A Battle to Be the Best: A Comparison of Two Powerful Sidestream Treatment Technologies: Post Aerobic Digestion and Anammox
|
|
- Bertina Austin
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 A Battle to Be the Best: A Comparison of Two Powerful Treatment Technologies: Post Aerobic Digestion and Anammox David Oerke/CH2M Tom Johnson/CH2M Bruce Johnson/CH2M Heidi Bauer/CH2M Steve Graziano/CH2M 2016 Vail Operator Training Seminar
2 What are PAD & Anammox? Treatment Technologies Reduction of nitrogen No supplemental carbon or alkalinity WEF Webcast 12/9/2009: Treatment for Nutrient Removal and Recovery
3 What is Post Aerobic Digestion? Aerobic digestion after anaerobic digestion Advantages: Reduction of N without chems. VSS reduction Odor reduction Struvite stabilization Challenges: Biological heat Foam
4 Example Full-Scale PAD Facilities Raw Chemically Enhanced Primary Treatment Spokane County Regional WRF Denver Metro WRD NTP 11/16 Boulder 75 th Street WWTP -10/16 Step Feed Bioreactor Membranes Solids Reduction & Nitrogen Removal Centrifuge Waste Solids Anaerobic Digesters Aerobic Digester Centrate
5 What is Anammox Anaerobic Ammonium Oxidation Advantages: Reduction of N without chems. Lower energy Challenges: Slow growth Competition with nitrite oxidizing bacteria
6 Example Full-Scale Anammox Facility Alexandria Renew Enterprises (AlexRenew) Water Resources Recovery Facility (WRRF) Wett, B., Murthy, S., Takacs, I., Hell, M., Bowden, G., Deur, A., Shaughnessy, M. (2007). Key Parameters for Control of DEMON Deammonification Process. Wat. Practice
7 Comparison of Technologies Post Aerobic Digestion Anammox Target Flow Stream Nitrogen Removal Method Entire anaerobic digestion effluent Nitrification/ Denitrification Dewatering liquors Partial Nitritation/ Deammonification - Carbon Input Degradable material from anaerobic digestion Not needed - Aeration Intermittent Intermittent Biomass Used Conventional Specialized
8 Methodology Pro2D 2 whole plant simulator: Baseline PAD Anammox CPES cost estimating system Assumptions: 75.7 ML/d (20 mgd) Aeration Basins: 5-stage Bardenpho 8.5 day SRT Biosolids facilities: 24/7 operation Disposal via land application mg/l Influent Effluent Limitation BOD TSS VSS 192 TKN 39 NH TN TP 6 1.0
9 Baseline PFD -No Treatment RAW INFLUENT PUMP STATION SCREENING AND GRIT REMOVAL PRIMARY CLARIFIERS Anaerobic AERATION BASINS Anoxic Aerobic Anoxic Aerobic SECONDARY CLARIFIERS FILTRATION PLANT EFFLUENT Recycle RAS Gravity Thickener Supernatant GRAVITY THICKENER GBT FILTRATE GRAVITY BELT THICKENER Thickened WAS Thickened Primary Solids ANAEROBIC DIGESTION Backwash BELT FILTER PRESS BIOSOLIDS Filtrate WAS
10 Post Aerobic Digestion PFD RAW INFLUENT PUMP STATION SCREENING AND GRIT REMOVAL PRIMARY CLARIFIERS Anaerobic AERATION BASINS Anoxic Aerobic Anoxic Aerobic SECONDARY CLARIFIERS FILTRATION PLANT EFFLUENT Recycle RAS Gravity Thickener Supernatant GRAVITY THICKENER GBT FILTRATE GRAVITY BELT THICKENER Thickened WAS Thickened Primary Solids ANAEROBIC DIGESTION Backwash BELT FILTER PRESS BIOSOLIDS Filtrate WAS POST AEROBIC DIGESTION
11 Anammox PFD RAW INFLUENT PUMP STATION SCREENING AND GRIT REMOVAL PRIMARY CLARIFIERS Anaerobic AERATION BASINS Anoxic Aerobic Anoxic Aerobic SECONDARY CLARIFIERS FILTRATION PLANT EFFLUENT Recycle RAS Gravity Thickener Supernatant GRAVITY THICKENER GBT FILTRATE GRAVITY BELT THICKENER Thickened WAS ANAEROBIC DIGESTION Backwash BELT FILTER PRESS Thickened Primary Solids BIOSOLIDS WAS Filtrate WAS Treated Filtrate ANAMMOX
12 Baseline: Design Criteria Average of 778 kg/d (1,715 lb/d) of carbon 3.66 m (12 ft) dia. tank for 30-day max month storage PAD: Aerobic digester volume of 4,656 m 3 (1.23 MG) Anammox: Based on DEMON process with an estimated total reactor volume of 1,079 m 3 (0.285 MG) Two SBR basins with an equally sized basin for Equalization
13 Cost Assumptions Life Cycle Assumptions: Life of Study 20 years Discount Rate 5.0 % Inflation Rate 3.0 % Capital Cost Assumptions: Start of Construction 2015 Construction Duration 2 years Markup Factor 2.38 Annual Cost Assumptions: Electricity Cost $0.0768/kWh Maintenance and Repair Cost 3.0%/year of equipment cost Biosolids Hauling Cost $20.58/wet metric ton ($18.67/wet U.S. ton) Biosolids Disposal Cost $33.07/wet metric ton ($30.00/wet U.S. ton) Trash Hauling and Disposal Cost $78.33/m 3 ($59.89/yd 3 ) Revenue $0/year Contingency 20% of annual costs
14 Mass Balance: Results Treatment Filtrate Quality Plant Effluent Biosolids Costs: Annual Capital Life Cycle
15 Results-Mass Balance -Mass Removed from
16 Results-Mass Balance -Filtrate Quality Baseline (No Treatment) Treatment with PAD Treatment with Anammox mg/l (kg/d) mg/l (kg/d) % Change from Baseline mg/l (kg/d) % Change from Baseline NH3 440 (390) 4.5 (4.0) 99% 43 (37) 90% TKN 490 (430) 45 (40) 91% 59 (51) 88% TIN 440 (390) 25 (23) 94% 93 (80) 79% TN 490 (430) 66 (59) 86% 110 (94) 78% Both sidestream treatment technologies remove significant amounts of nitrogen from the filtrate compared to the baseline.
