Entrepreneurship training and self-employment among university graduates: Evidence from a randomized trial in Tunisia
|
|
- Penelope Conley
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Entrepreneurship training and self-employment among university graduates: Evidence from a randomized trial in Tunisia Patrick Premand (World Bank) Stefanie Brodmann (World Bank) Rita Almeida (World Bank and IZA) Rebekka Grun (World Bank) Mahdi Barouni (CNSS) IZA/World Bank/OECD Conference on Activation and Employment Policies Istanbul, May 1, 2012
2 High youth unemployment among graduates Figure 1: High unemployment among graduates (Unemployment rate, by level of education and age group) 50,0 45,0 44,2 44,3 40,0 38,2 35,0 33,6 30,0 25,0 20,0 18,7 Tertiary, All, ,0 13,2 13,5 13,3 10,0 5,0 0,0 Source: Tunisia Labor Force Surveys
3 No good jobs available Figure 2: Lack of good jobs main obstacle to get a job (What is the primary obstacle in (country for youth to get a job or a better job that enables them to start a family?) Tunisia Egypt Syria Lebanon Palestine Jordan UAE Yemen Bahrain Kuwait Algeria Saudi Arabia Iraq Qatar Libya Djibouti Morocco 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% No good jobs available Jobs given only to connected people Lack training Other Source: Gallup opinion poll 3
4 Intervention: The entrepreneurship track Objective: Increase self-employment among graduates, by improving skills and affecting attitudes towards entrepreneurship National reform during academic year (inter-ministerial committee: Min of Vocational Training & Employment; Industry; Education & Higher Education) Entrepreneurship track for third year university students in applied programs Business training: Entrepreneurship courses offered by the public employment office (20 days/full time, small groups) Practical research on the ground and interactive sessions, aimed at fostering participants : (i) behavioral skills; (ii) business skills; and (iii) networking skills Initial business idea: modified after evaluation by bankers and experts Personalized coaching: Private sector entrepreneurs or specialized coaches (8 sessions, either individually or in small groups) University professors: Supervision in development and finalization of the business plan Graduation and possibility to enter into business plan thesis competition 4
5 Questions & key findings Questions of interest: What are the impacts on labor market outcomes? What are the channels behind the employment results? Key findings: The entrepreneurship track was effective in increasing selfemployment; However, the overall employment rate among beneficiaries remained the same as for the control group; The program fostered business skills, expanded networks, and affected a range of behavioral skills; Participation also heightened graduates sense of opportunities and optimism towards the future; 5
6 Evaluation design, data & empirical strategy 6
7 Impact Evaluation Design Beginning of the 2009/10 academic year: All students enrolled in the third year of their licence appliquée invited to apply for the program at the 1,702 students apply (out of 18,000), 1506 projects Given over-subscription of interested students no resources to reach all interested students Half of the students randomly assigned to entrepreneurship track, other half assigned to standard curriculum Stratification by gender and study subject (14 licences ) 757 projects assigned to treatment group; 742 to control group Randomization achieved good balance Few systematic differences; differences quantitatively small
8 Data Baseline Application Survey (online and paper, December 2009) Baseline Entrepreneurship Survey (phone, January February 2010) Capture broader range of characteristics, particularly on personal traits, preferences, attitudes towards entrepreneurship, 90% re-contact rate Qualitative work (October - November 2010) To finalize content of follow-up survey instrument and provide feedback on program implementation Follow-up survey (face-to-face; April-June 2011) 93% re-contact rate (uncorrelated with treatments status) 1-year after graduation First labor-market survey after the revolution; only panel survey tracking the cohort of graduates.
9 Intent-to-Treat Estimates (ITT) Impact of offering business training and coaching: Y i = βt i + γx i + π is + ε i With: Y i = employment outcomes T i = randomized assignment to entrepreneurship track X i = baseline controls π is = strata fixed effects (by gender and subject) Standard errors clustered by strata Robustness checks: Different sets of baseline controls Standard errors clustered by governorate 9
10 Treatment on the treated Estimates (TOT) Impact of actually completing entrepreneurship training and coaching: IV estimation: (1 st Stage) U i = βt i +γx i + π is + η i With: U = Actual program take-up (from administrative data) (2 nd Stage) Y i = фû i +ξx i + π is + ε i With: Û = Predicted Program take-up (from (1)) Actual take-up considered as completing training and coaching (59%) Local-average treatment effects (LATE) to be interpreted as impact on compliers (those who complete the training if offered, and do not complete if not offered) In practice, take-up among control very low (3.4%) 10
11 Results 11
12 Results : Outline What are the impacts on labor-market outcomes? Self-Employment Employment Quality of Employment What are the channels behind the employment results? Business skills Networks Preferences Behavioral Skills (Entrepreneurial Skills, Big 5, ) Attitudes towards the future and opportunities Access to credit 12
13 Results: Labor-Market Outcomes 13
14 Labor-market Outcomes: Self-Employment Mean C Mean T ITT SE TOT SE Self-employed (last 12 months) Self-employed, including seasonal (last 7 days) Self-employed, excluding seasonal (last 7 days) *** *** ** ** * * 0.01 Note: n = The intervention led to an increase in self-employment Small absolute effects Effect sizes ranging between 48%-81% for ITT 14
