Portrait of Forestry Governance Implementation Case Studies: Central Kalimantan and West Nusa Tenggara
|
|
- Garry Barnett
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Fact Sheet Portrait of Forestry Governance Implementation Case Studies: Central Kalimantan and West Nusa Tenggara A. Background The good forests governance seems to be the unfinished issue in Indonesia. Forestry Law no.41 of 1999 is expected to give spaces for openness and inclusivity in the forestry governance, in fact still so far from the expectation in its implementation. Several regulations on forestry information, public involvement in forestry planning and forests area establishment haven t really answer the needs of Indonesia peoples. Horizontal conflict between the communities who live in the forests with communities who live around the forests remains high. Picture by Huma HuMA found that the conflict in communities that happened in the forestry sectors happened in 722,637 Hectares area. 1 That a figure is not included the overlapping government policies that obstructing the implementation of good forests governance. There are several problems that need to be solved in order to improve the forestry condition in Indonesia. 1 Sources from the Documenting System of Land and Other Natural Resources Conflict HuMaWin) Partner Organizations of HuMa (Qbar, RMI, LBHSemarang, LBBT, Bantaya and Wallacea) updated on June The IndonesiaGovernance Forest Initiative (GFI Indonesia) since 2009 has been developing the indicator tools to analyze the gap between policies and good forests governance in Indonesia. This analysis tools, at first developed by the global network that based in the USA and Brazil. This network then expanded and including Indonesia and Cameroon as countries that have wide forests cover. As global tool, the implementation of criteria and indicators in the tools need some adjustment with the local characteristic in the user countries, including Indonesia. GFI Indonesia has done some assessment and revision as effort of the context adjustment, especially in Kalimantan and West Nusa Tenggara (NTB). B. Forests Governance Assessment Assessment by GFI Indonesia was not intended to give index comparison of good and bad scale, but highlights on depth analysis on aspects of actors, policies/regulations and effectiveness/ practices in forestry governance in Indonesia. All of that aspect viewed from the good governance perspective (transparency, participation, accountability and coordination). Hopefully the analysis can give real recommendations for the improvement of forests governance in Indonesia. The analysis highlights more into the State s action in recognizing and fulfilling the basic rights of its people. All indicators developed with considering the impact implication that experienced by the communities who live in and around the forests area. The scope of this research is more into all actors point of view on the implementation of forests governance in their own area. It means the research also looked at how the existing actors
2 (government, civil society, academics, NGOs, Parliament and media) have roles in the process. Based on the basic issues faced by the forestry sector in Indonesia, this research looked at the forestry sectors from the forests management problem (including law enforcement), land tenure and other important aspect is revenue or State s income from the forestry sector. The problems are not easy to be answered, even through research because a lot of variables impacted the resolution. The complexity of this problem is understood as one of the consideration in this research, so the objective of the research is not to find a secret recipe one size fits all but to find what can be improved and what the priorities to be resolved immediately are. From the assessment of the issue, we get the preview of the real conditions of forests governance processes. The assessment in this research conducted in 2 provincial areas in Indonesia, Central Kalimantan and West Nusa Tenggara. The reason why those 2 provinces are selected based on the thinking that both sites have unique characteristics in Indonesia. Central Kalimantan is a province that can be considered as a mainland province while West Nusa Tenggara is a small archipelago province. The forests management on those sites also different, where in Central Kalimantan there s huge deforestation problems, besides that this province also a pilot province for several REDD+ schemes in Indonesia. While for West Nusa Tenggara, the forests cover is smaller and have several Forests Management Unit(FMU) model in Indonesia, including the West Rinjani Protection Forests Management Unit (KPHL)-one of the pilot FMU in Indonesia. With those two reasons, the researchers conducted in Central Kalimantan and West Nusa Tenggara. 1. Portrait of West Nusa Tenggara Forestry Governance The assessment findings in West Nusa Tenggara resulted in interesting information and facts on the portrait of forests resources governance. It showed that the management of forests resources in West Nusa Tenggara (NTB) is still weak in implementing the principles of good governance in the forestry sector. This conclusion came from the accumulation of long process of assessment conducted the GFI Indonesia, with highlighting the assessment on the consistency of implementation of governance, in the level of regulations, actors and the practices, for example, the mechanisms of information management in the agency/fmu level. To date, the information on forests management in NTB can be accessed through one document which titled forestry statistic. There are no groupings or categorization of information by the FMU, to comply with the regulations. In the other side, there aren t any systematic and comprehensive efforts by the FMU/agency to disseminate the information to public through accessible and easy-to-understand media. The information dissemination still conducted limitedly through extension and socialization processes. 2. Portrait of Forests Governance in West Kalimantan The forests governance in Central Kalimantan is still weak which showed with the unclear Spatial Planning. There s conflict of interests between National and Regional Spatial Planning Agency, where the national institution refers to the Letter of Decision Ministry of Forestry 529 (SK Menhut 529), while the regional/local institution refers to the Agreed Functional Forest Classification (TGHK) 1982 and Provincial Spatial Planning 8/2003. In that differences, related to the change of forests status to date, is still facing a dead-end.
