Zugspitze Solar FTIR: NDSC Primary-Status Instrument cm-1 resolution (OPD = 486 cm) Bruker IFS120HR FT-spectrometer

Similar documents
NDACC differences to TCCON German contribution to NIDFORVal & TCCON4S5P CO an CH 4 validation strategy

The FP7 NORS project and way forward: The evolution of NDACC and perspectives for satellite validation.

Retrieval of formaldehyde from FTIR spectra preliminary results

VALIASI - Validation of IASI trace gas. Acknowledgments. retrievals by GB - FTIR measurements. Sven Kühl

In-situ Ozone Observations at Zugspitze (2962 m) from 1978 to 2008

COPERNICUS Air quality monitoring satellite missions and user needs

Electric Forward Market Report

IASI AND IASI NG, MERLIN, MICROCARB FOR CH 4 AND CO 2 OBS. IN THE TROPOSPHERE

Administration Division Public Works Department Anchorage: Performance. Value. Results.

California Independent System Operator Corporation. California ISO. Import resource adequacy. Department of Market Monitoring

NOxy Measurements at Hohenpeissenberg Meteorological Observatory

Chapter 6 Planning and Controlling Production: Work-in-Process and Finished-Good Inventories. Omar Maguiña Rivero

Progress of GOSAT Project in 2012 and 2013

CEOS Intercalibration of Ground-Based Spectrometers and Lidars

Potential Impact of Biomass Burning on Urban Air Quality: Case-study of Chiang Mai

Woking. q business confidence report

University of Michigan Eco-Driving Index (EDI) Latest data: August 2017


TL 9000 Quality Management System. Measurements Handbook. BRR Examples

DOAS Meeting Feb

MAPPING OF THE CARBON DIOXIDE MID-TROPOSPHERIC MIXING RATIO AND METHANE TOTAL COLUMN FROM HYPERSPECTRAL SOUNDERS DATA

MONITORING AIR POLLUTION AT GLOBAL SCALE USING IASI THERMAL INFRARED INSTRUMENT

Mapping smallholder agriculture using simulated Sentinel-2 data; optimization of a Random Forest-based approach and evaluation on Madagascar site

2017 KEY INSIGHTS ON. Employee Attendance and Tardiness

Approach to Maize and Wheat Crop Forecast

THREE YEARS OF SCIAMACHY CARBON MONOXIDE MEASUREMENTS

The Baltic Proper Ecosystem & Climate Change

ECVS IN THE STRATOSPHERE

Climate Change Impacts for the Central Coast and Hunter Regions

State of play for a European operational monitoring system for fossil fuel CO 2 emissions

Trace Gas Performance of Sentinel 4 UVN on Meteosat Third Generation

ESA Climate Change Initiative (CCI) Version 1.0, revision February Author: Will Hewson

Stuart McDermid Table Mountain Facility Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology

The recent increase of methane from 10 years of NDACC ground-based FTIR observations

Peter Randall Solar Kingdom Ltd

Land surface albedo and downwelling shortwave radiation from MSG: Retrieval, validation and impact assessment in NWP and LSM models

Assessing PV Potential on New York City s Network Distribution System

Expert Meeting on Crop Monitoring for Improved Food Security, 17 February 2014, Vientiane, Lao PDR. By: Scientific Context

Traffic Department Anchorage: Performance. Value. Results.

Sales Forecast for Rossmann Stores SUBMITTED BY: GROUP A-8

Sentinels for Agriculture Global, Operational, Open, Reliable

Midtropospheric CO 2 Concentration derived from infrared and microwave sounders. Application to the TOVS, AIRS/AMSU, and IASI/AMSU instruments.