15 Labor-market Outcomes: Employment Mean C Mean T No evidence that the program significantly affected overall employment (note: general equilibrium effects not captured) ITT SE TOT Employed (last 7 days) Self-employed (last 7 days) ** ** 0.02 Salaried worker (last 7 days) Unemployed (last 7 days ) Studying (last 7 days) Inactive (last 7 days) Suggests substitution between employment and self-employment (as in Fairlie et al. (2012) in the US) SE 15
16 Labor-market Outcomes: Quality of Employment Mean Mean ITT SE TOT SE C T Monthly labor earnings Reservation wage (private sector) * ** Reservation wage (public sector) Has contract Covered by Social Security Work in large firm Hours worked in last week N= 1580 No evidence of impacts on earnings Increase in reservation wage for private sector wage jobs (but not public sector wage jobs) No effects on other measures of quality of employment 16
17 Results: Channels 17
18 Channels: What is behind these employment results? Channels Business skills +++ Networks ++ Preferences Behavioral skills: Big Five ++ Behavioral skills: Entrepreneurial skills Attitudes towards the future +++ Access to credit + 18
19 Channels: Behavioral skills (Big Five Personality traits) Measures of Behavioral Skills (10-item Big Five Scale from Gosling, 2003) Suggests the intervention affected a range of behavioral skills (personality traits) Consistent with Cobb-Clark and Tan (2010): agreeableness negatively associated with probability of being a manager or business professional Trade-off in soft-skills for wage employment and self-employment? 19
20 Channels: Attitudes towards the future Subjective measures of optimism and attitudes towards the future (inspired by de Mel et al. (2010) and positive items from a depression scale) Suggests beneficiaries have higher optimism and more positive attitudes towards the future 20
21 Channels: Access to credit? Entrepreneurship track did not directly aim to alleviate credit constraints (clients main hypothesis was that skills are the constraint, not credit) Training involved providing information to students about credit applications, as well as connecting them to bankers Mean Mean N ITT SE TOT C T Knows how to apply for credit 1, Expect to be able to obtain credit 1, ** ** 0.06 Has applied for credit ( business idea) ** ** 0.02 SE Treatment group more confident to be able to obtain credit and more likely to have actually applied for credit (conditional on business idea) However, not more likely to report knowing how to apply for credit Many applications remain pending, too few observations to identify impact on access to credit at follow-up 21
22 Credit as the main perceived constraint to self-employment Personality traits Lack of follow-up Lack of technical skills Lack of ideas Lack of business skills Lack of experience Lack of opportunities Lack of finance 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% Women Men More than 70% of graduates state that access to credit is the main constraint for entry into self-employment. 22
23 Conclusions 23
24 Conclusions Diagnostics: Insufficient labor demand / high youth UE among graduates How To: Operations manual; joint / short / French MFPE/WB report Design of entrepreneurship tack, who does what, lessons from implementation Impact: Entrepreneurship track led to higher self-employment Employment rate among beneficiaries remained unchanged Affected a range of behavioral skills Costs:? Scalability: Confirms (at least some) non-cognitive skills are malleable highlights potential trade-offs between skills for self-employment and for wage empl.? Scaled up and expanded to engineering and masters program Despite large effect size, not a mass effective channel given low base Can skills create jobs? Intervention did not alleviate capital constraint for most (consider accompanying measures (i.e., credit, incubation focus on women?) Ensure quality service delivery (in particular staffing at public employment office and external coaches) 24
25 Thank you 25
26 Contribution to the broader evidence base A unique randomized impact evaluation in the context of a national higher education reform, providing skills training to the more educated while still at university Effectiveness of policies to foster employability and productivity among youth in developing countries [Almeida et al., 2011a; Angel-Urdinola et al., 2010; Betcherman et al., 2004, 2007; and Kluve et al., 2010 for recent reviews] Focus mostly on Latin American programs and on vocational training programs for atrisk youth [e.g., Ibararran and Rosas, 2008; Attanasio et al., 2011; Card et al., 2011] Effectiveness of entrepreneurship-support interventions in developing countries Focus mostly on activation of existing low productivity workers, the inactive, or the unemployed [e.g., Almeida and Galasso, 2010; De Mel et al., 2010; Klinger and Schündeln, 2011] Effectiveness of business training for micro finance clients, mainly women [e.g., Karlan and Valdivia, 2011; Drexler et al., 2010; Bruhn and Zia, 2011] Profiles of successful entrepreneurs [Elston et al., 2005; Djankov et al., 2006; de Mel et al., 2010] Effects of training programs on behaviors and attitudes [e.g., Carneiro et al. 2010; Blattman, Fiala and Martinez, 2011; Blattman and Annan, forthcoming] 26
27 Randomization achieved balance N Mean Control Treatment Difference StEr Application form Male 1, Age 1, * 0.06 Average grade in 2nd year of university 1, Took entrepreneurship course 1, Ever worked 1, Age at first job 1, Duration of first job (months) 1, Household size 1, Father is salaried worker 1, Father is self-employed 1, Mother is salaried worker 1, Mother is self-employed 1, HH earnings between 0 and 300 TND 1, HH earnings between 301 and 500 TND 1, HH earnings between 501 and 800 TND 1, Family can provide financial support 1,