17 Results-Mass Balance -Plant Effluent Baseline (No Treatment) Treatment with PAD Treatment with Anammox Flow, m 3 /d (mgd) 76,000 (20.0) 76,000 (20.0) 76,000 (20.0) BOD, mg/l (kg/d) 1.7 (130) 1.7 (130) 1.7 (130) TSS, mg/l (kg/d) 3.1 (240) 3.1 (240) 3.1 (240) VSS, mg/l (kg/d) 2.1 (160) 2.0 (150) 2.0 (160) NH3, mg-n/l (kg-n/d) 0.4 (30) 0.4 (31) 0.3 (19) TKN, mg-n/l (kg-n/d) 1.8 (140) 1.8 (140) 1.7 (130) NO3, mg-n/l (kg-n/d) 2.6 (200) 2.1 (160) 2.2 (170) TP, mg/l (kg/d) 0.4 (34) 0.5 (37) 0.5 (34) No significant differences between the two sidestream treatment technologies compared to each other or to the baseline.
18 Results-Mass Balance -Biosolids
19 Results-Annual Costs -Energy Use Baseline (No Treatment) Treatment with PAD Treatment with Anammox Treatment, kw Methanol Feed, kw Aeration Basins, kw Anaerobic Digestion, kw Anaerobic Digestion Energy Generation, kw (462) (452) (457) Net Energy, kw Annual Energy Consumption, kwh/yr 2,800,000 3,190,000 2,790,000 Annual Energy Cost, $/yr $215,000 $245,000 $214,000 Energy Cost Compared to Baseline, $/yr $30,000 -$1,000 Energy Cost Compared to Baseline, % 14.0% -0.5%
20 Results-Annual Costs -Chemical Use Baseline (No Treatment) Treatment with PAD Treatment with Anammox Methanol Consumption, kg/d (lb/d) 778 (1,715) - - Methanol Consumption, MG/yr (dry tons/yr) 284 (313) - - Annual Methanol Cost, $/yr $139,
21 Results-Annual Costs -Biosolids Production Baseline (No Treatment Treatment with Treatment) with PAD Anammox Biosolids Production, kg/d (lb/d) 7,982 (17,598) 6,965 (15,354) 7,878 (17,368) Biosolids Production, dry metric tons/day Biosolids Production, wet metric tons/day Biosolids Production, wet metric tons/yr 12,100 10,600 12,000 Annual Disposal Cost, $/yr $651,000 $568,000 $643,000 Disposal Cost Compared to Baseline, $/yr -$83,000 -$8,000 Disposal Cost Compared to Baseline, % -12.7% -1.2%
22 Results-Annual Costs -Total Energy, Chemical, & Biosolids Baseline (No Treatment Treatment with Treatment) with PAD Anammox Energy Use, $/yr $215,000 $245,000 $214,000 Chemical Use, $/yr $139, Biosolids Production, $/yr $651,000 $568,000 $643,000 Total Annual Costs for Energy, Methanol, & Biosolids Disposal, $/yr $1,005,000 $813,000 $857,000 Total Cost Compared to Baseline, $/yr -$192,000 -$148,000 Total Cost Compared to Baseline, % -19.1% -14.7%
23 Costs in Million Dollars Results-Capital Costs Baseline (No Treatment) Treatment with PAD Treatment with Anammox Aeration Basins $19.4 $19.1 $19.1 Aeration Basin Blowers $4.4 $4.2 $4.3 Carbon Feed and Storage Facility $ Anammox Facility - - $3.8 Post Aerobic Digestion - $5.3 - Other 11 Facilities $81.6 $81.6 $81.6 Additional Project Costs $15.6 $16.1 $15.9 Total Construction Cost $122.5 $126.3 $124.7 Percent Increase from Lowest Construction Cost - 3.1% 1.8%
24 Results-Total Annual Costs Costs in Million Dollars Baseline (No Treatment) Treatment with PAD Treatment w/ Anammox Aeration Basins $0.24 $0.23 $0.23 Aeration Basin Blowers $0.39 $0.35 $0.36 Carbon Feed and Storage Facility $ Anammox Facility - - $0.05 Post Aerobic Digestion - $ Biosolids Hauling and Disposal $1.40 $1.20 $1.40 Other 11 Facilities $1.96 $1.96 $1.96 Misc. Annual Costs & Contingency $0.20 $0.20 $0.20 Total Annual Cost $4.43 $4.04 $4.20 NPV of Annual Costs $55.1 $50.7 $52.2 Percent Increase from Lowest Annual Cost 9.7% - 4.0%
25 Results-Life Cycle Costs Costs in Million dollars Baseline (No Treatment) Treatment with PAD Treatment with Anammox Aeration Basins $22.3 $22.1 $22.1 Aeration Basin Blowers $9.3 $8.6 $8.7 Carbon Feed and Storage Facility $ Anammox Facility - - $4.5 Post Aerobic Digestion - $6.5 - Biosolids Hauling and Disposal $17.7 $15.4 $17.4 Other 11 Facilities $105.8 $105.8 $105.8 Standard Items $18.0 $18.6 $18.4 Total Net Present Value $177.6 $177.0 $176.9 Percent Increase from Lowest Life Cycle Cost 0.40% 0.06% -
26 Conclusions-1 Post Aerobic Digestion and Anammox Similarities: Excellent option for reduction of nitrogen recycled back to the liquid stream Supplemental chemicals not typically required Similar effluent quality achieved Significant removal of constituents in filtrate Less energy required for nutrient removal in aeration basins
27 Conclusions-2 Post Aerobic Digestion and Anammox Differences: Different sidestream flow streams targeted PAD removes more BOD, VSS, and Nitrogen Greater net annual cost savings for PAD Greater net energy savings for Anammox
28 Costs: Conclusions-3 Baseline (No Treatment) offers lowest capital cost Treatment with PAD offers the lowest annual cost Equivalent life cycle costs for Baseline, PAD, and Anammox: Consider PAD when N removal without chems. desired in addition to additional VSR. Consider Anammox when N removal without chems. desired in addition to energy minimization, or if future phosphorus recovery is desired.
