IJSOM November 2015, Volume 2, Issue 3, pp
|
|
- Lesley James
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 International Journal of Supply and Operation Management IJSOM November 2015, Volume 2, Iue 3, pp ISSN-Print: ISSN-Online: A tochatic programming approach for a multi-ite upply chain planning in textile and apparel indutry under demand uncertainty Houem Felfel *a, Omar Ayadi a and Faouzi Mamoudi a a National Engineering School of Sfax (ENIS), Univerity of Sfax, Tuniia, Road Soukra, Sfax, Tuniia Abtract In thi tudy, a new tochatic model i propoed to deal with a multi-product, multi-period, multi-tage, multi-ite production and tranportation upply chain planning problem under demand uncertainty. A two-tage tochatic linear programming approach i ued to maximize the expected profit. Deciion uch a the production amount, the inventory level of finihed and emi-finihed product, the amount of backorder and the quantity of product to be tranported between uptream and downtream plant in each period are conidered. The robutne of production upply chain plan i then evaluated uing tatitical and rik meaure. A cae tudy from a real textile and apparel indutry i hown in order to compare the performance of the propoed tochatic programming model and the determinitic model. Keyword: multi-ite; upply chain planning; tochatic programming; textile; robutne. 1. Introduction Modern proce indutrie operate no more a traditional ingle-plant but a multi-ite upply chain tructure where different production facilitie are erving a global market. In the lat decade, upply chain management ha received a remarkable interet in order to cope with highly * Correponding author addre: houem.felfel@gmail.com 925
2 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar continuou competition. Supply chain planning i an important proce within the upply chain management involving deciion undertaken by a company from the procurement of raw material to the hipping of end product to the cutomer. The upply chain planning problem can be claified following the time horizon into three categorie: trategic, tactical, and operational (Chopra and Meindl 2010). The trategic level concern the deign and the tructure of the upply chain over a long time horizon between five and ten year. The operational level i related to hort term deciion lating from few day to few week uch a cheduling, lot izing and equencing. The tactical planning model i between thee two extreme and include procurement, production, and ditribution deciion. Thi tudy i particularly motivated by a tactical upply chain planning problem faced by multi-ite upply network from textile and apparel indutry. Textile manufacturing proce conit of knitting and dyeing, cutting, embroidery, cloth making, and packaging tage. Each production tage may include more than one plant, forming a multi-ite, multi-tage manufacturing environment. The fluctuation of product demand i among the mot important ource of uncertainty in the textile and apparel indutry. In fact, the cutomer demand could be determined only at the end of the planning horizon. The under-etimation of overall demand lead either to lo ale or unatified cutomer. However, the over-etimation of the product demand reult in high production and inventory cot. In thi paper, we deal with a multi-product, multi-period, multi-tage, multi-ite upply chain planning problem under cutomer demand uncertainty. A two-tage tochatic programming model i developed in order to incorporate the effect of the uncertainty in the conidered problem. Deciion variable uch a amount of production and quantity to be tranported between different manufacturing facilitie are conidered a firt-tage variable and are aumed to be made before the realization of the uncertainty. Otherwie, deciion variable related to the inventory level, backorder amount, and tranportation amount of end product to be hipped to the cutomer are conidered a econd-tage variable made after the realization of uncertain demand. Subequently, the robutne of production planning olution i evaluated. Statitical metric and financial rik metric, uch a value at rik (VaR) and conditional VaR (CVaR), are calculated in order to evaluate the robutne of planning olution generated by the tochatic programming model compared to the determinitic model. Beide, a real example from a textile and apparel manufacturer cae in Tuniia i illutrated to compare the propoed tochatic model with the traditional determinitic upply chain planning model. The main cientific contribution of thi work i to develop a new tochatic model for a multi-product, multi-period, multi-tage, multi-ite upply chain production and tranportation planning problem under cutomer demand uncertainty. Beide, the propoed model and the evaluation approach are applied to a real cae tudy from textile and apparel indutry. The ret of the paper i organized a follow. In the next ection, we preent the literature review of related topic. Section 3 decribe the textile and apparel upply network under conideration. In ection 4, a two-tage tochatic formulation i propoed in order to incorporate demand 926
