Investigating the Impacts of Septic Systems and Straight Pipes in the Alabama Black Belt. Mark Elliott

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Investigating the Impacts of Septic Systems and Straight Pipes in the Alabama Black Belt. Mark Elliott"

Preston York
6 years ago
Views:

1 Investigating the Impacts of Septic Systems and Straight Pipes in the Alabama Black Belt Mark Elliott

2 ~75% Municipal Wastewater Treatment by US Population Municipal: POTW / WWTP ~25% Onsite On-Site System

3 Background: Septic Systems In the US, ~25% of households use an onsite wastewater treatment system (OWTS) Vast majority of OWTS are conventional septic systems

4 Source: Purdue Univ. Extension Service DRAIN FIELD

5 Background: Septic Systems Nearly all of the ~25% of households using on-site wastewater treatment system (OWTS) have conventional septic systems 1 trillion gallons of wastewater are discharged from septic systems in the US each year Affordably protect public health and environment in most rural areas of the US Septic system ~$2500 Alternative systems $6000+

6 Black Belt Counties Black Belt characterized by impermeable clay soil >50% of Black Belt area unsuitable for septic systems (He et al., 2011):

7 Black Belt Counties Black Belt characterized by impermeable clay soil >50% of Black Belt area unsuitable for septic systems (He et al., 2011): Poverty limits alternatives Counties typically 25-40% below poverty line How bad is it?

8 Black Belt Counties Black Belt characterized by impermeable clay soil >50% of Black Belt area unsuitable for septic systems (He et al., 2011): Poverty limits alternatives Counties typically 25-40% below poverty line How bad is it?

9 Photos: acrecdc.com Best Case Scenario for the Black Belt Bibb County: detailed study of >4000 homes not connected to public sewer (White and Jones, 2006)

10 Best Case Scenario for the Black Belt Bibb County: detailed study of >4000 homes not connected to public sewer (White and Jones, 2006) 35% had failing septic system 15% straight pipe (direct discharge) Photos: acrecdc.com

11 Best Case Scenario for the Black Belt Bibb County: detailed study of >4000 homes not connected to public sewer (White and Jones, 2006) 35% had failing septic system 15% straight pipe (direct discharge)

12 Bibb County Straight Pipe Bibb County: 15% straight pipe (White and Jones, 2006) This corresponds to (Bibb Co only): >60,000 gallons of raw sewage discharged to the ground per day (20 million gal per year) Billions of pathogens discharged into watershed per day (just three types listed): >1 billion enteric viruses >1 billion Giardia cysts >300 million Cryptosporidium oocysts

13 Black Belt Counties Bibb County compared to Black Belt counties: Less poverty (% of households below the poverty line, according to the US Census): Bibb Co. : 18.1% Hale Co.: 26.6% Wilcox Co.: 39.2% Bibb Co. has much better soil for conventional septic systems Straight pipe and failing septic likely to be even higher in Black Belt

14 Health Impacts? Possible impacts on health? Little surveillance for infectious diseases

15 Health Impacts? Possible impacts on health? Little surveillance for infectious diseases Last survey of sewage-associated helminth infection (Wilcox Co) 1/3 of children under-10 tested positive for one or more helminths (Badham, 1993).

16 Health Impacts? Possible impacts on health? Little surveillance for infectious diseases Last survey of sewage-associated helminth infection (Wilcox Co) 1/3 of children under-10 tested positive for one or more helminths (Badham, 1993). Unpublished data from Lowndes County More than 1/3 of adults with poor sanitation were infected with helminths (Walton, 2015).

17 Health Impacts? Possible impacts on health? Little surveillance for infectious diseases Last survey of sewage-associated helminth infection (Wilcox Co) 1/3 of children under-10 tested positive for one or more helminths (Badham, 1993). Unpublished data from Lowndes County More than 1/3 of adults with poor sanitation were infected with helminths (Walton, 2015). Georgia Tech follow-up in 2017 (Joe Brown)

18 Various lines of evidence point to onsite wastewater as a substantial threat to Water quality Public health Diverse Evidence

19 Investigating the scope and impacts on water quality with funding from: EPA Gulf of Mexico Program Alabama WRRI through USGS UA Center for Freshwater Studies Methods: Research Approach Site-by-site inspections/surveys in Black Belt Data from local stakeholders Flow-routing Water sampling (microbiological and chemical)

20 Investigating the scope and impacts on water quality with funding from: EPA Gulf of Mexico Program Alabama WRRI through USGS UA Center for Freshwater Studies Methods: Research Approach Site-by-site inspections/surveys in Black Belt Data from local stakeholders Flow-routing Water sampling (microbiological and chemical)

21 Site-by-site Inspections

22 Wilcox County Preliminary Data 119 homes surveyed Includes 74 mobile homes Representative of county demographic and soil

23 Wilcox County Preliminary Data 119 homes surveyed Includes 74 mobile homes Representative of county demographic and soil 23 (19%) ADPH-permitted systems

24 Wilcox County Preliminary Data 119 homes surveyed Includes 74 mobile homes Representative of county demographic and soil 23 (19%) ADPH-permitted systems 96 (81%) without permitted systems 37 (31%) with straight pipe visible upon inspection 59 (50%) unpermitted, but some form of in-ground disposal or straight pipe buried/not visible

25 Wilcox County Preliminary Data 119 homes surveyed Includes 74 mobile homes Representative of county demographic and soil 23 (19%) ADPH-permitted systems 96 (81%) without permitted systems 37 (31%) with straight pipe visible upon inspection 59 (50%) unpermitted, but some form of in-ground disposal or straight pipe buried/not visible Data from Lynn and Robert Jones Down to Earth, Inc. (ongoing work, also Hale Co.)