29 A Battle to Be the Best: A Comparison of Two Powerful Treatment Technologies: Post Aerobic Digestion and Anammox QUESTIONS? David Oerke/CH2M (David.Oerke@ch2m.com) Tom Johnson/CH2M Bruce Johnson/CH2M Heidi Bauer/CH2M Steve Graziano/CH2M
THE DEMON ANAMMOX PROCESS: RESOURCE SAVINGS THROUGH SIDE STREAM TREATMENT, AND THE STEPS TOWARDS AN ENERGY NEUTRAL WWTP PRESENTED AT: NC AWWA-WEA 97
THE DEMON ANAMMOX PROCESS: RESOURCE SAVINGS THROUGH SIDE STREAM TREATMENT, AND THE STEPS TOWARDS AN ENERGY NEUTRAL WWTP PRESENTED AT: NC AWWA-WEA 97 TH ANNUAL CONFERENCE PRESENTED ON: 13 NOVEMBER, 2017
More informationPost-Aerobic Digester with Bioaugmentation Pilot Study City of Meridian, ID WWTP PNCWA 2010
Post-Aerobic Digester with Bioaugmentation Pilot Study City of Meridian, ID WWTP by: William Leaf Adrienne Menniti Bruce Johnson CH2M HILL, Inc. Clint Dolsby Tracy Crane City of Meridian October 26, 21
More informationPresentation Outline
Presentation Outline Nitrification/denitrification refresher Treatment technologies available for nitrification and BNR/ENR What is the problem? BNR/ENR VPDES permitting Causes of reduced BNR performance
More informationWWTP Side Stream Treatment of Nutrients Considerations for City of Raleigh s Bioenergy Recovery Project. Erika L. Bailey, PE, City of Raleigh
WWTP Side Stream Treatment of Nutrients Considerations for City of Raleigh s Bioenergy Recovery Project Erika L. Bailey, PE, City of Raleigh LNBA / NRCA 2017 Wastewater Treatment Plant Operators Training
More informationThe following biological nutrient removal processes were evaluated in detail in the 2016 Liquid Processing Facilities Plan:
Nitrite Shunt Pilot Project Purpose: The purpose of this project is to full scale pilot test the nitrite shunt biological nutrient removal process to confirm process design criteria, impacts to sludge
More informationPLANNING FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL: WHAT STEPS CAN WE BE TAKING NOW?
PLANNING FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL: WHAT STEPS CAN WE BE TAKING NOW? LEONARD E. RIPLEY, PH.D., P.E., BCEE SENIOR PROCESS ENGINEER FREESE AND NICHOLS, INC. General Action Categories 1. Collect wastewater characterization
More informationBEING GOOD STEWARDS: IMPROVING EFFLUENT QUALITY ON A BARRIER ISLAND. 1.0 Executive Summary
BEING GOOD STEWARDS: IMPROVING EFFLUENT QUALITY ON A BARRIER ISLAND Brett T. Messner, PE, Tetra Tech, Inc., 201 E Pine St, Suite 1000, Orlando, FL 32801 Brett.Messner@tetratech.com, Ph: 239-851-1225 Fred
More informationSidestream Treatment Overview. Kam Law, P.E. Beverley Stinson, Ph.D.
Sidestream Treatment Overview Kam Law, P.E. Beverley Stinson, Ph.D. March 20, 2012 Presentation Outline Concerns with sidestream Treatment options Treatment processes comparison Summary Concerns with sidestream
More informationDeammonification for Cost-Effective Sidestream Treatment
Deammonification for Cost-Effective Sidestream Treatment MWEA Process Seminar November 8, 2017 Lucy Pugh, P.E., BCEE Vice President Wastewater Technical Practice Leader Overview 1. What is deammonification?