SOLAR RADIATION ESTIMATION UNDER CLEAR SKY CONDITIONS FOR BRAŞOV AREA (ROMANIA) LINKE TURBIDITY FACTOR

Lucas Finco NY INFORMS October 2014

Total Carbon Column Observing Network. Paul Wennberg, David Griffith, Justus Notholt, Tae-Young Goo & TCCON network partners

The Arctic Energy Budget

Soil moisture (and vegetation?) remote sensing products in Oklahoma

CHS. Midwest Cooperatives. Pre-Harvest Marketing Plan

Product Specification Document. Tropospheric NO 2

Development of Carbon Data Products for the Coastal Ocean: Implications for Advanced Ocean Color Sensors

Crop Monitoring for Food Security from Space

The Call Center Balanced Scorecard

Study of Water Quality using Satellite data

TARGET GASES: CFC-11, CFC-12, HCFC-22, HCFC-142b, CCl 4, CH 3 Cl, CF 4, SF 6

Forest Biomass Change Detection Using Lidar in the Pacific Northwest. Sabrina B. Turner Master of GIS Capstone Proposal May 10, 2016

Raynet Software Lifecycle

Air Quality Applications of Satellite Remote Sensing

Total Column Ozone Measurements at Visakhapatnam Using Microtops - II Sun-photometer

Observations of the terrestrial carbon cycle

Technical note on seasonal adjustment for Non oil exports

Traffic Division Public Works Department Anchorage: Performance. Value. Results.

Department of Transportation Rapid City Region Office 2300 Eglin Street P.O. Box 1970 Rapid City, SD Phone: 605/ FAX: 605/

Future climate scenarios for phosphorus and nitrogen dynamics in the Gulf of Riga

PEACE RIVER MANASOTA REGIONAL WATER SUPPLY AUTHORITY BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING December 5, 2018 ROUTINE STATUS REPORTS ITEM 1

Raynet Software Lifecycle

Radiation protection at a reprocessing plant. Jim Bishop Head of Radiological Protection Sellafield

Estimating aerosol emissions by assimilating aerosol optical depth in a global aerosol model

Climate-induced tree response in the forest-tundra and forest-steppe ecotones

GRUAN ICM-4 visit to NIES/CGER, March 8, The GOSAT Project. Tatsuya Yokota

The Market Watch Monthly Housing Report

MONTHLY OPERATIONS REPORT

Municipal Solid Waste Characteristics

Koeberg Nuclear Power Station. Water Resilience Strategy. Presenter: Velaphi Ntuli Date: 14 February 2018

GOSAT. -CO 2 and CH 4 measurements from space - Tatsuya Yokota

Models are an Integral Part of ABC Studies

The EUMETSAT Satellite Application Facility on Land Surface Analysis (LSA SAF) Continuous Development 2 Phase

Climate Change Impact Assessments: Uncertainty at its Finest. Josh Cowden SFI Colloquium July 18, 2007

Appendix C Baseline Tatelkuz Lake Levels

Appendix 3A Water Demand Projections

Development of Microsatellite in Monitoring Initial Harmful Algal Bloom (HAB) Presenting by: TAN AIK KWAN Univesiti Sains Malaysia (USM)

Chain Linking and Annual Update of Weights for Producer Price Indices for Services in Italy

Monitoring of trace-gases, pollution and aerosols with EUMETSAT satellite instruments

City of San Clemente Water Usage Report

EUMETSAT current activities on desert targets

The monthly variation of the Business Turnover 1 stands at 1.6%, after seasonal and calendar adjustment

DEVELOPING A MEDIA ADVOCACY ACTION PLAN

A New Type of Hybrid Groundwater Energy System

Supplemental Lighting in High-Wire Cucumber Production on Raised- Troughs

2016 ISO Flexible Capacity Needs Assessment: Study Methodology, Assumptions, and Preliminary Results

WATER SHORTAGE RESPONSE PLAN

Media Planning and Strategy

CHP Case Studies. Midwest CHP Application Center (MAC) .org (312) University of Illinois at Chicago Energy Resources Center UIC

Surveys Show Insuladd Saves Energy!

Current status of the FRM 4 DOAS project

Wind Update. Renewable Energy Integration Lessons Learned. March 28, 2012

Water planning and climate change: actionable intelligence yet?