3 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) uncertainty in the upply chain planning problem. Section 5 decribe the tochatic programming algorithm. By conducting a real cae tudy, Section 6 verifie the effectivene and the robutne of the propoed tochatic model compared to the determinitic model. Finally, concluion, limitation of the developed model, and future reearch direction are drawn in Section Literature review To cope with highly competitive and global market, the tructure of manufacturing companie ha changed from traditional ingle-ite to multi-ite tructure. Multi-ite production planning problem have received a lot of attention in the literature. Mot of the paper dealing with multi-ite production planning problem focu on determinitic approache. Toni and Meneghetti (2000) addreed the production planning problem of a textile-apparel indutry upply chain. The author invetigate the influence of production planning period length a well a color aortment in the ytem' time performance. A real cae tudy from an Italian network of firm wa treated uing a imulation model. Lin and Chen (2007) developed a monolithic model of a multi-tage multi-ite multi-item production planning problem. The propoed model combined imultaneouly two different time cale, i.e., monthly and daily time bucket. A practical example from the thin film tranitor-liquid crytal diplay (TFT-LCD) indutry i illutrated to explain the planning model. Leung et al (2003) tudied a multi-ite aggregate production planning problem of a multinational lingerie company located in Hong Kong uing a goal programming approach. Three major objective function were conidered, which are minimization of the cot of worker hiring and laying-off, the maximization of profit and the minimization of the over-or under-utilization of import quota of different product. Shah and Ierapetritou (2012) treated the integrated planning and cheduling problem for multi-ite, multi-product batch plant uing the augmented Lagrangian decompoition method. Given the fixed demand forecat, the model aim to minimize production, torage, hipping, and backorder cot. Felfel et al (2014) propoed a multi-objective, multi-tage, multi-product, and multi-period model for production and tranportation planning in a multi-ite manufacturing network. The developed model aim imultaneouly to minimize the total cot and to maximize product quality level. It hould be noted that mot of the paper dealing with multi-ite production planning problem focu on determinitic olution. However, real production planning problem are characterized by everal ource of uncertainty. Hence, the aumption that all model parameter are known with certainty will lead to non-optimal and even unrealitic reult. Many approache have been propoed in the literature to cope with uncertainty. According to Sahinidi (2004), thee approache can be claified into four major categorie: fuzzy programming approach, robut optimization approach, tochatic programming approach, and tochatic dynamic programming approach. Stochatic programming approach (Birge and Louveaux, 1997; Dantzig, 1955) i one of the mot widely pread technique in the literature ued in upply chain planning problem under uncertainty. In thi approach, the deciion variable of the optimization problem are divided into two et. The deciion variable of the firt tage called here and now deciion have to be made before the realization of uncertainty. Subequently, the econd-tage deciion variable are choen after the preence of uncertain parameter in order to 927
4 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar correct the infeaibilitie caued by uncertainty realization ( wait and ee deciion). Therefore, the value of the objective function i the um of firt-tage deciion variable and the econd-tage expected recoure variable. Several work in the literature have been intereted in tochatic programming model for upply chain planning problem. Gupta and Marana (2000) propoed a multi-ite midterm upply-chain planning problem under demand uncertainty uing two-tage tochatic programming approach. The upply chain deciion are devied into two categorie: manufacturing deciion and logitic deciion. The manufacturing deciion are taken here and now before the realization of uncertainty while the logitic deciion are potponed in a wait and ee mode. A ingle period i conidered in the developed model. Leung et al (2006) developed a two-tage tochatic programming model in order to optimize a multi-ite aggregate medium-term production planning problem under an uncertain environment. The firt-tage deciion include the amount of manufactured product in regular-time and overtime, volume of ubcontracted product and number of required