, built during the 60s, presenting high height-to-width ratio (>3), with no inner patios or an internal atrium. The street materials are porous asphalt, concrete pavement tiles and old dirty stucco for the vertical building surfaces. Those low reflectance and high thermal emitance materials are

common to the Greek urban fabric. Furthermore, the case study area consists of a sequence of urban canyons (Koutsourakis 2010), resulting to inadequate street ventilation. Figure 4: Study area map: Area type / Road classification The neighbourhood is facing the prevailing northeast winds on roof level. There is lack of empty space, greenery or air circulation areas in a site of flat organised topography. Being close to the city centre, dense traffic fortifies the concentration of air pollution, which combined with encapsulated high temperatures, can be stressful and indirectly dangerous to the urban environment. Considering all of the above features and the recorded low surface reflectivity, the region, on street level, faces high temperatures. Using Tables 3 and 4 shown below, one is able to understand specific features concerning the district of this study. While Table 3 shows the metrological factors in the area of the case study, Table 4 analyses the street characteristics, in terms of orientation, H/W ratio, material reflectance factor and surface temperature.

Figure 5: Study area map: Road classification /Roof type Figure 6: Photograph taken at the centre of the study area

meteorological factors Table 3: Meteorological Factors case study (Sunday 21/07/2013, 12:00 from www.airquality.gr) air temperature (Tair_met) oc 33 o C solar radiation (Sol_met) W/m² 1000W/m² wind speed (at roof level)(v_h) m/s 2.1m/s Relative humidity (RH_met) % 38% PMV=4.8 ASV (Actual Sensation Vote) 0.034(Tair_met- 2)+0.0001(0.2*Sol_met)- 0.086(0.4*V_met)- 0.001RH_met-0.412 Figure 7: Photograph of Vasileos Konstantinou Avenue Through recording urban parameters, it is becoming clear that there are many restrictions in terms of geometry, materials and meteorological quantities. The above, set the immediate challenge to improve the qualities of artificial surfaces and the simultaneous improvement of the ventilation of the city, both without changing the urban geometry. The most important factor is urban geometry. It is very important to analyse the urban volume (buildings) in relation to the unbuilt areas, such as streets and empty fields (which are very limited), and understand the importance of orientation. The case study area faces intermediate street orientations of NE-SW and NW-SE, which translate to short periods of thermal discomfort, as the streets are always partially in the shade (Ali-Toudert, F. et al 2006). Table 4: STREET ANALYSIS (air Temperature 33 o C) Road Name Orientation H/W Materials Solar reflectance/ Thermal emmitance Surface T (ASTM E1980) Direct Sunlight 1 Vas.Kon/nou NE-SW <1 Porous asphalt, 0.05/0.93(asphalt) 81.2 Yes 2 Fokianou NE-SW >3 cement 0.1/0.63(tiles) (asphalt) No 3 Arktinou NE-SW >3 pavement tiles 86.3(tiles) Yes 4 Ironda NE-SW >3 Yes 5 Agiou Spiridonos NW-SE >3 Porous asphalt, 0.05/0.93(asphalt) 81.2 Yes 6 Pausaniou NW-SE 1-2 cement 0.1/0.63(tiles) (asphalt) Yes pavement tiles, 0.25/0.75 (trees) row of trees 86.3(tiles) 75.6 (trees) Wind Speed 0.4*2.1=0.84m/s (depending on the direction)

The area experiences dense street canyons (H/W>3), so it is critical to understand the air movement through the canyon and the various whirls that are created near the buildings and through the vertical development of the canyons. The wind direction within the canyon depends on the incidence of ambient air in respect to street axis. Those whirls block the air circulation and create a heat sink, while constantly interacting with high surface temperatures. In case of light winds, the air canyon flow is not only a mechanically driven circulation but thermal effects, due to canyon surface irradiation, may play a role. Discomfort can extend under balconies when sidewalks in the open street area already experience thermal stress (Ali-Toudert, F. Et al 2006), because of the direct irradiation, especially in wide canyons. In the study area, there are tall buildings with roofs and many recesses that modify the H/W ratio. Asymmetries of street canyons tend to cause thermal stress because of direct exposure. Nevertheless, when H/W>2 (as most cases of the district), an asymmetrical canyon shows better thermal behaviour than a symmetrical (Ali-Toudert, F. Et al 2006). The use of rows of trees improves thermal comfort within a street canyon only where direct solar radiation appears. In other cases, the use of low vegetation is ideal. Furthermore, the use of water has been found very effective at the street level, as air temperature was found to be a secondary factor in influencing thermal comfort (Ali-Toudert, F., 2005). If buildings are coated with high albedo materials or vegetation then temperatures could decrease and balance thermal comfort. The street surface temperature (Table 3 surface T) can decrease up to 21.2 o C, with the implementation of >0.50 albedo street materials (calculated by using the ASTM standard E1980). Figure 8: Study area: Actual number of floor & recesses & H/W ratio

