MORE EFFICIENT MECHANISMS OF BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL
|
|
- Baldwin Eaton
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 NEWEA ANNUAL CONFERENCE & EXHIBITION MORE EFFICIENT MECHANISMS OF BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL JAMES BARNARD, MARK STEICHEN & PATRICK DUNLAP January Boston MA
2 AGENDA History of EBPR Proposed mechanisms Alternative flowsheets Possible limitations of existing practices Problems with modeling alternative flow sheets Proposed remedies
3 2 SOME EARLY OBSERVATIONS Hi-rate no nitrification 30 to 40 h in Stripper Supernatant high in P treated with lime All primary effluent to aeration basin RAS thru deep anaerobic conditions Influent Wastewater Return Biomass Aerated P-enriched Lime Sludge Phostrip Process Levin et al (1975) Lime Settling Stripper Effluent Wasted Biomass 3
4 MIXED LIQUOR FERMENTER (MLF) Fermenter resulted from basin configuration and not deemed important Excellent phosphorus removal resulted Note orthophosphates profile through plant Performance could not be replicated in laboratory Barnard suggested organisms (PAO) should pass through anaerobic phase with low ORP which triggered EBPR Suggested Phoredox process by adding anaerobic zone up front Barnard 100 m 3 /d pilot 1972
5 PHOREDOX (AKA AO) CONCEPT OF PASSING ALL PRIMARY EFFLUENT THROUGH ANAEROBIC ZONE
6 2 FUHS & CHEN (1975) Studied the Pho-strip process Suggested PAO take up P when aerobic, use that energy to take up VFA in anaerobic zone Identified PAO as Acinetobacter Mechanisms further developed by Comeau & Wentzel As adapted by Comeau & Wentzel Problem not always sufficient VFA in primary effluent 6
7 VFA FROM FERMENTERS
8 VIEW OF KELOWNA B.C. Fermenter Anaerobic Zones PST
9 2 FURTHER STUDIES IDENTIFIED CANDIDATUS ACCUMULIBACTER AS THE DOMINANT PAO it was incorrectly considered that PAOs were of the genus Acinetobacter. or Tetrasphaera by Fuhs & Chen and others* More recently, culture-independent methods have shown Accummulibacter phosphatis is a PAO which can be grown in enriched cultures * For the purpose of design it will be considered that anoxic P uptake is not significant * *IWA Biological Wastewater Treatment - Principles,, Modeling and Design Henze et al 9
10 WESTBANK WITH FERMENTER Westside Kelowna BC (Westbank) X TN < 6 mg/l BOD < 5 mg/l TSS < 2 mg/l TP < 0.15 mg/l
11 WESTBANK WWTP Primary Anaerob Anoxic 1 Anoxic 2 Anoxic 3 Aerobic 1 Aerobic 2 Aerobic Phosphorus mg/l Tetrasphaera can denitrify Bioreactor Profile Phosphorus by Zone Primary Anaerob Anoxic 1 Anoxic 2 Anoxic 3 Aerobic 1 Aerobic 2 Aerobic 3 Note P uptake in Anoxic Zone
12 MIX OF ORGANISMS IN WESTSIDE PLANT Dunlap et al 2015 FISH Image from WR WWTP Sludge with EUB mix (all bacteria) Shown in Green, Tet2-174 (Tetrasphaera clade 2B) in Orange, and Tet3-654 (Tetrasphaera clade 3) in Red.
13 0.3 PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITH SIDE- STREAM FERMENTATION Iowa Hill CO plant From Chris Maher 9/8/2011 9/9/2011 9/10/ Effluent Ortho P mg/l
14 EXPERIMENT AT DENVER METRO RAS Cavanaugh, L., Carson, K., Lynch, C., Phillips, H., Barnard, J. and McQuarrie, J. (2012) A Small Footprint Approach for Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal: Results from a 106 mgd Full-Scale Demonstration. Proceedings of the 85 th Annual Water Environment Federation Technical Exhibition and Conference, New Orleans, LA, October 2012.
15 PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL BY RAS FERMENTATION DENVER METRO NSEC Effluent TP NSEC Effluent TSS 15 mg-p/l mg-tss/l NSEC Effluent PO4-P 10/4/ /6/ /8/ /10/ /12/ /14/ /16/ /18/ /20/ /22/ /24/ /26/ /28/ /30/ /1/ /3/ /5/ /7/ /9/ /11/ /13/ /15/ /17/ /19/ /21/ /23/ /25/ /27/ /29/ /1/ /3/ /5/ Cavanaugh, L., Carson, K., Lynch, C., Phillips, H., Barnard, J. and McQuarrie, J. (2012) A Small Footprint Approach for Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal: Results from a 106 mgd Full-Scale Demonstration. Proceedings of the 85 th Annual Water Environment Federation Technical Exhibition and Conference, New Orleans, LA, October 2012.