worker, hired worker and laid-off worker. Deciion uch a inventory level of product, and the amount of under-fulfilment product are conidered a econd-tage deciion. The effectivene of the propoed model wa highlighted through a real-world cae tudy from a multinational lingerie company ituated in Hong Kong. Karabuk (2008) conidered a yarn production planning problem under demand uncertainty in a textile manufacturing upply chain. The author developed a tochatic programming model where the rover configuration, frame configuration, and production quantity are the firt-tage deciion. Inventory level i conidered a recoure deciion. A two-tep preproceing algorithm i developed to olve the optimization problem and to reduce computational complexitie of the large-cale reulting model. Neverthele, thee work didn t conider tranportation in the mathematical optimization model. Nagar and Jain (2008) tudied a multi-period upply chain planning problem for new product launche under demand uncertainty. A two-tage tochatic programming approach i developed in order to incorporate uncertainty. Production quantity, raw material procurement, and capacity utilization are preented a here and now deciion. Outourcing, inventory and hipping of end product to cutomer are propoed a wait and ee deciion until the realization of uncertain demand. Subequently, thi model i extended uing a multi-tage tochatic programming formulation. Mirzapour Al-e-hahem et al (2011a) propoed a mid-term multi-product, multi-period, multi-ite production-ditribution planning problem under cot and demand uncertaintie. A two-tage tochatic programming model wa developed to incorporate the uncertain parameter. Mirzapour Al-e-Hahem et al (2011b) developed a multi-ite, multi-product, multi-period aggregate production planning problem. To olve thi problem, a new robut multi-objective mixed integer nonlinear programming model wa propoed. The common critic of thee work i the conideration of a ingle production tage in the planning problem. Awudu and Zhang (2013) developed a two-tage tochatic programming model for a production planning problem in a biofuel upply chain under uncertainty in order to maximize the expected 928
5 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) profit. Amount of product to be produced, and amount of raw material to be purchaed and conumed are conidered a the firt-tage deciion. Deciion uch a backlog, lot ale, and old product quantity are conidered a econd-tage deciion. A cae tudy from a biofuel upply chain i illutrated to demontrate the effectivene of the propoed model. A ingle period and a ingle production tage are taken into account in thi work. In the context of upply chain planning, robutne can be defined a a meaure of reilience of the objective function, uually cot or profit, to change under random event and uncertain parameter. Therefore, the evaluation of robutne repreent an important iue in order to ae the performance of the upply chain planning in the face of parameter uncertainty. Vin and Ierapetritou (2001) developed a trategy to quantify cheduling robutne in the face of uncertainty under uncertainty. To do o, everal robutne metric were ued, uch a the corrected tandard deviation, the determinitic tandard deviation and the extent of violation. Lin et al (2011) propoed a tochatic programming model for trategic capacity planning in thin film tranitor-liquid crytal diplay indutry. The robutne of the capacity plan i evaluated uing financial rik meaure, uch a the value at rik and the conditional value at rik. Although the evaluation of robutne wa performed in cheduling and trategic planning, thi concept wa not extended to tactical multi-ite upply chain production and tranportation planning problem. 3. Problem tatement In thi paper, we conidered a upply network from the textile and apparel indutry wherein the finihed product i proceed by mean of different production tage. The textile and apparel manufacturing proce conit of five main tage: knitting and dyeing, cutting, embroidery, cloth making, and packaging. Each production tage may include more than one plant etablihing a multi-ite upply network manufacturing environment a illutrated in Figure 1. The conidered upply network i compoed of an internal plant (Textile-International TE-INTER ) and four ubcontractor: a dyer and a knitter, an embroiderer, and three cloth maker. The TE-INTER company i formed of three manufacturing department which are cutting, packaging, and cloth making. Other activitie uch a knitting, dyeing, and embroidery are ubcontracted becaue of the lack of technical competence and reource. Cloth making operation can be alo ubcontracted in order to extend the production capacity and to fulfill all the cutomer demand. 929