Figure 9: Study area: Solar Reflectance 5 RECOMMENDATIONS Using the developed model (Tables 2, 3 and 4), the following recommendations are suggested for improving thermal comfort in street level for the case study area by the simultaneous combination of UHI mitigation techniques: I. Reduction in anthropogenic heat release: i. Make pedestrian paths more pleasant for walking and social interaction by eliminating traffic at NE-SW oriented streets with H/W>3 ii. Using permeable pavements iii. Row of trees at the NW facade of the street for shading iv. Low vegetation on the SE facade of the street to prevent whirls II. Improvement of artificial surface covers: i. High albedo and light colour materials for facades and building covers in order to decrease the ambient air temperature and contribute to better urban thermal comfort (as above) ii. Creating a pocket park utilizing the only empty field of the neighbourhood connected with the private empty forgotten spaces, adjacent to the unbuilt land iii. Permeable pavements (transpiring surfaces) iv. Green roofs where flat roofs v. Green walls where direct solar radiation occurs (otherwise, lack of sun implies discomfort) vi. Canopies (shade) & vegetation where direct solar radiation occurs

III. Improvement of city air ventilation: i. No windbreaks needed ii. Increasing wind speed: Warm air stagnates in the urban canyons unless ventilated with the use of water and evapotranspiration by greenery (as above) iii. Using urban geometry vertical voids (building skylights) to create a cool tower to ventilate the existing canyon The method applied in this study is recommended for existing locations, as it uses the real vote of the users, registered in questionnaires, making it possible to evaluate situations were inadequacies of the urban space are observed. 6 VALIDATION OF THE PROPOSED RECOMMENDATIONS Capeluto and Shaviv (2001) highlighted the importance of street orientation in deciding on the plan density (by implication H/W). Basically, rows of buildings along NE-SW, E-W and NW-SE streets reveal to allow (in this order) the highest urban plan density while preserving winter solar rights. Similarly, vegetation is a modifying factor of the local climate. Its use as a strategy to mitigate the urban heat island (UHI) and improve the microclimate has been widely emphasized. Within an urban structure, the climatic effectiveness of vegetation depends on the ratio of green area to built area, as well as on the size, location and individual characteristics of the plant (species, density, shape, size, volume, age, etc.). It has been suggested that several smaller areas with sufficient intervals are more cooling effective than one large green space (Honjo and Takakura 1990). Therefore, street greenery and pocket parks seem effective in the neighbourhood scale of implementation, in respect to orientation and solar access as implied on chapter 5, on recommendations concerning categories I & II. With respect to urban surfaces, Aseada et al. (1996) pointed out the importance of pavement materials in the resulting heat fluxes and air-ground interface on summer days. Urban surfaces with high albedo, typical of light colors, reduce the thermal storage in the materials. So, the improvement of surface covers is correctly suggested on previous chapter on recommendations concerning category II, in terms of high albedo materials and transpiring surfaces. 7 CONCLUSIONS This paper has shown that there are ways to improve the outdoor environment in Athens, without altering the city planning by the simultaneous integration of various UHI mitigation techniques. If implemented, the recommendations gained through the model developed, have the potential to influence human thermal comfort within urban canyons. Shading might be the key strategy in a hot and dry climate like Athens, but various urban parameters, site restriction and possibilities must be considered in the design process. Microclimatic conditions differ in the aspect ratio H/W, street orientation and a number of design details. Symmetrical and asymmetrical urban canyons with different sky view factors may occur, interacting with the same meteorological factors, requiring different implementation techniques in terms of thermal comfort. The disconnection observed so far between urban climatology on the one hand and urban geometry on the other hand, is inadequate towards the integrated sustainable urban design. This paper presented a subjective quantitative tool that has been developed and is constantly improving. This tool integrates climatic and environmental factors, as well as issues and environmental problems in Greece, while providing a simple design guideline understandable by practitioners, adequate for large scale implementation.

