Renewable Energy in The Netherlands November 2016
Dr. Martien Visser Professor Energy Transition & Network Integration Hanze University of Applied Sciences Groningen Partner of the Energy Academy Europe E-mail: b.m.visser@pl.hanze.nl This analyses contains information of various sources and own analyses, including various estimates. Readers are encouraged to add, to improve the quality of the information provided. Nov-16 Page 2
The Entrance database on Renewable Energy is regularly improved by the creation and/or refinement of (sub)models Recent improvements October 2016: in cooperation with Peter Segaar of PolderPV, the capacity of solar panels in the Netherlands has been adjusted upwards On 1 November 2016, a real time application for solar, wind biogas energy has been launched: Energieopwek.nl This real-time application was sponsored by SER, Gasunie New Energy, TenneT and NetbeheerNederland Nov-16 Page 3
November 2016 In a Nutshell CO2 emissions from energy usage were 16.1 Mton, 8% higher than last year The fraction renewable energy was 5.3%, down from 5.9% last year. The percentage renewable power was 10.9%, down from 14.2% last year. Electricity production by wind was 30% lower y-o-y and reached 0.71 TWh. Electricity production by solar-pv was 45% higher y-o-y and reached 0.04 TWh Average utilization of wind capacity was (just) 24% and of solar-pv, it was 4% The fraction renewable energy in Q3 2016 has been assessed at 5.8% Nov-16 Page 4
Fraction Renewable Energy until Q3 2016 The fraction renewable energy has been calculated using the official EU regulations. In Q3 2016, the Netherlands produced 5.8% of its final energy consumption in the form of renewables. Dutch energy policy is focused to reach 14% renewable energy in 2020. Nov-16 Page 5
Content November 2016 data Monthly profiles Monthly data Energy Demand in a Nutshell Hourly data Miscellaneous Nov-16 Page 6
SELECTED ENERGY DATA FROM NOVEMBER 2016 Nov-16 Page 7
Renewable Energy November 2016 Renewable Energy is produced in various forms. The most important contributor is biomass (biogas, waste, wood and bio-oil). In November 2016, according to the official rules, 5.3% of energy consumed in the Netherlands was renewable energy. Nov-16 Page 8
Final Energy Demand November 2016 Energy is used for many different purposes. In November 2016, the most important energy applications were gas (heating and industry) and oil for various forms of transport. Nov-16 Page 9
CO2 Emissions November 2016 In November, the national energy-related CO2 emissions, calculated using the official formula, are estimated at 16.1 Mton, up from 14.9 Mton in November 2015. Main reason is the colder weather in November 2016 Nov-16 Page 10
Power Generation Capacity November 2016 The capacity (beginning of November) is the so-called name-plate capacity. In practice, not all capacity is available for the market due to planned and unplanned maintenance and mothballing. Nov-16 Page 11
Power Supplies November 2016 In November 2016, power consumption was 10,0 TWh, 2% higher than last year. Nov-16 Page 12
CO2 from Power Generation November 2016 In November 2016, 70% of the CO2 emissions from the power sector came from the coalfired power stations. The CO2 emissions from the net imports are given for comparison, since these do not contribute to the national CO2 emissions. Nov-16 Page 13
CO2 from Dutch Power Generation November 2016 The daily CO2 emission per kwh produced varies due to variations in the power mix. On average, the CO2 emission in November was 466 g/kwh, down from 494 gr/kwh in October. Nov-16 Page 14
SELECTED MONTHLY PROFILES (using daily data) Nov-16 Page 15
Daily Renewable Energy November 2016 The daily contributions to the renewable energy, according to the classification by CBS. In November, for comparison, the average daily gross final energy consumption was 1960 GWh per day. One GWh is one million kwh or about 100.000 m3 of natural gas. Nov-16 Page 16
Energy Demand November 2016 Energy demand shows a typical weekday-weekend pattern. Gas demand is (partly) dependent on ambient temperature. Nov-16 Page 17
Conventional Power Generation November 2016 Conventional power generation is characterized by high volatility in wind and solar production and low imports, and hence, fossil fuel generation, including coal-fired generation, varied significantly. A special day was Sunday November 19 th, with relative low power demand, high wind availability and high imports. Nov-16 Page 18
Daily Wind and Solar Power Production November 2016 November 2016 was characterized by low availability of wind and relative high solar production. The average utilization rate of the wind turbines was 24% and for solar-pv it was 4%. 1 GWh is sufficient to provide power for a year for 300 households. Nov-16 Page 19
Contribution of Renewable Energy November 2016 In November, the percentage of renewable power varied between 5% and 25%, with an average of 10.9%. The average percentage of renewable energy was 5.3%. These percentages have been calculated using the official EU procedures. Nov-16 Page 20
SELECTED MONTHLY ENERGY DATA Nov-16 Page 21
Gross Final Energy Consumption 2016 (and 2015) The gross final consumption of energy is a quantity used to calculate the percentage of renewable energy. This quantity excludes the energy used in the energy sector (mainly due to the production of electricity), for international shipping and for feedstock and the energy used for international aviation above 6.18% of the total Nov-16 Page 22
Gas Demand (excluding gas-to-power) 2016 (and 2015) Gas consumption in November, excluding gas-to-power, was much higher than last year, due to lower temperatures. Nov-16 Page 23
Gas Production 2016 (and 2015) In November, Dutch natural gas production was similar than last year. Nov-16 Page 24
Power Demand 2016 (and 2015) In November, Dutch power demand was 2% higher than last year. Nov-16 Page 25
Wind Production 2016 (and 2015) Wind production in November 2016 was 0.47 TWh, 30% lower than November last year. The average utilization of wind capacity, combined onshore and offshore, was 24%. Nov-16 Page 26