6 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar Figure 1. The multi-ite upply network environment of textile and apparel indutry In textile and apparel indutry, product are uually characterized by volatile demand and hort life cycle. The objective of the production upply network planning i to maximize the expected profit, computed by ubtracting the expected total cot from the total revenue. The expected total cot comprie production cot, torage cot, hortage cot, and tranportation cot. Deciion to be decided include the production amount at each plant, the amount of inventory of finihed or emi-finihed product, and the flow of material between different plant taking into account product demand uncertainty. The multi-ite upply chain planning model i built on the following aumption: - It i aumed that there i no initial amount of inventory and backorder. - Since the demand i uncertain, hortage of product may occur in each period, which i aumed to be backordered. - The uncertain demand i defined under different cenario and it i aumed to follow a dicrete ditribution aociated with known probability. - A ditribution lead time i taken into account in hipping the finihed product to the cutomer and emi-finihed product between different plant of the network. - There i no wate of product during the tranportation of finihed and emi-finihed product. To formulate the mathematical model, we introduce the following indice parameter and deciion variable: 930
7 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) Indice L i Set of direct ucceor plant of i. ST j i, i k t Set of tage (j= 1,2,..., N). Production plant index (i,i = 1, 2,...,I) where i belong to tage n and i belong to tage n+1. Product index (k = 1,2,..., K). Period index (t = 1,2,..., T). Scenario index ( = 1,2,...,S). Deciion variable P ikt S ikt JS ikt Production amount of product k at plant i in period t in regular-time. Amount of end of period inventory of product k for cenario at plant i in period t. Amount of end of period inventory of emi-finihed product k for cenario at plant i in period t. BD kt Backorder amount of finihed product k for cenario in period t. TR Amount of product k tranported from plant i to i in period t. i i', kt TRi CUS, kt Amount of product k tranported from the lat plant i to cutomer for cenario in period t. Q ik, Amount of product k received by plant i for cenario in period t. Parameter cp ik Unit cot of production for product k in regular-time at plant i. cti i ', k Unit cot of tranportation between plant i and i of production for product k. ct Unit cot of tranportation between the lat plant i and the cutomer. i CUS, k c ik Unit cot of inventory of finihed or emi-finihed product k at plant i. cbk Unit cot of backorder of product k. prk Unit ale price of finihed product k. 931
8 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar capp it Production capacity at plant i in normal working hour in period t. cap it Storage capacity at plant i in period t. captr Tranportation capacity at plant i in period t. i i', t D kt Demand of finihed product k for cenario in period t. b k DL Time needed for the production of a product entity k [min]. Delivery time of the tranported quantity. The occurrence probability of cenario where S Propoed two-tage tochatic programming model Due to the uncertainty of finihed product demand, the determinitic model i inappropriate to optimize the expected net profit. Therefore, a two-tage tochatic programming model i propoed in order to incorporate uncertainty in the deciion-making. It hould be noted that the tage of the tochatic programing model correpond to different tep of deciion-making and it i not related to time period. Due to the coniderable lead time required in the production proce, the production amount in each plant and the product amount to be tranported between uptream and downtream plant are taken here and now before the realization of the uncertainty. Other deciion variable uch a inventory, backorder ize and flow of finihed product to be hipped to the cutomer can be achieved in a wait and ee mode. Conequently, the two-tage tochatic programming model can be formulated a follow. The objective function (1) aim to maximize the expected profit obtained by ubtracting the total expected cot from the expected revenue. The occurrence probability of each cenario i conidered in order to calculate the expected revenue and the expected cot. The total cot include production cot, inventory cot, backorder cot, tranportation cot of emi-product between uptream and downtream plant, and tranportation cot of finihed product to cutomer. S T K I k i CUS, kt ik ikt ikt 1 t 1 k 1 i 1 Max E[ Profit] pr TR c ( S JS ) T K I i CUS, k i CUS, kt k k, t ik ikt i i', k i i', kt t 1 k 1 i 1 ct TR cb BD cp P ct TR (1) Contraint (2) i the balance for the inventory level of product in each production tage excluding the lat tage. 932
