Columbia River Treaty
|
|
- Wilfrid Paul
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Columbia River Treaty Paul Lumley, CRITFC Executive Director October 3,
2 First Foods Salmon Berries Water Game Roots
3 the right of taking fish at all usual and accustomed places, in common with the citizens of the Territory, and of erecting temporary buildings for curing them: together with the privilege of hunting, gathering roots and berries Treaty with the Yakima
4 millions of fish Salmon Decline Returning Columbia River salmon (chinook, steelhead, sockeye, coho) Estimated Average 17,000,000 1,754,334
5 Four Tribes Ceded Lands Combined, the land comprising this ceded area: 66,591 square miles More than 25% of the entire Columbia Basin 55% of the rivers and streams that are still accessible to salmon Includes almost all of the salmon habitat above Bonneville Dam 13
6 Celilo Falls Tribal Fishery On the Columbia River near The Dalles, Oregon (inundated by The Dalles Dam in 1957)
7 Fish and Wildlife Impacts On the Upper Snake River in Idaho (salmon blockage in 1901) Loss of salmon impacted wildlife and other ecosystem functions
8 Columbia River Treaty Treaty came into force in 1964, no end date. Canada builds three dams, U.S. gets to build Libby. Two goals: optimize hydropower and coordinate flood control. With a 10 year notice, Treaty may be terminated starting in 2024 (Sept 2014). No mention of tribes, fish or wildlife Mica Keenleyside US Corps of Engineers dam Other dam US Bureau of Reclamation dam Duncan Libby 18
9 U.S. Commitments Payment for flood control benefits ~ $65 million total payment through 2024 Canada is entitled to one-half the downstream power benefit produced by U.S. projects due to the increment of Canadian storage Replacement value of Canadian Entitlement is about $300 million annually After 2024, US reservoirs must be used for flood control before we can ask Canada for assistance
10 Transboundary Coordination Columbia Basin Tribes and First Nations Tribal and First Nations leaders toured upper and middle basin to see issues first hand. Tribes and First Nations agree that: Ecosystem based functions need to be part of river management under the Treaty Salmon should be reintroduced throughout the basin over time Alternative management frameworks should be explored in future meetings
11 Columbia Basin Tribes 15 tribes with management authorities and responsibilities affected by the Columbia River Treaty Coalition formed 2009
12 Tribal Concerns No tribal consultation during negotiation nor tribal representation during implementation Adopted hydropower and flood control as management goals, disregarding fisheries and other ecosystem elements Flood control plan moved a permanent flood upriver and eliminated annual flooding and freshets Grand Coulee and Treaty projects built without passage and eliminated salmon spawning habitat Benefits of Treaty system not shared with tribes Tribal Goals Governance a seat at the table during Treaty Review, negotiations for a new Treaty followed by implementation Incorporate ecosystem-based function into Treaty Review and modernized Treaty Restore spring freshet while balancing tribal needs in upper basin reservoirs Restore salmon runs and protect salmon passage at all historic locations Share in benefits of coordinated systems
13 Tribal Caucus Products Common Views Document: Feb 2010 Tribal Leaders meet with US Entity: July 2010 Sovereign Participation Process established to develop a Regional Consensus
14 Sovereign Participation Process U.S. (Entity & Federal Agencies), Tribes, States Government-to-government level: Decision makers Sovereign Review Team: Guides technical analysis, resolves process issues Sovereign Technical Team: Modeling and technical analysis Stakeholder Involvement Throughout
15 Regional Consensus is Forming Sovereigns and Stakeholders agree: Treaty should be modified Potential Recommendation: Add ecosystem-based functions Reduce Canadian Entitlement Address flood control management post-2024 Adapt for Climate Change impacts
16 Ecosystem-based management approach Restore and preserve tribal natural and cultural resources Restore spring freshets: Helps to restore estuary Helps move fish Restore fish passage to all historic locations. Minimize draw downs at upper reservoirs
17 Restore Fish Passage Specifically include fish passage restoration as an element of a modernized Treaty A modernized Treaty should not interfere with opportunities to re-introduce anadromous fish into blocked areas Bilateral, comprehensive and phased approach Planning, Testing, Construction, Evaluation and Adaptation
18 Kettle Falls Tribal Fishery On the Columbia River in Washington State (inundated by Grand Coulee Dam in 1940)
19 Restore Fish Passage - Canada Five dams: Chief Joseph and Grand Coulee in US; Arrow, Brilliant, and Waneta in Canada Initiate bilateral planning and testing phases prior to enactment of a modernized Treaty Commitment to both study and then implement based on successful results Shared Benefits from Integrating Ecosystem-based Function
20 Downstream Benefits and the Canadian Entitlement The Treaty optimized hydropower production by coordinating Canadian storage releases with U.S. hydropower operations Downstream benefit is the additional power produced by this optimization Canadian Entitlement is half of the downstream benefit (current value is $300 million annually)
21 Downstream Benefits and the Canadian Entitlement - Concerns Faulty assumptions made about thermal power development in U.S. Not part of calculation: wind power, other renewables, and conservation U.S. is currently integrating ecosystem-based function into its operations Canada is receiving ecosystem benefits from U.S. operations
22 Flood Risk Management U.S. loses assured storage in Canada in 2024 Without any changes, U.S. must use all of its reservoirs ( effective use ) before it can ask Canada for assistance ( called upon ) Can result in heavy drafting of all U.S. reservoirs and result in limits on salmon flows Uncertainties associated with forecasting and climate change
23 River Level at The Dalles lower summer flow flow pushed earlier in the year
24 Flood Risk Management - Tribal Concerns Corps not reluctant to balance reservoir operations that will provide necessary ecosystem flows while maintaining adequate flood control. What is Flood Risk Management (FRM)? FRM = Cost Probability FRM Probability Why is this important? Salmon survival improves with better spring freshet. Current flood control approach creates havoc in upriver reservoirs, perhaps for little flood risk benefit. Updated flood risk management approaches can reduce havoc in upriver reservoirs, increase salmon survival, and improve estuary health while maintaining adequate flood control.