More informationReview of WEFTEC 2016 Challenge & Overview of 2017 Event. Malcolm Fabiyi, PhD, MBA Spencer Snowling, PhD. P.Eng
Review of WEFTEC 2016 Challenge & Overview of 2017 Event Malcolm Fabiyi, PhD, MBA Spencer Snowling, PhD. P.Eng Agenda Review 2016 Challenge Provide overview of updates to 2017 event Frequency WEFTEC Scores
More informationManaging the Risk of Embracing Disruptive Technology
Managing the Risk of Embracing Disruptive Technology Julian Sandino PhD, PE, BCEE, IWA & WEF Fellow May 2016 Wastewater management evolution through time < 1900 1950 2000 Basic Sanitation Pollution Control
More informationA Critical New Look at Nutrient Removal Processes
A Critical New Look at Nutrient Removal Processes Thomas E. Wilson,* John McGettigan* *Earth Tech, Inc. 675 North Washington Street Alexandria, Virginia 22314 ABSTRACT This paper questions the basic practice
More informationFiltrate Treatment Facility Update
Nitrogen Removal Technology: Past, Present and Future- Blue Plains Advanced Wastewater Treatment Plant s Current Nutrient Regulation and Nitrogen Removal Processes Filtrate Treatment Facility Update May
More informationEnergy Efficient Wastewater Treatment. Emily Gonthier & Jennifer Lawrence April 30, 2018
Energy Efficient Wastewater Treatment Emily Gonthier & Jennifer Lawrence April 30, 2018 Outline ReNUWIt What is it? Our Partnership through ReNUWIt Research Municipal Wastewater Treatment 101 Anammox Broader
More informationOWEA Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition Upgrading WRFs for Biological Nutrient Removal. June 25, 2015
OWEA Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition Upgrading WRFs for Biological Nutrient Removal June 25, 2015 Agenda Permitting and Planning BNR Overview Case Example Innovative Approaches Proactive Participation
More informationSTRUVITE HARVESTING: A UTILITY S PERSPECTIVE
STRUVITE HARVESTING: A UTILITY S PERSPECTIVE MWEA Annual Conference June 2016 Mike Harvey, PE Agenda Why the focus on Phosphorus? Struvite What does it mean for me? Phosphorus Management and Harvesting
More informationGeneral Operational Considerations in Nutrient and Wet Weather Flow Management for Wastewater Treatment Facilities Part II
General Operational Considerations in Nutrient and Wet Weather Flow Management for Wastewater Treatment Facilities Part II Samuel Jeyanayagam, PhD, PE, BCEE Julian Sandino, PhD, PE, BCEE Ohio WEA Plant
More informationEnergy Neutral Opportunities
April 8, 2016 Energy Neutral Opportunities STEVE TARALLO, BLACK & VEATCH MDEQ - Michigan Water Resource Recovery Leadership Summit AGENDA Definition of energy neutrality at WRRFs Energy types, use, and
More informationOptimisation of the WWTP performance and design using computer simulation
Optimisation of the WWTP performance and design using computer simulation Jacek Mąkinia, Ewa Zaborowska Gdańsk University of Technology (Poland) Department of Sanitary Engineering IWAMA 6th International
More informationSide Stream Nutrient Considera6ons and Nutrient Harves6ng
Side Stream Nutrient Considera6ons and Nutrient Harves6ng Eric Spargimino, PE CDM Smith October 23, 2014 High Strength Side Streams Drivers Permit, Cost to treat, O&M and equipment Nitrogen Treatment AlternaFves
More informationPreparing for Nutrient Removal at Your Treatment Plant
Summer Seminar Emerging Issues in the Water/Wastewater Industry Preparing for Nutrient Removal at Your Treatment Plant Rajendra P. Bhattarai, P.E., BCEE Austin Water Utility Ana J. Peña-Tijerina, Ph.D.,
More informationNutrient Removal Optimization at the Fairview WWTP
Alyssa Mayer, PE Principal Engineer Nutrient Removal Optimization at the Fairview WWTP Mark Strahota, PE Associate Presentation Overview Project Background Process Model Development BNR Design Considerations
More informationOperation and Control of Multiple BNR Processes in One WWTP
Operation and Control of Multiple BNR Processes in One WWTP CENTRAL PLANT Williamsport Sanitary Authority s Chesapeake Bay and CSO Compliance Program Presented by: Phil Anderson 1 June 24, 2015 Purpose
More information2015 Spring Conference
2015 Spring Conference Meeting Strict Summer Permit Requirements on Day One: Start-up of the Western Wake Regional Water Reclamation Facility Chris White, PE April 13, 2015 Acknowledgements Town of Cary
More informationEfficient Design Configurations for Biological Nutrient Removal
Efficient Design Configurations for Biological Nutrient Removal A Case Study: Upper Blackstone Water Pollution Abatement District Jane E. Madden, P.E., BCEE August 30, 2017 UBWPAD Wastewater Treatment
More informationPerformance Evaluation of the Moores Creek Advanced Water Resource Recovery Facility
Performance Evaluation of the Moores Creek Advanced Water Resource Recovery Facility Richard W. Gullick, Ph.D. Director of Operations Timothy Castillo Wastewater Manager Presented to the Albemarle County
More informationNITROGEN REMOVAL GRANT WEAVER, PE & WWTP OPERATOR PRESIDENT THE WATER PLANET COMPANY. Create Optimal Habitats