9 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) (2) S S P TR, i ST, k, t, ik, t ik, t 1 ikt i i', kt j N i' L i Contraint (3) provide the balance for end of period inventory in the lat production tage. I I ik, t ik, t 1 ikt i CUS, kt i 1 i 1 S S P TR, i ST, k, t, j N (3) Equation (4) repreent the inventory balance for the emi-finihed product. JSik, t JSik, t 1 Q Pikt, i, k, t, (4) ikt Contraint (5) repreent the balance equation for hortage in end product demand. BDkt BDk, t 1 Dkt TRi CUS, kt, k, t, (5) Contraint (6) provide the balance for tranportation between different production plant. Q TR, i, k, t, i' k, t DL i i', kt i' L i (6) Contraint (7) enure that the production capacity i repected. K bk Pikt cappit, i, t (7) k 1 Equation (8) i the torage capacity contraint. 933
10 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar K Sikt JSikt capit, i, t, (8) k 1 Contraint (9) guarantee that the tranportation capacity i repected. K TRi i', kt captrit, i, t, (9) k 1 Contraint (10) i the non-negativity retriction on the deciion variable. P,,, ',,,,,, ikt Sikt JSikt TRi i kt TRi CUS kt Qi k BDkt 0, i, k, t, (10) 5. Stochatic programming algorithm The major tep of the two-tage tochatic programming algorithm to olve the propoed model are given below: Step 1: make the firt-tage deciion including the production amount in each plant and the product amount to be tranported between uptream and downtream plant. Step 2: Compute the firt tage cot, Cot1 a follow: T K I Cot1 cp P ct TR t 1 k 1 i 1 ik ikt i i', k i i', kt (11) Step 3: at the beginning of tage 2, the realization of all uncertain demand occur. Step 4: at the end of tage 2, having een the realization of the uncertainty, and the firt-tage deciion, make the econd-tage deciion including inventory and backorder ize a well a the amount of product to be hipped to the cutomer. Step 5: compute the econd-tage cenario cot, Cot2 a well the cenario revenue, Revenue. The econd-tage cenario cot i equal to: T K I Cot2 c ( S JS ) ct TR cb BD (12) ik ikt ikt i CUS, k i CUS, kt k k, t t 1 k 1 i 1 The revenue of each cenario i given by: 934
11 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) Revenue T K I (13) t 1 k 1 i 1 pr TR k i CUS, kt Step 6: Calculate the expected total profit E[Profit] a follow: S (14) E[ Profit] ( Revenue Cot2 ) Cot1 1 The propoed two-tage programming model i olved uing the tochatic programming olver for multitage tochatic program with recoure of Lingo 14.0 oftware. 6. Computational experiment The main purpoe of thi ection i to evaluate the effectivene and the robutne of tochatic model in comparion with the determinitic model uing real cae indutrial data from textile and apparel indutry. In Section 6.1, the related input data are decribed. Then, the determinitic and tochatic model are olved and the quality of the obtained olution i compared uing tochatic programming parameter in Section 6.2. It i worthwhile mentioning that the determinitic model i widely ued in the literature (Kall and Wallace, 1994; Birge and Louveau, 1997; Awudu and Zhang, 2013) to evaluate the performance of the tochatic programming model. To olve the determinitic model, the random parameter are aumed to be known with certainty and thu only one cenario with mean random value i conidered. Giving the imulation reult, we evaluate the robutne of the propoed model through many tatitical and rik metric a detailed in Section 6.3. Section 6.4 give other cae tudie under randomly generated cutomer demand to validate the obtained reult. The experiment are conducted uing LINGO 14.0 package program and MS-Excel 2010 with an INTEL(R) Core (TM) and 2 GB RAM Indutrial cae decription In thi ection, real data i provided from a medium and mall enterprie located in Tuniia in textile and apparel indutry. The planning horizon of the planning problem cover two month and the length of a period i one week. On the bai of pat ale record and future long-term and hort-term contract, the future economy can be aumed to be one of four cenario: poor, fair, good, or boom. The market demand of the finihed product P1 and P2 under each cenario i reported in Table1. Different plant indice are lited in Table 2. Table 3 decribed the production capacitie of different plant. It hould be noted that the production capacity varie from one period to another becaue of the abenteeim. Table 4 provide information about production and inventory unit cot. The tranportation unit cot and capacity are hown in Table 5. The proceing time of different manufacturing proce are reported in Table
12 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar Table 1. Finihed product demand. Period Scenario T1 T5 T6 T7 T8 P1 P2 P1 P2 P1 P2 P1 P P1: product 1, P2: product 2. Table 2. Plant indice and deignation. Plant A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A7 A8 Deignation Knitting and dyeing proce Subcontractor1 Cutting- TE-INTER Embroidery Subcontractor2 Cloth making- TE-INTER Cloth making Subcontractor3 Cloth making Subcontractor4 Cloth making Subcontractor5 Packaging- TE-INTER 936