3 The communities who would like to initiate and to manage their forests better facing complex and long bureaucracy and processes. This could be seen by on the struggle of Kalawa village communities in Pulang Pisau Regency, where they need 7 years ( ) to get what they want, to get the legality of forests management in the Village Forests status that defined by the Ministry of Forestry. The struggle of indigenous peoples in the recognition of their indigenous forests in the local/regional context is supported by the Local Regulation no. 16/2008 on Dayak Tribe Institutions in Central Kalimantan. In this context, it is intended to encourage the recognition on the forests management by the indigenous institutions, which then strengthened by the Governor Regulation no. 13/2009 on Indigenous Land and Indigenous Rights of Land. Of course, this is a red notes on the ineffective coordination between the national and regional in fulfilling the rights of indigenous peoples which already recognized through the law and regulations. In the public disclosure issue, Central Kalimantan province at least already showed some efforts on implementing the principles, even before the issuance of Law no 28/2006, through the Governor Instruction 28/2006 on Responsibility to Publish Central Kalimantan s Data and Information to Public. It is the responsibility of public institutions in Central Kalimantan to disseminate the information through the Central Kalimantan government s website ( Unfortunately, not all public institutions comply with this instruction, proven by several public institutions that never give any information at all about their programs on the government s website. The information on the website provided on the website is only general/ceremonial information. If there s any important data from public institutions, it s not the updated version. A year after the issuance of Law no 14/2008, Central Kalimantan province has established the Provincial Information Commission, through the Governor Regulation no: /322/2011 on the Provincial Information Commission Members Appointment for period. Of course the public expect that this commission can encourage the information disclosure in this province. C. Road to the Forests Governance Improvement The consistency of implementation on good forest governance is what every party longed for, including the communities. Of course, this is not only an empty dream, keep in mind that findings in this research already identified several opportunities for the implementation of the principles, though it is still not apart with the existing limitations. 1. Transparency The implementation of transparency principles in government system is an important pillar to encourage good forest governance. The issuance of Law no. 14/ 2008 on Public Information Disclosure, supposed to be the main instrument in the implementation of that principle. Without any transparency and proper information
4 access, it can trigger the resistance and bias of interests on the policy-makers. The needs for information transparency in the forestry sector have been responded by the Ministry of Forestry with the issuance of Ministry of Forestry Regulation no.2/2010 (Permenhut no.2/2010) on Forestry Information System and Ministry of Forestry Regulation no.7/2011 (Permenhut no.7/2011) on Public Information Services in the Ministry of Forestry. We can see the progressive process of preparation of the tools and facilities in the national level related to the information transparency. This is also should be happening in the local/regional level. 2. Participation Picture by Huma The public involvement in the decisionmaking related to the forests management is a part of Forestry Law (Chapter X). In fact, the Forestry Law based on the participative and just principles (article 3, letter d). This legal basis, though categorized as general and not stating clearly how the communities participation implemented in the forests management, the basic and general guarantee have given the communities to their rights to participate in the forests management, including in the forestry policy-making processes. The communities who live in and around the forests have the rights to be involved in each process of forestry policy-making. The Development Planning Consultation (Musrenbang) from the village until provincial level is one of the interpretation of public participation in the development and policy-making processes. But is that enough for the participative and just forests governance context? This research looked at several basic regulations that can accommodate the public participation in the policy-making and forestry planning processes. This is important to be done because to implement the ideal participation, it needs clear mechanisms for the communities to be able to involve. The general and principle regulation tends to blur the participation process and in the end will make the participation aspect further. 3. Coordination An issue that never been apart with the discussion on forest governance in Indonesia is the issue of coordination. In the last almost 40 years, the coordination issue always showed up but never resolved and gets clear solutions and answers. The forestry sector also is not apart with that issue. The cross-ministries/institutions coordination is still shadowing the implementation of forests governance in Indonesia. The implementation of coordination sometimes interpreted through the law, with the issuance of multistakeholders forum. Just like happened in the forestry sector, where in the Forestry Law stated about the establishment of the forestry experts forum (article 70 clause 3). In its implementation, the National Forestry Council (DKN) is established. In the context of spatial planning, the multi-stakeholders forum accommodated through the National/Regional Spatial Planning Coordination Body (BKPRN/D). Looking at the regulation structure and the availability of resources, the portrait of coordination implementation in Indonesia supposed to be going well. But in its process, the existence of those instruments still leaves problems in the implementation. Of course everyone hopes for one same direction towards the sake of the State, but that direction will be understood differently