Solar PV Production 2016 (and 2015) In November 2016, electricity generation by Solar PV in The Netherlands reached 0.04 TWh. This was 45% higher than last year, because of the increase in solar-pv capacity and more sunshine. In November, the average utilization rate of solar-pv capacity was 3%. Nov-16 Page 27
Coal-to-Power 2016 (and 2015) For November 2016, coal-fired power generation has been estimated to be lower than last year. Nov-16 Page 28
Gas to Power 2016 (and 2015) For November 2016, gas-fired power has been estimated to be higher than last year. Nov-16 Page 29
LNG imports 2016 (and 2015) This figure depicts the amount of LNG injected into the gas grid, as presented by GTS. The figure excludes the usage of LNG as transport fuel. 1 TWh is equal to about 100 million m3. November--15 Page 30
Renewable Energy All Sources 2016 (and 2015) This assessment is based on various assumptions. Renewable energy production in November was equal to last year. The lower availability of wind energy was compensated by higher utilization of wood in households. Nov-16 Page 31
Renewable Energy Percentage 2016 (and 2015) In November, the percentage of renewable energy was 5.3%, this is 0.6% lower than last year, primarily due to higher usage of energy by society. Nov-16 Page 32
CO2 Emissions 2016 (and 2015) After a significant rise of the CO2 emissions in 2015, compared to 2014, the CO2 emissions in 2016 are similar to those in 2015. In November, am increase by 8% was recorded, due to lower ambient temperatures and hence, higher usage of energy for heating. Nov-16 Page 33
ENERGY DEMAND IN A NUTSHELL Nov-16 Page 34
Energy Demand November 2016 Dutch government has allocated Energy Demand in four categories. These categories (and this figure) do not take into account energy demand for international shipping, aviation and feedstock. During summer, energy demand for low temperature heat is very low. (1 GWh is about equal to the average daily energy production of 40 wind turbines of 3 MW each) Nov-16 Page 35
Energy Demand Low Temperature Heat The primary energy requirement for Low Temperature heat, mainly buildings and green houses, varies with ambient temperature. Nov-16 Page 36
Energy Demand High Temperature Heat The primary energy requirement for High Temperature Heat (mainly industry) varies with the economic activities in the Netherlands. The higher gas demand from industry indicates economic growth. Nov-16 Page 37
Energy Demand Transportation The primary energy requirement for Transportation (excluding international shipping and aviation) varies with the economic activity in the Netherlands. Fuel bought abroad, e.g. since taxes are lower, are not included in this figure. Nov-16 Page 38
Energy Demand Power Sector The primary energy requirement for the power sector varies, with the import/export balance and with the production of renewable power. This figure excludes the primary energy demand caused by power imports. Nov-16 Page 39
CO2 Emissions November 2016 This figure shows the daily CO2 emission of each of the four demand sectors. This figure does not take into account the energy demand for shipping, aviation and feedstock. During summer, CO2 emissions from lower temperature heat are very low. (1 kton CO2 is equal to the average daily CO2 emission of 90.000 households, each using 1500 m3 gas and 3500 kwh electricity annually. Nov-16 Page 40
CO2 emissions Low Temperature Heat The CO2 emissions from Low Temperature Heat, mainly buildings and green houses, vary with ambient air temperature and the fraction of renewable energy which is used, mainly biomass and heat pumps. This figure excludes the CO2 emissions due to the production of electricity used in low temperature heating. Nov-16 Page 41
CO2 emissions High Temperature Heat CO2 emissions from High Temperature Heat, mainly industry, vary mainly with the economic activity in the Netherlands. Nov-16 Page 42
CO2 emissions Transportation CO2 emissions from Transportation (excluding international shipping and aviation, which are not accounted for in the national CO2 emissions) vary with the economic activity in the Netherlands. Fuel bought abroad, e.g. because of lower prices, is not included in this figure as well. Nov-16 Page 43
CO2 emissions Power Sector CO2 emissions from the power sector vary with the amount of coal used for power generation, the amount of renewable power produced, and the level of power imports. Nov-16 Page 44
SELECTED HOURLY ENERGY DATA Nov-16 Page 45
Gas Supply November 2016 The send-out of the gas storages is mainly related to ambient temperatures, but shows as well a week-weekend pattern. In November the storages were sometimes being filled, which is represented by negative values. Gas supplies include Dutch consumption and exports. Nov-16 Page 46
Gas Demand Including Gas-to-Power November 2016 Domestic gas demand in November peaked at 100 GW. In this graph, the term industry is defined as direct connections to the Gasunie grid. The term distribution includes households, offices, commercials and small and medium size industries which are connected to the distribution grid. Nov-16 Page 47
Gas Imports & Exports November 2016 In November 2016, gas exports were about 70 TWh, while gas imports were 42 TWh. Nov-16 Page 48
Power Imports & Exports November 2016 In November 2016, power imports were 1.2 TWh, while power exports were 1.0 TWh. Nov-16 Page 49
Wind Power November 2016 November 2016 was characterized by a low and volatile wind availability; the average utilization rate of the wind turbines was 24%. Nov-16 Page 50
Solar PV Power November 2016 November was not very sunny and the utilization rate of solar PV installed was just 3%. Nov-16 Page 51
The following set of slides presents for each month in 2016 the hourly contributions of various energy sources to total power consumption in The Netherlands. Nov-16 Page 52
Power Generation January 2016 In the week of 19-23 January, gas-fired power generation peaked, due to low wind availability and net exports that occurred simultaneously. Nov-16 Page 53
Power Generation February 2016 In the second half of February, gas-fired power generation peaked, due to low wind availability and low imports. Nov-16 Page 54
Power Generation March 2016 Around Eastern, the demand for power was relatively low and there was a high availability of wind, both domestic and imported. Hence, significant domestic gas and coal-fired power production had to be taken out. Nov-16 Page 55
