Ambient Outdoor Air Quality Standards in the UAE

Transcription

1 Ambient Outdoor Air Quality Standards in the UAE Introduction Ambient outdoor air quality is an important metric used to measure overall environmental quality in a particular area. Declining levels of air quality can lead to a host of health problems, besides causing harm to the natural and built environments. Industrial processes, burning of fossil fuels, construction activities, vehicular traffic, agricultural activities, and deforestation are among the most prominent causes of air pollution worldwide. Governments worldwide have been monitoring ambient outdoor air quality to keep track of major pollutants and accordingly plan out mitigation measures. The most common pollutants that are measured are particulate matter, which includes both PM 10 and PM 2.5, ozone, nitrogen dioxide, sulphur dioxide, carbon monoxide, lead, and volatile organic compounds. This paper will look at ambient outdoor air quality standards in the UAE, the existing monitoring network, and the extent of available data. These will then be compared to standards in the UK as defined by the Environment Agency, and standards in the US as defined by the Environmental Protection Agency, as well as their corresponding monitoring networks and data availability. Ambient outdoor air quality in the UAE Air quality standards in the UAE currently exist at the federal level. Cabinet Decree (12) of 2006 Regarding Regulation Concerning Protection of Air from Pollution [1] has set out limits for the six major air quality pollutants in the country, as shown in Table 1. All the Emirates currently follow the Federal standards, and no other Emirate-specific standards have been published to date. Table 1: Federal Ambient Air Quality Standards in the UAE (Source: Cabinet Decree 12 of 2006) Substance Symbol Maximum Average Time Allowable Limits (µg/m 3 ) Sulphur Dioxide SO hour hours 60 1 year Carbon Monoxide CO 30 (mg/nm 3 ) 1 hour 10 (mg/nm 3 ) 8 hours Nitrogen Dioxide NO hour hours Ozone O hour hours Total Suspended TSP hours Particles Particulate Matter (with 10 microns or less in diameter) 90 1 year PM hours Lead Pb 1 1 year PO Box 2556, Dubai 1

2 Air quality monitoring stations exist all over the country, and are operated separately by each Emirate within their respective jurisdictions. In Abu Dhabi, 19 air quality monitoring stations are located all throughout the Emirate as per the most recent data available, which is from These are operated by the Environment Agency- Abu Dhabi. Figure 1 shows the distribution of these. As expected, the urban areas of Abu Dhabi city and Al Ain have the most monitoring stations, with 8 and 4, respectively. The remaining stations are scattered around the Emirate, with the bulk of these spaced out in the Western Region. [2] Figure 1: Air quality monitoring stations in Abu Dhabi (source: EAD, 2015) Similarly, the Emirate of Dubai also has a network of monitoring stations. The figure below shows the network of monitoring stations scattered throughout the city of Dubai. Additionally, there is one station located in Hatta. The total number of stations operating in 2015 was 12. [2] PO Box 2556, Dubai 2

3 Figure 2: Air quality monitoring stations in Dubai (source: Gulf News, 2012) The Emirate of Sharjah also has an air quality monitoring network consisting of two stations as per data available from These are located in Kalba and Al Hummariah. [2] The Federal Competitiveness and Statistics Authority (FCSA) of the UAE has data available from each Emirate s air quality monitoring network for the years Pollutants measured include PM 10, SO 2, NO 2, O 3, and CO. The graphs below show average air quality readings for 2015 for each pollutant in Abu Dhabi, Dubai, and Sharjah. [2] PO Box 2556, Dubai 3

4 Abu Dhabi Air Quality Readings, PM10 SO2 NO2 CO O3 Figure 3: Abu Dhabi Air Quality Readings (Source: FCSA, 2015) Dubai Air Quality Readings, PM10 SO2 NO2 CO O3 Figure 4: Dubai Air Quality Readings (Source: FCSA, 2015) PO Box 2556, Dubai 4