16 CAROUSEL PLANT HENDERSON NV 60 ML/D UPGRADED TO BNR Switching off a mixer in the anaerobic zone resulted in In-plant Fermentation Ortho-P for May ANA Eft SPS SCC Final Eft 0.4 Phosphorus (mg/l) /3/2010 5/4/2010 5/5/2010 5/6/2010 5/7/2010 5/8/2010 5/9/2010 5/10/2010 5/11/2010 5/12/2010 5/13/2010 5/14/2010 5/15/2010 5/16/2010 5/17/2010 5/18/2010 5/19/2010 5/20/2010 5/21/2010 5/22/2010 5/23/2010 5/24/2010 5/25/2010 5/26/2010 5/27/2010 5/28/2010 5/29/2010 5/1/2010 5/2/2010 5/30/2010
17 POSSIBLE LIMITATIONS OF EXISTING CONFIGURATION Were we perhaps selecting mostly for species of Accumulibacter that needed a supply of acetic & propionic acid They could have prevailed in standard anaerobic zones since conditions were not ideal for fermenting species like Tetrasphaera Tetrasphaera can ferment glucose and amino acids and other higher carbon forms and store phosphorus Nguyen et al They actually produce VFA that allow a population of Accumulibacter to grow alongside them They can denitrify under anoxic conditions Why did we not grow them not deep enough anaerobic conditions 2 17
18 WHY DID WE MISS IT? It appears that we need an ORP of <-300 mv most anaerobic zones struggle to get -150 mv Impossible to achieve with nitrates or DO anywhere Most plants were over-mixed with turbulent surfaces that entrained air which prevented deeper anaerobic conditions Standard mixing energy 0.6 hp/kcf need 0.08 hp/kcf (huge saving in energy) Too much air entrained in primary effluent Too much primary effluent per se which may contain very little VFA thus diluting the content of the anaerobic zone and reducing the anaerobic SRT 18
19 ORP IN ANAEROBIC ZONES Anaerobic Zone Conventional Anaerobic Zone Side-stream Fermenter 0 VFA -100 Accummulibacter Accummulibacter ORP (mv ) -200 Tetrasphaera VFA Glucose
20 2 MODIFIED WESTBANK PROCESS Aim for 1 to 2 day SRT in anaerobic zone (12-18 h with fermentate 20
21 WHEN NO PRIMARIES USE MIXED LIQUOR FERMENTER OLATHE KS, SACRAMENTO CA Flow Split Fermentation Power Outage End of MLF Ortho-Phosphate, mg-p/l COD: TKN 7.2 Nitrates 7.5 Average SVI ~ 90 ml/g Hardly any Acetate addition Present Limit 2.3 mg/l /2/13 1/1/14 1/31/14 3/2/14 4/1/14 5/1/14 5/31/14 6/30/14 7/30/14 Time MLF mixed only once per day or less often Guideline SRT of MLF approximately 2 days And here I would like to thank Kevin Clark from Pinery Water for showing us the way 21
22 Black & Veatch LAY-OUT OF CHANGIPLANT - SINGAPORE Aerobic Aerobic Aerobic Aerobic Aerobic RAS Feed Step-feed nitrification/denitrification Achieve EBPR Denite PAO Presence of Accumulibacter & Tetrasphaera The Occurrence of Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal in a 200,000 m3/day Partial Nitration and Anammox Activated Sludge Process at the Changi Water Reclamation Plant, Singapore Cao et al,
23 2 23
24 TETRASPHAERA IMPACTS MODEL BEHAVIOR Anaerobic Process Aerobic Processes Fermentation With Tetrasphaera OHOs Only Sb Tetrasphaera Ordinary Heterotroph Poly-P Growth COD Acetate COD Typical PAO Poly-P PO 4 PO 4 Tetrasphaera Ordinary Heterotroph Growth PO 4 Poly-P Sb COD O 2 COD Poly-P Growth Typical PAO PO 4
25 DRAWBACKS OF PARAMETER ADJUSTMENT Coarse parameter adjustment can offer insight into current model shortcomings but; the adjustment of many variables likely results in over adjustment & compensation, calibration is only possible if all relevant mechanisms are incorporated, and it will provide little predictive power when extrapolating beyond specific scenario. We are working with Northeastern University towards recommendations for better modeling sidestream EBPR as part WERF study Refer to WWTmod 2016 paper for more information; Rethinking EBPR: What do you do when the model will not fit real-world evidence?