25 Impacts from Dramatic Reservoir Level Changes Spokane River in Washington State, impacts from Grand Coulee Reservoir Drawdown (cultural resources, dust)
26 Flood Risk Management - Update Initiate regional review in 2014 Involve sovereigns and stakeholders Continue coordinated flood risk management Measure system capability for a range of flows and flood years Review current infrastructure capability, assess future needs Identify opportunities to reconnect floodplains
27 Why Modernize the Treaty? The NW depends on healthy Columbia River Hydropower contributes to energy independence Public safety Economic well-being A Modernize Treaty is in the Best Interest of the Region and the United States
28 Regional Consensus is Needed (Recommendation to U.S. Dept of State Dec 20, 2013) The U.S. Department of State will decide on whether to request negotiations with Canada Broad regional consensus is needed (details are important) Power group concerned about adding ecosystembased function Without broad regional consensus, U.S. Dept of State may not pursue modernized Treaty
29 Activities for 2014 Initiate joint fish passage studies Initiate regional flood risk assessment Undertake Treaty governance study Initiate water supply allocation discussion
30 Steps Forward Sovereign Participation Process, or some variant, needs to continue after 2013 to support U.S. State Department Treaty options: continue, terminate, or modernize Senate ratification needed for a new Treaty and potentially needed for major changes to the Treaty Regional Consensus is Key to Success
31
32 Columbia River Restoring Fish Passage Paul Lumley, Yakama CRITFC Executive Director 1
33 Celilo Falls Tribal Fishery On the Columbia River near The Dalles, Oregon (inundated by The Dalles Dam in 1957)
34 Kettle Falls Tribal Fishery On the Columbia River in Washington State (inundated by Grand Coulee Dam in 1940) Many tribes lost all access to salmon
35 Examine Broad, Coordinated Development of Columbia River International Joint Commission established under Boundary Waters Treaty of With initial power development proposals in Canada rejected, U.S. and Canada agree in 1944 on study: having in mind (A) domestic water supply and sanitation, (B) navigation, (C) efficient development of water power, (D) the control of floods, (E) the needs of irrigation, (F) reclamation of wetlands, (G) conservation of fish and wildlife, and (H) other beneficial purposes. International Columbia River Engineering Board undertakes extensive technical analysis of benefits of developing basin s water resources.
36 Vanport Flood The Columbia River flooded in 1948, completely wiping out Vanport, Oregon
37 Decision to Focus on Hydropower and Flood Risk Management International Columbia River Engineering Board, narrow 1959 referral for negotiating a Columbia River Water Treaty (a) benefits on storage of waters and electrical interconnection within the Columbia River system (b) benefits apportionment between the two countries focused on electrical generation and control. Underlying Assumptions: ecosystem-based function for the basin could be achieved through unilateral management and that hatcheries could mitigate for stocks lost because of no fish passage Mistaken Assumption
38 Columbia River Treaty Mica Treaty came into force in 1964, no end date Canada builds three dams, US builds Libby no passage Twin goals: - optimize hydropower - coordinate flood control With 10 year notice, Treaty may be terminated in 2024 Tribes not consulted, no fish & wildlife coordination Keenleyside US Corps of Engineers dam Other dam Duncan Libby US Bureau of Reclamation dam 18
39 Mitchell Act Hatcheries Bonneville Dam
40 Ecosystem-Based Management Approach Restore and preserve tribal natural and cultural resources Restore spring freshets: - Helps to restore estuary - Helps move fish Minimize draw downs at upper reservoirs Restore fish passage at all historic locations
41 Transboundary Coordination Columbia Basin Tribes and First Nations Conducted meetings about Treaty to learn, share issues and express concerns Toured upper and middle basin to see issues first hand Columbia Basin tribes and First Nations agree that: - Ecosystem based functions need to be part of river management under the Treaty - Salmon should be restored throughout the basin over time - Alternative management frameworks should be explored in future meetings
42 Primary Salmon Passage Blockages Grand Coulee Dworshak Hells Canyon US Corps of Engineers dam Other dam US Bureau of Reclamation dam
43 Restore and Protect Salmon Passage to Historical Habitats US Projects: Hells Canyon Complex, Dworshak, Chief Joseph, Grand Coulee Canadian projects: Waneta, Seven Mile, Brilliant, Keenleyside (Arrow) Provide modified passage devices at each structure for adult and juvenile migration Address reservoir travel time issues
44 Columbia River Watershed Fish Passage Paper The narrow focus on flood risk management and hydropower generation has decimated anadromous and resident fish stocks Decisions to block fish passage were made without prior and informed consent of the Columbia Basin tribes and First Nations Restoring fish passage is a key element of integrating ecosystem based function into a modern Treaty Columbia Basin tribes and First Nations are developing a joint paper Fish Passage into the Upper Columbia and Snake Rivers to inform the Canadian and U.S. Entities and governments.
