Process Risk through Application of FMEA. A Case Study. INTERPHEX March 17, 2009
|
|
- Miranda Sharp
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Managing Process Risk through Application of FMEA to Batch Records A Case Study INTERPHEX March 17, 2009 Jon Hardy Lonza Head of Operations Hopkinton, MA Fred Greulich Maxiom Consulting Group, Inc. Director of Operational Excellence Maxiom Consulting Group, Inc. 230 Third Avenue 3 rd Floor Waltham, MA (781)
2 Case Study Topics Case Background and Situation Risk Discussion Introduction to Failure Mode & Effects Analysis (FMEA) and Root Cause Analysis (RCA) FMEA and RCA Project Approach Current Status and Results 2
3 Case Background and Situation Lonza is a worldwide leader in providing development and manufacturing services for the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries Portsmouth, NH is a large scale mammalian cell culture site Strategically important to Lonza Operational Excellence, including risk management, are ongoing business imperatives Project objective was to reduce manufacturing process risk Lonza had previous experience utilizing Failure Mode and Effects Analysis and Root Cause Analysis Lonza partnered with Maxiom Group to utilize FMEA and RCA applied to batch record steps to reduce risk in the purification process for one key customer s s product 3
4 Risk in Biologics Manufacturing Risk and uncertainty exist across the entire value chain as a result of many factors Product & process technology Commercial process improvements Changing product specifications Human/operator variability Supplier vulnerabilities Scale-up and launch uncertainty Demand fluctuations Raw material & component pricing Supply base market dynamics It is essential to identify and understand risks in order to effectively manage the many sources of uncertainty t 4
5 Categories of Value Chain Risks Value chain risks can be grouped into four categories Diversion Authentication Product Security Risks Brand security Physical facility Information security Supply Risks Production Risks Demand Risks Supply disruption Facility & equipment Demand upside/ Continuity planning Pricing fluctuations Material variability Process variability Process failures Production scale-up downside Capacity constraints Product expiry Non-Compliance FMEA applied to batch records is the key tool for helping Lonza - Portsmouth manage process failures 5
6 Introduction to FMEA FMEA is a rigorous method of identifying and preventing process problems before they occur An established tool for identifying, prioritizing and managing process and business risk Focused on preventing defects, enhancing safety, and increasing customer satisfaction Minimizes Cost Of Quality Focuses on Prevention vs. Detection Applied to manufacturing batch records, FMEA results in more robust processes and reduction/elimination of the need for corrective action 6
7 Introduction to FMEA There are a few terms that are important to understand Failure Mode Failure Effects Risk Priority Number (RPN) The manner in which a process fails to meet its intended purpose The consequences if the failure occurs RPN = (Potential Severity) x (Likelihood of Occurrence) x (Ability to Detect) t) Used for each process step/failure mode combination. The RPN is used to prioritize failure modes. High priority failure modes are analyzed to identify their root causes and solutions are then developed which lead to reduced risk 7
8 FMEA and RCA Approach FMEA and RCA work is completed in three phases, starting with education and ending with implementation PHASE I. FMEA Assessment & RPN Scoring Conduct team education on FMEA Identify RPN s for each failure mode Determine top priority failure modes PHASE II RCA & Solution Identification Conduct RCA for top priority failure modes Develop solutions for selected root causes PHASE III Detailed Design & Implementation Develop detailed implementation designs and action plans for solutions identified in Phase II Implement action plans All Phases were completed with the active involvement of cross-functional teams of Lonza employees to ensure quality and ownership of results 8
9 Phase I - FMEA Assessment & RPN Scoring Results from Phase I, FMEA Assessment and Risk Priority Scoring, were captured in a spreadsheet format Process Step Potential Failure Mode Potential Failure Effects S E V Potential Causes O C C Current Controls D E T R P N What is the process step? In what way could the process step go wrong? What is the impact if the failure mode occurs? What causes the failure mode? What is the likelihood of this occurring? What are the existing controls/ that prevent the failure mode? How difficult is it to detect if the failure mode occurs? 9
10 Phase I - FMEA Assessment & RPN Scoring Templates were customized by the Lonza team to ensure standards were applied to the assessment and scoring process Effect Categories & Severity Rating Scale Severity = The seriousness of the effect of a failure mode on a downstream operation, equipment, safety, product, customer, or regulation. Rating Description Definition Product Impact Operator Safety Impact Compliance Impact Schedule Impact 5 4 Dangerously High High Lose batch Potentially salvageable Could result in death Would require calling 911 Occurrence Rating Scale Notify FDA Months Occurrence = How likely a failure mode is to occur for a given cause. Major deviation Weeks Rating Description Definition Detection Rating Scale Moderate Low Minor Salvageable with substantial rework Salvageable with minimal rework No impact Proprietary & Confidential 19 Would require first aid First aid not required No impact NOTE: Take the highest effect rating for the severity score 5 Very High Minor deviation Days 4 High Comment Hours 3 Moderate No impact No impact 2 Low 1 Remote Failure is almost inevitable; 5 or more occurrences Detectability likely in = 10Difficulty events of detecting the defect or failure with current process controls. Failure is likely; repeated failures have been observed in similar processes; 3 or more occurrences likely in 10 Rating events (approximately Description 1 Definition Sigma) Occasional failures have been experienced in similar processes; 3 or more occurrences likely in 100 events Very difficult to No known controls available to detect failure mode, or defect is not 5 (approximately 2 Sigma) detect detectable. Relatively few or isolated failures experienced in similar processes; 3 or more occurrences likely in 1000 events (approximately 3 Somewhat Sigma) difficult to 4 Remote likelihood current controls will detect failure. Failure is unlikely; Never been experienced; No failures detect ever associated with similar processes 3 Moderate Moderate likelihood current controls will detect failure. Proprietary & Confidential 20 2 Somewhat easy to detect High likelihood current controls will detect failure. 1 Easy to detect Current controls almost certain to detect the failure mode. Proprietary & Confidential 21 This customization was done in a project kickoff session at the beginning of Phase I of the project 10