5 by each stakeholder. Based on that, the coordination from the government and nongovernment institutions is important to be improved and implemented. With that, all actions can be done effectively, systematic, and integrated. 4. Accountability The final result of the good governance with highlighting the information transparency, participation and coordination is a decision from the government that can be accounted for. It means that the public can question each decision made, if they feel that decision is not in accordance with their aspirations. This condition is a logical consequence of a law state. Same thing with Indonesia, it is already stated clearly in the constitution that each citizen have same position in the eyes of law (article 27 clause 1). This legal basis is a basic principle for public to have same position and rights to ask for accountability. However, the accountability in this context is interpreted widely not only in the relationship between the public with policy-makers, but also look at how the mediation process implemented when conflict happened between the communities. D. Recommendations Several facts covered in the process of research in West Nusa Tenggara and Central Kalimantan, generates several ideas to encourage the optimization and improvement of forest governance. Related to that, GFI Indonesia suggests several important recommendations to be followed up, which: 1. To improve the capacity and the technical skills of the communities and the government, in the context of fulfilling the communities procedural rights (information, participation, and accountability). 2. To improve the accuracy, availability, and the disclosure of information from institutions related to forestry sector. The principle of every information is open, unless the exception needs to be used as main reference. To strengthen the data and information baseline through optimization the activity of Periodic Comprehensive Forest Inventory (IMHB) nationally, is an effort that needs to be done. 3. The provided information also needs to include the information on permits, mapping, environmental condition, and other important information, so the community can also monitor. 4. To immediately implement the mandate from Law of Public Information Disclosure, to prepare and establish the institutions in the local level, in order to effectively implement the information disclosure across Indonesia. This needs to be done through the appointment of Information and Data Management Officials (PPID) in all government and public institutions, especially in provincial and regency level. 5. To evaluate the implementation of Musrenbang, which more systematic and inclusive, especially the ones related to the forestry sector. The process from village Musrenbang (Musrenbangdes) to the national Musrenbang (Musrenbangnas) needs to be improved to be more systematic and open. This to resolve the discrepancy between the planning (and budgeting) in the national level with the local/village s needs. 6. To provide and have minimum services standard for information provision and communities participation in the whole process of forests management. The inclusive (involving all stakeholders) needs to be done, started from the planning, implementation until the evaluation. 7. To optimize the inclusive process to be implementation through the acceleration of the Forests Management Unit (FMU) establishment-not only in the areas distribution but physically existence). Tools, facilities and capacity from the
6 FMU s actors have to be prepared so it can be immediately effective once it s established. 8. To improve the effectiveness of law enforcement on the forest crimes actors in order to give deterrent effect for the intellectual actors of the forest crimes and to encourage law breakthrough with using instrument from other regulations, such as corruption and money laundering, in order to strengthening the law enforcement in forestry sector.
CONDITIONS FOR IBSAP IMPLEMENTATION
7 CONDITIONS FOR IBSAP IMPLEMENTATION The strategy and action plan as described in Chapters 5 and 6 provides an illustration of the efforts that Indonesia needs to undertake to implement its long-term
More informationREDD Readiness Progress Fact Sheet COUNTRY: Indonesia May 2013
1. R-PP Preparation and FCPF Readiness grant - R-PP was endorsed in June 2009 - FCPF grant was signed in June 2011. The grant consisted of four main components: Analytical work, Support to Readiness Process,
More informationBP REDD+ REDD+ Management Agency: Operational Strategy
BP REDD+ REDD+ Management Agency: Operational Strategy 2014-2015 Agus P. Sari Deputy Chair on Planning and Funding REDD+ Management Agency Keeping our forests standing and peatlands intact is important
More information6. Cross-Cutting Issues Indicators
6. Cross-Cutting Issues Indicators This thematic area evaluates in more detail several key topics that transcend each of the first four thematic areas. As such, the indicators in this section can be applied
More informationREDD Readiness Progress Fact Sheet COUNTRY: Indonesia October 2013
1. R-PP Preparation and FCPF Readiness grant R-PP was endorsed in June 2009 FCPF grant was signed in June 2011. The grant consisted of four main components: i) Analytical work; ii) Support to Readiness
More informationPGI REDD+ Governance Assessment: A Preliminary Framework
PGI REDD+ Governance Assessment: A Preliminary Framework Rome, 18 November 2010 WHAT IS PGI (Partnership Governance Index) It s a tool to assess local governance performance based on a set of objective
More informationGOVERNANCE ASSESSMENT OF PARTICIPATORY FOREST MANAGEMENT
GOVERNANCE ASSESSMENT OF PARTICIPATORY FOREST MANAGEMENT Experience Applying the WRI s GoF Initiative Assessment Methodology and Indicator Framework in Malawi PERFORM Lilongwe, Malawi September, 2015 Why