45 There s more to Hatcheries than Science Hatcheries are an obligation Mitigation for effects of dams Legal obligations: US v. Oregon Management Agreements Accords Pacific Salmon Treaty 13
46 Salmon Recovery and Hatchery Programs: Two Different Approaches Harvest Hatchery (Mass Marking and Mark Selective Fisheries) Designed to keep hatchery and wild fish separated Promotes harvest of hatchery fish and avoids wild fish Wild fish mortalities occur too, often multiple catch and release Provides access to fish for non- Indian fishers under ESA restrictions Is not a recovery program, does not lead to recovery Supplementation (Conservation Wild Salmon Nurseries) Designed to keep hatchery and wild fish as similar as possible; combined with habitat restoration/protection. Tribes prefer these fish not be mass marked for selective fishing Under careful design, leads to rebuilding and possible ESA de-listing Competing science to support each approach. What s wrong with both approaches 13 at the same time?
47 Salmon Recovery and Hatchery Programs: What does Success Look Like? Should success be defined by the number of wild fish returns?...hatchery? Who defines wild fish? Is an ESA de-listing goal enough fish? Full rebuilding to a significant harvest for treaty Indian and non- Indian fisheries? Is there a shared vision in the Columbia River Basin on what success looks like? What is an appropriate response for hatchery programs? Resource struggle between non-indian and tribal fishery interests. Competing uses of existing hatchery facilities and funding. If we cannot agree on what success looks like or how to get there, we will continue to struggle for increased federal funding. 13
48 Supplementation Successes Tribal hatchery programs have shown success (supplementation) such as: Snake River Fall Chinook, huge returns, record redd counts (ESA delisting on the horizon?) Coho re-introduction in the Yakama, Umatilla, Wenatchee and Clearwater rivers Spring Chinook re-introduction in the Umatilla and Walla Walla rivers.
49 Fall chinook estimated escapement to Lower Granite Dam
50 Benefits of Supplementation By expanding the tribal hatchery objectives: We will make progress towards salmon recovery We will contribute to ecosystem health We will help maintain economically important salmon fisheries that benefit everyone in the region We maintain the treaty right to harvest at all usual and accustomed fishing places in perpetuity
51 Managing Supplementation Risk Any action has risks, even the option to do nothing Managing risk is a share responsibility Taking a stand of no risk should be rejected Tribes are managing risks and minimizing where possible Scrutiny of tribal supplementation programs is immense. Where is scrutiny of Mass Marking and Selective Fisheries? Significant impacts to unmarked (wild) fish Steelhead experiment over several decades failed, fish are ESA-listed
52 Defining the Question? What are the risks of tribal supplementation programs? OR What is the proper role of artificial propagation in to achieving ESA delisting and full salmon recovery? 52
53 Hatcheries are an Obligation a Solution, but Not the Problem As long as we have dams, we will have hatcheries. We should use the tool to benefit recovery and rebuilding. We do not have low productivity because of hatcheries. We have hatcheries because of low productivity. 53
54
55 Pelton Dam Fish Passage Tower Deschutes River, Oregon Joint project of Warm Springs Tribe and Portland General Electric Began operating in December foot underwater tower that alters the reservoir s current to attract migrating fish The tower allows juvenile salmon and steelhead to migrate past three Deschutes River dams for the first time since 1968.
56 Lamprey Flume System at Bonneville Dam 1. Upper Entrance 2. Lower Entrance 3. Thimble, Closure Gate, and Elbow Flume Section 4. Filler Plate 5. Flow Splitter Flume Section 6. Downstream School Bus Flume Section 7. Upstream School Bus Flume Section 8. Lamprey Flume System (LFS) & Lamprey Passage Structure (LPS) Junction (LPS not shown) 9. Gravity Water Supply Pipe
Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission. Columbia River Treaty 2014/2024 Review Paul Lumley, CRITFC Executive Director Yakama 1
Columbia River Treaty 2014/2024 Review Paul Lumley, CRITFC Executive Director Yakama 1 Columbia River Treaty Mica Keenleyside Duncan Libby Treaty came into force in 1964, no end date. Canada builds three
More informationModernizing the Columbia River Treaty
Modernizing the Columbia River Treaty Jim Heffernan, Policy Analyst, Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission On behalf of the Columbia Basin Tribes Coalition for the Pacific Northwest Waterways Association
More informationModernizing the Columbia River Treaty D.R. Michel, Executive Director, Upper Columbia United Tribes Jim Heffernan, Policy Analyst, Columbia River
Modernizing the Columbia River Treaty D.R. Michel, Executive Director, Upper Columbia United Tribes Jim Heffernan, Policy Analyst, Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission On behalf of the Columbia
More informationFood Systems, Conservation, and Climate Change
Food Systems, Conservation, and Climate Change Nicole Charley Confederated Tribes of the Warm Springs Reservation of Oregon, Tribal Member & Traditional Food Gatherer Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission
More informationJUVENILE SALMON MIGRATION SECTION 5. blank page
blank page FISH AND WILDLIFE PROGRAM 5-16 September 13, 1995 SECTION 5 JUVENILE SALMON MIGRATION temperature improvement measures contained in this program will have a substantial impact on the operations