11 Phase I - FMEA Assessment & RPN Scoring Here is a example of the completed FMEA Assessment and Priority Scoring Template PROCESS STEP POTENTIAL FAILURE MODE (HOW) EFFECT (WHAT) SEV CAUSE (WHY) OCC CURRENT CONTROLS DET RPN 7.2 Starting Material preparation Record harvest batch Do not record Lost traceability 1 Oe 2 batch record 3 6 number ; room temperature Record harvest batch number ; room temperature Temperature out of specificxation noncompliance with quality systems (deviation) 2 Probe oot 2 PM Program Harvest confirmation Temperature out of specification lost process time (bad temp probe, out of spec temperature) Harvest confirmation Print,record weight not done noncompliance with quality systems (deviation) Mix permeate Not able to mix Lost process time (mixer problem) Mix permeate Mix time out of specification noncompliance with quality systems (deviation) 2 probe oot 2 Metrology program Oe 2 batch record equipment failure 2 PM Program Oe 2 batch record Setup and obtain a bulk Sampler expired lost administration time 2 Oe 3 batch record 3 18 sample of the harvest (comments) Setup and obtain a bulk Sampler not connected negligible XXXX XXXXX sample of the harvest 11
12 Severity = The seriousness of the effect of a failure mode on a downstream operation, equipment, safety, product, customer, or regulation. Rating Description Definition Product Impact Operator Safety Impact Compliance Impact Schedule Impact 5 Dangerously High Lose batch Could result in death Notify FDA Months Potentially Would require calling 4 High Major deviation Weeks salvageable 911 Rating Description Definition Salvageable with 3 Moderate substantial Would require first 5 aid Minor Very High deviation Days Failure is almost inevitable; 5 or more occurrences likely in 10 events rework Failure is likely; repeated failures have been observed in similar Salvageable with 2 Low First aid not required 4 Comment High Hours processes; 3 or more occurrences likely in 10 events (approximately 1 minimal rework Sigma) Occasional failures have Rating been experienced Description in similar processes; 3 or Definition 1 Minor No impact No impact 3 No Moderate impact No more impact occurrences likely in 100 events (approximately 2 Sigma) NOTE: Take the highest effect rating for the severity score Very difficult to No known controls available to detect failure mode, or defect is not Relatively few or isolated failures 5 experienced in similar processes; 3 or 2 Low detect detectable. more occurrences likely in 1000 events (approximately 3 Sigma) Failure is unlikely; Never been experienced; No failures ever associated Proprietary & Confidential 19 1 Remote Somewhat difficult to with similar processes 4 Remote likelihood current controls will detect failure. detect Proprietary & Confidential Moderate Somewhat easy to detect Easy to detect Proprietary & Confidential 21 Moderate likelihood current controls will detect failure. High likelihood current controls will detect failure. Current controls almost certain to detect the failure mode. Phase I - FMEA Assessment & RPN Scoring The Lonza team began with 8 batch records which eventually mapped to 25 critical failure modes... 8 Purification Batch Records Analyzed >2600 Batch Record line items 266 High Risk RPN Steps 25 Critical Failure Modes Chrom BRs: - Chrom A - Chrom B - Chrom C - Chrom D UF BRs: - UF A -UF B -UF C Fill Finish: - Bulk Fill A Customized Rating Scales Effect Categories & Severity Rating Scale Occurrence Rating Scale Occurrence = How likely a failure mode is to occur for a given cause. Detection Rating Scale Detectability = Difficulty of detecting the defect or failure with current process controls. FMEA Table to Calc RPN S O D R Process Potential Failure Potential Failure E Potential Causes C Current Controls E P Step/Input Mode Ef fects V C T N What is the In what ways What is the impact What causes the Key What are the process step does the Key on the Key Output Input to go wrong? existing controls and Input Input go wrong? Variables (Customer and procedures under Requirements)? (inspection and test) investigation that prevent eith the? cause or the Failure Mode? Introduced 2-Slope Plots y-axis x-axis 50 Determined High Risk RPN steps for each batch record Grouped High Risk RPN Steps by Failure Mode Q FF Chrom Phenyl Chrom
13 Phase I - FMEA Assessment & RPN Scoring Of the 25 critical failure modes, 6 were selected to move into Phase II based on alignment with existing initiatives at Lonza and anticipated magnitude of impact The selected failure modes fell into categories such as - Skid or equipment preparation Process limitations Filter set-up/testing 13
14 Phase II RCA & Solution Identification Root causes were identified and solutions were created and prioritized Six Failure Modes (from FMEA Assessment Phase) Perform Root Cause Analysis for Each Failure Mode Group Root Causes Develop Solutions for Each Root Cause(s) Prep for Implementation Root Cause Analysis Workshops Training Root Cause Analysis Develop Fishbone Diagrams/ 5 Why s Converge on root causes Root cause grouping Identify teams for Solutions Solution Sessions Develop solution(s) for each root cause Rate solutions against batch record steps Develop Implementation Approach Management Team Review 14
15 Phase II RCA & Solution Identification RCA was performed for each of the six failure modes Cause & Effect Analysis Structured brainstorming of potential root causes Utilized fishbone diagrams 5Why s Asks why does that happen? Supports fishbone diagram by helping to drill deeper Large set Potential Root Causes Narrowing Narrows potential root causes down to the likely ones Based on judgment of the people who are familiar with the process Smaller set Likely Root Causes Selection Selects the root cause(s) for solution identification Based on qualitative/ ti quantitative basic data Actual Root Causes As a result, 23 actual root causes were identified 15