28 Channels: Business skills Measures of self-reported business skills related to the core content of the training and business plan (BP): Mean Mean ITT SE TOT SE C T Has experience in projects *** *** 0.04 Knows how to produce a BP *** *** 0.05 Knows BP contains commercial analysis *** *** 0.05 Knows BP contains demand assessment *** *** 0.04 Knows BP contains supply assessment *** *** 0.05 Knows BP contains marketing plan *** *** 0.05 Knows BP contains market share analysis *** *** 0.04 Knows BP contains technical analysis *** *** 0.04 Knows BP contains financial analysis *** *** 0.05 Knows BP contains profitability analysis *** *** 0.06 N=1580 Unsurprisingly, significantly better knowledge about topics taught in entrepreneurship track 28
29 Channels: Networks Mean Mean N ITT SE TOT SE C T Registered at Employment Office 1, * 0.04 Knows an employment agent 1, *** *** 0.03 # spoke to employment agent (in month) Knows an entrepreneur 1, * * 0.04 # spoke to entrepreneur (in month) Knows a banker 1, *** *** 0.03 # spoke to a banker (in month) ** ** 0.88 Would seek advice from professor 1, * ** 0.02 Would seek advice from employment agent 1, Would seek advice from an entrepreneur 1, Entrepreneurship training expanded participants business and employment networks 29
30 Channels: Preferences Self-reported preference parameters often associated with entrepreneurs: Mean C Mean T ITT SE TOT SE Willingness to take risk (0-10) Certainty equivalent for lottery with 50% chance of winning 0 and 50% chance of winning 2000DT Risk taker (Certainty Equivalent>1000DT) Patience (prefers 1000 DT in 6 months to 800DT now) N = 1427; controls include behavioral measures from baseline phone survey. No evidence that entrepreneurship training affected time or risk preference 30
31 Channels: Behavioral Skills (Entrepreneurial skills) Measures of entrepreneurial skills (as in de Mel et al., 2010) Mean Mean ITT SE TOT SE C T Impulsiveness ** ** 0.09 Passion for work Tenacity Polychronicity Locus of control Achievement Power Motivation Centrality of work * * 0.09 Personal organization N = 1427; controls include behavioral measures from baseline phone survey. Some evidence of changes in entrepreneurial skills such as impulsiveness and centrality of work. 31
32 Channels: Opportunities and the revolution Perceptions of the effects of the revolution on labor-market (from 1 = very negatively, to 5 = very positively): Mean C Mean T ITT SE TOT Revolution affected desire to find a job SE Revolution affected desire to work in public sector Revolution affected desire to work in private sector Revolution affected desire to work on a project Revolution affected desire to emigrate * 0.12 Overall, heightened sense of opportunities because of the revolution (higher desire to find a job, lower desire to emigrate) Particularly so for beneficiaries? 32
Entrepreneurship training and self-employment among university graduates: Evidence from a randomized trial in Tunisia
Entrepreneurship training and self-employment among university graduates: Evidence from a randomized trial in Tunisia Patrick Premand (World Bank) Stefanie Brodmann (World Bank) Rita Almeida (World Bank
More informationPromoting Entrepreneurship Among University Graduates: Evidence from Tunisia
Promoting Entrepreneurship Among University Graduates: Evidence from Tunisia By Rita Almeida (HNDSP), Stefanie Brodmann (MNSHD), Patrick Premand (HDNCE), in collaboration with ONEQ June 7, 2011 Please
More informationEntrepreneurship Training and Self-Employment among University Graduates
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Policy Research Working Paper 6285 Entrepreneurship Training and Self-Employment among
More informationWhich skills for women s success?
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Which skills for women s success? Experimental evidence from entrepreneurship training programs in Togo Markus Goldstein PRELIMINARY PLEASE DO
More informationAssessment of the situation of women entrepreneurship in Algeria, Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Palestine, Tunisia
Assessment of the situation of women entrepreneurship in Algeria, Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Palestine, Tunisia Neila Amara UNIDO Expert E-mail: n.amara@unido.org Seminar on Female Participation in the Labour
More informationYOUTH EMPLOYMENT SEMINAR. Meghan Mahoney Policy Manager, J-PAL Global 13 October 2015
YOUTH EMPLOYMENT SEMINAR Meghan Mahoney Policy Manager, J-PAL Global 13 October 2015 OUTLINE Why Focus on Youth? Review of the Evidence General Lessons Job Training Programs Entrepreneurship and Self-employment
More informationEvidence on Youth Active Labour Market Programmes
Evidence on Youth Active Labour Market Programmes Susana Puerto International Labour Organization Geneva, 26 September 2014 Overview I. The ILO and the What Works II. The Evidence III. Takeaways 2 I. The
More informationPromoting women s empowerment in the Middle East and North Africa
Investing in rural people Impact Brief Series, Issue 9 Promoting women s empowerment in the Middle East and North Africa A rapid evidence assessment of labour market interventions The Taqeem (meaning evaluation
More informationIZA/World Bank Conference on Evaluation of Labor Market Programs in Developing Countries
IZA/World Bank Conference on Evaluation of Labor Market Programs in Developing Countries Date: February 20 th and 21 st 2009 Location: IZA, Bonn, Germany ORGANIZING COMMITTEE Rita K. Almeida (World Bank
More informationImpact Evaluation for Safety Nets
Impact Evaluation for Safety Nets Methods and Applications Patrick Premand (Africa HD) Safety Nets Course, December 2013 This material builds on Gertler, P. J.; Martinez, S., Premand, P., Rawlings, L.