More informationolumbia River Treaty The Columbia by Steve Oliver, Vice President, Generation Asset Management, Bonneville Power Administration 16 Oct
The Columbia by Steve Oliver, Vice President, Generation Asset Management, Bonneville Power Administration 16 Oct 2006 1 Presentation Outline Geography of the Pacific Northwest Bonneville Power Administration
More informationModernizing the Columbia River Treaty to Address the Needs of a 21 st Century Transboundary Watershed
Modernizing the Columbia River Treaty to Address the Needs of a 21 st Century Transboundary Watershed Environmental Law: Year In Review Friday, October 24, 2014 McMenamins Edgefield Manor Troutdale, Oregon
More informationColumbia River System Operations Environmental Impact Statement Newsletter
Summer 2017 (revised) Columbia River System Operations Environmental Impact Statement Newsletter INSIDE: CRSO EIS Columbia River System multiple uses The CRSO and integrating renewable energy Fish passage
More informationAnadromous Fish Reintroduction in the Upper Columbia River Basin An Overview
University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst International Conference on Engineering and Ecohydrology for Fish Passage International Conference on Engineering and Ecohydrology for Fish
More information2014/2024 Review Columbia River Treaty
Bonneville Power Administration - U.S. Army Corps of Engineers 2014/2024 Review Columbia River Treaty Overview of Treaty Review Process January 31, 2013 For Central Asia Cross Border Water Management Exchange
More informationJuly 1, Jim Ruff -- Manager, Mainstem Passage and River Operations
Bruce A. Measure Chair Montana Rhonda Whiting Montana W. Bill Booth Idaho James A. Yost Idaho Dick Wallace Vice-Chair Washington Tom Karier Washington Melinda S. Eden Oregon Joan M. Dukes Oregon July 1,
More informationEcosystem-Based Function Integration Into the Columbia River Treaty
Ecosystem-Based Function Integration Into the Columbia River Treaty Columbia Basin Tribes Concept Upper Arrow Lake. Photo wallpaperup.com version 2014.10.17 The Columbia River Treaty (Treaty) was established
More informationColumbia River Treaty 2014/2024 Review U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Bonneville Power Administration Review
Columbia River Treaty 2014 2024 Review Update January 11, 2013 PNUCC Presentation Stephen Oliver Bonneville Power Administration U.S. Co Coordinator for Columbia River Treaty Co Chair Sovereign Review
More informationColumbia Basin Operations and Flood Risk Management
Columbia Basin Operations and Flood Risk Management Julie Ammann, PE Chief, Reservoir Control Center Northwestern Division USACE US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING STRONG The Columbia River Basin Drainage
More informationFINDING COMMON THREADS FOR RESTORING THE COLUMBIA RIVER ECOSYSTEM THROUGH SALMON AND STEELHEAD RECOVERY
FINDING COMMON THREADS FOR RESTORING THE COLUMBIA RIVER ECOSYSTEM THROUGH SALMON AND STEELHEAD RECOVERY National Conference on Ecosystem Restoration July 29, 2013 Elizabeth Holmes Gaar NOAA Fisheries,
More informationColumbia River Treaty
Columbia River Treaty 2014/2024 Review United States Entity Supplemental Report September 2010 United States Entity United State Entity Supplemental Report Columbia River Treaty 2014/2024 Review Executive
More informationColumbia River Basin Reservoir Operations
Columbia River Basin Reservoir Operations Future of Our Salmon Conference Portland, OR October 18, 2016 Pete Dickerson, P.E. USACE Northwestern Division US Army Corps of Engineers 2 Columbia River Basin!
More informationColumbia River Treaty Review. Water Resources Commission Meeting November 15, 2012 Ruben E. Ochoa, Water Policy Analyst
Columbia River Treaty Review Water Resources Commission Meeting November 15, 2012 Ruben E. Ochoa, Water Policy Analyst Presentation Columbia River Basin A Few Facts and Figures. Columbia River Treaty Provisions/Operations.
More information2016 WATER MANAGEMENT PLAN
2016 WATER MANAGEMENT PLAN Dworshak Dam Ahsahka, Idaho Bonneville Power Administration U.S. Bureau of Reclamation U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Table of Contents 1 Introduction... 1 2 Governing Documents...
More informationColumbia River Treaty Review. PNWA Summer Meeting LaConner, WA June 24, 2013
PNWA Summer Meeting LaConner, WA June 24, 2013 1 Treaty Basics Purpose of 2014/2024 Treaty Review Mechanics of Treaty Review Summary of Iteration 2 Navigation Impact Assessment Stakeholder involvement
More informationAltered Flood Control, Climate Change, and Rebuilding Pacific Northwest Salmon Stocks
Altered Flood Control, Climate Change, and Rebuilding Pacific Northwest Salmon Stocks Kyle Dittmer Hydrologist Meteorologist March 24, 2006 Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission Portland, Oregon
More informationOverview of Columbia Basin Water Management
Overview of Columbia Basin Water Management Walla Walla District and Portland District Navigation Meeting Port of Morrow SAGE Center Karl Kanbergs, acting RCC Chief Columbia Basin Water Management May
More informationCanadian Entity s Preliminary View of Columbia River Treaty Post-2024 Called Upon Procedures. BC Hydro and Power Authority
Canadian Entity s Preliminary View of Columbia River Treaty Post-2024 Called Upon Procedures BC Hydro and Power Authority February 14, 2013 1 1.0 Introduction Under the Columbia River Treaty (Treaty),
More information2014/2024 Review Columbia River Treaty
Bonneville Power Administration - U.S. Army Corps of Engineers 2014/2024 Review Columbia River Treaty Briefing for the Central Asian Delegation January 28, 2013 Why Conduct a Treaty 2014/2024 Review? 1.