16 Phase II RCA & Solution Identification The 23 actual root causes were then grouped by affinity to help in the identification of teams and the approach for solution development... UF Operations Chromatography Operations Root Cause 1 Root Cause 2 Root Cause 3 Root Cause 4 Root Cause 5 Root Cause 6 Root Cause 7 Root Cause 11 Root Cause 12 Root Cause 13 Root Cause 14 Root Cause 15 Root Cause 16 Root Cause 17 Root Cause 18 Root Cause 19 Documentation Root Cause 8 Root Cause 9 Root Cause 10 Root Cause 20 Root Cause 21 Root Cause 22 Root Cause Filter Integrity Testing
17 Phase II RCA & Solution Identification Solutions for the 23 root causes were then developed and captured in a standard format... Solution Name: Root Cause: Install Vent to Improve Draining of Caustic Header in UF Developed By: Andy, Derek, Stuart, Dan Date: 01Apr2008 XXXXXX Failure Mode: Solution Description: XXXXXX Install block and bleed/vent after liquid filter housings of caustic tanks (T-35013/T-35014) to improve header draining. Solution Sketch/Notes: New vent & valve block Key Install block and bleed/vent after liquid id filter housings of Characteristics caustic tanks (T-35013/T-35014) of Solution: Engineering and Technical Requirements SOP updates Validation (I, Q, CSV) Controls work, EM s Equipment downtime to install Will likely require a vent filter Could be done with ambient or pressurized air Key Assumptions: Additional Benefits: Solution can be applied to chromatography skids as well Opening bleed/vent valve will provide a high point vent of drain line quickly and effectively Impact Rating: 750 No issues with pipe slope, introducing air to filter housing Don t change drain header from T Feasibility Rating: 3 Wet test required to better determine feasibility & impact Prioritization Index:
18 Phase II RCA & Solution Identification Solutions were then prioritized based on estimated impact and implementation feasibility Potential Impact to RPNs For each impacted batch record line item, we will calculate a potential RPN if the solution were to be implemented Example: Incorrect Probe Standardization 36 batch record line items are impacted 1. If solution were implemented, here is (Chrom & UF) what RPN we would For each impacted line item, we will assess expect solution impact 2. Potential impact of the solution Solution X for Incorrect Probe Standardization BR Line Item Baseline RPN RPN To Be RPN 1 USPO Ensure conductivity probes have been cleaned USPO Post standardization conductivity standard check result Feasibility of Implementation The team used this table to evaluate solution feasibility Feasibility Rating Extent of Control Within Team Within Group Within Plant Mgr. Impact on Customer Internal Change Control only (e.g. SOP Changes) Customer notified, no approval needed Customer signoff required as CC Capital Cost to Implement Time to Implement Resource Commitment $0 - $8K Days 0-20 hrs $8K - $25K Weeks hrs $25K - $50K Months hrs MORE FEASIBLE 36 USPO Standardize UF Sum of all conductivity probe RPN values Total Potential Impact of this Solution: Within NH Site Beyond NH Site FDA Notified; CMC filing changes necessary New Clinical trials / approval necessary $50K - $150K Quarters hrs >$150K > 1 year > 1600 hrs 8 Low feasibility number is better Proprietary & Confidential 17 RPN (beginning) RPN (estimated after action) Feasibility Rating = Solution Priority Index 18
19 Phase III Detailed Design & Implementation Detailed Design & Implementation typically includes the following Deployment Planning Detailed Design Implementationn Sustain Improvements Charter teams Develop detailed d Conduct testing/ ti Develop metrics and Develop design design for each validation tracking methods and implementation solution Complete SOP/ Develop processes to plan for each Conduct vendor Batch Record sustain improvements solution selection(s) as rollout and training Conduct regular required status/update reviews Ensure integration across the plans Establish timelines and milestones Complete SOP / Batch Record updates and obtain approvals Obtain management & customer approvals Implement solution elements Obtain management & customer sign-off Identify and implement continuous improvement ideas that occur in day Sprints to ensure focus and momentum. 19
20 Phase III Detailed Design & Implementation The schedule for these implementation Sprints typically looks as follows Month 1 Month 2 Month 3 Month 4 Month 5 Deployment Planning Detailed Design Implementation LEGEND: Wave 1 Sprint Sustain Improvements Deployment Planning Wave 2 Sprint Detailed Design Implementation This aligns with Lonza s overall Operational Excellence approach of Plan, Do, Check, Act Sustain Improve- ments 20
21 Current Status and Results Cross functional teams have begun, and in some cases completed, implementation of the 23 solutions as targeted projects utilizing the current systems within Lonza Implementation progress varies due to the nature and scope of the solution. Since most solutions were identified at a high level, Lonza was able to then take them through detailed design and into the implementation phase through its change control and document change systems. The solutions were mainly championed through Manufacturing with significant support from Engineering, Controls, Validation, and Quality Assurance. Benefits in terms of reduced failures are already being realized 21
22 Maxiom Group Overview Maxiom Group is a business and information technology consulting firm exclusively serving the life sciences industry Our clients include emerging, established, and mature Biotechnology, Pharmaceutical, Diagnostic and Medical Device companies Maxiom Group helps life science companies transform their strategies, business processes, and business systems to achieve excellence at each stage of their life cycle From drug discovery to clinical development From clinical development to commercial launch From commercial launch to market leadership Clients rely on our Focus, Insight and Approach to guide them in transforming their business and in addressing their ongoing business challenges 22
Chapter 6-1: Failure Modes Effect Analysis (FMCEA)
Chapter 6-1: Failure Modes Effect Analysis (FMCEA) Learning Outcomes: After careful studying this lecture You should be able: To Define FMEA To understand the use of Failure Modes Effect Analysis (FMEA)
More informationFMEA Failure Mode Effects Analysis. ASQ/APICS Joint Meeting May 10, 2017
FMEA Failure Mode Effects Analysis ASQ/APICS Joint Meeting May 10, 2017 FMEA (Failure Mode and Effects Analysis) Failure Mode and Effects Analysis Agenda What is it? Motivation FMEA Methods Examples What
More informationContinuous Improvement Toolkit. Risk Analysis. Continuous Improvement Toolkit.