More informationReflections on Principles for Architecture for the 21 st Century
Reflections on Principles for Architecture for the 21 st Century Background: 1. We (you) are unique, and have a unique opportunity (and we all have a responsibility) to add value; 2. There is a demand
More informationForest Carbon Accounting for REDD+ Readiness at District and FMU Level Experiences from Kalimantan
Indonesian-German Forests and Climate Change Programme (FORCLIME) Forest Carbon Accounting for REDD+ Readiness at District and FMU Level Experiences from Kalimantan Jakarta, 03.03.2015 Franz-Fabian Bellot
More informationThis is not an ADB material. The views expressed in this document are the views of the author/s and/or their organizations and do not necessarily
This is not an ADB material. The views expressed in this document are the views of the author/s and/or their organizations and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the Asian Development
More informationForest governance reform in Indonesia and niche for EFI interventions
Forest governance reform in Indonesia and niche for EFI interventions EU REDD Facility Steering Committee 29 January 2013 Leif John Fosse, Adeline Dontenville Agenda overview 1 Agenda overview REDD+ forest
More informationGetting Ready with Forest Governance
A Review of the World Bank Forest Carbon Partnership Facility Readiness Preparation Proposals and the UN-REDD National Programme Documents Lauren Goers, Andrew Williams, Florence Daviet, Crystal Davis,
More informationTaking Stock of International Contributions to Low Carbon, Climate Resilient Land Use in Indonesia
Taking Stock of International Contributions to Low Carbon, Climate Resilient Land Use in Indonesia Angela Falconer Skye Glenday BRAZIL CHINA EUROPE INDIA INDONESIA UNITED STATES Menara Bank Danamon, 11th
More informationPolicy Brief FOREST Governance
Policy Brief FOREST Governance FIRST EDITION 1 DESEMBER 2014 This Policy Brief was prepared by the Working Group on Forest Governance which was formed in May 2014 by forestry agencies and institutions
More informationDeveloped through cooperation between Ministry of Forestry, GIZ-FORCLIME Programme, Daemeter Consulting, and stakeholders process ( )
Developed through cooperation between Ministry of Forestry, GIZ-FORCLIME Programme, Daemeter Consulting, and stakeholders process (2011-2012) SAFEGUARD 1. Actions complement or are consistent with the
More informationSESA Terms of Reference FOREST CARBON PARTNERSHIP FACILITY (FCPF) INDONESIA: STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL ASSESSMENT (SESA) 1
SESA Terms of Reference Updated Draft subject to final consultation FOREST CARBON PARTNERSHIP FACILITY (FCPF) INDONESIA: STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL ASSESSMENT (SESA) 1 May 25, 2011 These TORs are
More informationParticipatory Governance Assessment: THE 2012 INDONESIA FOREST, LAND AND REDD+ GOVERNANCE INDEX
The 2012 Indonesia Forest, Land, and REDD+ 1 Executive Summary Participatory Governance Assessment: THE 2012 INDONESIA FOREST, LAND AND REDD+ GOVERNANCE INDEX 2 The 2012 Indonesia Forest, Land, and REDD+
More informationImproving law compliance in the tropical forest sector: tracking, certification and ITTO Steven Johnson (ITTO)
Improving law compliance in the tropical forest sector: tracking, certification and ITTO Steven Johnson (ITTO) I work for ITTO 1 based in Yokohama, Japan. The organization is set up with the goal to try
More informationDAY1 Session 3. National Forest Monitoring Systems in the Context of REDD+: Important of Data Collection. Dr. Maria Jose Sanz-Sanchez (UN-REDD, FAO)
National Forest Monitoring Systems in the Context of REDD+: Important of Data Collection DAY1 National Forest Monitoring Systems in the Context of REDD+: Important of Data Collection My presentation is
More information2 Years of FLEGT License, Credibility and Accountability of Timber Legality Assurance System (SVLK) Must Be Improved
1 Position Paper Position Paper 2 Years of FLEGT License, Credibility and Accountability of Timber Legality Assurance System (SVLK) Must Be Improved Jaringan Pemantau Independen Kehutanan Independent Forest
More informationMarch 2012, Version 1.9
World Resources Institute Working Papers contain preliminary research, analysis, findings, and recommendations. They are circulated to stimulate timely discussion and critical feedback and to influence
More informationAn Early Idea of Emissions Reduction Program in Indonesia PRESENTED AT THE 10 TH CARBON FUND MEETING, BONN, JUNE 2014
An Early Idea of Emissions Reduction Program in Indonesia PRESENTED AT THE 10 TH CARBON FUND MEETING, BONN, 16-19 JUNE 2014 Indonesia s Forests Forestry Context and Political Commitment The annual deforestation
More informationEfforts to Eradicate the Forestry Legal Mafia in Indonesia
Efforts to Eradicate the Forestry Legal Mafia in Indonesia Diah Raharjo Member of the Indonesian Working Group on the Legal Mafia in Forestry HOW CONFLICT IS USED TO GET ILLEGAL LOGS TO THE INDUSTRY CUKONG
More information(FMU) Legislation related to. Forest Management Units
MINISTRY OF FORESTRY DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF FORESTRY PLANNING DIRECTORATE OF AREA MANAGEMENT AND PREPARATION OF FOREST AREA UTILISATION Legislation related to Forest Management Units (FMU) COOPERATION
More informationGREEN COMMODITIES FACILITY. Sustainable Palm Oil Programme: A public private partnerships approach UNDP
Sustainable Palm Oil Programme: A public private partnerships approach UNDP June 2014 1 About UNDP Poverty reduction and MDGs Democratic Governance Crisis Prevention and Recovery Environment and Energy
More informationEmission Reduction Program in Indonesia: A District-wide Approach to REDD+
Emission Reduction Program in Indonesia: A District-wide Approach to REDD+ Agus Sari Chair, Working Group on Funding Instruments Presidential Task Force on REDD+ Paris,France, June 23, 2013 WWF-Indonesia