More informationColumbia River Treaty
Columbia River Treaty 2014/2024 Review United States Entity Supplemental Report Appendix A September 2010 United States Entity APPENDIX A U.S. ENTITY SUPPLEMENTAL STUDIES METHODOLOGY TABLE OF CONTENTS
More information2017 WATER MANAGEMENT PLAN
2017 WATER MANAGEMENT PLAN Libby Dam Libby, Montana Bonneville Power Administration U.S. Bureau of Reclamation U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Table of Contents 1. Introduction... 1 2. Governing Documents...
More informationNorthwest Hydropower and Columbia Basin River Benefits Fast Facts
Northwest Hydropower and Columbia Basin River Benefits Fast Facts 2015-16 Rich in Hydropower The Northwest today is an oasis of clean, renewable energy, the result of its hydro heritage. Northwest dams
More informationOverview of Columbia River System Operations for Hydropower and Fish Passage
Consultation on MRC s Hydropower Programme Vientiane, Lao PDR, 25-26 September 2008 Overview of Columbia River System Operations for Hydropower and Fish Passage By Bolyvong Tanovan, PhD, PE Chief, Water
More informationManaging Idaho Power Company s Hydro Projects During Drought Conditions The Benefits of Communication and Collaboration
Managing Idaho Power Company s Hydro Projects During Drought Conditions The Benefits of Communication and Collaboration Kresta Davis-Butts Northwest Hydroelectric Association Fall Workshop October 15,
More informationPassage Over Canadian Projects
Passage Over Canadian Projects Keenleyside Brilliant and Waneta Columbia Power Corporation Hydro Expansion Projects Peter Christensen, P.E. R2 Resource Consultants, Redmond, Washington Keenleyside, Brilliant,
More informationUS Columbia Operations Overview. Columbia Basin Advisory Committee
US Columbia Operations Overview Columbia Basin Advisory Committee October 27, 2015 The Role of Reservoir Storage The The Role Role of of of Reservoir Storage Reservoir Inflow Reservoir Level Electricity
More informationAppendix B. Operations on the Columbia River - Relationship between Columbia River Treaty, Non Treaty Storage Agreement, and Water Use Plans
Appendix B Operations on the Columbia River - Relationship between Columbia River Treaty, Non Treaty Storage Agreement, and Water Use Plans The actual physical operations on the Columbia River are a result
More informationPBDEs, PCBs, and Mercury Presence in the Columbia Basin
PBDEs, PCBs, and Mercury Presence in the Columbia Basin Paul Lumley, CRITFC Executive Director LCEP 2014 Science to Policy Summit June 13, 2014 1 Four Tribes Ceded Lands Combined, the land comprising this
More informationNorthwest Hydropower and Columbia Basin River Benefits Fast Facts
Northwest Hydropower and Columbia Basin River Benefits Fast Facts 2013-14 Northwest RiverPartners is an alliance of farmers, utilities, ports and businesses that promotes: the economic and environmental
More informationOVERVIEW OF RESERVOIR OPERATIONS AND FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT
OVERVIEW OF RESERVOIR OPERATIONS AND FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT 255 255 255 237 237 237 0 0 0 217 217 217 163 163 163 200 200 200 COLUMBIA RIVER BASIN 131 132 122 239 65 53 80 119 27 110 135 120 252 174.59
More informationIII. Recommendation summary and synthesis:
Staff summary of Issues and Recommendations Long Term Agreements and Accords *Preliminary draft, please refer to full recommendations for complete review 10/29/2013 10:09 AM I. 2009 Fish and Wildlife Program
More informationCRT Operations in Low Water Conditions
CRT Operations in Low Water Conditions Friday, May 27, 2016 Outline Utility Planning Background CRT Rule Curves 2015 Operations Future possibilities? Integrated Resource Plan - Key Planning Questions 1.
More informationNew Science Requirements in Support of a Modernized Columbia River Treaty Prepared by the UC Berkeley Columbia River Treaty Science Advisory Group
14 June 2017 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY Canadian Studies Program Institute of International Studies 213 Moses Hall #2308 Berkeley California 94720-2308 USA Tel: +1 510 642 0531 email: canada@berkeley.edu
More informationColumbia River Treaty
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Bonneville Power Administration Columbia River Treaty History and 2014/2024 Review 1 The Columbia River Treaty between the and Canada has served as a model of international
More informationIntroduction to Bonneville Power Administration
Introduction to Bonneville Power Administration Greg Delwiche, Senior Vice President, BPA Power Services January 31, 2013 Federal Columbia River Power System Columbia River Basin & BPA Service Area WHAT
More informationColumbia River Treaty Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Columbia River Treaty Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Spring 2012 Columbia River Treaty 1. What is the Columbia River Treaty? The Columbia River Treaty is a trans-boundary water management agreement
More informationJuly 28, OVERVIEW: Lower Clearwater Exchange Project (Idaho)
Bruce A. Measure Chair Montana Rhonda Whiting Montana W. Bill Booth Idaho James A. Yost Idaho Joan M. Dukes Vice-Chair Oregon Bill Bradbury Oregon Tom Karier Washington Phil Rockefeller Washington July
More informationInventory of Management Programs
Appendix C Salmon Recovery Plan Inventory of s Table 1 Inventory of management programs, sponsors or agencies, area affected by the programs, goal of the programs, and a determination whether the program
More informationTestimony of James J. Anderson Associate Professor School of Fisheries University of Washington, Seattle Washington
Testimony of James J. Anderson Associate Professor School of Fisheries University of Washington, Seattle Washington before the U.S. House of Representatives Subcommittee on Water and Power in Lewiston
More informationFISH & WILDLIFE COSTS < 12th ANNUAL REPORT TO the Northwest Governors < PAGE Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program Costs Report
FISH & WILDLIFE COSTS < 12th ANNUAL REPORT TO the Northwest Governors < PAGE 1 2012 Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program Costs Report 12th Annual Report to the Northwest Governors PAGE 2 > 12th
More informationColumbia River Treaty the setting
the setting Whistler Vancouver Jasper Banff USA has hydro plants & flood control needs Canada has good storage dam sites Canada has 15% of the basin area Canadian basin is mountainous, with lots of snow
More information2011 ISRP Retrospective
Presented by: Rich Alldredge Tom Poe Pete Bisson Greg Ruggerone Eric Loudenslager 2011 ISRP Retrospective Northwest Power and Conservation Council Portland, OR January 10, 2012 ISRP Retrospective Report
More information1.1 Historical Overview 1.2 Feasibility Study Process 1.3 Purpose and Need 1.4 Background 1.5 Scope 1.6 Alternatives 1.7 Authority.