26 2 CONCLUSIONS Shortcomings of design resulted in selection for limited variety of PAO, mainly those that need a supply of SCVFA Deeper anaerobic conditions are needed to cultivate fermenting PAO such as Tetrasphaera These organisms can also take up phosphorus under anoxic conditions Limit HRT in anaerobic zone by reduced primary effluent discharge and/or reduced RAS flow Wastewater characteristics irrelevant Modeling for alternative species of fermenting PAOs 26
27 2 27
28 2 28
29
Re Thinking Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal
Looking for a different photo? Click view slide show and click this link to access the Black & Veatch Digital Gallery. If you need to create an account, use code bvphotos09. Re Thinking Enhanced Biological
More informationMore Affordable, Reliable and Recoverable Nutrient Removal
More Affordable, Reliable and Recoverable Nutrient Removal Jim Fitzpatrick Senior Process Engineer OWEA 2017 Technical Conference and Exhibition June 26-29, 2017 Cincinnati, Ohio Agenda Drivers Optimize
More informationEnhanced biological phosphorus removal
FWRJ Sidestream Biological Phosphorus Removal: The New Frontier Lucas Botero, James L. Barnard, Ed Kobylinski, and Kenny Blanton Enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR), also known as biological
More informationAn Attempt to Sustainably Stabilize EBPR Performance at Meriden, CT with Side-Stream EBPR
An Attempt to Sustainably Stabilize EBPR Performance at Meriden, CT with Side-Stream EBPR Nick Tooker 1, Paul Dombrowski 2, Frank Russo 3, Annalisa Onnis-Hayden 1, April Z. Gu 1 1 - Northeastern University
More informationMeeting SB1 Requirements and TP Removal Fundamentals
Meeting SB1 Requirements and TP Removal Fundamentals June 5, 2017 Agenda SB1 requirements for P TP removal mechanisms Biological removal Chemical removal SB No. 1 Requirements for Phosphorus ** WWTP /
More informationAdvances in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal at Low DO Conditions
Advances in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal at Low DO Conditions Pusker Regmi Vail Operator Training Seminar 13 October, 2016 Wastewater Treatment and Energy The water quality industry is currently facing
More informationBIOLOGICAL PHOSPHOROUS REMOVAL AN OPERATOR S GUIDE
BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHOROUS REMOVAL AN OPERATOR S GUIDE ABSTRACT If you have ever faced a rising effluent phosphorous concentration and you are relying on biological phosphorous removal, the information offered
More informationOWEA Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition Upgrading WRFs for Biological Nutrient Removal. June 25, 2015
OWEA Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition Upgrading WRFs for Biological Nutrient Removal June 25, 2015 Agenda Permitting and Planning BNR Overview Case Example Innovative Approaches Proactive Participation
More informationGRANULAR ACTIVATED SLUDGE
CLARKE PRIZE CONFERENCE ON WATER SUSTAINABILITY GRANULAR ACTIVATED SLUDGE THE FUTURE OF BIOLOGICAL NUTRIENT REMOVAL JAMES BARNARD CONTENTS Early observations of granular sludge Selection processes in activated
More informationMetropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago
Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago Brett Garelli Deputy Director of M&O September 12, 2013 Outline Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal Principles Implementation at SWRP Optimization
More informationBiological Phosphorus Removal Technology. Presented by: Eugene Laschinger, P.E.
Biological Phosphorus Removal Technology Presented by: Eugene Laschinger, P.E. Overview What is phosphorus and why do we care? How can you remove phosphorus? Biological phosphorus removal Biological phosphorus
More informationADVANCING NOVEL PROCESSES FOR BIOLOGICAL NUTRIENT REMOVAL
ADVANCING NOVEL PROCESSES FOR BIOLOGICAL NUTRIENT REMOVAL PNCWA Boise, Idaho September 15, 29 Presented by: Alexander Mockos, EIT Co-Author: Dr. Erik Coats University of Idaho, Civil Engineering Department
More informationBiological Nutrient Removal Operations. December 9 th, 2015 Presenter Georgine Grissop PE, BCEE
Biological Nutrient Removal Operations December 9 th, 2015 Presenter Georgine Grissop PE, BCEE Outline Nutrient Removal Overview Process Considerations Process Monitoring Problems & Troubleshooting Questions
More informationNEW BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL CONCEPT SUCCESSFULLY APPLIED IN A T-DITCH PROCESS WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT
NEW BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL CONCEPT SUCCESSFULLY APPLIED IN A T-DITCH PROCESS WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT ABSTRACT C. Yang*, L. Zhou**, W. Luo***, and L. Johnson**** *Corstar International Corp. 111
More informationBiological Phosphorus Removal
Biological Phosphorus Removal 2017 ORWEF Short School Clackamas Community College Chris Maher, Operations Analyst Rock Creek AWTF Outline Phosphorus Cycle Players: PAOs, GAOs, OHOs, DNHOs, DPAOs Process
More informationSeeking the Optimum Approach to Generate VFA/rbCOD to Ensure Reliable EBPR at the Robert W. Hite Treatment Facility
Seeking the Optimum Approach to Generate VFA/rbCOD to Ensure Reliable EBPR at the Robert W. Hite Treatment Facility Kim Cowan, Lab Support Specialist Kurt Carson, O&M Engineer RMWEA JTAC December 17 th,
More informationSecondary Treatment Process Control
SARBS One-Day Training Seminar Phoenix Club, Anaheim Secondary Treatment Process Control Graham Juby June 5, 2013 Objectives Provide an understanding of nitrogen removal process interactions to support
More informationRE ENGINEERING O&M PRACTICES TO GET NITROGEN & PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITHOUT FACILITY UPGRADES
RE ENGINEERING O&M PRACTICES TO GET NITROGEN & PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITHOUT FACILITY UPGRADES GRANT WEAVER, PE & WASTEWATER OPERATOR WISCONSIN WASTEWATER OPERATORS ASSOCIATION WISCONSIN DELLS, WI OCTOBER
More informationFundamental and practical studies on Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal (EBPR) Daniel R. Noguera
Fundamental and practical studies on Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal (EBPR) Identifying polyphosphate accumulating organisms and achieving very low effluent phosphorus concentrations Daniel R. Noguera
More informationBIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL PLUS CHEMICAL POLISHING FOR LOW LEVEL COMPLIANCE
BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL PLUS CHEMICAL POLISHING FOR LOW LEVEL COMPLIANCE Nathan Cassity, Donohue Lake Michigan District Regional Operators Meeting May 21, 2015 Presentation Outline Background BPR
More informationENHANCED BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITHIN MEMBRANE BIOREACTORS. 255 Consumers Road Toronto, ON, Canada, M2J 5B6
ENHANCED BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITHIN MEMBRANE BIOREACTORS G. Crawford 1,2, G. Daigger 1, and Z. Erdal 1 1 CH2M HILL 2 CH2M HILL 255 Consumers Road Toronto, ON, Canada, M2J 5B6 ABSTRACT Several
More informationGeneral Operational Considerations in Nutrient and Wet Weather Flow Management for Wastewater Treatment Facilities Part II
General Operational Considerations in Nutrient and Wet Weather Flow Management for Wastewater Treatment Facilities Part II Samuel Jeyanayagam, PhD, PE, BCEE Julian Sandino, PhD, PE, BCEE Ohio WEA Plant
More informationNutrient Removal Processes MARK GEHRING TECHNICAL SALES MGR., BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT
Nutrient Removal Processes MARK GEHRING TECHNICAL SALES MGR., BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT Presentation Outline 1. Nutrient removal, treatment fundamentals 2. Treatment strategies Treatment methods: CAS, SBR,
More informationAquaPASS. Aqua MixAir System. Phase Separator. System Features and Advantages. Anaerobic. Staged Aeration. Pre-Anoxic.