More informationE-government Report Presentation for ITA. Presentation by Richard Kerby, UNDESA
E-government Report Presentation for ITA Presentation by Richard Kerby, UNDESA Review of Methodology Among the objectives of e-government four are of paramount importance and of relevance here: Efficient
More informationEvidence on Youth Employment. Susana Puerto, ILO Jochen Kluve, RWI & Humboldt University Friederike Rother, World Bank
Evidence on Youth Employment Susana Puerto, ILO Jochen Kluve, RWI & Humboldt University Friederike Rother, World Bank Overview I. Collecting and building the evidence II. What works III. The Road Ahead
More informationDelivering Opportunities to Youth in Northern Uganda
Delivering Opportunities to Youth in Northern Uganda Short Term Impacts of NUSAF YOP on Non-Migrant Youth* Christopher Blattman, Yale University Nathan Fiala, World Bank Sebastian Martinez, World Bank
More informationParticipating or not? Characteristics of Female Entrepreneurs Participating and Completing Entrepreneurial. Training Program
Participating or not? Characteristics of Female Entrepreneurs Participating and Completing Entrepreneurial Training Program Leonardo Iacovone 1, Gabriela Calderón 2, Cristina Mac Gregor 3 If you can empower
More informationThe effectiveness of labor market training: Evidence from meta-analyses
The effectiveness of labor market training: Evidence from meta-analyses Jochen Kluve Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin and RWI Doha Evidence Symposium 06 March 2014 1 Key policy questions Broader perspective:
More informationAssessing the Impact of KASHF s Capacity Building and Social Advocacy Interventions
Assessing the Impact of KASHF s Capacity Building and Social Advocacy Interventions 1 Kashf Foundation Focus Notes Series October 2017 Assessing the Impact of KASHF s Capacity Building and Social Advocacy
More informationMalika Abdelali-Martini
Empowering Women in the Rural Labor Force with a focus on Agricultural Employment in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) Malika Abdelali-Martini International Center for Agricultural Research in the
More informationImproving job creation potential through Skills and SME Development. Raffaele Boldracchi May 7, Cairo
Improving job creation potential through Skills and SME Development Raffaele Boldracchi May 7, 2012 - Cairo Topics for discussions IFC initiatives taken in the context of the Deauville Partnership The
More informationIs personal initiative training a substitute or complement to the existing human capital of. women? Results from a randomized trial in Togo
Is personal initiative training a substitute or complement to the existing human capital of women? Results from a randomized trial in Togo Francisco Campos 1, Michael Frese 2,3, Markus Goldstein 1, Leonardo
More informationThe Nuts and Bolts of Designing and Implementing Training Programs in Developing Countries
The Nuts and Bolts of Designing and Implementing Training Programs in Developing Countries Maddalena Honorati and Thomas McArdle The World Bank IZA-World Bank-OECD Conference on Activation and Employment
More informationStaying ahead of the crowd
www.pwc.com/middle-east/mepsi Staying ahead of the crowd Getting the Middle East Public Sector to perform A publication by PwC Middle East Public Sector Institute A publication by PwC Middle East Public
More informationYouth Employment and Entrepreneurship: Evidence and Open Questions. Marianne Bertrand University of Chicago
Youth Employment and Entrepreneurship: Evidence and Open Questions Marianne Bertrand University of Chicago The Youth Employment Challenge More than 300 million young people worldwide are not in employment,
More informationREPUBLIC OF KENYA. Terms of Reference - Field Supervisor Individual Consultant March I. Summary
REPUBLIC OF KENYA I. Summary Ministry of Public Service, Youth and Gender State Department for Public Service and Youth Kenya Youth Employment and Opportunities Project (KYEOP) Terms of Reference - Field
More informationContents. 1. Introduction Jordan and the GTCI Jordan s Strongest and Weakest Sub-Indicators Policy Recommendations...
Contents 1. Introduction... 3 7. Jordan and the GTCI... 5 8. Jordan s Strongest and Weakest Sub-Indicators... 10 9. Policy Recommendations... 11 Jordan on the Global Talent Competitiveness Index 2018 APRIL
More informationCOMPLEMENTING MANAGERIAL TRAINING WITH SOFT SKILLS
COMPLEMENTING MANAGERIAL TRAINING WITH SOFT SKILLS PRELIMINARY EVIDENCE FROM MEXICO September 2016 OUTLINE 1.MOTIVATION 2.THE INTERVENTION 3.PRELIMINARY RESULTS 1 1. MOTIVATION MOTIVATION (1/3) Micro-enterprises
More informationHUMAN CAPACITY BUILDING: EDUCATION, VOCATIONAL AND SKILLED LABOR PROMOTING POLICIES
HUMAN CAPACITY BUILDING: EDUCATION, VOCATIONAL AND SKILLED LABOR PROMOTING POLICIES Economic And Social Commission For Western Asia Dr. Nibal Idlebi Chief, Innovation Section Technology for Development
More informationActivation strategies and active labor market policies
Activation strategies and active labor market policies Jochen Kluve Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin and RWI The World Bank Labor Market Policy Core Course Washington, DC, 07 May 2013 1 Global unemployment
More informationAGENDA. Improving Competitiveness in the MENA Region
AGENDA Improving Competitiveness in the MENA Region Training of the MENA-OECD Investment Programme in collaboration with the IMF Institute Venue IMF-Middle East Center for Economics and Finance The Symphony
More informationWomen school to work transition in the MENA Region. Jordan, Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia, Lebanon, Egypt