More informationSensitization document for communities and other stakeholders in compliance with the National Guidelines on FPIC within the framework of REDD+ in
Sensitization document for communities and other stakeholders in compliance with the National Guidelines on FPIC within the framework of REDD+ in Cameroon FODER is working towards a more just society,
More informationSTRENGTHENING THE ENABLING ENVIRONMENT FOR STBM IN EAST NUSA TENGGARA (NTT) PROVINCE
STRENGTHENING THE ENABLING ENVIRONMENT FOR STBM IN EAST NUSA TENGGARA (NTT) PROVINCE Reflections from Final Project Learning Event with Change Agents and Delivery Team June 2016 A more conducive enabling
More informationAnalysis of the final version of Cameroon s R-PP
Analysis of the final version of Cameroon s R-PP CAMEROON presented its Readiness Preparation Proposal (R-PP) for assessment by the FCPF Participants Committee (PC) at its 13 th meeting held in October
More informationCambodia Readiness Preparation Proposal to FCPF PC8. Omaliss Keo 25 March 2011, Dalat, Vietnam
Cambodia Readiness Preparation Proposal to FCPF PC8 Omaliss Keo 25 March 2011, Dalat, Vietnam Outline 1. Background 2. R-PP development and process 3. R-PP components 4. Budget 5. Conclusion 1. Background
More informationThe enactment ofsocial Forest Areas: from people to state initiative
EPILOGUE After the policy of Social Forest (Hutan Kemasyarakatan) had stagnated for around five years, it eventually experienced a revival in 2007. Minister of Forestry Regulation number P.37/2007, which
More informationIndonesia: New Opportunities for Climate Compatible Agriculture. KEMEN AUSTIN Research Analyst
Indonesia: New Opportunities for Climate Compatible Agriculture KEMEN AUSTIN Research Analyst Background GHG emissions profile GHG emissions from land cover change comprise 10-15% of global GHG emissions
More informationCOMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE REGIONS
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 2.10.2013 COM(2013) 686 final COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE
More informationDRAFT MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION
EUROPEAN PARLIAMT 2009-2014 Plenary sitting 4.12.2013 B7- DRAFT MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION to wind up the debate on the statement by the Commission pursuant to Rule 110(2) of the Rules of Procedure on the
More informationDEFORESTATION NDONESIA S COMMITMENT IN ACHIEVING MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT AND FORESTRY OF REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA ZEROI
ZEROI NDONESIA S COMMITMENT IN ACHIEVING DEFORESTATION DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF FORESTRY PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENTAL GOVERNANCE MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT AND FORESTRY OF REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA Tokyo, January
More informationForest Carbon Partnership Facility (FCPF): Readiness Plan Idea Note (R-PIN) Template
Forest Carbon Partnership Facility (FCPF): Readiness Forest Plan Carbon Idea Note Partnership (R-PIN) Facility External (FCPF) Review Form Readiness Plan Idea Note (R-PIN) Template Guidelines for Reviewers:
More informationREQUIRED DOCUMENT FROM HIRING UNIT
Terms of reference GENERAL INFORMATION Title: Field Dinamisator Consultant for Riau Province Project Name: Support Facility for BRG Institutional Set-Up Reports to: Deputy III Peatland Restoration Agency
More informationGovernment of Ethiopia Ministry of Agriculture REDD+ Secretariat Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Government of Ethiopia Ministry of Agriculture REDD+ Secretariat Addis Ababa, Ethiopia Terms of Reference(ToR) for the Strategic Environmental and Social Assessment (SESA) and Environmental Social Management
More informationGovernment of Ethiopia Ministry of Agriculture REDD+ Secretariat Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Government of Ethiopia Ministry of Agriculture REDD+ Secretariat Addis Ababa, Ethiopia Terms of Reference(ToR) for the Strategic Environmental and Social Assessment (SESA) and Environmental Social Management
More informationPresentation on TLD1 Production Forest (V4.2)
Presentation on TLD1 Production Forest (V4.2) TWG Meeting, Vientiane Plaza Hotel, 29 January 2017 Mr. Soukan Inthanouhak, Acting DG, Forestry Section, Khammouane Province Contents 1. Background of revision
More information1) Stakeholder participation in ER-PIN planning and ERP design
Grading for ER-PIN Assessments: Color Qualification Analysis Green The indicator is clearly addressed and supported by country stakeholders and other sources of evidence; Yellow The indicator is partially
More informationLEDS Cooperation: Indonesia s Perspective
LEDS Cooperation: Indonesia s Perspective Farhan Helmy Secretary of Mitigation Working Group National Council on Climate Change -Indonesia (DNPI) Bonn, 18 May 2012 Indonesia's View on Future Cooperation
More informationPUTTING ACCOUNTABILITY INTO PRACTICE IN REDD+ PROGRAMS
WORKING PAPER PUTTING ACCOUNTABILITY INTO PRACTICE IN REDD+ PROGRAMS LAUREN WILLIAMS AND FREE DE KONING EXECUTIVE SUMMARY International programs designed to compensate developing countries for reducing
More information1) Stakeholder participation in ER-PIN planning and ERP design
Grading for ER-PIN Assessments: Color Qualification Analysis Green The indicator is clearly addressed and supported by country stakeholders and other sources of evidence; Yellow The indicator is partially
More informationPRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA DECREE NUMBER 62 YEAR 2013 REGARDING
Considering: PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA DECREE NUMBER 62 YEAR 2013 REGARDING MANAGING AGENCY FOR THE REDUCTION OF EMISSION FROM DEFORESTATION AND DEGRADATION OF FOREST AND PEATLANDS WITH THE
More informationSubmission from the Republic of Chad on behalf of the Central Africa Forests Commission (COMIFAC) member countries.