13 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) Table 3. Production capacity per week [min]. Plant Period T1 T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 T7 T8 A A A A A A A A Table 4. Unit production cot and inventory unit cot. Unit cot Product Plant A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A7 A8 cp P P c P1, P
14 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar Table 5. Unit cot and capacity of tranportation per week. Plant i Plant j Capacity (captr) Unit Cot (ct) (P1,P2) A1 A A2 A A3 A A3 A A3 A A3 A A4 A A5 A A6 A A7 A A8 Cutomer Table 6. Proceing time [min]. Product Plant A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A7 A8 P P
15 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) 6.2. Computational reult In order to evaluate the impact of uncertainty parameter on the planning deciion, two tochatic well-known meaure were ued: the expected value of perfect information (EVPI) and the value of tochatic olution (VSS) (Birge and Louveau 1997). The EVPI parameter help to determine the expected profit lo under uncertainty. It can be calculated a: EVPI= WS TSP (15) Where TSP i the objective value of two-tage tochatic programming model and WS repreent the objective value of the wait and ee model. The WS model involve a family of linear programming model. Each model i aociated with an individual cenario. The olution of the WS model i obtained by weighting each individual cenario with it correponding probability. Such a model would allow to alway make the bet deciion regardle of the uncertain parameter which i not poible in practice. The VSS parameter calculate the poible profit from olving the two-tage tochatic programing model over the determinitic model. If the VSS i poitive, it implie that the olution of tochatic programming model are better than thoe of the determinitic model. It i defined a: VSS= TSP- EEV (16) Where EEV repreent the expected olution of determinitic model. The EVPI i then computed: EVPI=WS-TSP= = According to the reult mentioned in Table 7, the EVPI/WS ratio i equal to 14.45%, which how the big influence of product demand uncertainty on the obtained olution. Therefore, it i worthwhile to have better forecat about the demand cenario. Then, the VSS i calculated: VSS= TSP- EEV= = Therefore, the two-tage tochatic model can lead to 7.45% more gain than the determinitic model a hown in Table7. Table 7. Stochatic programming parameter WS TSP EEV EVPI= WS-TSP VSS= TSP-EEV EVPI/WS (%) VSS/EEV (%) % 7.45% 939
16 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar 6.3. Robutne evaluation Robutne evaluation metric In order to evaluate the robutne of the production planning, different tatitical and rik metric were ued. Thee metric are baically: 1. Mean value ( ). It i defined a follow : (17) Where are the value of the ample item. 2. Standard deviation of profit ditribution (SD): It meaure the diperion or variation of a et of data from it mean. A high tandard deviation indicate a larger diperion or variability. A low tandard deviation implie that the data point are cloe to the average value. It can be formulated a: (18) 3. Value at rik (VaR): it i a percentile-baed metric widely ued in the literature for rik meaurement purpoe. It i defined a the minimal return or the maximal lo of a production planning over a pecific time horizon at a pecified confidence level.the VaR can be defined a the minimal portfolio return or the minimal profit at a pre-pecified confidence level a follow (Topaloglou and al 2002): VaR( x, ) min{ u : F( x, u) 1 } min{ u : P{ R( x, r) u} 1 }. (19) ~ Where ~ r : the return vector, ~ ~ ~ ~ ( 1, 2... ) T r r r r n R: Uncertain return of the portfolio at the end of the holding period. F: Ditribution function and F( x, u) P{ R( x, r) u} ~ 940
17 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) 4. Conditional value at rik (CVaR): It i alo called the mean hortfall, the mean exce lo, and tail VaR. It i a more conitent and coherent meaure of rik than the VaR ince it give information about the average lo which exceed the VaR. Topaloglou et al (2002) have introduced a general definition of the CVaR for continuou and dicrete ditribution a follow: p { R( x, r ) } 1 z VaR( x, ) (1 ) z pr( x, r) 1 1 { R( x, r ) z} (20) Where z VaR( x, ) ; p Aociated probability to the return value r ~ ~ ~ ~ ( r1, r 2... rn ) T under a cenario. Both VaR and CVaR are calculated for different rik level ( ): 0.85, 0.9, and Meaurement of robutne The cae tudy i olved with a ample ize of 64 cenario. The profit ditribution reult for the two-tage tochatic and determinitic model are illutrated in Figure 2. According to thee ditribution, we make a rik aement analyi by comparing different ditribution and we evaluate the robutne of the production planning of the tochatic and determinitic model. Two-tage tochatic model Figure 2. Profit ditribution for tochatic and determinitic model 941