Continuous Improvement Toolkit Risk Analysis The Continuous Improvement Map Managing Risk FMEA Understanding Performance Check Sheets Data Collection PDPC RAID Log* Risk Analysis* Fault Tree Analysis Traffic
More informationEXAMINING RISK FAILURE MODES EFFECT ANALYSIS (FMEA)
EXAMINING RISK FAILURE MODES EFFECT ANALYSIS (FMEA) LYNNE SLIVOVSKY CPE 450 W2016 Source: http://www.petzl.com/de/en/outdoor/headlamps/batteries 1 RISK IN A NUTSHELL Risk Description 5 [A] Vibration 4
More informationChapter 1 The Manufacturing Plant as a Business System
Chapter 1 The Manufacturing Plant as a Business System We tend to focus on snapshots of isolated parts of the system. And wonder why our deepest problems never get solved. Peter Senge The Scene Beta International
More informationAgenda. Enterprise Risk Management Defined. The Intersection of Enterprise-wide Risk Management (ERM) and Business Continuity Management (BCM)
The Intersection of Enterprise-wide Risk (ERM) and Business Continuity (BCM) Marc Dominus 2005 Protiviti Inc. EOE Agenda Terminology and Process Introductions ERM Process Overview BCM Process Overview
More informationIMPROVE. Chapter 3-6 FMEA Institute of Industrial Engineers 3-6-1
Chapter 3-6 FMEA 3-6-1 FMEA Definition A procedure by which each potential failure mode in a system is analyzed to determine the results of effects thereof on the system and to classify each potential
More informationSo, How Will You Audit a Risk Assessment in ISO 9001:2015?
So, How Will You Audit a Risk Assessment in ISO 9001:2015? Bob Deysher Senior Consultant Quality Support Group, Inc. bob.deysher@qualitysupportgroup.com 2017 QSG, Inc. Inc. Questions? Does ISO 9001:2015
More informationLIFE CYCLE FACILITY ASSET MANAGEMENT. Presented by Pedro Dominguez Managing Principal, The Invenio Group
LIFE CYCLE FACILITY ASSET MANAGEMENT Presented by Pedro Dominguez Managing Principal, The Invenio Group LEARNING OBJECTIVES Correlate the current business environment to the demands placed on facility
More informationSEEING THE FUTURE A REVIEW OF THE ISPE 2016 FACILITY OF THE FUTURE CONFERENCE. Phil McDuff VP Global Engineering Biogen
SEEING THE FUTURE A REVIEW OF THE ISPE 2016 FACILITY OF THE FUTURE CONFERENCE Phil McDuff VP Global Engineering Biogen Robert Chew President & CEO Commissioning Agents Inc. Jim McGlade Client Leader BHDP
More informationDaitan White Paper The Software Development versus Maintenance Dilemma COMMON MISCALCULATIONS IMPACT REVENUE AND MARKET SHARE
Daitan White Paper The Software Development versus Maintenance Dilemma COMMON MISCALCULATIONS IMPACT REVENUE AND MARKET SHARE Highly Reliable Software Development Services http://www.daitangroup.com Daitan
More informationRisk Based Validation. Why, How and with what tools?
Risk Based Validation Why, How and with what tools? Tech Talk Agenda History of FDA GMP initiative for the 21 st Century. Industry response to FDA initiative. Harmonisation through ICH. ASTM Standard on
More informationAvoiding the Most Frequent Joint Commission Laboratory Survey Findings using Robust Process Improvement Tools (RPI) AVOIDING THE MOST
Avoiding the Most Frequent Joint Commission Laboratory Survey Findings using Robust Process Improvement Tools (RPI) AVOIDING THE MOST FREQUENT JOINT COMMISSION LABORATORY SURVEY FINDINGS USING ROBUST PROCESS
More informationImprovement of the robustness of the purification process of the intravenous immunoglobulin product (10%) Gammagard Liquid/Kiovig
Improvement of the robustness of the purification process of the intravenous immunoglobulin product (10%) Gammagard Liquid/Kiovig Baxter BioScience F. Hupet, E. Felix, J. Van Malleghem, D. Delplace, C.
More informationArticle from: CompAct. April 2013 Issue No. 47
Article from: CompAct April 2013 Issue No. 47 Overview of Programmatic Framework and Key Considerations Key elements Description Items to consider Definition and identification of EUCs The statement that
More informationTable of Contents. Presented by
Table of Contents Presented by HighTech Business Decisions 3150 Almaden Expressway, Suite 222, San Jose, CA 95118 Tel: (408) 978-1035 Fax: (408) 978-8925 www.hightechdecisions.com May 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS
More informationIng.-Büro Pfeufer. FMEA Alignment AIAG and VDA. Join the conversation: #AQMS2018 VDA QMC
Ing.-Büro Pfeufer New Your global Workshop FMEA Title standard Goes Here FMEA Alignment AIAG and VDA Join the conversation: #AQMS2018 Status November 2018 FMEA Alignment AIAG and VDA Project Leader: AIAG:
More information17/12/1437. Lecture. Project Scope Management. Lecture 4. Project Management Knowledge Areas Section 3 Chapter 5. Project Scope Management.
17/12/137 Project Management Knowledge Areas Section 3 Chapter 5 Project Scope Management 2 of 33 1 17/12/137 Quick Re-cab Plan Scope Management Collect Requirement Define Scope Create WBS Validate Scope
More informationRisk comes from not knowing what you are doing.