5 Sharjah Air Quality Readings, Al Hummariah PM10 SO2 NO2 CO O3 Kalba Figure 5: Sharjah Air Quality Readings (Source: FCSA) The 150 µg/m 3 limit for PM10 over 24 hours was exceeded at a few locations, however most of these are industrial or open space, such as Mussafah, Mafraq, Liwa Oasis, and Jebel Ali Port, and are therefore expected to have higher concentrations of particulate matter caused by dust or industrial emissions. SO 2 readings were well under the 150 µg/m 3 limit measured over 24 hours at all stations except Warsan in Dubai, which is an area of several industries, some of which might release high quantities of SO 2 through their processes. O 3 exceeded the 8-hour 120 µg/m 3 limit at Bida Zayed in Abu Dhabi, as well as in Kalba. Several stations in Abu Dhabi were very close to the limit; these are all located in industrial areas such as Mussafah, Mafraq, and Ruwais. Ozone is typically emitted through vehicular emissions and industrial activity; therefore it is likely that industrial processes located in these areas are the cause of the high readings observed. Readings at all stations for carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide were well under the limits. However, not all pollutants are measured at each station, and not each station has readings for every month of the year. The table below provides a summary of the Abu Dhabi, Dubai, and Sharjah monitoring networks for 2015, pollutants measured, and the number of months for which data is available. [2] PO Box 2556, Dubai 5

6 Table 2: Analysis of Monitoring Stations Data Collection (Source: FCSA, 2015) Emirate / Pollutant Number of Stations that Monitor Pollutant Percentage Abu Dhabi PM 10 19/19 100% Yes SO 2 19/19 100% Yes NO 2 19/19 100% Yes O 3 14/19 74% No CO 6/19 32% Yes Dubai PM 10 7/12 58% No SO 2 10/12 83% No NO 2 12/12 100% No O 3 7/12 58% No CO 9/12 75% No Sharjah PM 10 2/2 100% No SO 2 2/2 100% Yes NO 2 2/2 100% Yes O 3 1/2 50% Yes CO 2/2 100% Yes Is Data Available for All Months Comparison with International Standards To gain a better understanding of the strength of the UAE s networks and available data, two case studies were considered those of the US and UK. Both have stringent air quality monitoring networks and are widely considered as benchmarks for countries worldwide. United Kingdom The UK s air quality standards are designed to align with those of the European Union. Details on permissible limits are provided in the table below. [3] Table 3: UK Air Quality Permissible Limits (Source: DEFRA) Substance Symbol Maximum Average Time Allowable Limits (µg/m 3 ) Sulphur Dioxide SO hour hours Carbon Monoxide CO 10 (mg/nm 3 ) 8 hours Nitrogen Dioxide NO hour 40 1 year Ozone O hours Total Suspended TSP NA NA Particles PM hours PO Box 2556, Dubai 6

7 Particulate Matter 40 1 year (with 10 microns or less in diameter) Lead Pb year The network of monitoring stations in the UK is quite wide ranging. The total number of stations, fixed and manual, numbers more than 1,500 across the country. For the purpose of this paper, only fixed stations were considered, which number 161. [4] Figure 6: Air quality monitoring stations in the UK (source: DEFRA, 2017) Table 4: Analysis of monitoring stations in the UK (Source: DEFRA, 2017) Pollutant Number of Stations that Monitor Pollutant Percentage PM 10 71/161 44% Yes SO 2 29/161 18% Yes NO 2 147/161 91% Yes O 3 82/161 51% Yes CO 8/161 5% Yes Is Data Available for All Months United States The United States, like the EU, also has stringent air quality permissible limits, called the National Ambient Air Quality Standards. These are part of the Clean Air Act, and cover six major air pollutants. The permissible limits for these are shown in the table below. [5] PO Box 2556, Dubai 7

8 Table 5: US Air Quality Permissible Limits (Source: US EPA) Substance Symbol Maximum Average Time Allowable Limits (µg/m 3 ) Sulphur Dioxide SO 2 75 ppb 1 hour 0.5 ppm 3 hours Carbon Monoxide CO 9 ppm 8 hours 35 ppm 1 hour Nitrogen Dioxide NO ppb 1 hour 53 ppb 1 year Ozone O ppm 8 hours Total Suspended TSP NA NA Particles Particulate Matter PM hours (with 10 microns or less in diameter) Lead Pb month average Data is available for every state in the US through each state s data portal. For comparison purposes, this section will look at the state of Indiana s air quality monitoring network, since the state is similar in area and population to the UAE. Figure 7: Indiana air quality monitoring stations (Source: US EPA, 2015) PO Box 2556, Dubai 8