PHASED ACTIVATED SLUDGE SYSTEM PHASED ACTIVATED SLUDGE SYSTEM Aqua-Aerobic Systems has led the industry in time-managed, biological technology since 1984. In 2004, Aqua-Aerobic applied its expertise in
More informationOverview of Supplemental Carbon Sources for Denitrification and Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal
JANUARY 19, 2017 Overview of Supplemental Carbon Sources for Denitrification and Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal Maahedi Savvy & Brad Hice, EOSi, Massachusetts Speakers Brad Hice, P.E., Business
More informationOPTIMIZING THE OPERATION OF ACTIVATED SLUDGE WASTEWATER TREATMENT FACILITIES GRANT WEAVER, PE & WASTEWATER OPERATOR WEBINAR MARCH 18, 2014
OPTIMIZING THE OPERATION OF ACTIVATED SLUDGE WASTEWATER TREATMENT FACILITIES TO REMOVE NITROGEN & PHOSPHORUS GRANT WEAVER, PE & WASTEWATER OPERATOR WEBINAR MARCH 18, 2014 www.cleanwaterops.com Optimizing
More informationFuture Directions In Wastewater Treatment
Future Directions In Wastewater Treatment Kenneth Williamson Emeritus Professor Chemical, Biological and Environmental Engineering Our Predicament 1. Choose to dilute and then concentrate 2. Choose processes
More informationOptimizing Nutrient Removal. PNCWA - Southeast Idaho Operators Section Pocatello, ID February 11, 2016 Jim Goodley, P.E.
Optimizing Nutrient Removal PNCWA - Southeast Idaho Operators Section Pocatello, ID February 11, 2016 Jim Goodley, P.E. Types of Optimization Outline Wastewater Characterization BNR Optimization N Removal
More informationTHE SEQUENCED AERATION PROCESS MONTAGUE, MASSACHUSETTS
THE SEQUENCED AERATION PROCESS MONTAGUE, MASSACHUSETTS GRANT WEAVER, PE & WASTEWATER OPERATOR THE WATER PLANET COMPANY WEBINAR APRIL 15, 2014 www.cleanwaterops.com Montague, Massachusetts 1.8 MGD Population
More informationTWO YEARS OF BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITH AN ADVANCED MSBR SYSTEM AT THE SHENZHEN YANTIAN WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT
TWO YEARS OF BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITH AN ADVANCED MSBR SYSTEM AT THE SHENZHEN YANTIAN WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT Chester Yang, Ph.D., Gaowei Gu, Baowei Li, Hongyuan Li, Wanshen Lu, Lloyd Johnson,
More informationBiological Phosphorous Removal Is Coming! Michigan Water Environment Association Annual Conference, June 23, 2008; Boyne Falls MI
Biological Phosphorous Removal Is Coming! Michigan Water Environment Association Annual Conference, June 23, 2008; Boyne Falls MI EUTROPHICATION CHOPNS CO 2 H 2 0 PO 4 NH 4 SO 4 CHOPNS NO 3 1 lb P grows
More informationNutrient Removal Optimization at the Fairview WWTP
Alyssa Mayer, PE Principal Engineer Nutrient Removal Optimization at the Fairview WWTP Mark Strahota, PE Associate Presentation Overview Project Background Process Model Development BNR Design Considerations
More informationEfficient Design Configurations for Biological Nutrient Removal
Efficient Design Configurations for Biological Nutrient Removal A Case Study: Upper Blackstone Water Pollution Abatement District Jane E. Madden, P.E., BCEE August 30, 2017 UBWPAD Wastewater Treatment
More informationCSR Process Simulations Can Help Municipalities Meet Stringent Nutrient Removal Requirements
CSR Process Simulations Can Help Municipalities Meet Stringent Nutrient Removal Requirements Continuous Flow Sequencing Reactor (CSR) Basin with Moving Bridge, Submerged Diffusers, and Stationary Diffusers
More informationDesigning Single-Sludge Bionutrient Removal Systems
Designing Single-Sludge Bionutrient Removal Systems Richard O. Mines, Jr., Ph.D., P.E. Environmental Engineering Mercer University 2001 World Water & Environmental Resources Conference Orlando, FL Activated
More informationJames Winslade Instructor, Environmental Resources Training Center Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville
James Winslade Instructor, Environmental Resources Training Center Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville In Memory of Steven Fiepke Chief Operator Village of Algonquin WWTP Skilled in Operation Dedicated
More informationNUTRIENT MANAGEMENT PROVEN METHODS FOR UPGRADING YOUR FACILITIES
. Crowne Plaza Hotel Springfield, IL NUTRIENT MANAGEMENT PROVEN METHODS FOR UPGRADING YOUR FACILITIES Steve Arant, Ed Kobylinski, James Barnard and Mark Steichen Presentation Outline Where are we and where
More informationJTAC Presentation May 18, Nutrient Removal Process Fundamentals and Operation
JTAC Presentation May 18, 2017 Nutrient Removal 101 - Process Fundamentals and Operation Steve Polson, P.E. Presentation Goals Develop understanding of: Why to remove nutrients How to remove nutrients
More informationProcess Monitoring for Biological and Chemical Nutrient Removal