A major focus shift in ISO 900:20 vs 2008 and associated industry specific standards is the emphasis on risk management. I will offer my insights into risk management to achieve sustained success in supply
More informationSystematic Risk Management: An Overview of ICH Q-9
Systematic Risk Management: An Overview of ICH Q-9 March 12, 2014 12014 ParagonRx International LLC Today s Session Systematic Risk Management: An Overview of ICH Q-9 Speakers: Jeff Fetterman, President,
More informationGxP Auditing, Remediation, and Staff Augmentation
GxP Auditing, Remediation, and Staff Augmentation TABLE OF CONTENTS 3 Introduction 4 GxP Auditing 4 GMP Auditing 5 GCP Auditing 5 GLP Auditing 6 Pharmacovigilance Auditing 6 Vendor/Supplier Auditing 7
More informationRobert Posgai Director of Materials Procurement, Biogen (BPOG)
Keynote Speaker Building the Foundations for Excellence in Biopharmaceutical Raw Material Supply Chain and Impact of Modality on Excipient Expectations Robert Posgai Director of Materials Procurement,
More informationImprove Septic Billing
Improve Septic Billing Define Green Belt: Tiffany Dunkley 1 Define Phase 1.Identify and Scope Project 1. Identify the specific problem that needs to be solved per the business case or other source. 2.
More informationWelcome ISO9001:2015 /ISO14001:2015
Welcome ISO9001:2015 /ISO14001:2015 DQS 2017 All rights reserved. Unless otherwise specified, no part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized otherwise in any form or by any means, electronic
More informationinventivhealthclinical.com The Goal: Reducing Uncertainty A Word on RBM
Seeing Around Corners: Risk Assessment Is the Foundation of Risk-Based Monitoring By: Jeff Fetterman, President ParagonRX, an inventiv Health Company, Michael Macri, Director, Strategic Services, inventiv
More informationTechnical leadership in a world that values business results.
Technical leadership in a world that values business results. May 1, 2015 Victor Moudgil MS, MBA Certified Lean Six Sigma Black Belt Victor.Moudgil@gmail.com www.innsys.com The content of this document
More informationLG SOURCING VENDOR QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS
LG SOURCING VENDOR QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS LG Sourcing QMS ver01 03.29.2010 Page 1 of 16 PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK Copyright 2010, LF Corporation - All rights reserved No part of this
More informationDeveloping QC Plans Part 3. Performing a Risk Assessment to Identify Hazards and Target Failure Modes
Webinar Series sponsored by Thermo Fisher Scientific Developing QC Plans Part 3. Performing a Risk Assessment to Identify Hazards and Target Failure Modes James O. Westgard Sten A. Westgard Westgard QC,
More informationGxP Auditing, Remediation, and Staff Augmentation
GxP Auditing, Remediation, and Staff Augmentation TABLE OF CONTENTS 3 Introduction 4 GxP Auditing 4 GMP Auditing 5 GCP Auditing 6 GLP Auditing 7 Pharmacovigilance Auditing 7 Vendor/Supplier Auditing 8
More informationAchieving Operational Excellence in Pharma & Biotech Adapting best practice to meet the unique characteristics of the industry
Achieving Operational Excellence in Pharma & Biotech Adapting best practice to meet the unique characteristics of the industry Executive Summary With the pharmaceutical industry currently going through
More informationThe Impact of Quality Culture on Quality Risk Management. FDA Perspective on Quality Culture; how it Impacts Risk Management
The Impact of Quality Culture on Quality Risk Management FDA Perspective on Quality Culture; how it Impacts Risk Management Teresa Gorecki Practice Lead Compliance Architects Agenda The WHAT Definitions
More informationA COMPARATIVE FRAMEWORK BETWEEN NEW PRODUCT & LEGACY PRODUCT PROCESS VALIDATION
A COMPARATIVE FRAMEWORK BETWEEN NEW PRODUCT & LEGACY PRODUCT PROCESS VALIDATION By Mark Mitchell, Principal Consultant, Process and Engineering, Pharmatech Associates, Inc. PHARMATECH WHITE PAPER.DOCX
More informationPMO In A Box. Prepared for UBS
PMO In A Box Prepared for UBS Roadmap Why PMO In A Box? Establish PMO Governance Standardize Methodology Create a Stakeholder Partnership Plan 2 PMOs Are In Transition 3 CEB PMO Executive Council pmo in
More informationQualification and Delivery of All Things Pharmaceutical. Blaik C Jensen Associate Quality Engineering Consultant
Qualification and Delivery of All Things Pharmaceutical Blaik C Jensen Associate Quality Engineering Consultant Commissioning and Qualification Sequence Design Follows the methodology found in the ISPE
More informationDefining Project Scope
Defining Project Scope Casey Ayers PMP MBA CaseyAyers.com @caseyayers linkedin.com/in/caseyayers PMP is a registered mark of the Project Management Institute, Inc. Module Overview Overview Project Scope
More informationSterilizing and Bioburden Filter Risk Assessment in Vaccine Processes as part of QRM
Sterilizing and Bioburden Filter Risk Assessment in Vaccine Processes as part of QRM DCVMN Workshop, Hyderabad, 4-8 April 2016 G. Somasundaram Associate Director - Technology Management Overview Key Regulatory
More informationDefect Intelligence A Must-have for Building World-class Quality
Defect Intelligence A Must-have for Building World-class Quality By Karthik Padmanabhan Karthik.padmanabhan@cognizant.com Karthikeyan Shanmuga Shanmuga.karthikeyan@cognizant.com Cognizant Technology Solutions,
More informationHow To Manage a Troubled Project GTC Center for Project Management, All Rights Reserved
How To Manage a Troubled Project GTC 2007 1 How To Manage a Troubled Project 2 Logistics Start and finish Breaks and lunch Morning: one 15-minute break Lunch: 60 minutes Afternoon: one 15-minute break
More informationPROJECT QUALITY MANAGEMENT. 1 Powered by POeT Solvers LImited
PROJECT QUALITY MANAGEMENT 1 www.pmtutor.org Powered by POeT Solvers LImited WHAT S PROJECT QUALITY MANAGEMENT? WHAT S PROJECT QUALITY MANAGEMENT? Project Quality Management processes include all the activities
More informationWhile the recognition
