nfp process evaluation - matrix

Transcription

1 nfp process evaluation - matrix Country Date Submitted by NEPAL Sept. 8 (Fan) How it works In order to assess the progress and status of the nfp process a matrix has been designed. The matrix contains a number of indicators (or elements) for the different phases of the process: a)- analysis; b) policy formulation; c) implementation; and d) monitoring and evaluation). The above indicators are clustered according to the main nfp-principles: a) country ownership, b) inter- and intrasectoral linkages, c) partnerships nand participation). The matrix is aiming at providing an understanding of how the country nfp process is evolving, which elements are developed and to what extent, which elements are still weak or could require further attention. Number of indicators Phase Cluster Leadership Inter/intra linkages Partnerships Analysis 3 indicators 6 indicators 3 indicators Policy formulation 7 indicators 4 indicators 8 indicators Implementation 8 indicators 6 indicators 9 indicators Monitoring and evaluation 6 indicators 3 indicators 4 indicators Ranking Legend = if the indicator has not been developed / if it is absent from the country nfp process = if the indicator exists but is incipient / just starting / plenty of room to develop it further = if the indicator is developed / is progressing well within the country nfp process 3 = if the indicator is completed to the country's full satisfaction / can serve as a model

2 Updated by: (Fan) NEPAL Sept. 8 Phase I - Analysis Please give a value to only - check missing values (summary) Indicator Cluster - Country leadership Forest sector review Forest information (in website and other depositories) freely available and accessible to all stakeholders Forestry outlook study Analysis of the consistency of laws and legal prescriptions related to forestry Identifiaction of traditional forest-related knowledge Compilation and analysis of policies, laws, regulations and strategic plans of other sectors that influence forestry Assessment of the role of forests in the national economy (including valuation of its contributions) and the linkages with central issues in other sector strategies Rating Assessment of impact of other sectors on forestry sector development Identification of approaches for intra and inter-sectoral dialogue(working with Ministry of Local Government on Rural Development Project, others are Ministry of Food and Agriculture on Integrated Forest Plantations, etc.) Stakeholder analysis: identification of stakeholders, their importance/influence Training in use of participatory tools to promote stakeholder participation Existence of qualified staff to conduct participatory processes

3 NEPAL Sept. 8 Phase II - Policy formulation Cluster Indicator Rating Country leadership Existence of an officially adopted and broadly accepted Forest Policy Statement Nfp coordination mechanism established Mechanisms for decentralised policy debate and feed back are in place Existence of national and sub-national forest development action plans Existence of a financial strategy for sustainable forestry development Existence of subject-specific strategies, e.g. to promote plantations, to combat illegal logging, to control forest fires, etc. Country participation in UNFF and other international or regional forest related meetings Inconsistencies in the forest related policy and legal framework have been addressed Harmonization of forest policy with other sector policies and development plans Participation of the forest sector in other sectors strategic planning exercises Thematic working groups for policy related discussions Mechanisms for stakeholder consultation and participation are established and functional The mechanism of the participatory process is well-known by all relevant stakeholder groups Stakeholders are sufficiently organized to participate in the nfp process. Evidence of participation of non-government stakeholders in the policy formulation process. Stakeholder consultation/meetings or fora to discuss forest policy objectives and priorities Evidence of stakeholder initiative to participate in the nfp process High percentage of stakeholders have access to relevant information Stakeholders informed and engaged in the commitments of the country participation in UNFF and 3

4 NEPAL Sept. 8 Phase III - Implementation Cluster Indicator Rating Country leadership Recent review or reformulation of forest legislation Capacity building of stakeholders to implement nfp related activities (training programmes of FD, NGOs, private sector representatives, etc) Level of domestic (public and private) funding for national forestry programme related activities to promote sustainable forest management. Donor coordination mechanisms under the leadership of a national institution are in place. Recent institutional reform and/or modernization of forest related institutions and services Efforts to improve law compliance, governance and transparency in the sector Participation in networks, regional and international initiatives to promote sustainable forest Evidence of contributions to the regional and international forest debate Recognition of customary laws and traditional rights related to forestry Assessment of contributions of the forest sector to the economy, taking into account the multiple benefits of forest products and services Integration of forestry in national poverty reduction strategies and strategies Joint meetings with other sectors to promote integrated natural resources management (e.g. soil conservation / watershed management) Inter-ministerial or inter-institutional mechanisms to support nfp implementation are in place Coordination with country units/focal points responsible for implementation of international Clarification and definition of roles and responsibilities of forest administration and other Existence of mechanisms for dialogue and joint decision making among forestry sector Joint forest stakeholder activities (e.g. private-public partnerships) Capacity building of stakeholders in technical and managerial aspects Training in conflict management provided to stakeholders Gender equity issues addressed Public awareness campaigns and information initiatives are being developed. Government supports active participation and institutionalization of non-government stakeholders in Existence of multi-sectoral development committees at local level

5 NEPAL Sept. 8 Phase IV - Monitoring and evaluation Cluster Indicator Rating Country leadership Regular data collection and assessment/review of forest development action plans National forest program evaluation reports Evidence that lessons learned are used to adjust/improve the process Regularly updated forest information available to support strategic planning of government and Revised policies, nfp documents and action plan Country implementation of IPF/IFF proposals for action regularly appraised Coordination of nfp monitoring mechanisms with other monitoring mechanisms of poverty reduction Revision of nfp progress with all relevant stakeholders from within and outside the forest sector Harmonization of revised nfp documents with strategic planning of other sectors Sharing of information on progress in nfp implementation among forestry stakeholders Procedures for stakeholder feedback instituted, e.g. stakeholder forum to discuss lessons learned Evaluation of stakeholder participation and satisfaction with the nfp process Awareness of nfp achievements by general public, including information dissemination and adoption

6 Evaluation of the national forest programme process Ranking Legend = if the indicator has not been developed / if it is absent from the country nfp process = if the indicator exists but is incipient / just starting / plenty of room to develop it further = if the indicator is developed / is progressing well within the country nfp process 3 = if the indicator is completed to the country's full satisfaction / can serve as a model NEPAL Sept. 8 Total Total Ranking 3 Number of indicators % Number and rank of indicators by cluster of principle Phase Ranking 3 I - Analysis 6 5 II - Formulation 8 9 III - Implementation IV - Monitoring and evaluation 7 4 Number and rank of indicators by cluster of principle Cluster of principle Ranking 3 Country leadership Partnership and participation 4 Updated by (Fan)

7 NEPAL Sept. 8 Summary of the national forestry program process Overall Number of indicator 5 Number of indicator 3 Number of indicator 3 Number of indicator 3 Number of criteria filled out 67 Missing values Summary by phase Phase I - Analysis Number of indicator Number of indicator 6 Number of indicator 5 Phase II - Formulation Number of indicator Number of indicator 8 Number of indicator 9 Number of indicator 3 Phase III - Implementation Number of indicator Number of indicator Number of indicator Phase IV - Monitoring & Evaluation Number of indicator Number of indicator 7 Number of indicator 4 Summary by cluster of principles Country leadership Number of indicator Number of indicator Number of indicator 9 Number of indicator 3 Number of indicator 3 Number of indicator 9 Number of indicator 7 Partnership and participation Number of indicator Number of indicator Number of indicator 4