October 27, 2016 Process Monitoring for Biological and Chemical Nutrient Removal OWEA 2016 PLANT OPERATIONS & LABORATORY WORKSHOP Agenda Why Consider Nutrient Removal? Nitrogen Monitoring & Removal Phosphorus
More information2.0 Nutrient Removal Alternatives
2.1 Introduction and Background The purpose of this chapter in the Master Plan Update is to assess the feasibility of incorporating nutrient removal facilities and processes at the Leavenworth Wastewater
More informationEffective Use of Carbon in Nutrient Removal Systems
Effective Use of Carbon in Nutrient Removal Systems Anthony D. Giovannone, PE Gary Sanitary District Case Study November 13 th, 2018 Overview PAO Metabolism (& the Future of Nutrient Removal) Operational
More informationContents General Information Abbreviations and Acronyms Chapter 1 Wastewater Treatment and the Development of Activated Sludge
Contents Contents General Information Abbreviations and Acronyms... 6 Chapter 1 Wastewater Treatment and the Development of Activated Sludge... 8 The Importance of Wastewater Treatment... 8 The Scope of
More informationSimultaneous Nutrient Removal: Quantification, Design, and Operation. Leon Downing, Ph.D., PE Donohue & Associates
Simultaneous Nutrient Removal: Quantification, Design, and Operation Leon Downing, Ph.D., PE Donohue & Associates Simultaneous Nutrient Removal Simultaneous nitrification, denitrification, and potentially
More informationAquaNereda Aerobic Granular Sludge Technology
Aerobic Granular Sludge AquaNereda Aerobic Granular Sludge Technology The AquaNereda Aerobic Granular Sludge (AGS) Technology is an innovative biological wastewater treatment technology that provides advanced
More informationChoices to Address Filamentous Growth
Michigan Water Environment Association Process Seminar November 12, 2015 Choices to Address Filamentous Growth Richard Beardslee City of Battle Creek Nathan Cassity Donohue & Associates Outline Battle
More informationThe following biological nutrient removal processes were evaluated in detail in the 2016 Liquid Processing Facilities Plan:
Nitrite Shunt Pilot Project Purpose: The purpose of this project is to full scale pilot test the nitrite shunt biological nutrient removal process to confirm process design criteria, impacts to sludge
More informationPreparing for Nutrient Removal at Your Treatment Plant
Summer Seminar Emerging Issues in the Water/Wastewater Industry Preparing for Nutrient Removal at Your Treatment Plant Rajendra P. Bhattarai, P.E., BCEE Austin Water Utility Ana J. Peña-Tijerina, Ph.D.,
More informationOhio Water Environment Association Present and Future Technologies for Nutrient Removal
Ohio Water Environment Association Present and Future Technologies for Nutrient Removal James L Barnard, Ph.D., D.Ing. h.c. BCEE, WEF Fellow, Dist. MASCE Contents Problems relating to Nutrients Wastewater
More informationEnvironmental Biotechnology Cooperative Research Centre Date submitted: March 2008 Date published: March 2011
final report Project code: A.ENV.0044 Prepared by: Environmental Biotechnology Cooperative Research Centre Date submitted: March 2008 Date published: March 2011 PUBLISHED BY Meat & Livestock Australia
More informationCE421/521 Environmental Biotechnology. Nitrogen and Phosphorus Cycles Lecture Tim Ellis
CE421/521 Environmental Biotechnology Nitrogen and Phosphorus Cycles Lecture 9-269 26-06 Tim Ellis Nitrification Kinetics µ = µ K maxs NH 4 S + S NH4 K O S O2 + S O2 where µ max = maximum specific growth
More informationIncreasing Biological Phosphorus Removal: Texas Case Study
Increasing Biological Phosphorus Removal: Texas Case Study Leon Downing, Ph.D. Theodore W. Chan, P.E. David R. Jackson, P.E., BCEE Leonard E. Ripley, Ph.D., P.E. Freese and Nichols, Inc. Tod K. Maurina
More informationENHANCING THE PERFORMANCE OF OXIDATION DITCHES. Larry W. Moore, Ph.D., P.E., DEE Professor of Environmental Engineering The University of Memphis
ENHANCING THE PERFORMANCE OF OXIDATION DITCHES Larry W. Moore, Ph.D., P.E., DEE Professor of Environmental Engineering The University of Memphis ABSTRACT Oxidation ditches are very popular wastewater treatment
More informationMicrobial Population Database for Evaluating Biological Nutrient Removal Process in Kwa- Zulu Natal
Microbial Population Database for Evaluating Biological Nutrient Removal Process in Kwa- Zulu Natal Sheena Kumari, Deepnarain N, Pillay K and Bux F Institute for Water and Wastewater Technology, Durban
More informationA Battle to Be the Best: A Comparison of Two Powerful Sidestream Treatment Technologies: Post Aerobic Digestion and Anammox
A Battle to Be the Best: A Comparison of Two Powerful Treatment Technologies: Post Aerobic Digestion and Anammox David Oerke/CH2M Tom Johnson/CH2M Bruce Johnson/CH2M Heidi Bauer/CH2M Steve Graziano/CH2M
More informationPLANNING FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL: WHAT STEPS CAN WE BE TAKING NOW?