Women school to work transition in the MENA Region Jordan, Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia, Lebanon, Egypt Presentation Plan Executive Summary What the paper aim at Status of the school-to-work transition in
More informationMEXA Module on Entrepreneurship: Household data collection option 3
MEXA Module on Entrepreneurship: Household data collection option 3 Social and Housing Statistics Section - UNSD EDGE conceptual framework Determinants Outcomes Impact Motivations and aspirations Entrepreneurial
More informationProblems that workers face to access wage employment? An age-based approach. David Newhouse Labor Markets Team, HDNSP
Problems that workers face to access wage employment? An age-based approach David Newhouse Labor Markets Team, HDNSP Why should we care? Introduce section of the course focusing on wage employment Examine
More informationFuel Subsidies, the Oil Market, and the World Economy
Fuel Subsidies, the Oil Market, and the World Economy Nathan Balke, Michael Plante and Mine Yücel Southern Methodist University Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas June 16, 2014 Disclaimer The results presented
More informationFINANCIAL EDUCATION IN THE ARAB WORLD: STRATEGIES, IMPLEMENTATION AND IMPACT. Gender Financial Education October 2016 Rabat,Morocco
FINANCIAL EDUCATION IN THE ARAB WORLD: STRATEGIES, IMPLEMENTATION AND IMPACT Gender Financial Education 20-21 October 2016 Rabat,Morocco Definition of Financial Literacy The ability to use knowledge and
More informationM&E FOR JOBS OPERATIONS INTRODUCTION TO THE JOBS M&E TOOLKIT. Siv Tokle Raphaela Karlen World Bank Group, Jobs Group
M&E FOR JOBS OPERATIONS INTRODUCTION TO THE JOBS M&E TOOLKIT Siv Tokle Raphaela Karlen World Bank Group, Jobs Group October 17, 2017 Table of Contents Introduction Jobs Conceptual Framework A Menu of Jobs
More informationJunior Professional Officer Project Development, Monitoring and Evaluation
TERMS OF REFERENCE JUNIOR PROFESSIONAL OFFICER 5-1 I. POSITION INFORMATION Position Title Position Grade Duty Station Reporting directly to Duration Junior Professional Officer Project Development, Monitoring
More informationBangladesh Skills for Employment and Productivity (B-SEP) Project ILO, Dhaka Component 4: Improved Access to Skills
Bangladesh Skills for Employment and Productivity (B-SEP) Project ILO, Dhaka Component 4: Improved Access to Skills Terms of References (ToR) Implementing Specific Programmes (Skills Development/ Self-employment/
More informationTORINO PROCESS 2014 IN LEBANON
IN LEBANON Eva Jimeno Sicilia, Beirut, 23 September 2014 WHY THE NAME TORINO PROCESS? Why the LOGO? It represents la Mole Antonelliana, emblematic monument of Torino Height: 163 meters!!! 2 WHAT IS THE
More informationLife Skills, Employability and Training for Disadvantaged Youth: Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation Design
Life Skills, Employability and Training for Disadvantaged Youth: Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation Design May 15th th, 2012 Abstract This paper presents an impact evaluation of a revamped version of
More informationEMPLOYEE MOTIVATION STUDY. September 2009
EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION STUDY September 2009 Objectives To understand how the current environment is impacting the satisfaction levels of an employee in the Middle East. Identification of the drivers that
More informationWhat Are We Learning from Business Training and Entrepreneurship Evaluations around the Developing World?
What Are We Learning from Business Training and Entrepreneurship Evaluations around the Developing World? David McKenzie and Christopher Woodruff Business training programs are a popular policy option
More informationRole of AWARENET in supporting capacity building for IWRM: Lessons learnt. Roula Majdalani Sustainable Development and Productivity Division UN-ESCWA
Role of AWARENET in supporting capacity building for IWRM: Lessons learnt Roula Majdalani Sustainable Development and Productivity Division UN-ESCWA 1 Outline Why do we need a capacity building network
More informationApplication of IAEA Safeguards in the Middle East
Board of Governors General Conference GOV/2016/40-GC(60)/14 Date: 5 August 2016 General Distribution Original: English For official use only Item 19 of the Conference's provisional agenda (GC(60)/1, Add.1
More informationImpact Evaluation AND. Human Development
Impact Evaluation AND Human Development Impact evaluation carefully measuring the capacity of poverty reduction programs to deliver results is central to the mission of the World Bank s Human Development
More informationKENYA YOUTH EMPOWERMENT PROJECT
KENYA YOUTH EMPOWERMENT PROJECT PRIVATE SECTOR TRAINING AND INTERNSHIPS IMPACT EVALUATION SURVEY KYEP (Pilot) is a Government of Kenya Project Financed by the World Bank It has two components; Capacity
More informationRURAL DEVELOPMENT POLICIES AND PROGRAMS IN THE ESCWA REGION: EVALUATION OF SUCCESSES AND FAILURES
Expert Group Meeting on Promoting Best Practices On sustainable Rural Livelihoods in the ESCWA Region Beirut, 24-25 November 2010 RURAL DEVELOPMENT POLICIES AND PROGRAMS IN THE ESCWA REGION: EVALUATION
More informationEnhancing Employability in OIC Countries The Role of Capacity Building and Microfinance. DR. SAVAS ALPAY Director General SESRIC
Enhancing Employability in OIC Countries The Role of Capacity Building and Microfinance DR. SAVAS ALPAY Director General SESRIC Enhancing Employability in OIC Countries Crises and Unemployment Increase
More informationCountry: Egypt. Case Study. Organization: Association of Upper Egypt for Education and Development (AUEED)