8 FUTURE WORK BASED ON THIS RESEARCH Future work can focus on the simulation of this quantitative analysis for establishing this implementation model into a simple tool for street design assessment and design guide. For this purpose we may use ENVImet, a three-dimensional model which stimulates the microclimatic modifications due to buildings and vegetation (Bruse, 1997). ENVImet also needs relatively few input parameters and calculates meteorological parameters. If air temperature, wind speed and direction, air humidity and the mean radiant temperature are known, then it is possible to calculate the PET (Physiologically Equivalent Temperature) index. Future work will import the PET which is measured in o C and therefore can be easily applied for planning purposes. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Special thanks to Melachroini-Michaella Karageorgiou for the graphics and map processing. REFERENCES ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2010, Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy Asaeda T., Ca V.T., Wake A. (1996). Heat storage of pavement and its effect on the lower atmosphere. Atmos. Envir. 30: 413-427 ASTM standard E1980, (2013). http://www.astm.org/ Climate Change Impacts Study Committee. (2011). The environmental, economic and social impacts of climate change in Greece. Bank of Greece. http://www.bankofgreece.gr/bogekdoseis/climatechange_fullreport_bm.pdf Brandemuehl, M.J., (2005). AREN 3050, Environmental systems for buildings: Lecture notes, University of Colorado at Boulder, Civil-Environmental and Architectural Engineering Bruse M., (1997). www.envi-met.com.de Capeluto I.G., Shaviv E. (2001) On the use of solar volume for determining the urban fabric. Solar Energy 70: 275-280. Che-Ani A.I. et al. (2009). Mitigating the urban heat island effect: Some points without altering existing city planning, EuroJournals Publishing Inc., pp.204-216 http://www.eurojournals.com/ejsr.htm Fazia Ali Toudert (2005). Dependence of outdoor thermal comfort on street design in hot and dry climate, Berichte des Meteorologischen Institutes der Universitat Freiburg Nr.15. Freibutg, Nevember Fazia Ali Toudert, Mayer H. (2006). Effects of street design on outdoor thermal comfort, www.sci.u-szeged.hu Fanger, P.O. (1970). Thermal Comfort, Copenhagen: Danish Technical Press Givoni, B. (1998) Climate Considerations in Building and Urban Design, Canada, John Wiley & Sons. Golden A.S., (2004). The built environment induced urban heat island effect in rapidly urbanizing arid regions a sustainable urban engineering complexity, Environmental Sciences, Vol.00 No.0, Taylor & Francis Ltd. Honjo T., Takakura T. (1990/91). Simulation of thermal effects of urban green areas on their surrounding areas. Energy and Buildings 15-16: 457-463. Ito M., Nitta H., Kido H., (2004). Study on environment-friendly pavement structure for cities, Public works research institute bulletin, Japan, April Kartalis K. et al, (1999). Introduction to natural and human environment: Natural environment, Hellenic Open University Kim B. et al,, (2011). Effects of indoor environmental variables on human thermal comfort sensation, The Japanese Journal of Ergonomics, vol. 47, pp. 374-377

Koutsourakis N. (2010). Flow and pollutant dispersion in urban canyons: Review, Tech.Chron.Sci. J. TCG, I, No 1 Kwon JY, Parsons K. (2009), Evaluation of the PMV thermal comfort index in outdoor weather conditions, J. Energy and Building - lboro.ac.uk LTPEP (laboratory of thermo physical properties and environmental processes) (2013). www.airquality.gr. Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Nilsson H. (2005). PMV calculation programme, Department of Technology and Built Environment, Laboratory of ventilation and air quality, University of Gavle) www.atecyr.org/ Nikolopoulou M. et al (2003). Thermal comfort in outdoor spaces: Field studies in Greece, Centre for renewable energy sources (CRES), Athens, Greece Nikolopoulou M. (Project coordinator, 2004). Rediscovering the urban realm and open spaces (RUROS), Centre for renewable energy sources (CRES), Athens, Greece Oke T., (1988). Street design and urban canopy layer climate. Energy and Building 11:103-113 Oke T.R., (1987). Boundary Layer Climates. Methuen, London Pearlmutter D., Bitan A., Berliner P, (1999). Microclimatic analysis of compact urban canyons in an arid zone, Atmospheric environment 33 Slosberg R. et al (2006). Mitigating New York s heat island with urban forestry, living roofs and light surfaces New York city regional heat island initiative, Columbia university center for climate systems research & Nasa/Goddard Institute for space studies & Department of geography, Hunter College-CUNY & SAIC Tan J. et al (2009). The urban heat island and its impact on heat waves and human health in Shanghai, Int J Biometeorol (2010) 54:75 84 Yamamoto Y., (2006). Measures to Mitigate urban heat islands. Quartefly Review No.18, January Yamamura S. et al. (2009). Study on methodology about environmentally friendly urban development dor creating cool spots and reducing CO 2 emissions in urban area, The seventh international conference on urban climate, 29 June-3 July, Yokohama, Japan Zambrano L. et al, (2006). Thermal comfort evaluation in outdoor space of tropical humid climate, PLEA2006 The 23 rd conference on Passive and Low energy architecture, Geneva, Switzerland, 6-8 September View publication stats