Sample Reports. for. HAP v4.80 Example Problem

Title Assessment of PM pollution in the Arctic from European sources with the EMEP model (2006)

Root zone soil moisture and drought indices

Proceedings of the Kanyakumari Academy of Arts and Sciences Physics O 7 TOTAL COLUMNAR OZONE CONTENT OVER NAGERCOIL DATA SMOOTHING AND ANALYSIS

Transcription:

Zugspitze Solar FTIR: NDSC Primary-Status Instrument 0.00186 cm-1 resolution (OPD = 486 cm) Bruker IFS120HR FT-spectrometer SFIT1.09e/2.38 FASCATM 2.03 raytracing

SCIAMACHY Validation by FTIR at Zugspitze: Schedule, Activity Species: CO, CH4, N2O, O3, NO2 Contract-Committment: Commissioning Phase: Intense measurement phase between L+3 and L+6; measurement intensity: two weeks per month; columns be made available within 45 days. Main validation phase: Intense measurement phase between L + 6 and L + 18 months; measurement intensity: one week per month; columns will be made available within 90 days. Long-term validation phase: L+18 project end: Routine operation (once a week). We did much more: permanent 4 weeks per month operation on all clear sky days 5.5 months Commissioning Phase : including weekends 15 July - 31 Dec 2002: 60 Measurement days at Zugspitze within first 5.5 months. Main validation phase: 15 July 2002 1 July 2003: 127 measurement days within first 11.5 months. All retrievals have been submitted to Cal/Val database Long-term validation phase: 15 July 2002 15 Oct 2004: 278 measurement days within 27 months = 2.3 measurement days / week.

Zugspitze FTIR: Relative Activity during Commissioning (15 Jul 1 Dec 2002) Measurement Days 15 Jul 1 Dec 02 Data submitted to the Cal/Val data base 15 Jul 1 Dec 02 Lauder Zugspitze Wollongong 60 Jungfraujoch Kiruna Izana 40 20 0 Arrival Heights Egbert Harestua Ny Alesund Kitt Peak Proc. ESA-ACVE1 Meeting, Dec 2002

Permanent Ground Truthing Facility Zugspitze/Garmisch according to the WMO requirements. Validation of and Synergistic use with Satellite Measurements MAPS, MOPITT, SAGE, ENVISAT Selected by EUMETSAT as European Site for operational AIRS/IASI Validation FTIR In situ IFU GPS 2964 m Zugspitze UV LIDAR IFU Radio sondes IFU LIDAR Example: 2002 AIRSVAL Campaign 3-months-7-days-a-week operation data delivery twice a day within 12 h FTIR IFU Garmisch GPS UV In situ 734 m

Zugspitze FTIR: Quality control/intercomparison (taken from Report Form 2003 ): Name, date, and location of last intercomparison and/or validation: 1996 intercomparison with Jungfraujoch: coincident measurements and independent analyses of HF, HCl. Agreement within 2 per cent In 2001 evaluation of the Zugspitze time series since 1995 of HCl and ClONO2, and comparison to the Jungfraujoch series; showed very good overall agreement! In spring 2003 comparison of the Zugspitze time series (1996-2002) of CO to the Jungfraujoch series; showed very good overall agreement! Intense 3 months water vapor validation campaign at Zugspitze (mid Aug mid Nov 2002) with permanent FTIR water vapor measurements compared to 4 radio sondes launched on site daily and permanent GPS water column measurements on site. Very good agreement of FTIR to sonde columns within a few per cent! Detailed FTIR validation study also relative to GPS measurements under way.