Country: Egypt Case Study Organization: Association of Upper Egypt for Education and Development (AUEED) The MENA ISO 26000 project (1/2) Donor agency: Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency
More informationPersonality vs. Practices in the Making of an Entrepreneur: Experimental Evidence from Togo
Personality vs. Practices in the Making of an Entrepreneur: Experimental Evidence from Togo Draft paper for the 2017 CSAE Francisco Campos* Michael Frese** Markus Goldstein* Leonardo Iacovone* Hillary
More informationIDAL & THE SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS (SDGS)
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS (SDGS) investinlebanon.gov.lb THE ROLE OF IDAL IN ACHIEVING THE UNITED NATIONS SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS IN LEBANON INTRODUCTION In 2016, the UN launched its 2030 Agenda
More informationStatus and Progress of CPFs in the NENA Region February 2016 FAO RNE Regional Professional Staff Meeting
Status and Progress of CPFs in the NENA Region Status of CPFs (as of January 2016) 2 PLANNED: Libya & Syrian Arab Republic 6 EXPIRING IN THE NEXT BIENNIUM: Algeria, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Mauritania, Morocco
More informationArab Fund for Economic and Social Development and Kuwait Fund for Arab Economic Development
Arab Fund for Economic and Social Development and Kuwait Fund for Arab Economic Development Joint Technical Meeting Arab Coordination Group Institutions and The OECD Development Assistance Committee Vienna,
More informationEgypt Country Report. Hesham Abd El-Hamid Nuclear Power Plants authority March March 2013
Egypt Country Report Hesham Abd El-Hamid Nuclear Power Plants authority March 2013 March 2013 Installed Capacity (MW) 31090 Consumers (Million) 28 Access to Electricity > 99% Diversifying Energy Resources
More informationE Distr. LIMITED E/ESCWA/ECW/2017/IG.1/L.1 12 August 2017 ENGLISH ORIGINAL: ARABIC
UNITED NATIONS ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COUNCIL E Distr. LIMITED 12 August 2017 ENGLISH ORIGINAL: ARABIC Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA) Committee on Women Eighth session Beirut, 4-5
More informationYouth Employment National Action Plan Sri Lanka
Youth Employment National Action Plan Sri Lanka Presented by YEN Secretariat Ministry of Youth Affairs 19/03/2007 Dr. Markus Mayer/ 26.05.2006 Youth Employment Network, Sri Lanka Is a UN Millennium Development
More informationSolar Water Heaters Development In MENA Region
Solar Water Heaters Development In MENA Region Prof. Dr. Mohamad KORDAB Expert on Energy for Sustainable Development Prof. At Damascus University Solar Thermal Application in Egypt, Palestine, Lebanon,
More informationWhat are the problems that young, adult and elderly workers face?
What are the problems that young, adult and elderly workers face? Labor Markets Core Course David N. MARGOLIS With help from Jean N. Lee, David Newhouse and Eduardo Zylberstajn Labor Markets Team, HDNSP
More informationThe Youth Employment Network. M&E implementation at Education for Employment (EFE), Morocco
Taqeem The Youth Employment Network Issue 1, July 2013 Case Studies M&E implementation at Education for Employment (EFE), Morocco An overview of the technical support initiative delivered as part of the
More informationChallenges to Reduce Non-Revenue Water
Challenges to Reduce Non-Revenue Water ACWUA NRW Diagnostic Tool AWAJ Water & Energy Conference Amman November 29 th, 2016 Mohammad Kurdi Morocco Algeria Tunisia Syria Palestine Lebanon Kuwait Iraq Bahrain
More informationG.M.B. Akash/Panos. Education for All Global Monitoring Report 2
G.M.B. Akash/Panos Education for All Global Monitoring Report 2 0 1 2 296 Education for All Global Monitoring Report 0 2 1 2 Women in Bangladesh attend a literacy class given at a BRAC support centre 297
More informationNUCLEAR DESALINATION ACTIVITIES AND PROSPECTS IN THE ARAB COUNTRIES
NUCLEAR DESALINATION ACTIVITIES AND PROSPECTS IN THE ARAB COUNTRIES M.M. Megahed Nuclear Power Plants Authority, Cairo, Egypt E-mail: MMegahed@hotmail.com International Conference on Nun-Electric Applications
More informationCareerMotion PRESENTATION
CareerMotion: A DEMONSTRATION PROJECT TO ASSIST PSE GRADUATES IN THEIR CAREER PLANNING Carole Vincent, SRDC Canadian Evaluation Society 31 st Annual Conference Victoria, BC, May 2010 CareerMotion PRESENTATION
More informationEntrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries:
DISCUSSION PAPER NO. 1302 Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries: A Meta Regression Analysis Yoonyoung Cho and Maddalena Honorati April 2013 Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries:
More informationKey Accountabilities (not all-inclusive, within delegated authority):
WORLD FOOD PROGRAMME REGIONAL BUREAU EGYPT EXTERNAL VACANCY ANNOUNCEMENT WFP/24/03/2016 DATE OF ISSUE: 24th of March 2016 DEADLINE: 10 th of April 2016 Job Title: Program Policy Officer Contract: Service
More informationArab Youth Unemployment: February 10 th, 2011
Arab Youth Unemployment: Roots, Risks and Responses February 10 th, 2011 Youth Unemployment in Syria: An Overview Nader Kabbani Director of Research Syria Trust for Development Presented at the Conference
More informationEvidence on Youth Employment. Susana Puerto, ILO
Evidence on Youth Employment Susana Puerto, ILO Overview I. Collecting and building the evidence II. What works 2 I. Collecting and Building the Evidence 3 The Youth Employment Inventory www.youth-employment-inventory.org
More informationIssue paper for Session 1. Employability: Education, skills development and technology. Bridging knowledge gaps