NITROGEN REMOVAL Create Optimal Habitats Recognize the Importance of People Skills Full-scale Experimentation GRANT WEAVER, PE & WWTP OPERATOR Regulatory Support Utility Support PRESIDENT THE WATER PLANET
More informationDefining the Benefits of Harvesting Phosphorus from Dewatering Filtrate
Defining the Benefits of Harvesting Phosphorus from Dewatering Filtrate Cameron Clark, PE CDM Smith August 1, 2013 Agenda Des Moines WRA Background Plant Nutrient Balance Nutrient Issues P Removal Technology
More informationPrepared by the Operation of Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants Task Force of the Water Environment Federation
Operation of Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants WEF Manual of Practice No. 11 Chapter 31 Aerobic Digestion Sixth Edition Prepared by the Operation of Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants Task Force
More informationUDWQ POTW Nutrient Removal Cost Impact Study: Analysis of Tremonton City Wastewater Treatment Plant
TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM UDWQ POTW Nutrient Removal Cost Impact Study: Analysis of Tremonton City Wastewater Treatment Plant PREPARED FOR: PREPARED BY: COPIES: Utah Division of Water Quality CH2M HILL DATE:
More informationAMMONIACAL NITROGEN REMOVAL FROM SLUDGE LIQUORS OPERATIONAL EXPERIENCE WITH THE DEMON PROCESS
Abstract AMMONIACAL NITROGEN REMOVAL FROM SLUDGE LIQUORS OPERATIONAL EXPERIENCE WITH THE DEMON PROCESS DeMooij, H.W. 1 and Thomas, G 2 1 Grontmij Nederland B.V., 2 Grontmij UK, H.W. de Mooij, Tel. +31
More informationAppendix D JWPCP Background and NDN
Appendix D JWPCP Background and NDN JWPCP Background JWPCP Water Quality Primary Clarifiers HPO Reactors Final Clarifiers Unit Influent Primary Effluent Secondary Effluent BOD mg/l 460 240
More informationAltoona Westerly Wastewater Treatment Facility BNR Conversion with Wet Weather Accommodation
Pennsylvania Water Environment Federation PennTEC Annual Technical Conference June 4, 2013 Altoona Westerly Wastewater Treatment Facility BNR Conversion with Wet Weather Accommodation Presented by: Jim
More informationWINNIPEG SEWAGE TREATMENT PROGRAM --- SEWPCC --- Process Selection Report presentation
WINNIPEG SEWAGE TREATMENT PROGRAM --- SEWPCC --- Process Selection Report presentation January 24th 2011 - Winnipeg Purpose of the meeting 2 immediate purposes : Explain the recommandation of the PSR to
More informationFY17 Technical Survey of Nitrogen Removal Alternatives for the Deer Island Treatment Plant
FY17 Technical Survey of Nitrogen Removal Alternatives for the Deer Island Treatment Plant Massachusetts Water Resources Authority Environmental Quality Department Report 2017-09 Pacheco, N. 2017. Technical
More informationDesign, Construction and Startup of the First Enhanced Nutrient Removal Plant in Maryland Funded by the Chesapeake Bay Restoration Fund
Design, Construction and Startup of the First Enhanced Nutrient Removal Plant in Maryland Funded by the Chesapeake Bay Restoration Fund Rip Copithorn, Jeff Sturdevant, Vince Maillard GHD Clients People
More informationTechnologies for Sustainable Wastewater Treatment. Nitrogen Removal from Sludge Dewatering Liquor
Technologies for Sustainable Wastewater Treatment Nitrogen Removal from Sludge Dewatering Liquor For every 1 mil. gal. of water treated: 330 lbs. N Primary Settler Primary Sludge (30 lbs. N) Waste Activated
More informationAndrea Nifong, World Water Works (formerly HRSD) Stephanie Klaus, VT & HRSD
Recommendations and Lessons Learned from the Startup of the First Two Full-Scale Sidestream Deammonification Processes in North America: DEMON and ANITA Mox Andrea Nifong, World Water Works (formerly HRSD)
More informationAMPC Wastewater Management Fact Sheet Series Page 1
Nitrogen removal Nitrogen present in meat processing wastewater are termed a nutrient, since they are essential elements for life. They largely derive from proteins dissolved into wastewater from meat
More informationAMPC Wastewater Management Fact Sheet Series Page 1
Nitrogen removal Nitrogen present in meat processing wastewater are termed a nutrient, since they are essential elements for life. They largely derive from proteins dissolved into wastewater from meat
More informationMasses at Massillon: IFAS for Industrial Loads and Nutrient Removal
OWEA Annual Conference, Sandusky, OH, Wednesday, June 24, 3:00-3:45 PM Masses at Massillon: IFAS for Industrial Loads and Nutrient Removal Kristin Waller, O Brien & Gere Kristin.Waller@obg.com #obgpresents
More informationRE ENGINEERING O&M PRACTICES TO GET NITROGEN & PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITHOUT FACILITY UPGRADES
RE ENGINEERING O&M PRACTICES TO GET NITROGEN & PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL WITHOUT FACILITY UPGRADES GRANT WEAVER, PE & WASTEWATER OPERATOR WISCONSIN WASTEWATER OPERATORS ASSOCIATION WISCONSIN DELLS, WI OCTOBER
More informationAquaPASS. Aqua MixAir System. Phase Separator. System Features and Advantages. Anaerobic. Staged Aeration. Pre-Anoxic.