PLANNING FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL: WHAT STEPS CAN WE BE TAKING NOW? LEONARD E. RIPLEY, PH.D., P.E., BCEE SENIOR PROCESS ENGINEER FREESE AND NICHOLS, INC. General Action Categories 1. Collect wastewater characterization
More informationCOMPARISON OF SBR AND CONTINUOUS FLOW ACTIVATED SLUDGE FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL
COMPARISON OF SBR AND CONTINUOUS FLOW ACTIVATED SLUDGE FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL Alvin C. Firmin CDM Jefferson Mill, 670 North Commercial Street Suite 201 Manchester, New Hampshire 03101 ABSTRACT Sequencing
More informationPresentation Outline
Presentation Outline Nitrification/denitrification refresher Treatment technologies available for nitrification and BNR/ENR What is the problem? BNR/ENR VPDES permitting Causes of reduced BNR performance
More informationSECTION 14.0 BIOLOGICAL NUTRIENT REMOVAL
SECTION 14.0 BIOLOGICAL NUTRIENT REMOVAL 14.1 INTRODUCTION Up to this point in the report, the physical and biochemical concepts considered for application to the secondary treatment sections of the three
More informationChemical and Biological Phosphorus Removal at One of the World s Largest Water Resource Recovery Facilities
Chemical and Biological Phosphorus Removal at One of the World s Largest Water Resource Recovery Facilities Glen T. Daigger 1, Wendy Barrott 2, Cheng Yang 1, Jin Yan 1, Zheyi Tian 1, Majid Kahn 2, Nancy
More informationEvaluation of Preformance for a Novel Side Stream Enhanced Biological Phopshporus Removal Configuration at a Full-Scale Wastewater Treatment Plant
University of Colorado, Boulder CU Scholar Civil Engineering Graduate Theses & Dissertations Civil, Environmental, and Architectural Engineering Spring 1-1-2012 Evaluation of Preformance for a Novel Side
More informationCharacteristics of Nutrient Removal in Vertical Membrane Bioreactors
The 2 nd MBR workshop at Hokkaido University Characteristics of Nutrient Removal in Vertical Membrane Bioreactors Prof. Hang-Sik Shin Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering Korea Advanced Institute
More informationCRUDE COD CHARACTERISTICS SIGNIFICANT FOR BIOLOGICAL P REMOVAL: A U.K. EXAMPLE
CRUDE COD CHARACTERISTICS SIGNIFICANT FOR BIOLOGICAL P REMOVAL: A U.K. EXAMPLE Jarvis, S. 1, Burger, G. 2, Du, W. 2, Bye, C. 2 and Dold, P. 2 1 Thames Water Utilities Ltd., 2 EnviroSim Associates Ltd.
More informationNUTRIENT REMOVAL PROCESSES IN WASTEWATER TREATMENT. We re Glad You re Here!
NUTRIENT REMOVAL PROCESSES IN WASTEWATER TREATMENT We re Glad You re Here! Please, put your cell phones on vibrate during sessions and, take calls to the hallway NUTRIENT REMOVAL PROCESSES IN WASTEWATER
More information2015 Spring Conference
2015 Spring Conference Meeting Strict Summer Permit Requirements on Day One: Start-up of the Western Wake Regional Water Reclamation Facility Chris White, PE April 13, 2015 Acknowledgements Town of Cary
More informationEmerging Issues in the Water/Wastewater Industry. Austin s Full-Scale Step-BNR Demonstration
Summer Seminar Emerging Issues in the Water/Wastewater Industry Austin s Full-Scale Step-BNR Demonstration Rajendra P. Bhattarai, P.E., DEE Austin Water Utility, City of Austin 625 East 10 th Street, Suite
More informationBIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL IN OXIDATION DITCH PLANTS
BIOLOGICAL PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL IN OXIDATION DITCH PLANTS Dave Arnott, P.E. Mark Van Weelden, P.E. WWOA Annual Conference October 18, 2017 January 20, 2015 Topics Traditional Ditch Configurations Mechanism
More informationSIMPLE and FLEXIBLE ENERGY SAVINGS And PERFORMANCE ENHANCEMENT for OXIDATION DITCH UPGRADES
SIMPLE and FLEXIBLE ENERGY SAVINGS And PERFORMANCE ENHANCEMENT for OXIDATION DITCH UPGRADES Oxidation ditches are very popular wastewater treatment processes for small to medium sized municipalities that
More informationA Roadmap for Smarter Nutrient Management in a Carbon and Energy Constrained World. Samuel Jeyanayagam, PhD, PE, BCEE
A Roadmap for Smarter Nutrient Management in a Carbon and Energy Constrained World Samuel Jeyanayagam, PhD, PE, BCEE 91 st Annual Conference 21 June 2016 The Importance of Carbon Without carbon, life as
More informationUpgrade of an Oxidation Ditch Using Bio-Mass Carriers
Upgrade of an Oxidation Ditch Using Bio-Mass Carriers Nir Assulin and Yigal Master Aqwise - Wise Water Technologies Ltd. The Problem Oxidation ditches (OD) are very popular wastewater treatment processes
More informationFull Scale Testing to Demonstrate Anaerobic Selector Effect for Low Strength Wastewater
OWEA State Conference June 20, 2012 Full Scale Testing to Demonstrate Anaerobic Selector Effect for Low Strength Wastewater Presenters Bill Donohue NEORSD Bob Hrusovsky MWH Don Esping BC Easterly Plant
More informationASA Analytics ChemScan Process Analyzers Reprint ASA Publication #194
ASA Analytics ChemScan Process Analyzers Reprint ASA Publication #194 Tertiary Denitrification and Very Low Phosphorus Limits: A Practical Look at Phosphorus Limitations on Denitrification Filters Published
More informationTROUBLESHOOTING BNR PROCESSES E. Stone, S. Walker, R. Reardon Carollo Engineers, Inc.