Views on experiences and lessons learned from the development of systems for providing information on safeguards and on types of information from systems for providing information on safeguards. Submission
More informationNeed for presence of consultant in office: partial, consultant will come to office to work with team two days in a week. intermittent (explain)
Terms of reference Position: REDD+ Agency Supporting Consultant for Public Campaign & Communications (National, Jakarta Base, 1 Post) GENERAL INFORMATION Title: Support Consultant For Public Campaign &
More informationWorking Group on Jurisdictional Certification of Palm Oil Minutes of Meeting Jakarta, 11 March 2016
Participants: Working Group on Jurisdictional Certification of Palm Oil Minutes of Meeting Jakarta, 11 March 2016 1. Director for Food and Agriculture of the Ministry of National Development Planning (PPN)
More informationMaking NAMAs work for Indonesian provinces
Policy Brief Making NAMAs work for Indonesian provinces This policy brief looks at how Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions (NAMAs) in Indonesia can be developed with provincial diversity in mind.
More informationREDD+ Pilots and Landscape Approach. Herry Purnomo Scientist at CIFOR Professor at Bogor Agricultural University
REDD+ Pilots and Landscape Approach Herry Purnomo Scientist at CIFOR Professor at Bogor Agricultural University Forest Carbon Partnership Facility & Indonesia Ministry of Forestry June 2-4, 2014 Jakarta,
More informationPublic Forestry Institutions
Public Forestry Institutions Basic knowledge Public forestry institutions contributes to SDGs: The purpose of this module is to equip forestry directors, facilitators and decision-makers with the basic
More informationBreakout Session One Questions What specific examples illustrate these challenges? What other critical challenges are there? What specific examples?
Breakout Session One Questions What specific examples illustrate these challenges? What other critical challenges are there? What specific examples? What specific actions are needed to tackle these challenges?
More informationBig Commitments, Slow Results
Big Commitments, Slow Results An Assessment on President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono s Climate Change Policies 2004-2014 Avi Mahaningtyas, Asep Firdaus, Patrick Anderson Indonesia Update, Canberra, 20 September
More informationREDD+: Is it sufficient for Forest Solution? Zulfira Warta (WWF 156 Indonesia)
REDD+: Is it sufficient for Forest Solution? Zulfira Warta (WWF 156 Indonesia) The presentations before already talked a lot about the national mechanism, MRV and the work that has been done. My presentation
More informationApplying State-Of-The-Art Monitoring and Accountability to Green Development
Applying State-Of-The-Art Monitoring and Accountability to Green Development Sultan Hotel and Residence-Jakarta, 11 November 2014 Indonesia has committed to 26-41 percent CO 2 emission reduction target
More informationFOREST CONSERVATION POLICY
FOREST CONSERVATION POLICY 4 TH ANNIVERSARY REPORT FEBRUARY 2017 www.asiapulppaper.com 1 2 FOREWORD: MANAGING DIRECTOR OF SUSTAINABILITY & STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT The implementation of APP s landmark Forest
More informationWelcome to today s webinar How companies are managing biodiversity in their supply chains
Welcome to today s webinar How companies are managing biodiversity in their supply chains Presenters Verity Lawson, British American Tobacco; Steven Lowe, Fauna & Flora International; Joseph Yalley-Ogunro,
More informationDAY2 Session 2. Beyond Bilateral Funding: Creating New Mechanisms for REDD+ Operationalization in Indonesia. Hideyuki Kubo (REDD+ Expert)
Beyond Bilateral Funding: Creating New Mechanisms for REDD+ Operationalization in Indonesia DAY2 Beyond Bilateral Funding: Creating New Mechanisms for REDD+ Operationalization in Indonesia International
More informationPROJECT INFORMATION DOCUMENT (PID) CONCEPT STAGE
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized PROJECT INFORMATION DOCUMENT (PID) CONCEPT STAGE Report No.: Project Name Region EAP
More informationParticipatory Prospective Analysis (PPA):
Participatory Prospective Analysis (PPA): Scenario building approach for improving, exploring and anticipating challenges in complex multi-stakeholders systems Bayuni Shantiko & Nining Liswanti Outline
More informationContext. R-PP versions submitted to FCPF in 2010: Draft January 12 April 19 May 9 June 12
Context R-PP versions submitted to FCPF in 2010: Draft January 12 April 19 May 9 June 12 MRV system Readiness Managements Arragements Agriculture Environment Education Science and Tech Labor Government
More informationRevitalizing Irrigation in Indonesia
This is not an ADB material. The views expressed in this document are the views of the author/s and/or their organizations and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the Asian Development
More informationCombating illegal logging
Combating illegal logging Lessons from the EU FLEGT Action Plan A summary In this summary of the publication Lessons from the EU FLEGT Action Plan, we look at the Action Plan s impact in the 10 years since
More informationForest Carbon Partnership Facility (FCPF)
Forest Carbon Partnership Facility (FCPF) Readiness Mechanism National Consultation and Participation for REDD May 6, 2009 This note presents some technical guidance on how to prepare an effective Consultation
More informationBasic information on the MSS proposal
Basic information on the MSS proposal 1 What is the proposed purpose and scope of the MSS? Is the document supposed to be a guidance document or a document with requirements? The proposed scope of the
More informationSyrian Arab Republic. National progress report on the implementation of the Hyogo Framework for Action. Name of focal point : Engineer Erfan Ali
Syrian Arab Republic National progress report on the implementation of the Hyogo Framework for Action Name of focal point : Engineer Erfan Ali Organization : Ministry of Local Administration and Environment
More informationFacts on Ulu Masen REDD project
The importance of governance to REDD+ activities: Lessons from Ulu Masen Lesley McCulloch Facts on Ulu Masen REDD project Ulu Masen 750,000 ha Leuser Ecosystem y 2,600,000 ha Facts on Ulu Masen REDD+ Demonstration
More informationPNPM Rural Supervision and Monitoring
PNPM Rural Supervision and Monitoring Quarterly Progress Report: January to March 2014 Summary Information Status Active Activity Number TF092138 Task Team Leader Sonya Woo (swoo1@worldbank.org) Executing
More informationReadiness for REDD implementation in Vietnam. Page 1
Readiness for REDD implementation in Vietnam Page 1 Outline! Overview of forestry in Vietnam! State of readiness preparation in Vietnam! REDD challenges and opportunities! Risks from REDD implementation!