1.1 Historical Overview 1.2 Feasibility Study Process 1.3 Purpose and Need 1.4 Background 1.5 Scope 1.6 Alternatives 1.7 Authority Introduction 1. Introduction 1. INTRODUCTION 1-1 1.1 Historical Overview
More informationa) Implementation of the Northwest Power and Conservations Council s 2014 Fish and Wildlife Program Priorities and Measures
a) Implementation of the Northwest Power and Conservations Council s 2014 Fish and Wildlife Program Priorities and Measures Discussion Draft 8/4/15 The Council s 2014 Fish and Wildlife Program (Program)
More informationColumbia River Operations
Columbia River Operations P R E S E N T E D B Y Kieran Connolly Vice President Generation Asset Management Bonneville Power Administration 4 th longest river in North America; drains 258,000 square miles
More informationStaff summary of Issues & Recommendations Biological Objectives *Preliminary draft, please refer to full recommendations for complete review
Staff summary of Issues & Recommendations Biological Objectives *Preliminary draft, please refer to full recommendations for complete review 10/29/2013 10:05 AM 2009 Fish and Wildlife Program Section Section
More informationWapato Access Feasibility Study
Wapato Access Feasibility Study David Gorman, PE Michael Rounds, PE August 5, 2011 Lower Columbia River Estuary Partnership (LCREP) Non-profit two state public-private initiative Primary Responsibility:
More informationFact Sheet. A Northwest energy solution: Regional power benefits of the lower Snake River dams. CLEAN: Emission-free renewable energy
B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Fact Sheet March 216 A Northwest energy solution: Regional power benefits of the lower Snake River dams Clean, flexible and reliable. The lower
More informationFact Sheet. A Northwest energy solution: Regional power benefits of the lower Snake River dams. CLEAN: Emission-free renewable energy
B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Fact Sheet March 216 A Northwest energy solution: Regional power benefits of the lower Snake River dams Clean, flexible and reliable. The lower
More informationBonneville Power Administration
U.S Army Corps of Engineers Northwestern Division Bonneville Power Administration U.S. Department of the Interior Bureau of Reclamation for the Biological Assessment for Effects of Federal Columbia River
More informationStaff summary of Issues & Recommendations Protected Areas
Staff summary of Issues & Recommendations Protected Areas *Preliminary draft, please refer to full recommendations for complete review 10/29/2013 10:06 AM 2009 Fish and Wildlfe Program Section Section
More informationColumbia River Treaty:
SCIENCE in the service of WASHINGTON STATE Columbia River Treaty: Issues for the 21st Century Summary of the Proceedings of the Ninth Annual Symposium Held as Part of the 2016 Annual Meeting of the September
More informationDepartment of the Army, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Notice of Intent to Prepare the Columbia River System Operations Environmental
4332-90 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE Department of the Army, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY Bonneville Power Administration DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR Bureau of Reclamation Notice of Intent
More informationThe Columbia River and The Columbia River Treaty
The Columbia River and The Columbia River Treaty PROFESSOR BARBARA COSENS UNIVERSITY OF IDAHO COLLEGE OF LAW Water Resources Program Universities Consortium on Columbia River Governance River Restoration
More informationCedar River Watershed Habitat Conservation Plan
Cedar River Watershed Habitat Conservation Plan Briefing for the WRIA 8 Salmon Recovery Council November 21, 2013 Cyndy Holtz Seattle Public Utilities cyndy.holtz@seattle.gov What is an HCP? Habitat Conservation
More informationChehalis Basin Strategy Programmatic SEPA Draft EIS
Chehalis Basin Strategy Programmatic SEPA Draft EIS History of Flooding I-5 closed in 1990, 1996, 2007, 2009 Five largest flood events occurred since 1986 2 History of Habitat Degradation Harvest has been
More informationRestoration in the Context of NRDA Claims STRATUS CONSULTING
Restoration in the Context of NRDA Claims Overview Natural resource restoration Improvement or creation of natural resources Increase in tribal members interactions with natural resources Use of natural
More informationJohn Shurts General Counsel
Henry Lorenzen Chair Oregon Bill Bradbury Oregon Phil Rockefeller Washington Tom Karier Washington W. Bill Booth Vice Chair Idaho James Yost Idaho Pat Smith Montana Jennifer Anders Montana John Shurts
More informationColumbia River Treaty: Recommendations December 2013
L O CA L G O V E R N M E N TS CO M M I TTEE Columbia River Treaty: Recommendations The BC Columbia River Treaty Local Governments Committee (the Committee) has prepared these Recommendations in response
More informationIssues in Klamath River Dam Relicensing
Order Code RS22498 Updated January 7, 2008 Issues in Klamath River Dam Relicensing Summary Nic Lane Analyst in Environment and Resources Management Resources, Science, and Industry Division PacifiCorp,