Designing the Perfect Change Control System Change control systems today are expected to be designed in a way that provides a system to not only document and approve changes, but also to anticipate change
More informationThis resource is associated with the following paper: Assessing the maturity of software testing services using CMMI-SVC: an industrial case study
RESOURCE: MATURITY LEVELS OF THE CUSTOMIZED CMMI-SVC FOR TESTING SERVICES AND THEIR PROCESS AREAS This resource is associated with the following paper: Assessing the maturity of software testing services
More informationSoftware Project & Risk Management Courses Offered by The Westfall Team
Software Project & Risk Management is a 5-day course designed to provide a knowledge base and practical skills for anyone interested in implementing or improving Software Project and Risk Management techniques
More informationGxP Auditing, Remediation, and Quality System Resourcing
GxP Auditing, Remediation, and Quality System Resourcing TABLE OF CONTENTS 3 Introduction 4 GxP Auditing 4 GMP Auditing 5 GCP Auditing 6 GLP Auditing 7 Pharmacovigilance Auditing 7 Vendor/Supplier Auditing
More informationGUIDE TO THE CHANGES IN PMP simpl learn i
GUIDE TO THE CHANGES IN PMP- 2015 simpl learn i Table of contents Introduction the purpose of this manual 1 New Tasks: Initiating 3 New Tasks: Planning 4 New Tasks: Executing 6 New Tasks: Monitoring and
More informationLeft to Our Own Devices Design Control & Risk Management Strategies for Combination Products
Left to Our Own Devices Design Control & Risk Management Strategies for Combination Products DR. RICK WEDGE 12 MAR 2018 Overview Definitions Current Regulatory Landscape Design Controls Risk Management
More informationQbD BASED SCALE UP SERVICES THE DPT LABS APPROACH
DPT Thought Leadership Issue 14: 4 th in a Series QbD BASED SCALE UP SERVICES THE DPT LABS APPROACH INTRODUCTION This paper describes the approach and benefits of using DPT Labs QbD Scale Up service and
More informationHow a project approach will build change management capability across your organization
capability across your How a project approach will build change management capability across your Prosci Webinar How a project approach will build change management Enterprise Change Management Organizational
More informationTRANSFORM SAFETY CULTURE USING SIX SIGMA TOOLS. Mike Williamsen Ph.D. CSP
TRANSFORM SAFETY CULTURE USING SIX SIGMA TOOLS Mike Williamsen Ph.D. CSP AGENDA Safety Culture Models Overview Diagnostics - Safety Perception Surveys - Field Interviews Continuous Improvement Team Fundamentals
More informationPMP. Processexam.com. PMI Project Management Professional. Exam Summary Syllabus Questions
PMP PMI Project Management Professional Processexam.com Exam Summary Syllabus Questions Table of Contents Keys to success in PMP Exam on PMI Project Management Professional... 2 PMI PMP Certification Details:...
More informationPrequalification Team Inspection services WHO PUBLIC INSPECTION REPORT (WHOPIR) Finished Product Manufacturer. Tablets
Prequalification Team Inspection services WHO PUBLIC INSPECTION REPORT (WHOPIR) Finished Product Manufacturer Part 1: information about the inspection Name of manufacturer Physical address production departments
More informationIntegration Knowledge Area
Integration Knowledge Area Develop Project Charter Project statement of work Expert judgment Project charter Business case Contract (if third party project) EEF: government/industry standards, organizational
More informationISSN: ISO 9001:2008 Certified International Journal of Engineering Science and Innovative Technology (IJESIT) Volume 2, Issue 2, March 2013
FMEA Analysis for Reducing Breakdowns of a Sub System in the Life Care Product Manufacturing Industry Rakesh.R, Bobin Cherian Jos, George Mathew Abstract This paper provides the use of Failure Mode and
More informationIntroduction to Design for Sigma. Developed By
Introduction to Design for Sigma Developed By T. Lahdhiri, PhD, PE, PMP, BB-DFSS Introduction Sigma and Design for Six Sigma Measuring Quality - Sigma Quality: is the degree of completeness and perfection
More informationTHANK YOU! 5 PROJECT MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES TO TRANSFORM. Learning Objectives YOUR LEADERSHIP PERFORMANCE. Kristina Krail, MPH, RN, NEA-BC, FACHE, PMP
5 PROJECT MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES TO TRANSFORM YOUR LEADERSHIP PERFORMANCE Kristina Krail, MPH, RN, NEA-BC, FACHE, PMP November 8, 2016 2:30 PM 3:30 PM Session 132 Learning Objectives 1 2 3 To recognize
More informationQuality Overview. This is a photographic template your photograph should fit precisely within this rectangle.
This is a photographic template your photograph should fit precisely within this rectangle. Quality Overview 2008 Eaton Corporation. All rights reserved. Quality Quotes Quality is never an accident; it
More informationInitiation Group Process. Planning Group Process
Initiation Group Process Develop Project Charter Project statement of work Expert judgment Project charter Business case Contract (if third party project) EEF: government/industry standards, organizational
More informationPMP Exam Preparation Course Project Scope Management
Project Scope Management 1 Product Scope Product scope The features and functions that are to be included in your products or service or result of the project. Completion is measured against the product
More informationREQUIREMENTS DOCUMENTATION
REQUIREMENTS DOCUMENTATION Project Title: Date Prepared: Stakeholder Requirement Category Priority Acceptance Criteria REQUIREMENTS DOCUMENTATION Project Title: Date Prepared: Stakeholder Requirement Category
More informationRisk Based Testing. -Why we need RBT? -Types of risks -Managing risks -Methods of evaluation & risk analysis -Costs and benefits
Risk Based Testing -Why we need RBT? -Types of risks -Managing risks -Methods of evaluation & risk analysis -Costs and benefits Ladislau Szilagyi www.euroqst.ro Definitions (ISTQB glossary) Risk = a factor
More informationYou don t know, what you don t know.