PHASED ACTIVATED SLUDGE SYSTEM PHASED ACTIVATED SLUDGE SYSTEM Aqua-Aerobic Systems has led the industry in time-managed, biological technology since 1984. In 2004, Aqua-Aerobic applied its expertise in
More informationSecondary Treatment Process Control
SARBS One-Day Training Seminar Phoenix Club, Anaheim Secondary Treatment Process Control Graham Juby June 5, 2013 Objectives Provide an understanding of nitrogen removal process interactions to support
More informationIntegrated Activated Sludge and Biosolids Treatment to Conserve Energy & Waste Solids Disposal
Integrated Activated Sludge and Biosolids Treatment to Conserve Energy & Waste Solids Disposal Nathan Antonneau, P.E. Presentation Outline Typical Flowsheet Configurations Process Reconfiguration - ISBR
More informationExecutive Summary. ES.1 Introduction
Executive Summary ES.1 Introduction The East Central Regional Water Reclamation Facility (ECRWRF) is a 70-mgd conventional activated sludge secondary treatment plant. Portions of the main plant s secondary
More informationProcess Monitoring for Biological and Chemical Nutrient Removal
October 27, 2016 Process Monitoring for Biological and Chemical Nutrient Removal OWEA 2016 PLANT OPERATIONS & LABORATORY WORKSHOP Agenda Why Consider Nutrient Removal? Nitrogen Monitoring & Removal Phosphorus
More informationAPPENDIX A. 1. Background. 1.1 Existing Facilities. Page 1
APPENDIX A PRELIMINARY TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR BIOSOLIDS MANAGEMENT SERVICES JEA Buckman Residuals Management Facility 1. Background JEA is seeking biosolids management services from experienced biosolids
More informationAdvances in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal at Low DO Conditions
Advances in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal at Low DO Conditions Pusker Regmi Vail Operator Training Seminar 13 October, 2016 Wastewater Treatment and Energy The water quality industry is currently facing
More informationSECTION 6.0 NEWPCC CENTRATE TREATMENT
SECTION 6.0 NEWPCC CENTRATE TREATMENT 6.1 CENTRATE FLOWS AND LOADS 6.1.1 Background The digested sludge dewatering system at the North End Water Pollution Control Centre (NEWPCC) operates on a continuous
More information20 Years of Nutrient Removal City of Beloit
20 Years of Nutrient Removal City of Beloit Leon Downing, PhD, PE, & Bill Marten, PE, BCEE Donohue Harry Mathos & Nate Tillis City of Beloit IWEA Nutrient Removal and Recovery Workshop September 12, 2013
More informationMainstream ANITA Mox Pilot Testing at Los Angeles County Joint Water Pollution Control Plant. Meg Hollowed Veolia Water Technologies
Mainstream ANITA Mox Pilot Testing at Los Angeles County Joint Water Pollution Control Plant Meg Hollowed Veolia Water Technologies Presentation Outline Background Sidestream vs. Mainstream Deammonification
More informationNorth Side WRP Master Plan Research and Development Department 2006 Seminar Series October 27, 2006 Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of
North Side WRP Master Plan Research and Development Department 2006 Seminar Series October 27, 2006 Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago Today s Goals Discuss project background Provide
More informationWASTEWATER DEPARTMENT. Bentonville Wastewater Treatment Plant Facts:
Mission: The mission of the Bentonville Wastewater Treatment Utility and staff is to protect public health and the environment through the effective treatment of wastewater. Effective wastewater treatment
More informationCarbon Redirection and its Role in Energy Optimization at Water Resource Recovery Facilities
Carbon Redirection and its Role in Energy Optimization at Water Resource Recovery Facilities Samuel Jeyanayagam, PhD, PE, BCEE, WEF Fellow Joint Energy Conference NYSAWWA & NYWEA Albany, NY 16 November
More informationMeeting SB1 Requirements and TP Removal Fundamentals
Meeting SB1 Requirements and TP Removal Fundamentals June 5, 2017 Agenda SB1 requirements for P TP removal mechanisms Biological removal Chemical removal SB No. 1 Requirements for Phosphorus ** WWTP /
More informationProprietary AquaTron technology incorporates three (3) innovative features that increase its efficiency and reduces cost:
THE AQUATRON The Technology The AquaTron is the result of over twenty years of research, development, testing and practical experience. Using the principles of the activated sludge biological process,
More informationShortcut Biological Nitrogen Removal for sustainable wastewater treatment and achieving energy neutrality
METROPOLITAN WATER RECLAMATION DISTRICT OF GREATER CHICAGO Shortcut Biological Nitrogen Removal for sustainable wastewater treatment and achieving energy neutrality Fenghua Yang, P.E., BCEE Outline Nitrogen
More informationAn Innovative Approach to Retrofitting for Nitrogen Removal
June 29, 2017 An Innovative Approach to Retrofitting for Nitrogen Removal OWEA 2017 TECHNICAL CONFERENCE & EXPO Innovation From Wikipedia: The application of better solutions that meet new requirements.
More informationJTAC Presentation May 18, Nutrient Removal Process Fundamentals and Operation
JTAC Presentation May 18, 2017 Nutrient Removal 101 - Process Fundamentals and Operation Steve Polson, P.E. Presentation Goals Develop understanding of: Why to remove nutrients How to remove nutrients
More informationInnovative Phosphorus Control to Turn Struvite Headaches into Increase Revenue. Peter Schauer, Rob Baur, Brett Laney PNCWA 2010
Innovative Phosphorus Control to Turn Struvite Headaches into Increase Revenue Peter Schauer, Rob Baur, Brett Laney PNCWA 2010 Contents Where does the phosphorus go in BPR? How can WASSTRIP improve recovery?
More informationAdvances in Point Source Nitrogen Removal Technologies: Transitioning from Version 1.0 to 3.0
Advances in Point Source Nitrogen Removal Technologies: Transitioning from Version 1.0 to 3.0 Charles B. Bott, PhD, PE, BCEE Chief of Research and Development Hampton Roads Sanitation District Denitrification
More informationEmerging Issues in the Water/Wastewater Industry. Austin s Full-Scale Step-BNR Demonstration
Summer Seminar Emerging Issues in the Water/Wastewater Industry Austin s Full-Scale Step-BNR Demonstration Rajendra P. Bhattarai, P.E., DEE Austin Water Utility, City of Austin 625 East 10 th Street, Suite
More informationThe TRA CRWS Master Plan. Past, Present, & Future of CRWS. Kaylee Dusek, EIT, Garver Matt Jalbert, PE, TRA
The TRA CRWS Master Plan Past, Present, & Future of CRWS Kaylee Dusek, EIT, Garver Matt Jalbert, PE, TRA TRA operates the largest water resource recovery facility in Texas CRWS N Dallas CRWS currently
More informationCity of Loveland Nutrient Removal Evaluation Final Report
City of Loveland Nutrient Removal Evaluation Final Report Prepared for Prepared by March 28, 2014 Table of Contents Executive Summary... ES 1 Introduction... ES 1 Process Modeling of Nutrient Removal
More informationNUTRIENT REMOVAL FROM ANAEROBIC DIGESTER SIDE-STREAM AT THE BLUE PLAINS AWTP Overlook Ave., SW, Washington, DC 20032
NUTRIENT REMOVAL FROM ANAEROBIC DIGESTER SIDE-STREAM AT THE BLUE PLAINS AWTP Dimitrios Katehis *, Sudhir Murthy **. Bernhard Wett ***, Edward Locke * and Walter Bailey ** * Metcalf and Eddy, Inc. 5000
More informationAqua MSBR MODIFIED SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR
MODIFIED SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR MODIFIED SEQUENCING BATCH REACTOR For over three decades, Aqua-Aerobic Systems has led the industry in sequencing batch reactor technology with performance proven and
More informationSo You ve Removed Your Phosphorus? Now What? JTAC Luncheon April 9 th, 2014
So You ve Removed Your Phosphorus? Now What? JTAC Luncheon April 9 th, 2014 Agenda RWHTF and Upcoming Regulatory Requirements Biological Phosphorus Removal Outcomes Liquid and Solids Stream Interactions
More informationNutrient Removal Processes MARK GEHRING TECHNICAL SALES MGR., BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT
Nutrient Removal Processes MARK GEHRING TECHNICAL SALES MGR., BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT Presentation Outline 1. Nutrient removal, treatment fundamentals 2. Treatment strategies Treatment methods: CAS, SBR,
More informationApplying Extractive Nutrient Recovery for Managing Phosphorus in Sidestreams and Biosolids
Applying Extractive Nutrient Recovery for Managing Phosphorus in Sidestreams and Biosolids Wendell Khunjar PhD, PE May 11, 2017 Embracing the new resource management paradigm Source water Drinking Water
More informationStruvite Harvesting: Creating Value From Wastewater?