TROUBLESHOOTING BNR PROCESSES E. Stone, S. Walker, R. Reardon Carollo Engineers, Inc. INTRODUCTION Most biological nutrient removal (BNR) wastewater treatment plants are required by permit to significantly
More informationNITROGEN REMOVAL GRANT WEAVER, PE & WWTP OPERATOR PRESIDENT THE WATER PLANET COMPANY. Create Optimal Habitats
NITROGEN REMOVAL Create Optimal Habitats Recognize the Importance of People Skills Full-scale Experimentation GRANT WEAVER, PE & WWTP OPERATOR Regulatory Support Utility Support PRESIDENT THE WATER PLANET
More informationEnergy Savings Through Denitrification
Energy Savings Through Denitrification If Your Plant Nitrifies, Why Not Make it Denitrify Brett Ward Utility Operations Consultant Municipal Technical Advisory Service The University of Tennessee 1 Nitrate,
More informationGlobal Leaders in Biological Wastewater Treatment
Global Leaders in Biological Wastewater Treatment OVERVIEW OF ANOXKALDNES AnoxKaldnes is a global provider of leading-edge biological processes for wastewater treatment. The head-office is in Sweden. There
More informationWELCOME TO THE NOVEMBER EDITION OF THE 2016 M&R SEMINAR SERIES
2006 R&D SEMINAR SERIES WELCOME TO THE NOVEMBER EDITION OF THE 2016 M&R SEMINAR SERIES SAFETY PRECAUTIONS BEFORE WE BEGIN PLEASE FOLLOW EXIT SIGN IN CASE OF EMERGENCY EVALUATION AUTOMATED EXTERNAL DEFIBRILLATOR
More informationEFFECT OF FERROUS SULPHATE ON THE SIMULTANEOUS ORGANIC MATTER AND NUTRIENT REMOVAL PERFORMANCE OF SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR
EFFECT OF FERROUS SULPHATE ON THE SIMULTANEOUS ORGANIC MATTER AND NUTRIENT REMOVAL PERFORMANCE OF SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR Engin Gürtekin Department of Environmental Engineering, Firat University, Elazığ,
More informationInnovations in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal
1 st Annual Innovative Wastewater Technologies Seminar Innovations in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal Jose A. Jimenez, Ph.D., P.E. Director of Technology and Innovation Brown and Caldwell July 15 th, 2015
More informationImplementation and Results of a Feed-Forward Process Controller
Implementation and Results of a Feed-Forward Process Controller Matthew Gray 1*, Jim McQuarrie 2, Steven Kestel 1, Heather Phillips 3, and Tilo Stahl 1 1 BioChem Technology, King of Prussia, PA 2 Metro
More informationA Review of the Current State of Knowledge on Phosphorus Removal
A Review of the Current State of Knowledge on Phosphorus Removal Sam Jeyanayagam, Ph.D., P.E., BCEE Senior Associate Malcolm Pirnie sjeyanayagam@pirnie.com Phone: (614) 430-2611 OWEA Conference 16 June
More informationCITY OF WILSON WRF ACHIEVEMENTS IN TOTAL NITROGEN AND PHOSHPORUS REDUCTION BELOW ENR LEVELS
CITY OF WILSON WRF ACHIEVEMENTS IN TOTAL NITROGEN AND PHOSHPORUS REDUCTION BELOW ENR LEVELS Samuel A. Ledwell*, Environmental Operating Solutions, Inc. 160 MacArthur Blvd, Bourne, MA 02532. sledwell@eosenvironmental.com
More informationCity of Loveland Nutrient Removal Evaluation Final Report
City of Loveland Nutrient Removal Evaluation Final Report Prepared for Prepared by March 28, 2014 Table of Contents Executive Summary... ES 1 Introduction... ES 1 Process Modeling of Nutrient Removal
More informationAqua MSBR MODIFIED SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR
MODIFIED SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR MODIFIED SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR For over three decades, Aqua-Aerobic Systems has led the industry in sequencing batch reactor technology with performance proven and
More informationA Critical New Look at Nutrient Removal Processes
A Critical New Look at Nutrient Removal Processes Thomas E. Wilson,* John McGettigan* *Earth Tech, Inc. 675 North Washington Street Alexandria, Virginia 22314 ABSTRACT This paper questions the basic practice
More informationActivated Sludge Process Control: Nitrification
Activated Sludge Process Control: Nitrification 60 th Annual KWWOA Conference, Session 1: April 11, 2017 Dan Miklos, Senior Associate, Midwest Region, Hazen and Sawyer Agenda Overview of the Utopia Plant
More informationSepticity. Midwest Contract Operations. Presented by: Ryan Hennessy. (Organic Acids/ Sulfide)
Septicity (Organic Acids/ Sulfide) Presented by: Ryan Hennessy Midwest Contract Operations Types of Organisms Microorganisms can be classified by the type of respiration they use Aerobes use aerobic respiration
More informationCase Study. Biological Help for the Human Race. Bathurst Municipal Wastewater Treatment Works, New South Wales, Australia.