18 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar Baed on thee ditribution, we calculate the mean, the tandard deviation, and the VaR and CvaR value for different rik level ( =0.85, =0.95, =0.9) a hown in Table 8. The tandard deviation calculated from thee reult are and , repectively, for the two-tage tochatic and determinitic model. Thi reult implie that a larger pread of value i obtained when we take uncertainty into account. From the Table 8, we alo oberve that the mean i greater for tochatic programming model. However, the VaR and CVaR for different coefficient ( =0.9, =0.95, =0.99) are greater for determinitic model. The computational reult how that the determinitic model provide a more robut olution than the tochatic model. In order to meaure the improvement performance gap of the tochatic model over the determinitic model, a metric i defined a follow: Expected tochaticvalue Expected determiniticvalue Improvment gap (%) 100 (21) Expected determinitic value We can ee from Table 9 an improvement of 3% in mean value. Beide, we ee a negative improvement in VaR by %, % and %for ( =0.85), ( =0.9) and ( =0.95), repectively. Moreover, we can note a negative improvement in CVaRby %, % and % for ( =0.85), ( =0.9) and ( =0.95), repectively, which mean that the robutne of the obtained olution i reduced after applying the tochatic programming model. Table 8. Statitical and rik metric of the tochatic and determinitic model Mod el SD Mean VAR (85%) CVAR (85%) VAR (90%) CVAR (90%) VAR (95%) CVAR (95%) SPM DTM Table 9. Improvement gap (%) of the tochatic model over the determinitic model Improvement gap (%) Mean VaR CVaR VaR CVaR VaR CVaR (85%) (85%) (90%) (90%) (95%) (95%) 3.00% % % % % % % 942
19 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) 6.4. Validation by other cae tudie In order to validate the obtained reult in Section 6.2 and 6.3, we imulate five et of indutrial data for randomly generated cutomer demand. Then, we calculate the tochatic programming parameter and the tatitical and rik metric a hown in Table 10 and Table 11, repectively. A it i een in Table 10, the VSS in all cenario are poitive with an average of 8.21%. Therefore, the ue of the tochatic model can gain an average of 8.21% over the determinitic model in different cenario. Table 10 alo report that the EPVI/WS average ratio i %, which reflect the big impact of uncertain parameter on the olution model. Table 10. Stochatic programming parameter under other indutrial cae tudie. Cae WS TSP EEV EVPI=WS-TSP VSS=TSP-EEV EVPI/WS (%) VSS/EEV (%) % 8.55% % 8.46% % 6.03% % 8.58% % 9.45% Average 16.99% 8.21% From Table 11, we oberve that the SD of the tochatic ditribution i higher than thoe of the determinitic ditribution. It i clear that a larger diperion and variability i obtained when we conider uncertainty. We can alo ee from Table 11 that the mean value are greater for the tochatic model. Beide, the VaR value are greater for the determinitic model in all cenario at different coefficient expect for ( =0.85). Moreover, CVaR value are higher for determinitic model in all cenario. The performance improvement of the tochatic model over the determinitic model i ummarized in Table 12. The average performance improvement in mean value i 12.14%. However, the average performance improvement in VaR i 3.03%, -2.90% and % for ( =0.85), ( =0.9), and ( =0.95), repectively. In addition, the average performance improvement in CVaR i %,-17.60% and % for ( =0.85), ( =0.9) and ( =0.95), repectively. Thi finding ugget that the tochatic programing model improve profitability. However, it reduce the robutne of upply chain planning reult in comparion with the determinitic model under demand uncertaintie. 943
20 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar Table 11. Statitical and rik metric of the tochatic and determinitic model under other indutrial cae tudie. Cae Mode SD Mean VAR CVAR VAR CVAR VAR CVAR l (85%) (85%) (90%) (90%) (95%) (95%) 1 SPM DTM SPM DTM SPM DTM SPM DTM SPM DTM Table 12. Improvement gap (%) of the tochatic model over the determinitic model under other indutrial cae tudie. Improvement gap (%) Cae Mean VaR CVaR VaR CVaR VaR CVaR (85%) (85%) (90%) (90%) (95%) (95%) % 3.59% % -4.90% % % % % 2.47% % 2.39% % -8.71% % % 10.23% % -1.16% -8.69% -6.67% % % 4.91% % 2.80% % % % % -6.06% % % % % % Average 12.14% 3.03% % -2.90% % % % 944