STRUVIA Sustainable Recovery of Phosphorus from Wastewater Struvite Harvesting: Creating Value From Wastewater? NC WEA/AWWA Annual Conference November 13, 2017 Luke Wood, PE Kruger, Inc In recent years,
More informationAppendix A: Case Studies
September 2008 Municipal Nutrient Removal Technologies Reference Document Appendix A: Case Studies Appendix A provides detailed case studies with information from nine wastewater treatment facilities selected
More informationGlobal Leaders in Biological Wastewater Treatment
Global Leaders in Biological Wastewater Treatment OVERVIEW OF ANOXKALDNES AnoxKaldnes is a global provider of leading-edge biological processes for wastewater treatment. The head-office is in Sweden. There
More informationMembrane Thickening Aerobic Digestion Processes
Membrane Thickening Aerobic Digestion Processes 2013 NESOWEA Operator Seminar Bryen Woo, PE Membrane Thickening Digestion Aerobic digestion process using a Flat Sheet Membrane Unit Ideal for: Facilities
More informationAt the Mercy of the Process Impacts of Nitrogen Removal Performance on WWTP Disinfection
OBG PRESENTS: At the Mercy of the Process Impacts of Nitrogen Removal Performance on WWTP Disinfection Ned Talbot, PE Tri-Association Conference 2018 8/30/18 9:00-9:30AM AGENDA Overview of Plant Processes
More informationOMNIFLO ISBR. The most innovative SBR yet! Water Technologies
OMNIFLO ISBR The most innovative SBR yet! Water Technologies A Powerful Approach to Wastewater Treatment The new OMNIFLO Interchange Sequencing Batch Reactor (ISBR) system combines two of the most efficient
More informationA SUBMERGED ATTACHED GROWTH BIOREACTOR FOR DECENTRALIZED WASTEWATER TREATMENT
A SUBMERGED ATTACHED GROWTH BIOREACTOR FOR DECENTRALIZED WASTEWATER TREATMENT P.B. Pedros * and W.K. Dobie F.R. Mahony & Associates, Inc. 273 Weymouth Street Rockland, MA 02370 ABSTRACT The Amphidrome
More informationCity of Elk River Wastewater Treatment Facility Improvements. Achieving Wastewater Treatment Goals
City of Elk River Wastewater Treatment Facility Improvements Achieving Wastewater Treatment Goals By Tejpal Bala, P.E. Bolton & Menk, Inc. The City of Elk River received a new NPDES permit and the existing
More informationDevelopments in Mainstream Deammonification and Nitrite Shunt Haydée De Clippeleir
Developments in Mainstream Deammonification and Nitrite Shunt Haydée De Clippeleir LIFT Shortcut Nitrogen Removal Focus Group Webmeeting October 27, 2015 Outline Short-cut N removal Why mainstream? Challenges
More informationFIRST APPLICATION OF THE BABE PROCESS AT S-HERTOGENBOSCH WWTP. Pettelaarpark 70, PO Box GA, s-hertogenbosch, The Netherlands
FIRST APPLICATION OF THE BABE PROCESS AT S-HERTOGENBOSCH WWTP Bastiaan Hommel 1, Eric van der Zandt 2, Debby Berends 2, Victor Claessen 1 1 Dutch Water Authority Aa en Maas Pettelaarpark 70, PO Box 5049
More informationDevelopments in Mainstream Deammonification and Nitrite Shunt Haydée De Clippeleir
Developments in Mainstream Deammonification and Nitrite Shunt Haydée De Clippeleir Intensification of Resource Recovery (IR2) Forum 2015 Monday August 10 th 2015 Outline Short-cut N removal Why mainstream?