Zugspitze FTIR: Quality control/intercomparison Example CO Yurganov, et al., J. Geophys. Res. 109, 2004

Zugspitze FTIR: Quality control/intercomparison Zugspitze (2964 m) Total Column + also done for all other species! 4,7E+18 Jungfraujoch (3580 m) Total Column 4,6E+18 Zugspitze Partial Column above 3580 m 4,5E+18 4,4E+18 Column (cm-2) Example N2O 4,3E+18 4,2E+18 4,1E+18 4,0E+18 3,9E+18 3,8E+18 939,000 939,200 939,400 939,600 939,800 940,000 MJD2000 940,200 940,400 940,600 940,800

Ozone Operational NRT Product - July 2003: FTIR versus SCIA DOAS0 (UV) 1,4E+19 SCIA: Daily average of all pixels within 500-km radius Version 3.51 Version 3.52 Total Column (cm-2) FTIR: Individual measurements (15-min integr.) FTIR Zugspitze Column 1,2E+19 Version 3.53 Version 4.00 Version 4.01 1,0E+19 8,0E+18 6,0E+18 4,0E+18 Jul 02 Aug 02 Okt 02 Nov 02 Jan 03 Mrz 03 Apr 03 Jun 03 Time of year 2002/03

Ozone Operational Product - April 2004: FTIR versus SCIA Master Set Total Column (cm-2) 1.1E+19 1.0E+19 9.0E+18 8.0E+18 7.0E+18 6.0E+18 Zugspitze FTIR: individual measurements 5.0E+18 SCIA Master Set DOAS_0; individ. pixels within 500 km 4.0E+18 Jul-02 Aug-02 Sep-02 Oct-02 Oct-02 Nov-02 Dec-02

Ozone Operational Dec 2004: FTIR versus SCIA Master Set and Reprocessing 1.3E+19 SCIA Master Set; averages of pixels within 500 km Total Column (cm-2) 1.2E+19 1.1E+19 Zugspitze FTIR daily averages 1.0E+19 9.0E+18 SCIA Reprocessing; averages of pixels within 500 km 8.0E+18 7.0E+18 6.0E+18 5.0E+18 Jul-02 Oct-02 Feb-03 Jun-03 Oct-03 Feb-04 Jun-04 Oct-04

O3 Column Scaling Factor: FTIR = (SCIA Master Set, Reprocessing) * 0.95(±0.01) 1.3E+19 SCIA Master Set; averages of pixels within 500 km Total Column (cm-2) 1.2E+19 1.1E+19 Zugspitze FTIR daily averages 1.0E+19 9.0E+18 SCIA Reprocessing; averages of pixels within 500 km 8.0E+18 7.0E+18 6.0E+18 5.0E+18 Jul-02 Oct-02 Feb-03 Jun-03 Oct-03 Feb-04 Jun-04 Oct-04

NO2 Operational NRT Product July 2003: FTIR versus SCIA DOAS1 (vis) 1,8E+16 SCIA: Daily average of all pixels within 500-km radius Total Column (cm-2) FTIR: Individual measurements (15-min integr.) FTIR Zugspitze Column Version 3.51 Version 3.52 Version 3.53 Version 4.00 Version 4.01 1,6E+16 1,4E+16 1,2E+16 1,0E+16 8,0E+15 6,0E+15 4,0E+15 2,0E+15 0,0E+00 Jul 02 Aug 02 Okt 02 Nov 02 Jan 03 Mrz 03 Apr 03 Jun 03 Time of year 2002/03

NO2 Scientific Product UB 1.0 July 2003: FTIR versus UB 1.0 Total Column (cm-2) 1.2E+16 Zugspitze FTIR individ. measurements (15-min integration) 1.0E+16 8.0E+15 SCIA Scientif. UB1.0; individ. pixels within 200 km 6.0E+15 4.0E+15 2.0E+15 0.0E+00 Jul-02 Aug-02 Oct-02 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jun-03

NO2 Scientific Prod. UB1.0: Pollution episodes removed from satellite data Total Column (cm-2) 1.0E+16 Zugspitze FTIR individ. measurements (15-min integration) 8.0E+15 SCIA Scientif. UB1.0; individ. pixels within 200 km 6.0E+15 4.0E+15 2.0E+15 0.0E+00 Jul-02 Aug-02 Oct-02 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jun-03