Case Study BiOWiSH Aqua Bathurst Municipal Wastewater Treatment Works, New South Wales, Australia BiOWiSH Aqua Executive Summary The main objective of the study was to quantify the cost savings of using
More informationNEWEA 2015 Annual Conference Session 16
NEWEA 2015 Annual Conference Session 16 Meeting North Attleborough, MA s 0.1 mg/l Phosphorus Limit with Bio-P and Cloth Media Filters January 27, 2015 Sue Guswa, P.E., Tighe & Bond Merrill Hastings, Town
More informationAltoona Westerly Wastewater Treatment Facility BNR Conversion with Wet Weather Accommodation
Pennsylvania Water Environment Federation PennTEC Annual Technical Conference June 4, 2013 Altoona Westerly Wastewater Treatment Facility BNR Conversion with Wet Weather Accommodation Presented by: Jim
More informationISAM SBR with Blower Assisted Jet Aeration Design Calculations For Lyons, CO WWTP Upgrade
ISAM SBR with Blower Assisted Jet Aeration Design Calculations For Lyons, CO WWTP Upgrade May. 28, 2013 A. Site Conditions 1. Site elevation = 5,322 ft MSL 2. Average barometric pressure = 12.07 psia 3.
More informationTroubleshooting Activated Sludge Processes. PNCWA - Southeast Idaho Operators Section Pocatello, ID February 11, 2016 Jim Goodley, P.E.
Troubleshooting Activated Sludge Processes PNCWA - Southeast Idaho Operators Section Pocatello, ID February 11, 2016 Jim Goodley, P.E. Outline Process Types & Kinetics Influent Monitoring Process Monitoring
More informationInnovative Phosphorus Control to Turn Struvite Headaches into Increase Revenue. Peter Schauer, Rob Baur, Brett Laney PNCWA 2010
Innovative Phosphorus Control to Turn Struvite Headaches into Increase Revenue Peter Schauer, Rob Baur, Brett Laney PNCWA 2010 Contents Where does the phosphorus go in BPR? How can WASSTRIP improve recovery?
More informationUse of Activate Sludge Model No. 3 and Bio-P module for simulating five-stage step-feed enhanced biological phosphorous removal process
Korean J. Chem. Eng., 23(2), 203-208 (2006) Use of Activate Sludge Model No. 3 and Bio-P module for simulating five-stage step-feed enhanced biological phosphorous removal process Sung-Hak Lee, Joo-Hyoung
More informationMIXED LIQUOR FERMENTATION FOR CARBON AUGMENTATION BREAKING FREE FROM AN UNFAVORABLE INFLUENT CARBON BALANCE
MIXED LIQUR FERMENTATIN FR CARBN AUGMENTATIN BREAKING FREE FRM AN UNFAVRABLE INFLUENT CARBN BALANCE Matt Bond, Associate Vice President Patrick Dunlap, Wastewater Process Specialist UNDERSTANDING BI-P
More informationOperation and Control of Multiple BNR Processes in One WWTP
Operation and Control of Multiple BNR Processes in One WWTP CENTRAL PLANT Williamsport Sanitary Authority s Chesapeake Bay and CSO Compliance Program Presented by: Phil Anderson 1 June 24, 2015 Purpose
More informationMaking Your Plant Denitrify
Making Your Plant Denitrify Control the Process and Reap the Benefits Brett Ward Utility Operations Consultant Municipal Technical Advisory Service The University of Tennessee 1 Why Denitrify? Required
More informationTable A1 - Peak Factors Used In Preparation Of Synthetic Database...1. Table A2 - Hourly Factors Used In Preparation Of Synthetic Database...
Table of Contents Table A1 - Peak Factors Used In Preparation Of Synthetic Database...1 Table A2 - Hourly Factors Used In Preparation Of Synthetic Database...2 Table A3 - Selected Wastewater Characteristics
More informationReview of WEFTEC 2016 Challenge & Overview of 2017 Event. Malcolm Fabiyi, PhD, MBA Spencer Snowling, PhD. P.Eng
Review of WEFTEC 2016 Challenge & Overview of 2017 Event Malcolm Fabiyi, PhD, MBA Spencer Snowling, PhD. P.Eng Agenda Review 2016 Challenge Provide overview of updates to 2017 event Frequency WEFTEC Scores
More informationBiological Nutrient Removal Processes
Chapter 22 Biological Nutrient Removal Processes Overview of Biological Nutrient Removal 22-3 Biological Selectors 22-6 Growth Zones 22-6 Selector Size and Equipment 22-10 Yardsticks for Measuring Biological
More information