More informationFGLG-Mozambique. Work plan 2013
FGLG-Mozambique Work plan 2013 This research was part-funded by UK aid from the UK Government, however the views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of the UK Government. This document has been
More informationGAR s claim of victimhood is baseless
www.greenomics.org GAR s claim of victimhood is baseless 1 2 12 October 2011 What about the forest cleared illegally in GAR concessions? What about the invasion of conservation areas by GAR concessions?
More informationTerms of Reference GENERAL INFORMATION. APPROVED e requisition
Terms of Reference GENERAL INFORMATION Title: Community and CSO Outreach Senior Specialist Project Name : REDD+ Reports to: Work stream Coordinator Duty Station: Jakarta Expected Places of Travel (if applicable):
More informationRECOMMENDATIONS FOR. Implementing Freedom of Information at the National and Regional Levels: Lessons Learned and How to Move Forward
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR Implementing Freedom of Information at the National and Regional Levels: Lessons Learned and How to Move Forward Around 60 peoples gathered from a few regions (which have Transparency
More informationApplying State-Of-The-Art Monitoring and Accountability to Green Development
Applying State-Of-The-Art Monitoring and Accountability to Green Development Sultan Hotel and Residence-Jakarta, 11 November 2014 Applying State-Of-The-Art Monitoring and Accountability to Green Development
More informationPromoting Accountability & Transparency in Canada
Promoting Accountability & Transparency in Canada Michael Pickup International Symposium on National Integrity System February 18-19, 2016 Chiang Mai, Thailand 1 Presentation Overview Introduction to OAG
More informationForest Policy. Basic Knowledge. What is a forest policy?
Forest Policy Basic Knowledge This module sets out the key elements of public forest policies. It explores how forest managers can assist in developing consensus-based forest policies that balance the
More informationSECOND YEAR OF IMPLEMENTATION OF GOLDEN AGRI S FOREST CONSERVATION POLICY (GAR FCP):
www.greenomics.org 7 May 2013 SECOND YEAR OF IMPLEMENTATION OF GOLDEN AGRI S FOREST CONSERVATION POLICY (GAR FCP): GAR continues to apply reduced deforestation practices in palm oil plantation development
More informationFGLG-Mozambique WORK PLAN 2012
FGLG-Mozambique WORK PLAN 2012 FGLG MOZAMBIQUE Forest Governance Learning Group ACTIVITIES PLAN 2012 CENTRO TERRA VIVA ESTUDOS E ADVOCACIA AMBIENTAL 1. INTRODUCTION Forests in Mozambique and the world
More informationINSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY ON FOREST STATUS, GAPS AND WAY FORWARD TENURE IN NEPAL: KEY MESSAGES INTRODUCTION
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY ON FOREST TENURE IN NEPAL: Yurdi Yasmi, Toon De Bruyn, Kapil Neupane and Phadindra Phokarel Zabara Alexander KEY MESSAGES Government institutions, programmes/projects and civil society
More informationNational safeguard policies: A country-led approach to REDD+ safeguards and multiple benefits
National safeguard policies: A country-led approach to REDD+ safeguards and multiple benefits Steve Swan Institute for Global Environmental Strategies - International Conference REDD+ Safeguards: Fundamental;
More informationDECREE OF THE GOVERNOR OF CENTRAL SULAWESI NUMBER: 522/84/DISHUTDA-GST/2011 CONCERNING
DECREE OF THE GOVERNOR OF CENTRAL SULAWESI NUMBER: 522/84/DISHUTDA-GST/2011 CONCERNING ESTABLISHMENT OF WORKING GROUP ON REDUCING EMISSIONS FROM DEFORESTATION AND FOREST DEGRADATION PLUS (REDD+ WG) OF
More informationPAYMENT FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES FOR SUSTAINABLE WATER RESOURCE IN LOMBOK, INDONESIA
Australian Water Association Conference Perth, 17 TH June 2016 PAYMENT FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES FOR SUSTAINABLE WATER RESOURCE IN LOMBOK, INDONESIA Diswandi Phd Candidate Murdoch University Introduction
More informationPotrait of Forestry Governance Implementation: A Case Study in South Barito District, Central Kalimantan
Potrait of Forestry Governance Implementation: A Case Study in South Barito District, Central Kalimantan Jaringan Tata Kelola Kehutanan Secretariat : Forest Watch Indonesia Jl. Sempur Kaler No.26. Bogor
More informationPropose of Past-performance information system (PIS) for improving Indonesian public works performance
Propose of Past-performance information system (PIS) for improving Indonesian public works performance Key words: best value procurement, electronic information system, past performance evaluation, procurement
More informationParticipatory, inclusive, and effective forest governance mechanisms at all levels are crucial to the success of social forestry.