You don t know, what you don t know. Building an Enhanced CMMS to Prioritize Maintenance and Manage Risk - a Pilot Study at New York City s North River Wastewater Treatment Plant Gerald FitzGibbon 1, April
More informationIs your customer experience making an impact?
Is your customer experience making an impact? Or not? Workshops to help you accelerate to your next great customer experience Your CX Trek 1 2 3 Getting Started: Digital Foundation Increasing Momentum:
More informationIdentification and Control of Critical Process Points Using Complementary Risk Assessments (corrected)
Identification and Control of Critical Process Points Using Complementary Risk Assessments (corrected) Karen McCullough MMI Associates (908) 534-6463 PDA Metro Chapter Day June 2, 2009 RISK is a four letter
More informationM. Lynn Penn Lockheed Martin Integrated Systems and Solutions November 2004
Integrating CMMI and Six Sigma in Software and Systems Engineering M. Lynn Penn Lockheed Martin Integrated Systems and Solutions November 2004 Agenda IS&S Training Lean Thinking Technology Change Management
More informationHow To s and How Not To s for Data Integrity Governance Programs
How To s and How Not To s for Data Integrity Governance Programs A Case Study Cathlin Shapiro August 17, 2017 Data Integrity Governance Programs Covering all the Bases 2 Current Environment Risk Factors
More informationQuality Management System Guidance. ISO 9001:2015 Clause-by-clause Interpretation
Quality Management System Guidance ISO 9001:2015 Clause-by-clause Interpretation Table of Contents 1 INTRODUCTION... 4 1.1 IMPLEMENTATION & DEVELOPMENT... 5 1.2 MANAGING THE CHANGE... 5 1.3 TOP MANAGEMENT
More informationEnsuring An Effective Quality System. M. Kowolenko, Ph.D. SVP, Biopharmaceutical Operations & Technology
Ensuring An Effective Quality System M. Kowolenko, Ph.D. SVP, Biopharmaceutical Operations & Technology Role of the Quality Unit Compliance with all relevant regulations and commitments made in license
More informationProject Management Professional (PMP)
Project Management Professional (PMP) E X A M I N AT I O N CO N T E N T O U T L I N E Project Management Institute Project Management Professional (PMP) Examination Content Outline June 2015 Published
More informationOverview Engineering Unit
Overview Engineering Unit 2016 Montgomery County Community College Biomanufacturing Engineering Requirements A successful and productive biomanufacturing facility must meet and adhere to certain engineering
More informationRiskyProject Professional 7
RiskyProject Professional 7 Project Risk Management Software Getting Started Guide Intaver Institute 2 Chapter 1: Introduction to RiskyProject Intaver Institute What is RiskyProject? RiskyProject is advanced
More informationComplex Care Program Development: A New Framework for Design and Evaluation
BRIEF MARCH 2017 Complex Care Program Development: A New Framework for Design and Evaluation By David Labby, MD, PhD * IN BRIEF While medical-technological interventions undergo robust research and design
More informationLarry Strouse Railroad Safety Specialist (HM) Federal Railroad Administration
Transportation Technology Center, Inc., a subsidiary of the Association of American Railroads Larry Strouse Railroad Safety Specialist (HM) Federal Railroad Administration Root Cause Analysis 3:00 to 3:30
More informationRealize and Sustain the Value of Your Micro Focus Implementation
White Paper Professional Services Realize and Sustain the Value of Your Micro Focus Implementation Micro Focus Professional Services provides Solution Management Services to help you fully utilize, manage,
More informationTHE CASE FOR QUALITY: MOVING FROM COMPLIANCE TO PERFORMANCE IN THE REGULATORY WORLD
THE CASE FOR QUALITY: MOVING FROM COMPLIANCE TO PERFORMANCE IN THE REGULATORY WORLD NAME: Ron Lear TITLE: CMMI Institute Architect ORGANIZATION: CMMI Institute Learning Objectives Discuss the drawbacks
More informationProject Importance: Revision History: Project Charter
Page 1/8 Project Title: CSU Brewery Automation Date: 9/16/2016 Team Members: Mechanical Engineers Julia Tucker and Andrew Ross Chemical and Biological Engineers Briana Chamberlain and Keaton Sloan Computer
More informationQuality Assurance / Quality Control Plan
Quality Assurance / Quality Control Plan Table of Contents MANAGEMENT APPROACH... 3 SUBCONTRACT MANAGEMENT... 3 QUALITY MANAGEMENT APPROACH... 3 METHODOLOGY... 4 CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS... 5 QUALITY MANAGEMENT
More informationStartup Planning Process Overview
G S U M Startup Planning Process Overview Revision Date: Revision Number: Owner: Startup Leader: Interface with Eng/Const/PDD/Purchasing a. Preliminary C&F complete b. Final C&F complete c. EO's/Line Trials
More informationWorkplace HSE & Process Safety Consultancy
Company Profile Applied KPI Ltd provides consultancy in the following business critical disciplines: Process Safety; and Workplace HSE (Health, Safety and Environment). About Us Applied KPI was founded
More informationIntegrated Quality Systems
Integrated Quality Systems Introduction THE PRODUCT IQS provides a powerful and proven solution that offers a unique model for integrating quality systems to achieve superior enterprise-wide performance.