NO2 Column Scaling Factor: FTIR = SCIA UB 1.0 * 1.30(±0.02) Total Column (cm-2) 1.0E+16 Zugspitze FTIR individ. measurements (15-min integration) 8.0E+15 6.0E+15 SCIA Scientif. UB1.0; individ. pixels within 200 km 4.0E+15 2.0E+15 0.0E+00 Jul-02 Aug-02 Oct-02 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jun-03

NO2 Scientific 2004: FTIR versus UB 1.5 (1E+15 slant col. added) and UB 1.0 Zugspitze FTIR individ. measurements (15min integr.) Total Column (cm-2) 1.2E+16 1.0E+16 SCIA Scientif. UB1.0; individ. pixels within 200 km 8.0E+15 6.0E+15 SCIA Scientif. UB1.5; individ. pixels within 200 km 4.0E+15 2.0E+15 0.0E+00 Jul-02 Oct-02 Feb-03 Jun-03 Oct-03 Feb-04 Jun-04 Oct-04

2nd NO2 Column Scaling Factor: FTIR = SCIA UB 1.5 * 1.20(±0.02) Zugspitze FTIR individ. measurements (15-min integr.) Total Column (cm-2) 9.0E+15 7.0E+15 SCIA Scientif. UB1.5; individ. pixels within 200 km 5.0E+15 3.0E+15 1.0E+15 Jul-02 Oct-02 Feb-03 Jun-03 Oct-03 Jan-04 May-04 Sep-04

NO2 Operational Product - 2004: Master Set, Reprocessing versus UB 1.5, FTIR Zugspitze FTIR individ. measurements (15-min integr.) Total Column (cm-2) 1.2E+16 SCIA Scientif. UB1.5 1.0E+16 8.0E+15 SCIA Master Set (DOAS_1) 6.0E+15 4.0E+15 2.0E+15 0.0E+00 Jul-02 Oct-02 Feb-03 May-03 Sep-03 Jan-04 Apr-04 Aug-04 SCIA Reprocessing; Download of 2 Dec-04 (DOAS_1)

NO2 Operational Product - 2004: Master Set, Reprocessing versus UB 1.5, FTIR Zugspitze FTIR individ. measurements (15-min integr.) Total Column (cm-2) 9.0E+15 7.0E+15 SCIA Scientif. UB1.5 5.0E+15 SCIA Master Set (DOAS_1) 3.0E+15 1.0E+15 Jul-02 Aug-02 Sep-02 Oct-02 Nov-02 Dec-02 Jan-03 Feb-03 SCIA Reprocessing; Download of 2 Dec-04 (DOAS_1)

NO2 Operational Product - Wrong Annual Cycle: Role of Solar Zenith Agle 80 SZA("TOA") (deg) 70 60 50 40 30 20 Jun-02 Jul-02 Aug-02 Sep-02 Sep-02 Oct-02 Nov-02 Dec-02

NO2 Operational Product - Wrong Annual Cycle: Zenith Angle Dependence 9.E+15 NO2 Column (cm-2) 62 deg = 28 Oct-02 SCIA Master Set, columns within 200 km 8.E+15 7.E+15 6.E+15 5.E+15 4.E+15 3.E+15 2.E+15 1.E+15 20 30 40 50 SZA (deg) 60 70 80

CO Operational NRT Product Versions July-2003: FTIR versus SCIA BIAS2 (NIR) SCIA: Daily average of all pixels within 500-km radius 2,0E+18 Vertical Column (cm-2) FTIR: Individual measurements (15-min integr.) 1,6E+18 FTIR Zugspitze Column version 3.51 version 3.52 data out of this scale version 3.53 version 4.00 version 4.01 1,2E+18 8,0E+17 4,0E+17 0,0E+00 Jul 02 Aug 02 Okt 02 Nov 02 Jan 03 Mrz 03 Apr 03 Jun 03 Time of year 2002/03