Issue paper for Session 1 Employability: Education, skills development and technology Bridging knowledge gaps Globalization places a high premium on education and skills Globalization has intensified international
More informationEnhancing Skills Training for Access to Decent Work United Nations Conference on the Status of Women rd February 2011
Enhancing Skills Training for Access to Decent Work United Nations Conference on the Status of Women 2011 23rd February 2011 Subhangi M.K.Herath (PhD) Senior lecturer Department of Sociology University
More informationMeasuring Impact Impact Evaluation Methods. Nathan Fiala DIW Berlin March 2014
Measuring Impact Impact Evaluation Methods Nathan Fiala DIW Berlin March 2014 1 Why Evaluate? Refine program design Design new programs Improve program targeting (effectiveness) Identify inefficient programs
More informationMarket Place (Group 1) The role of ACWUA in promoting exchange of experiences
Market Place (Group 1) The role of ACWUA in promoting exchange of experiences Eng. Khaldon Khashman Secretary General 10/5/2011 1 Content Introduction Water Sector Situation Challenges & Constraints ACWUA
More informationValue of vocational qualifications in the Construction and Built Environment Sector Final Report
Value of vocational qualifications in the Construction and Built Environment Sector Final Report March 2017 Study prepared by ICF Consulting from a commission by CITB. The views expressed by research participants
More informationPolicies and Investments for Poverty Reduction and Food Security in MENA
Policies and Investments for Poverty Reduction and Food Security in MENA Clemens Breisinger Senior Research Fellow, IFPRI Antalya, September 25, 2014 Overview Brief history of policy recommendations From
More informationThe Needs of Water and Wastewater Utilities in the Arab Region - Overview Eng. Khaldon Khashman ACWUA Secretary General
The Needs of Water and Wastewater Utilities in the Arab Region - Overview Eng. Khaldon Khashman ACWUA Secretary General German Water Partnership Annual Conference 2012 Berlin, Germany 27 March, 2012 ACWUA
More informationYouth Unemployment Challenge in Uganda and the Role of Employment Policies in Jobs Creation
1 of 7 6/18/2015 5:32 PM «Previous Next» Gemma Ahaibwe and Swaibu Mbowa August 26, 2014 4:18pm Youth Unemployment Challenge in Uganda and the Role of Employment Policies in Jobs Creation Introduction Youth
More informationGreen Water Assessment in the Arab Region An Approach to Virtual Water Evaluation
برنامج إدارة الموارد الماي ية Green Water Assessment in the Arab Region An Approach to Virtual Water Evaluation Khaled AbuZeid PhD, PE, PMP Regional Water Resources Manager, CEDARE Centre for Environment
More informationClimate change and adaptation Policy lessons from experiments in Nicaragua
Climate change and adaptation Policy lessons from experiments in Nicaragua Renos Vakis September, 2014 0 5 10 15 20 The problem: Dramatic changes in rainfall patterns and agronomy Rainfall Pre and Post
More informationMAPPING THE DEVELOPMENT JOURNEY USING LARGE-SCALE SURVEYS TO UNDERSTAND CONTEXT AND ADDRESS LEARNING NEEDS
MAPPING THE DEVELOPMENT JOURNEY USING LARGE-SCALE SURVEYS TO UNDERSTAND CONTEXT AND ADDRESS LEARNING NEEDS Authors: Ali Hayat (Chief of Party, MESP) and Dan Killian (Technical Manager, MSI) Decision-makers
More informationInterventions for employment creation in micro, small and mediumsized enterprises in low- and middle-income countries. A systematic review 1
Interventions for employment creation in micro, small and mediumsized enterprises in low- and middle-income countries. A systematic review 1 Submission for consideration for presentation at the 8 th IZA/World
More informationE-government Report Presentation for Government Saudi Arabia. Presentation by Richard Kerby, UNDESA
E-government Report Presentation for Government Saudi Arabia Presentation by Richard Kerby, UNDESA United Nations Global e-government Survey 2008: From e-government to Connected Governance Presentation
More informationSkilled labour Published on Innovation Policy Platform (
Skilled labour Access to skilled labour is key for innovation in firms: skilled labour can contribute to innovation and growth by generating new knowledge, developing incremental innovations, supporting
More informationBayt.com Employee Motivation Report in the Middle East and North Africa. January 2013
Bayt.com Employee Motivation Report in the Middle East and North Africa January 2013 Research Objectives To understand how the current environment is impacting the satisfaction levels of employees in the
More informationEfficiency, Firm-size and Gender: The Case of Informal Firms in Latin America
World Bank From the SelectedWorks of Mohammad Amin December, 2010 Efficiency, Firm-size and Gender: The Case of Informal Firms in Latin America Mohammad Amin Available at: https://works.bepress.com/mohammad_amin/28/
More informationIMPACT EVALUATION STUDY PUNJAB SKILLS DEVELOPMENT FUND S FUNDED SKILLS FOR JOBS APRIL-JUNE 2017 AT KAARVAN CRAFTS FOUNDATION INSTITUTES - BAHAWALPUR
IMPACT EVALUATION STUDY PUNJAB SKILLS DEVELOPMENT FUND S FUNDED SKILLS FOR JOBS APRIL-JUNE 2017 AT KAARVAN CRAFTS FOUNDATION INSTITUTES - BAHAWALPUR CONTENTS 1 2 3 4 5 6 8 9 11 13 14 15 17 Introduction
More informationTable of Contents. Proposed Actions Topic Three Topic Four Topic Five... 9 Proposed Actions... 10
WORKING GROUP PAPER ON HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT (EDUCATION AND VOCATIONAL TRAINING) 1 Table of Contents Introduction... 3 Afghanistan and Regional Cooperation... 4 Five Priority Areas for Regional Cooperation...