26 Investigating the scope and impacts on water quality with funding from: EPA Gulf of Mexico Program Alabama WRRI through USGS UA Center for Freshwater Studies Methods: Research Approach Site-by-site inspections/surveys in Black Belt Data from local stakeholders Flow-routing Water sampling (microbiological and chemical)

27 Newbern (Hale Co) Preliminary Data Septic system installers/adph staff reporting on their experience and knowledge

28 Newbern (Hale Co) Preliminary Data Septic system installers/adph staff reporting on their experience and knowledge Newbern, AL 10% with licensed systems 90% unlicensed

29 Newbern (Hale Co) Preliminary Data Septic system installers/adph staff reporting on their experience and knowledge Newbern, AL 10% with licensed systems 90% unlicensed 40% have some field lines

Newbern (Hale Co) Preliminary Data Septic system installers/adph staff reporting on their experience and knowledge Newbern, AL 10% with licensed systems 90% unlicensed 40% have

30 Newbern (Hale Co) Preliminary Data Septic system installers/adph staff reporting on their experience and knowledge Newbern, AL 10% with licensed systems 90% unlicensed 40% have some field lines 50% straight pipe 30% solids settling (septic tank or 55-gal drum) 20% no solids setting Data from Tim Wenger of Cedar Ridge Excavating (work ongoing with others)

31 Investigating the scope and impacts on water quality with funding from: EPA Gulf of Mexico Program Alabama WRRI through USGS UA Center for Freshwater Studies Methods: Research Approach Site-by-site inspections/surveys in Black Belt Data from local stakeholders Flow-routing Water sampling (microbiological and chemical)

32 Flow-routing to Identify Sampling Points Determine drainage patterns to identify possible sampling points In collaboration with the GIS groups at UA GIS team is conducting drainage pattern modeling to determine Flow direction of wastewater on the surface Flow accumulation at any point on map Mark Simpson (UA master s grad) and Sagy Cohen (UA Geology)

33 Flow Routing and Description Map: Mark Simpson, Univ. of Alabama

34 Flow Routing and Description

35 Investigating the scope and impacts on water quality with funding from: EPA Gulf of Mexico Program Alabama WRRI through USGS UA Center for Freshwater Studies Methods: Research Approach Site-by-site inspections/surveys in Black Belt Data from local stakeholders Flow-routing Water sampling (microbiological and chemical)

Water Sampling and Analysis Baseflow and first

dry conditions First flush samples Autosamplers

collect sample when water level rises With

36 Water Sampling and Analysis Baseflow and first flush samples will be collected Baseflow under dry conditions First flush samples Autosamplers will be inserted in stream beds automatically collect sample when water level rises With Yuehan Lu Parnab Das Zachary Stephens Other students

37 Water Sampling and Analysis Analytes for water analysis: Fecal indicator bacteria (E. coli and coliforms) Conductivity, turbidity, ph Anions and cations Nutrients

38 Water Sampling and Analysis Analytes for water analysis: Human-specific bacterial genes (by qpcr) High specificity if successful F+ coliphages

39 Water Sampling and Analysis Dissolved organic analytes for water analysis: Yuehan Lu (UA Geology) will lead Organic matter fingerprinting Fluorescence to detect optical brighteners in laundry detergent

40 What Next? Findings to Solutions EPA Gulf Regional Partnerships emphasizes measurable impacts on environment and people We don t have the resources to solve this problem by connecting everyone to sewer or replacing all the failing systems

41 What Next? Findings to Solutions Possibility to make a difference: Education and outreach to homeowners Small monetary incentives toward proper inspection, maintenance, pumping Decreasing barriers to homeowners having their systems inspected, pumped, repaired Study and report on the feasibility of alternative onsite systems, community systems and connection to sewer

Collaborators and Students EPA Gulf Program Lael Butler AOWATC (UWA) Allen Tartt ADPH Parrish Pugh, Becky Wilson ADEM Carmen Yelle AL Clean Water Partnership Kellie Johnson Down to Earth, Inc.

42 Collaborators and Students EPA Gulf Program Lael Butler AOWATC (UWA) Allen Tartt ADPH Parrish Pugh, Becky Wilson ADEM Carmen Yelle AL Clean Water Partnership Kellie Johnson Down to Earth, Inc. Robert Jones, Lynn Jones GSA Marlon Cook HERO Pam Dorr U of South Alabama Kevin White UA Geology - Yuehan Lu UA Geography Sagy Cohen UA Civil/Environmental Eng. Bob Pitt, Mark Simpson UA Students: Parnab Das, Phillip Grammer, Erdogan Aytekin, Aaron Miller, Elliot McCandless, Charlotte Sheridan, Chad Barber, George Uku, Peng Sheng, Zachary Stephens, Brittany Shake, Mark Simpson

43 Questions?

Water Pollution. Objective: Name, describe, and cite examples of the eight major types of water pollution.

Water Pollution. Objective: Name, describe, and cite examples of the eight major types of water pollution. Water Pollution Objective: Name, describe, and cite examples of the eight major types of water pollution. Types of Water Pollution Water pollutants are divided into eight categories: 1. Sediment pollution