CO Scientif. WFMD v0.4 Prod.: FTIR versus WFMD Averaging Kernels 0 100 200 Pressure (hpa) 300 400 500 SCIA SZA=60 600 SCIA SZA=70 700 800 FTIR SZA=60 FTIR SZA=70 Uniform Sampling 900 1000 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 CO Total Column Averaging Kernel

CO WFMD v0.4: FTIR indiv. measurements versus WFMD indiv. pixels <500 km WFMD data for 33 days Jan Oct 2003 Zugspitze FTIR: Anomaly of pressure corrected CO columns, individ. measurements, 20 min integr. 9.00 7.00 Column anomaly 5.00 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4: CO/O2 columns anomaly, individ. pixels within 500 km; includ. cloud contaminated pixels (69 %) 3.00 1.00 Dec-02-1.00 Feb-03 Apr-03-3.00 Jul-03 Sep-03 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4: CO/O2 Nov-03 columns anomaly, individ. pixels within 500 km; cloud flagged pixels removed -5.00-7.00

CO WFMD v0.4: FTIR daily averages versus WFMD pixel averages <2000 km 36.00 Zugspitze FTIR CO column anomaly: daily means of pressure corrected columns 31.00 Column anomaly 26.00 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4 CO/O2 column anomaly: average of pixels within 2000 km; cloud contaminated pixels removed 21.00 16.00 11.00 6.00 1.00 Dec-02-4.00 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jul-03 Sep-03 Nov-03 Feb-04

CO WFMD v0.4: FTIR daily averages versus WFMD pixel averages <2000 km 2.00 Zugspitze FTIR CO column anomaly: daily means of pressure corrected columns 1.80 Column anomaly 1.60 1.40 1.20 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4 CO/O2 column anomaly: average of pixels within 2000 km; cloud contaminated pixels removed 1.00 0.80 0.60 0.40 0.20 0.00 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jul-03 Sep-03 Nov-03 Feb-04

CO WFMD v0.4: FTIR daily averages versus WFMD pixel averages <2000 km 2.00 Zugspitze FTIR CO column anomaly: daily means of pressure corrected columns 1.80 Column anomaly 1.60 1.40 1.20 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4 CO/O2 column anomaly: average of pixels within 2000 km; cloud contaminated pixels removed 1.00 0.80 0.60 0.40 0.20 0.00 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jul-03 Sep-03 Nov-03 Feb-04

CO WFMD v0.4: Linear Response to Annual Cycle? Zugspitze FTIR SCIA 2000 km SCIA 1000 km SCIA 1000 km incl. clds Slope Slope error R -9.5E-4-1.2E-3-6.4E-4-4.4E-4 9.8E-5 4.9E-4 5.9E-4 4.3E-4-0.70-0.43-0.21-0.18

CO WFMD Sep-04 Add-Release : Data Set increased from 33 Days to 153 Days 2.0 Zugspitze FTIR CO column anomaly: daily means of pressure corrected columns 1.8 Column anomaly 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.0 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4 CO, release Sep05; ground altitude corr. with barometr. eq.; column anomaly: average of pixels within 1000 km; cloud contaminated pixels removed; retrieval error < 60 % 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jul-03 Sep-03 Nov-03 Feb-04

CO Day-to-Day Scatter: STDV FTIR = 7.3 % STDV SCIA WFMD v0.4 = 25.4 % 2.0 Zugspitze FTIR CO column anomaly: daily means of pressure corrected columns 1.8 Column anomaly 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.0 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4 CO, release Sep05; ground altitude corr. with barometr. eq.; column anomaly: average of pixels within 1000 km; cloud contaminated pixels removed; retrieval error < 60 % 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jul-03 Sep-03 Nov-03 Feb-04

Total Column Corr. to Sea Level (cm-2) CO Column Scaling Factor: Zugspitze FTIR = SCIA WFMD v0.4 * 0.78(± 0.06) 5.0E+18 Zugspitze FTIR columns (daily means) corrected to sea level by barometr. eq. 4.0E+18 3.0E+18 SCIA columns averaged within 1000 km; corrected to sea level by barometr. eq. 2.0E+18 1.0E+18 0.0E+00 Dec-02 Feb-03 Apr-03 Jul-03 Sep-03 Nov-03 Feb-04