More informationUnderstanding and Restoring Natural Floodplain Function. Gary James CTUIR Fisheries Program Manager
Understanding and Restoring Natural Floodplain Function Gary James Fisheries Program Manager Future of Our Salmon Technical Workshop on Healthy Floodplains Spokane, WA - August 16-18, 2016 Presentation
More informationTopics. Lower Columbia River White Sturgeon Conservation Plan. Terms. Background. Background. Conservation Status 6/7/2011
/7/11 Lower Columbia River White Sturgeon Conservation Plan Presentation to the Oregon Fish and Wildlife Commission June 3, 11 1 Topics How the conservation and desired status benchmarks were developed
More informationBUDGETARY/ECONOMIC IMPACTS
Bruce A. Measure Chair Montana Rhonda Whiting Montana W. Bill Booth Idaho James A. Yost Idaho January 4, 2012 Joan M. Dukes Vice-Chair Oregon Bill Bradbury Oregon Tom Karier Washington Phil Rockefeller
More information2001 WATER MANAGEMENT PLAN For The Federal Columbia River Power System
Technical Management Team 2001 WATER MANAGEMENT PLAN For The Federal Columbia River Power System 9 July 2001 I. Introduction This Water Management Plan (Plan) describes the measures needed in 2001 to provide
More informationApril 28, 2017 Berkeley, California USA
The Columbia River Treaty: A Conversation April 28, 2017 Berkeley, California USA Elliott Smith, MA Canadian Studies Program University of California, Berkeley American Narrative 1948: Vanport City, Oregon
More informationU.S. Benefits from the Columbia River Treaty Past, Present and Future: A Province of British Columbia Perspective. BC Ministry of Energy and Mines
U.S. Benefits from the Columbia River Treaty Past, Present and Future: A Province of British Columbia Perspective BC Ministry of Energy and Mines June 25, 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
More informationTreaty History & Requirements
History & Requirements Too Much or Too Little Water! Vanport destroyed in 1948 Draught Grand Coulee spill Trail B.C. flood in 1948 30 January 2013 1 Why did we need a? About 1/3 of the Columbia water comes
More informationI. INTRODUCTION PURPOSE BASIN DESCRIPTION WATER RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT TYPES OF RESERVOIR PROJECTS ANNUAL REGULATION CYCLE
I. INTRODUCTION PURPOSE BASIN DESCRIPTION WATER RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT TYPES OF RESERVOIR PROJECTS ANNUAL REGULATION CYCLE A. PURPOSE This document reports on the activities of concerned governmental agencies
More information2017 Snake River Fall Chinook Salmon Spawning Summary 1,869* 2,095* ,596*
2017 Snake River Fall Chinook Salmon Spawning Summary by Bill Arnsberg, Nez Perce Tribe Brad Alcorn, Idaho Power Company Frank Mullins, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Debbie Milks, Washington Department
More information2017 Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program Costs Report
2017 Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program Costs Report 17TH ANNUAL REPORT TO THE NORTHWEST GOVERNORS PAGE 2 > 17TH ANNUAL REPORT TO THE NORTHWEST GOVERNORS > FISH & WILDLIFE COSTS Contents 04
More informationFish Passage Technologies at High-head Dams: A Review
University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst International Conference on Engineering and Ecohydrology for Fish Passage International Conference on Engineering and Ecohydrology for Fish
More informationFish Passage Technologies at High-head Dams: A Review
University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst International Conference on Engineering and Ecohydrology for Fish Passage International Conference on Engineering and Ecohydrology for Fish
More informationI Fish and Wildlife Program Section:
Staff summary of Issues and Recommendations Long Term O&M Contingency Plans *Preliminary draft, please refer to full recommendations for complete review 10/29/2013 10:10 AM I. 2009 Fish and Wildlife Program
More informationColumbia River Projects
Columbia River Projects Fish, Agriculture, and Water Resources September 13, 2012 Presented by Derek I. Sandison, Director Office of Columbia River Washington State Department of Ecology Columbia River
More informationRural and Municipal Water Supply Issues in Yakama Country
Rural and Municipal Water Supply Issues in Yakama Country Phil Rigdon, Yakama Nation Department of Natural Resources AWRA Washington State Conference Oct 26, 2016 Focus of Presentation Present Yakama Nation
More informationSub-Action Number General Measures Responsible Entity
ALL ACTIONS Strategy Investment strategy 199 High IS - 1 Investment strategy 199 High IS- 2 The will work with and the other action agencies to ensure that past fish-andwildlife-related investments are
More informationFish Politics in the Pacific Northwest
Fish Politics in the Pacific Northwest Hatchery and Harvest Reform Stephen Smith Canby, Oregon Hatchery & Harvest Reform Hatchery Scientific Review Group Process Issues Recommendations Implementation Headwater
More informationFloodplain Restoration Using a RiverVision Approach in Meacham Creek, Oregon USA.