Governance Mechanisms Participatory, inclusive, and effective forest governance mechanisms at all levels are crucial to the success of social forestry. Target 1 Establishing official regular mechanisms
More informationUNIVERSITY OF GUYANA Faculty of Agriculture and Forestry Department of Forestry. Presenters Ewart Smith and Gregory Hodge
UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA Faculty of Agriculture and Forestry Department of Forestry Presenters Ewart Smith and Gregory Hodge CONTENT AND REFERENCE 1. Forest carbon partnership facility (FCPF) - Guyana's submission:
More informationMultistakeholder Engagement in Developing SIS in the Philippines
Multistakeholder Engagement in Developing SIS in the Philippines Alaya de Leon Ateneo School of Government International Workshop for REDD+ Safeguard Tokyo, Japan 31 October 2014 Philippine context Philippine
More informationERD 2011 / 2012 Chapter 5 Managing Scarcity: Investment in Land. AERC-ERD Consultation, Nairobi July 2011
ERD 2011 / 2012 Chapter 5 Managing Scarcity: Investment in Land AERC-ERD Consultation, Nairobi 11-12 July 2011 Land focus: Issue to address How to balance trade-offs in land use decisions in line with
More informationForest Carbon Partnership Facility
Forest Carbon Partnership Facility Independent TAP Expert Review of Indonesia s REDD+ Readiness-Package Simon Rietbergen FCPF PC 24, Lao PDR September 25-29, 2017 Purpose and modalities of TAP review Assess
More informationRepublic of Malawi ANNEX 1: PUBLIC SECTOR MANAGEMENT POLICY IMPLEMENTATION PLAN
Republic of Malawi ANNEX 1: PUBLIC SECTOR MANAGEMENT POLICY IMPLEMENTATION PLAN Policy Priority Area 1: Shared understanding of the vision, mission and functions of the public service Policy Statement
More informationCEF. Cumulative Effects Framework. Interim Policy. for the Natural Resource Sector. October Cumulative Effects Framework
CEF Cumulative Effects Framework Cumulative Effects Framework Interim Policy for the Natural Resource Sector October 2016 Policy Approval The Cumulative Effects Framework Interim Policy is approved for
More informationAnnex 4.4. Recognition of Indigenous Peoples in East Kalimantan Article 50 Regional Regulation of East Kalimantan No. 1 of 2016 concerning East Kalima
Annex 4.4. Recognition of Indigenous Peoples in East Kalimantan Article 50 Regional Regulation of East Kalimantan No. 1 of 2016 concerning East Kalimantan Spatial Plan for 2016-2036 stated that in each
More informationGlobal Landscapes Forum. A roadmap to financing sustainable landscapes
Global s Forum A roadmap to financing sustainable landscapes Institutional investors, banks, insurance providers and hedge funds all play key roles in influencing land use. When investing in rural landscapes,
More informationStrategic Program API
Strategic API 2015-2020 (I): Strengthening API s Farmer Organization Members; Expected Key Results -- various shapes of organizations -- still based on board of leaders -- legal aspect of organizations,
More informationTHE REGIONAL FORUM ON REINVENTING GOVERNMENT IN ASIA: Towards Transparent and Accountable Governance. Jakarta, November 14-16, 2007
THE REGIONAL FORUM ON REINVENTING GOVERNMENT IN ASIA: Towards Transparent and Accountable Governance United Nations Government Centre (UNGC) and United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs
More informationMinistry of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations & Rural Development Assistant Deputy Minister, Integrated Resource Operations Victoria, BC
Ministry of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations & Rural Development Assistant Deputy Minister, Integrated Resource Operations Victoria, BC The Ministry of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations
More informationin practice Ways to improve the implementation of national forest programmes
in practice Ways to improve the implementation of national forest programmes More than a decade ago, countries formally recognized the importance of comprehensive forest policy frameworks for achieving
More informationStrengthening Forest Law Enforcement and Governance (FLEG) Presentation to the PROFISH Steering Committee, May 17, 2007 Tapani Oksanen,, WB FLEG TTL
Strengthening Forest Law Enforcement and Governance (FLEG) Presentation to the PROFISH Steering Committee, May 17, 2007 Tapani Oksanen,, WB FLEG TTL Scope of Forest Crime US$10 billion annual losses in
More informationNational Action Plan for on Promotion of Open Government. (Adopted with Presidential Decree of 27th April 2016)
2 National Action Plan for on Promotion of Open Government (Adopted with Presidential Decree of 27th April 2016) Name of measure Evaluation indicator 1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4. Improving List of the types of
More informationLand use, spatial planning, and potential implications for REDD+ in Indonesia: A preliminary analysis
Land use, spatial planning, and potential implications for REDD+ in Indonesia: A preliminary analysis Ida Aju Pradnja Resosudarmo Pekanbaru, May 11, 2012 Context-1: the Forest Area 187 MHa land area 93
More information