N2O Operational NRT Product July-2003: FTIR versus SCIA BIAS1 (NIR) FTIR Zugspitze Column version 3.51 + 3.52 not plotted (negative VMR s) version 4.00 FTIR: Individual measurements (15-min integr.) Total Column (cm-2) SCIA: Individual pixels within 500-km radius 5,0E+18 version 4.01 4,0E+18 3,0E+18 2,0E+18 1,0E+18 1,0E+00 Jul 02 Aug 02 Okt 02 Nov 02 Jan 03 Mrz 03 Apr 03 Jun 03 Time of year 2002/03

N2O Scientif. WFMD v0.4: FTIR versus WFMD < ±2000 km latitudinal band 1.40 Zugspitze FTIR N2O column anomaly: daily means of pressure corrected columns Column anomaly 1.30 1.20 SCIA_WFMD_v0.4 N2O/O2 column anomaly: average of pixels within a latitudinal band +- 2000 km; cloud contaminated pixels removed; retrieval error <100 % 1.10 1.00 0.90 0.80 Dec-02 Mar-03 May-03 Aug-03 Nov-03

CH4 Operational NRT Prod. Versions July-2003: FTIR versus SCIA BIAS2 (NIR) FTIR Zugspitze Column Version 3.52 Version 3.51 Version 3.53 Version 4.00 Version 4.01 1,0E+22 SCIA: Daily average of all pixels within 500-km radius Total Column (cm-2) FTIR: Individual measurements (15-min integr.) 1,0E+21 1,0E+20 1,0E+19 Jul 02 Aug 02 Okt 02 Nov 02 Jan 03 Mrz 03 Apr 03 Jun 03 Time of year 2002/03

XCH4 WFMD Product: FTIR versus WFMD v0.4 and WFMD v0.41 Column anomaly 1.40 Zugspitze FTIR 1.30 SCIAMACHY v0.41 1.20 SCIAMACHY v.0.4 1.10 decontamination phase (start/end) 1.00 pixel averages within 2000 km; retrieval error < 10 % 0.90 0.80 Dec-02 Mar-03 May-03 Aug-03 Nov-03

SCIAMACHY Validation by Zugspitze FTIR: CONCLUSIONS AS TO 7-DEC-2004 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Operational total ozone (Master Set plus Reprocessing) shows good pixel-to-pixel reproducabilitiy and a realistic day-to-day scatter (pixel average within 500 km) comparable to the ground FTIR. Column scaling factor: Zugspitze FTIR = SCIA * 0.95(±0.01). Operational total NO2 (Master Set plus Reprocessing) shows serious difficulties in monitoring the annual cycle (fall-winter decrease) above Zugspitze. Scientific total NO2 (UB 1.0, 1.5) perfectly monitors the annual cycle. It shows a realistic day-to-day scatter (200-km selection radius) after exclusion of pollution episodes. The column scaling factor (UB 1.5) is: Zugspitze FTIR = SCIA * 1.20(±0.02). Scientific WFMD CO v0.4 shows a day-to-day scatter that is too high by a factor of 3.5 compared to the ground FTIR for a 1000-km selection radius. Higher selection radii are required to reflect the CO annual cycle in terms of a linear response. In the September2003 Release an unrealistic enhancement around Jul-2003 shows up. Column scaling factor is: FTIR = SCIA * 0.78(±0.06). WFMD N2O v0.4 day-to-day scatter is too high by a factor 10 even for averaging all pixels within a ±2000-km latitudinal band. WFMD XCH4 has shown a quality break-though from v0.4 to v.0.41 (time dependent correction, ice issue). However, systematic ice features still dominate over the day-to-day scatter for a 2000-km selection radius, thus masking the CH4 annual cycle.