9 Figure 7 shows the distribution of Indiana s 85 monitoring stations. These are concentrated around the major urban centres in the state. The colors denote the different pollutants that are monitored. [6] Table 6: Analysis of Monitoring Stations Data Collection (Source: Indiana Department of Environmental Management) Pollutant Number of Stations that Monitor Pollutant Percentage PM 10 12/85 14% Yes SO 2 9/85 11% Yes NO 2 7/85 8% Yes O 3 43/85 51% Yes CO 6/85 7% Yes Is Data Available for All Months Discussion The table below shows a comparison of air quality monitoring standards across the UAE, UK, and the US. Table 7: Air quality standards comparison Substance Symbol Maximum Allowable Limits (µg/m 3 ) UAE Sulphur Dioxide Carbon CO 10 Maximum Allowable Limits (µg/m 3 ) UK Maximum Allowable Limits (µg/m 3 ) USA Average Time SO hour NA 24 hours 10 (mg/nm 3 ) 10 8 hours Monoxide (mg/nm 3 ) (mg/nm 3 ) Nitrogen NO hour Dioxide 150 NA NA 24 hours Ozone O hours Total TSP 230 NA NA 24 hours Suspended 90 NA NA 1 year Particles Particulate Matter (with 10 microns or less in diameter) PM hours NA 40 NA 1 year Lead Pb NA 1 year As seen from the data, not all countries measure pollutants within the same timeframes, so standards for some timeframes were not available. The only standard that is exactly the same across all three countries is that of carbon monoxide limits, which each country caps at 10 mg/nm 3. For sulphur dioxide, the limit in the UAE is almost twice as high as that of the US for measurements conducted over 1 hour, and 50 µg/m 3 higher than the UK limit for measurements over 24 hours. UAE limits are also well over twice as high for nitrogen dioxide measured over 1 hour. PM 10 standards in the UAE compare favorably with those in the US for 24 hour intervals. It is likely PO Box 2556, Dubai 9

10 that sulphur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide limits are higher in the UAE to account for several regional factors. Examples of these would include the presence of oil and gas industries, manufacturing facilities, high rate of urbanization and associated vehicular emissions. In terms of the extent of the monitoring networks, the UAE has a good number of stations in urban areas. Coverage in Abu Dhabi s non-urban areas is quite good as well, whereas Dubai has just one station outside the actual city limits, located in Hatta. Sharjah s network, as per published data, is insufficient, with only two monitoring stations in operation in The UK and US have more comprehensive networks, numbering in the hundreds. However, factors such as area, population, location of industries, and the ratio of urban to non-urban areas all play a part in determining the locations and numbers of these stations. Table 8 shows a summary of the comparison of monitoring networks. The UAE s network, averaged across the three main Emirates, has more stations that monitor each pollutant than either of the other two countries. Therefore, there is a better range of data available for each pollutant. Table 8: Air quality monitoring networks comparison Pollutant Percentage of Stations that Monitor in UAE Percentage of Stations that Monitor in UK PM 10 86% 44% 14% SO 2 94% 18% 11% NO 2 100% 91% 8% O 3 61% 51% 51% CO 69% 5% 7% Percentage of Stations that Monitor in Indiana Data availability was also found to vary. Air quality data in the UAE is only available from 2010 onwards, and not every station had consistent readings. Statistics obtained from the FCSA website showed gaps in readings, with some stations displaying measurements for only one or two months of the year. In contrast, the UK and US have data that goes back for decades, with data availability being much more consistent. Additionally, these countries also have data available hourly and daily, which the UAE does not provide. It is unclear if data in the UAE was simply not collected at regular intervals prior to 2010, or if the FCSA website does not display the complete data archive. Data presentation and accessibility is an important factor in influencing public awareness. In the UK and US, the respective agencies have a wide trove of readily accessible data, information pages, and interactive maps, with the corresponding standards and basic technical information clearly displayed. The UAE has public data available on the FCSA website from 2010 onwards, however since the UAE is a relatively young country, it is expected that data collection and availability will improve over time, along with stronger awareness on the subject. Overall, despite some limitations in the range of the monitoring network and availability of data, the UAE has been making rapid progress in terms of improving air quality through legislation and international agreements. The three main Emirates are continuing to add monitoring stations, with Dubai having recently purchased a mobile monitoring station to measure 100 different air quality components, and Sharjah adding seven new stations in partnership with Bee ah, the Emirate s environmental and waste management company. [7][8] PO Box 2556, Dubai 10