More informationManagement skill, entrepreneurial mindset, and enterprise survival: Evidence from randomized experiments and repeated surveys in Vietnam
Management skill, entrepreneurial mindset, and enterprise survival: Evidence from randomized experiments and repeated surveys in Vietnam Yuki Higuchi (Nagoya City University) https://sites.google.com/site/yukihiguchipage/
More informationMENA OECD WORKSHOP. How Could Business Associations Act As a driving force to Economic REFORM. 25 June 2007 Manama - Bahrain
MENA OECD WORKSHOP How Could Business Associations Act As a driving force to Economic REFORM 25 June 2007 Manama - Bahrain Presented by President Dr. Amany Asfour Egyptian Business Women Association (EBWA)
More informationCAPACITY DEVELOPMENT AT A TIME OF CRISIS: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES IN THE MENA REGION
CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT AT A TIME OF CRISIS: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES IN THE MENA REGION GIFT-MENA Annual Conference (Marrakesh, 10-12 February 2015) Atsuko Okuda Chief, Governance and Statebuilding Section,
More informationIFAD Rural Poverty Report 2010 Regional Consultation Workshop March 25-26, 2010 American University of Lebanon, Beirut, Lebanon
IFAD Rural Poverty Report 2010 Regional Consultation Workshop March 25-26, 2010 American University of Lebanon, Beirut, Lebanon Synthesis Report Introduction: In the context of the development of the Rural
More informationIDE Research Bulletin
http://www.ide.go.jp IDE Research Bulletin Research Summary based on papers prepared for publication in academic journals with the aim of contributing to the academia Skills Development for Youth in Africa
More informationThird Pillar: Knowledge, Innovation and Scientific Research
3 rd Pillar: Knowledge, Innovation & Scientific Third Pillar: Knowledge, Innovation and Scientific Overview of Current Situation The concept of knowledge,, and scientific research expands to include the
More informationAli Karnib, PhD Senior Water Expert Sustainable Development Policies Division
LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE MDG+ INITIATIVE INDICATOR FRAMEWORK 12/04/2016 الدروس المستفادة من خالل تنفيذ اطار مبادرة MDG+ Economic And Social Commission For Western Asia Ali Karnib, PhD Senior Water Expert
More informationThe Dynamics of Entrepreneurial Human Capital: Evidence from Indonesia
The Dynamics of Entrepreneurial Human Capital: Evidence from Indonesia August 29, 2012 Russell Toth Lecturer, School of Economics, The University of Sydney Affiliate, Small and Medium Enterprise Initiative,
More informationFIELD s interest in this area stems
OCTOBER 1999 ISSUE 1... training and technical assistance are arguably the most important components of microenterprise development services in the U.S. today, particularly for low-income clients. ASSESSING
More informationOverview & Initial Results. The World Bank
Overview & Initial Results The World Bank 1 Why measure skills? Skills are at the core of improving employment outcomes and increasing productivity and growth. Yet, in many countries education and training
More informationICQN/TVSD EXPERTS SEMINAR ON YOUTH EMPLOYMENT
MINISTRY OF STATE, MINISTRY OF EMPLOYMENT, SOCIAL AFFAIRS AND VOCATIONAL TRAINING ICQN/TVSD EXPERTS SEMINAR ON YOUTH EMPLOYMENT FROM 31 MARCH TO 1 st APRIL 2014 IVOTEL PLATEAU ~ ABIDJAN/IVORY COAST SUMMARY
More informationFOLLOW-UP REPORTS AND ACTIVITIES
FOLLOW-UP REPORTS AND ACTIVITIES OUTLINE 1. Outcomes of the Training Program on «Statistical Database Design and Visualization Tools Development» 2. Results of the Survey on the UN Minimum Set of Gender
More informationUse of household surveys for measuring entrepreneurship from a gender perspective
Use of household surveys for measuring entrepreneurship from a gender perspective Social and Housing Statistics Section - UNSD Building on existing household-level data collection Introducing changes in
More informationNew Thinking about Jobs. Presentation at UN Public Service Forum, 22 June 2017, The Hague Luc Christiaensen, Lead Economist, Jobs Group, World Bank
New Thinking about Jobs Presentation at UN Public Service Forum, 22 June 2017, The Hague Luc Christiaensen, Lead Economist, Jobs Group, World Bank Often the problem is not so much the QUANTITY of jobs,
More informationIndustrial Training Council
Ministry of Trade and Industry Industrial Training Council Overview The Industrial Training Council (ITC) is a publicly-funded organization affiliated to the Egyptian Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI).
More informationEmpowering Young Women through Business and Vocational Training
Investing in rural people Impact Brief Series, Issue 10 Empowering Young Women through Business and Vocational Training Evidence from Rural Upper Egypt This brief summarizes the findings of an impact evaluation1
More informationThe Research Reactors in Arab Countries: characteristics and utilizations. D. MOSBAH and S.TAKRITI Arab Atomic Energy Agency AAEA - Tunis
The Research Reactors in Arab Countries: characteristics and utilizations D. MOSBAH and S.TAKRITI Arab Atomic Energy Agency AAEA - Tunis The Arab Atomic Energy Agency AAEA is an Arab scientific organization
More information