Power Generation April 2016 April 2016 was characterized by high imports and a volatile wind availability. Hence, fossil fuel generation varied significantly during the month. Nov-16 Page 56
Power Generation May 2016 May 2016 was characterized by high imports and a volatile wind availability. Hence, fossil fuel generation varied significantly during the month. Nov-16 Page 57
Power Generation June 2016 June 2016 was characterized by high power imports, outages of the nuclear and coalfired power plants and low wind availability. Nov-16 Page 58
Power Generation July 2016 July 2016 was characterized by high power imports and low wind availability. Nov-16 Page 59
Power Generation August 2016 August 2016 was characterized by high power imports and low wind availability. Nov-16 Page 60
Power Generation September 2016 November 2016 was characterized by high power imports and low wind availability. Nov-16 Page 61
Power Generation October 2016 October 2016 was characterized by high power imports and low wind availability. Power demand in the second half of November was lower than in the first half. This may be due to erroneous data from TenneT in that period. Nov-16 Page 62
Power Generation November 2016 November 2016 was characterized by relatively low wind availability. In general, net power exports coincided with low wind availability; hence, power generation by gas fired power stations has been very volatile. Nov-16 Page 63
The following set of slides presents for each week in 2016 the hourly contributions of wind and solar-pv to the total power consumption in The Netherlands. Nov-16 Page 64
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 65
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 66
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 67
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 68
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 69
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 70
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 71
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 72
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 73
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 74
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 75
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 76
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 77
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 78
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 79
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 80
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 81
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 82
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 83
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 84
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 85
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 86
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 87
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 88
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 89
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 90
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 91
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 92
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 93
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 94
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 95
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 96
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 97
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 98
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 99
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 100
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 101
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 102
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 103
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 104
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 105
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 106
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 107
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 108
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 109
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 110
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 111
Hourly Solar-PV and Wind Generation 2016 Nov-16 Page 112
MISCELLANEOUS Nov-16 Page 113
Effective Temperature November 2016 In November 2016, the average daily effective temperature (temperature including wind shield factor) was only 7.8 o C, slightly lower than in November 2015. Nov-16 Page 114
Import/export balances of gas and power This curve represents the long term monthly net import/export balances of natural gas and power since January 2014. Negative numbers express net exports. Positive numbers net imports. Since 2015, the Groningen gas production has decreased significantly. Nov-16 Page 115
Fuel Specific CO2 Emissions g/kwh 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 204 279 341 450 298 396 798 Sources: CE-Delft, own analyses Fuels Power Generation Characteristic CO2 emissions used in this presentation. Nov-16 Page 116
Epilogue b.m.visser@pl.hanze.nl This presentation is based on numerous sources on energy demand, supply and production in The Netherlands. Unfortunately, these sources do not cover the entire Dutch energy system, nor do these sources provide the insights needed for this presentation. Thus, various approximations and scaling factors were derived and used. The author would like to thank students from Hanze University of Applied Sciences in Groningen and various consulted energy experts for there feedback on the methods used. Currently, the aggregated results of this work are in good agreement with data supplied by the Dutch National Office of Statistics (CBS) and it is believed that the this presentation gives a fair presentation of the complex reality of the Dutch energy system. Nevertheless, the author invites readers to comment on the data provided to further improve this work. After all, good and reliable data are at the heart of any successful policy to make our world more sustainable. Nov-16 Page 117