11 The UAE has also been pushing for stronger air quality and emissions legislation. A draft standard to lower vehicle emissions was passed in 2016, which will require cars to be more fuel-efficient by following the Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) guidelines used in the US. This is expected to significantly lower vehicular emissions over the next few years. [9] Along with this, a vehicle emissions tax is also being considered, under which motorists who own fuel inefficient vehicles would have to pay a polluter fee. [10] The Dubai Green Building Regulations and Estidama regulations in Abu Dhabi require certain percentages of bicycle parking spaces and preferred car parking spaces for electric and fuel-efficient vehicles, and electric car charging stations are in operation in several public areas across the country. Public transport has likewise also gained importance; the Dubai Metro and Al Sufouh trams have greatly eased up road congestion and consequently vehicle emissions, and the proposed Abu Dhabi metro and feeder bus and tram networks are expected to have the same effect. The country is also a signatory on several internationally prominent legislations, most recently the COP21 agreement of 2015, which requires all signing parties to prepare and periodically present Nationally Determined Contributions to achieve the intended goal of zero greenhouse gas emissions in the second half of the century. The UAE in particular has set a target of increasing the contribution of clean energy to 24% by 2021, along with several policy initiatives in the fields of transportation and infrastructure, energy efficiency, water management, education and public awareness. [11] Other important international legislations that the UAE has signed include the Kyoto Protocol, Montreal Protocol, and UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. The UAE also plans to target 90% adherence with WHO air quality standards by Conclusion Overall, it appears that many of the air quality standards compare favorably with those in the UK and US. The UAE s network performs well in terms of the actual number of monitoring stations deployed in the urban areas across the three major Emirates, with the exception of Sharjah. Coverage could be improved in some areas. For example, Musaffah and the outlying areas of Abu Dhabi city could benefit from additional stations since they are heavily industrial areas, and Sharjah s network could be expanded to cover the entire city, including the industrial and university areas. Coverage in non-urban areas is not as good, with only Abu Dhabi having several stations outside the main city limits. Most pollutants seem to be monitored across a good range of stations, thus providing several data points. However, data availability itself is not consistent; most stations on the FCSA website do not display data for more than a few months of the year Data presentation could also be improved, so as to better serve awareness and research purposes. There has been good overall progress in air quality data collection in the recent past, with several initiatives to add monitoring stations and improve data availability across the Emirates. Associated initiatives such as the widespread implementation of green building regulations, improvements in public transportation and policy making, and general awareness about environmental issues have also contributed towards these efforts. Long-term policies and plans recently implemented by the country are also noteworthy - the important COP21 agreement, as well as the national climate change adaptation plan are positive steps that will help spur further efforts towards improved air quality in the UAE. PO Box 2556, Dubai 11

12 References [1] Cabinet Decree (12) of 2006 Regarding Regulation Concerning Protection of Air from Pollution. (2006). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from Files/Federal-Bylaw-12-Air-pollution-2006-English-translation.pdf. [2] Statics By Subject (n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from [3] UK and EU Air Quality Limits (n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from [4] Data Selector (n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from [5] NAAQS Table (2016). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from [6] Air Quality in Indiana (n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from [7] Mobile air quality monitoring station soon in Dubai (March 15, 2017). Retrieved May 24, 2017, from [8] Sharjah Municipality to build seven air quality stations (December 8, 2015). Retrieved May 24, 2017, from [9] New car fuel economy standard for UAE (September 27, 2016). Retrieved May 24, 2017, from [10] UAE officials consider polluter pays policy for motorists (November 8, 2015). Retrieved May 24, 2017, from [11] Intended Nationally Determined Contribution of the United Arab Emirates (October 22, 2015). Retrieved May 24, 2017, from rst/uae%20indc%20-%2022%20october.pdf PO Box 2556, Dubai 12