Floodplain Restoration Using a RiverVision Approach in Meacham Creek, Oregon USA. 5 th National Conference on Ecosystem Restoration Greater Chicago, IL July 31, 2013 James Webster Confederated Tribes of
More informationThe State of the Columbia River Basin
The State of the Columbia River Basin west Pow Northwest Power and Conservation Council FISCAL YEAR 2015 ANNUAL REPORT To Congress and Citizens of the Pacific Northwest October 1, 2014 - September 30,
More informationColumbia River Operations Summary
Columbia River Operations Summary Spring 2018 Seven Mile Reservoir. Photo by Megan Chadwick. This publication provides an overview of BC Hydro s operations on the Columbia River. At 2,000 kilometres long,
More informationGardena Farms Irrigation District #13
Walla Walla County Conservation District Gardena Farms Irrigation District #13 Gardena South Farms Lateral Irrigation Pipeline District Project #13 Project Piping Implementation South Lateral Phase Report
More informationIdaho Wheat Commission Cereal Schools. January 28, 2016
Idaho Wheat Commission Cereal Schools January 28, 2016 About the Wheat Commission 2016 Supply Picture Segregating for Premium Price Protecting our Dams Maintaining Soft White Quality About the Idaho Wheat
More information2015 Snake River Fall Chinook Salmon Spawning Summary 3,155* 5, ,346
2015 Snake River Fall Chinook Salmon Spawning Summary by Bill Arnsberg, Nez Perce Tribe Phil Groves, Idaho Power Company Frank Mullins, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Debbie Milks, Washington Department
More informationPublic Scoping Report for the Columbia River System Operations Environmental Impact Statement
Public Scoping Report for the Columbia River System Operations Environmental Impact Statement October 2017 Public Scoping Report for the Columbia River System Operations Environmental Impact Statement
More information18 Little White Salmon Subbasin
18 Little White Salmon Subbasin Figure 18-1. Location of the Little White Salmon River Subbasin within the Lower Columbia River Basin. 18.1 Basin Overview The Little White Salmon Subbasin encompasses approximately
More informationCOLUMBIA RIVER TREATY FLOOD CONTROL OPERATING PLAN
COLUMBIA RIVER TREATY FLOOD CONTROL OPERATING PLAN October 1999 Prepared by Corps of Engineers, Northwestern Division, North Pacific Region For the United States Entity Hydrologic Engineering Branch Water
More informationLower Columbia River Ecosystem Restoration Program. Catherine Corbett, Chief Scientist Science to Policy Summit May 10, 2013
Lower Columbia River Ecosystem Restoration Program Catherine Corbett, Chief Scientist Science to Policy Summit May 10, 2013 Ecosystem-Based Management (EBM) Requires these conditions (UNEP 2006): holistic
More informationTim Hayden, Yurok Tribe Natural Resources Division Mat Millenbach, Western Rivers Conservancy Sarah Beesley, Yurok Tribal Fisheries Program
BLUE CREEK FOREST SANCTUARY: RESTORING OLD GROWTH FOREST ECOSYSTEM FUNCTION, PROTECTING SALMON, WILDLIFE, AND TRADITIONAL- LIFE WAYS AND CULTURE IN THE FACE OF CLIMATE CHANGE Tim Hayden, Yurok Tribe Natural
More informationFisheries Restoration Planning in the Klamath Basin
Fisheries Restoration Planning in the Klamath Basin Chris Wheaton PSMFC Annual Meeting, August 22, 2017 1 Map: Salem Capital-Press 2 Brief and Subjective Klamath Historical Timeline 1905 Klamath Project
More informationFebruary 4, Erik Merrill, ISAB Coordinator; Jim Ruff, ISAB Ex Officio; and Laura Robinson, Program Implementation and Liaison Specialist
Bill Bradbury Chair Oregon Henry Lorenzen Oregon W. Bill Booth Idaho James A. Yost Idaho Jennifer Anders Vice Chair Montana Pat Smith Montana Tom Karier Washington Phil Rockefeller Washington February
More information2012 TOTAL DISSOLVED GAS ABATEMENT PLAN WELLS HYDROELECTRIC PROJECT
2012 TOTAL DISSOLVED GAS ABATEMENT PLAN WELLS HYDROELECTRIC PROJECT Prepared by: Bao Le Long View Associates Portland, Oregon And Beau Patterson Public Utilities District No. 1 of Douglas County East Wenatchee,
More informationYakima River Basin Environmental & Salmon Restoration Act
Yakima River Basin Environmental & Salmon Restoration Act Table of Contents SECTION 1. PURPOSE...Page 3 SECTION 2. DEFINITIONS...Page 3 TITLE I. BLACK ROCK WATER EXCHANGE PROJECT...Page 4 SECTION 101.
More informationIcicle Creek Water Resource Management Strategy
Icicle Creek Water Resource Management Strategy Public Open House April 20, 2016 Mike Kaputa Chelan County Natural Resource Department Melissa Downes WA Dept. of Ecology Office of Columbia River Dan Haller
More informationPacheco Reservoir Expansion
California Water Commission Pacheco Reservoir Expansion Unique Opportunity for Fisheries Recovery, Flood Risk Reduction and Emergency Water Supply December 13, 2017 1 of 33 Project Partners Pacheco Pass
More informationANNUAL PROGRESS REPORT FOR 2015 ROGUE RIVER SPRING CHINOOK SALMON CONSERVATION PLAN ROGUE WATERSHED DISTRICT OREGON DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE
ANNUAL PROGRESS REPORT FOR 2015 ROGUE RIVER SPRING CHINOOK SALMON CONSERVATION PLAN ROGUE WATERSHED DISTRICT OREGON DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE INTRODUCTION In September of 2007, the Oregon Fish and
More information