More informationIntroducing Risk Based Testing to Organizations
Introducing Risk Based Testing to Organizations Abridged Version Dr. Rajesh Subramanyan Software Engineering Siemens Corporate Research Princeton NJ. Rajesh.subramanyan@siemens.com Outline Topics Introduction
More informationFMEA Saves Business From Shutdown A Case Study
FMEA Saves Business From Shutdown A Case Study Rai Chowdhary M. S., CQE, CQM rai_chowdhary@yahoo.com www.hownwhy.com 2001 Quality and Productivity Research Conference Austin, Texas May 22-25 2001 Topics
More information10/24/18. Printed document is uncontrolled after 10/24/2018, unless in a controlled book
10/24/18 Table of Contents Description Page CTA Acoustics Expectations 1 How to submit samples 2 How to process Corrective Action 3-7 How to request a temporary or permanent change 8-9 How your performance
More informationDriving Value through Innovation in Biotech Manufacturing. Agenda
Driving Value through Innovation in Biotech Manufacturing Jorg Thommes, PhD Senior Vice President Operations Technology and Innovation Biogen 7 October 2015 Agenda Biopharma Legacy, Trends, & Challenges
More informationMaterion AMTS Supplier Quality Manual
Advanced Materials Technologies and Services Inc. Materion AMTS Supplier Quality Manual Supplier Name: Supplier Address: Suppliers shall review the attached Supplier Quality Manual and acknowledge receipt
More informationBuildingEngines. Operations Performance Management (OPM) Don t Just Work... Perform. Success Kit. Operations Performance Management
Success Kit Market: Commercial Real Estate Role: All Purpose: Education Operations Performance Management (OPM) The last several years have brought a number of dramatic changes to your business. Today,
More informationJust the Facts. 12 missteps that can trip up your CAPA and ways to sidestep them
FEATURE CAPA Pitfalls and Pratfalls 12 missteps that can trip up your CAPA and ways to sidestep them by José Rodríguez-Pérez and Manuel E. Peña-Rodríguez Just the Facts A corrective and preventive action
More informationTransferring a process to a contract
Reprinted from PHARMACEUTICAL ENGINEERING The Official Magazine of ISPE July/August 2010, Vol. 30 No. 4 www.ispe.org Copyright ISPE 2010 This article presents a process transfer case study and the significance
More informationChallenges Integrating Regulatory Filings and Pre-Approval Inspection with the Expectations of Current Regulatory Guidance
Challenges Integrating Regulatory Filings and Pre-Approval Inspection with the Expectations of Current Regulatory Guidance Tony Mire-Sluis Vice President, North America, Singapore, Abingdon, Contract and
More informationBioprocessing Challenges: High-Titer Mammalian-Based Cell Systems. Elements influencing the way Biologics may be manufactured /supplied in the future
Bioprocessing Challenges: High-Titer Mammalian-Based Cell Systems Jonathan Romero CMC Leadership, Technical Development Pharmaceutical Operations & Technology 2015 ISPE PRODUCT SHOW Business Drivers Elements
More informationPROJECT SCOPE MANAGEMENT. 1 Powered by POeT Solvers Limited
PROJECT SCOPE MANAGEMENT 1 www.pmtutor.org Powered by POeT Solvers Limited At the end of this training, our goal is for you to: Be able to define the term scope Be able to identify primary sources who
More informationBest Practices for. new product development
Integrating Medical Device Product Development, Design for Six Sigma and Quality Systems Regulation Part I By Dr Vinny Sastri This article was originally published in Medical Device & Diagnostic Industry,
More informationProject Quality Management
1 Project Quality Management Unit 8 Eng.elsaka09@gmail.com Project Quality Management Includes the processes and activities of the performing organization that determine quality policies, objectives, and
More informationTop Annual 483 Observations: The Cycle of Quality June 2017 Presented by: Susan Schniepp
Top Annual 483 Observations: The Cycle of Quality June 2017 Presented by: Susan Schniepp 2016 Regulatory Compliance Associates Inc. Top Observation for 5 years Year Drugs #1 citation Device #1 citation
More informationMalay (Rumi, Roman script)
Hai Malay (Rumi, Roman script) Project Management Process Groups Project Integration Management Initiating Planning Executing Scope Monitoring & Controlling Closing Knowledge Areas Time Cost Quality Human
More informationCOMMERCIAL PRODUCT STABILITY
COMMERCIAL PRODUCT STABILITY Being Responsible for your Tweener, Senior Citizen and Hospice Stage Products Melissa Lambert Global Head Stability in Quality & Compliance Management, R&D Director Quality
More informationKey Account Management: 4 Steps to Growing Revenue From Your Key Accounts
Key Account Management: 4 Steps to Growing Revenue From Your Key Accounts It is estimated to be 7x easier to sell to an existing account than it is to open a new account. A company s customers are their
More informationA Case Study on the Application of Disposable Technologies in cgmp Manufacturing Processes for a Therapeutic Antibody.
A Case Study on the Application of Disposable Technologies in cgmp Manufacturing Processes for a Therapeutic Antibody. Jeremy M Tong (presenting), Mark S Kettel, Edward M Perry, David J Pain, David M Valentine,
More informationEXAMINATION CONTENT OUTLINE-6
PM tutor Empowering Excellence NEW PMP EXAMINATION CONTENT OUTLINE-6 BY DIPO TEPEDE, PMP, SSBB, MBA Learning Goals Domain 2 Planning The Project Explain the focus of this domain Describe the tasks in this
More informationRisk Management How are l l oca i compan es doing today?
Risk Management How are local l companies doing today? SIUE Project Mgmt Symposium Panel Mr. Doug Ascoli - Ameren Mr. Wes Frick - Boeing Retiree Ms. Mary Ann Gates - Gates IT Consulting Services Agenda
More informationChallenges and Opportunities in the Development of integrated Drug Device Combination Products CMC Strategy Forum, Tokyo, 5 December 2017
Challenges and Opportunities in the Development of integrated Drug Device Combination Products CMC Strategy Forum, Tokyo, 5 December 2017 F. Wildenhahn, Human Factors Engineering & U. Grauschopf, Head
More information