More informationA Roadmap for Smarter Nutrient Management in a Carbon and Energy Constrained World. Samuel Jeyanayagam, PhD, PE, BCEE
A Roadmap for Smarter Nutrient Management in a Carbon and Energy Constrained World Samuel Jeyanayagam, PhD, PE, BCEE 91 st Annual Conference 21 June 2016 The Importance of Carbon Without carbon, life as
More informationWe Know Water. AnoxKaldnes. Moving Bed Biofilm Reactor (MBBR) Integrated Fixed-Film Activated Sludge (IFAS) and ANITA Mox Deammonification
We Know Water AnoxKaldnes Moving Bed Biofilm Reactor (MBBR) Integrated Fixed-Film Activated Sludge (IFAS) and ANITA Mox Deammonification WATER TECHNOLOGIES AnoxKaldnes MBBR and Hybas Processes AnoxKaldnes
More informationChemically Assisted Primary Sedimentation as a tool to improve energy balance of a large wastewater treatment plant
Chemically Assisted Primary Sedimentation as a tool to improve energy balance of a large wastewater treatment plant Mateusz Muszyński-Huhajło 1,*, Stanisław Miodoński 1, and Katarzyna Rucka 1 1 Faculty
More informationHolistic Approach to Plant Optimization for Biosolids Management
NC-AWWA_WE 2013 Holistic Approach to Plant Optimization for Biosolids Management April 30, 2015 Presenter: Ron Latimer, PE Co Author: Scott Hardy, PE The F. Wayne Hill WRC is an advanced treatment facility
More informationNew Phosphorus Removal Requirement Tips the Scales: Lessons Learned on Biosolids Management and Odor Control at the Southington CT Treatment Plant.
New Phosphorus Removal Requirement Tips the Scales: Lessons Learned on Biosolids Management and Odor Control at the Southington CT Treatment Plant. Plant Overview Plant Operations Interim Phosphorus Permit
More informationCOMPARISON OF SBR AND CONTINUOUS FLOW ACTIVATED SLUDGE FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL
COMPARISON OF SBR AND CONTINUOUS FLOW ACTIVATED SLUDGE FOR NUTRIENT REMOVAL Alvin C. Firmin CDM Jefferson Mill, 670 North Commercial Street Suite 201 Manchester, New Hampshire 03101 ABSTRACT Sequencing
More informationSustainable Approaches to Sidestream Nutrient Removal and Recovery
Sustainable Approaches to Sidestream Nutrient Removal and Recovery 2012 MWEA Wastewater Administrators Conference Frankenmuth, Michigan Lucy Pugh, PE, BCEE and Beverley Stinson, Ph.D., PE, AECOM January
More informationRefinement of Nitrogen Removal from Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants
Refinement of Nitrogen Removal from Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants Prepared for Maryland Department of the Environment Presented by: Gannett Fleming, Inc. Stephen B. Gerlach, PE & Carrie DeSimone
More informationBiological Phosphorous Removal Is Coming! Michigan Water Environment Association Annual Conference, June 23, 2008; Boyne Falls MI
Biological Phosphorous Removal Is Coming! Michigan Water Environment Association Annual Conference, June 23, 2008; Boyne Falls MI EUTROPHICATION CHOPNS CO 2 H 2 0 PO 4 NH 4 SO 4 CHOPNS NO 3 1 lb P grows
More informationWastewater Nitrogen Characteristics, Treatment and Removal Options. Bob Smith, Orenco Systems, Inc. GEC 2013
Wastewater Nitrogen Characteristics, Treatment and Removal Options Bob Smith, Orenco Systems, Inc. GEC 2013 ##/##/#### #1 Nitrogen Nitrogen (N 2 ) in the environment exists primarily in the earth s atmosphere
More informationContents General Information Abbreviations and Acronyms Chapter 1 Wastewater Treatment and the Development of Activated Sludge
Contents Contents General Information Abbreviations and Acronyms... 6 Chapter 1 Wastewater Treatment and the Development of Activated Sludge... 8 The Importance of Wastewater Treatment... 8 The Scope of
More informationInnovations in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal
1 st Annual Innovative Wastewater Technologies Seminar Innovations in Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal Jose A. Jimenez, Ph.D., P.E. Director of Technology and Innovation Brown and Caldwell July 15 th, 2015
More informationStartup and Performance of the World s first Large Scale Primary Dissolved Air Floatation Clarifier ABSTRACT KEYWORDS INTRODUCTION
Startup and Performance of the World s first Large Scale Primary Dissolved Air Floatation Clarifier Bruce R. Johnson 1 *, Jennifer Phillips 2, Tim Bauer 3, Greg Smith 4, George Smith 5, John Sherlock 6
More informationThe Unexpected Consequences of Water Conservation on Water Reuse Facilities
The Unexpected Consequences of Water Conservation on Water Reuse Facilities Linda Sawyer Linda Sawyer 925.210.2536 LSawyer@brwncald.com WateReuse Northern California December 8, 2017 Water Conservation
More informationApplication of the AGF (Anoxic Gas Flotation) Process
Application of the AGF (Anoxic Gas Flotation) Process Dennis A. Burke Environmental Energy Company, 6007 Hill Road NE, Olympia, WA 98516 USA (E-mail: dennis@makingenergy.com http//www.makingenergy.com)
More informationMAINSTREAM DEAMMONIFICATION
MAINSTREAM DEAMMONIFICATION Mark W. Miller 2015 VWEA Education Seminar April 30 th, 2015 Charles Bott HRSD, Sudhir Murthy DC Water, Bernhard Wett ARA Consult GmbH Outline Conventional BNR to Mainstream
More informationWastewater Nitrogen Removal
Wastewater Nitrogen Removal Bill McAllister, P.E. AMI Conference on Worker Safety, Human Resources, and the Environment Kansas City, MO March 9, 2011 Outline Presentation Background Biological Nitrogen
More informationTaking the Waste out of WAS: Sludge Pretreatment for Beneficial Uses
Taking the Waste out of WAS: Sludge Pretreatment for Beneficial Uses December 5, 2013 Matt Van Horne, P.E. 1 1 Agenda Why Sludge Pretreatment? What is OpenCel? Case Study #1: Philadelphia Water Department
More information