21 Int J Supply Oper Manage (IJSOM) 7. Concluion In thi paper, we propoe a multi-product, multi-period, multi-tage, multi-ite production and tranportation upply chain planning problem faced by textile and apparel indutry under demand uncertainty. In order to incorporate the effect of the uncertainty in the upply chain planning problem, a two-tage tochatic model i developed. A real cae tudy from a textile and apparel upply network i illutrated to verify the effectivene and the robutne of the developed model. According to the computational reult, the propoed tochatic programming model provide higher expected profit and profit mean value than the determinitic model under demand uncertainty. However, the propoed tochatic model lead to le robut olution in comparion with the determinitic model. Improving the robutne of the planning olution in the face of uncertainty repreent an intereting future work. Thi perpective can be addreed by mean of rik management model that incorporate rik meaure into the tochatic programming model. Acknowledgement Thi reearch and innovation i carried out in the context of a thei MOBIDOC funded by the European Union under the program PASRI. The author are grateful to LINDO Sytem Inc for providing u with a free educational reearch licene of the extended verion of LINGO 14.0 oftware package. Reference Awudu, I., & Zhang, J. (2013).Stochatic production planning for a biofuel upply chain under demand and price uncertaintie. Applied Energy, 103, Birge, J. R., & Louveaux, F. (1997). Introduction to Stochatic Programming. New York: Springer. Chopra, S., & Meindl, P. (2010). Supply chain management: Strategy, planning, and operation(4th ed.). Pearon Education, Inc : Upper Saddle River, New Jerey. Dantzig, G. B. (1955). Linear programming under uncertainty. Management Science 1, 197. Felfel, H., Ayadi, O., & Mamoudi, F. (2014). Multi-objective Optimization of a Multi-ite Manufacturing Network. Lecture Note in Mechanical Engineering, Gupta, A., & Marana, C. D. (2000). A Two-Stage Modeling and Solution Framework for Multiite Midterm Planning under Demand Uncertainty. Indutrial & Engineering Chemitry Reearch, 39, Lin J.T., & Chen Y.Y. (2007). A Multi-ite Supply Network Planning Problem Conidering Variable Time Bucket - A TFT-LCD Indutry Cae. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,33(9-10),
22 Felfel, Ayadi and Dadgar Kall, P. & Wallace, S.W. (1994). Stochatic Programming. John Wiley and Son: Chicheter.Karabuk, S. (2008).Production planning under uncertainty in textile manufacturing.journal of the Operational Reearch Society,59(4), Leung, S. C. H., Wu, Y., & Lai, K. K. (2003). Multi-ite aggregate production planning with multiple objective: A goal programming approach. Production Planning & Control: The Management of Operation,14(5), Leung, S. C. H., Wu, Y., & Lai, K. K. (2006). A tochatic programming approach for multi-ite aggregate production planning. Journal of the Operational Reearch Society,57, Lin, J. T., Wu, C.H., Chen, T.L., & Shih, S.H. (2011). A tochatic programming model for trategic capacity planning in thin film tranitor-liquid crytal diplay (TFT-LCD) indutry. Computer & Operation Reearch, 38, Mirzapour Al-e-hahem, S. M. J, Baboli, A., Sadjadi, S. J., &Aryanezhad, M. B. (2011a). A Multiobjective Stochatic Production-Ditribution Planning Problem in an Uncertain Environment Conidering Rik and Worker Productivity. Mathematical Problem in Engineering, Article ID , doi: /2011/ Mirzapour Al-e-hahem, S. M. J., Malekly, H., &Aryanezhad, M. B.(2011b).A multi-objective robut optimization model for multi-product multi-ite aggregate production planning in a upply chain under uncertainty. International Journal of Production Economic, 134(1), Nagar, L., & Jain, K. (2008). Supply chain planning uing multi-tage tochatic programming. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal,13(3), Sahinidi, N. V. (2004). Optimization under uncertainty: tate-of-the-art and opportunitie. Computer and Chemical Engineering,28 (6-7), Shah, N. K., & Ierapetritou, M. G. (2012). Integrated production planning and cheduling optimization of multiite, multiproduct proce indutry. Computer and Chemical Engineering, 37, Toni, A. D., & Meneghetti, A. (2000).The production planning proce for a network of Firm in the textile-apparel indutry. Int. J. Production Economic,65, Topaloglou, N., Vladimirou, H., & Zenio, S. A. (2002). CVaR model with elective hedging for international aet allocation. Journal of Banking & Finance,26(7), Vin J. P., & Ierapetritou M. G. (2001). Robut Short-Term Scheduling of Multiproduct Batch Plant under Demand Uncertainty. Indutrial & Engineering Chemitry Reearch, 40,
Design a Sustainable Supply Chain under Uncertainty using Life Cycle Optimisation and Stochastic Programming
151 A publication of CHEMICAL ENGINEERING TRANSACTIONS VOL. 61, 2017 Guet Editor: Petar S Varbanov, Rongxin Su, Hon Loong Lam, Xia Liu, Jiří J Klemeš Copyright 2017, AIDIC Servizi S.r.l. ISBN 978-88-95608-51-8;
More informationCoordinating a Supply Chain Consisted of One Supplier and One Retailer When Demand Disruption Happens
Management Science and Engineering Vol., No., 07, pp. 9-3 DOI:0.3968/947 ISSN 93-034 [Print] ISSN 93-035X [Online] www.ccanada.net www.ccanada.org Coordinating a Supply Chain Conited of One Supplier and
More informationModel of Integrated Production and Delivery Batch Scheduling Under JIT Environment to Minimize Inventory Cost
Proceeding of the 2014 International Conference on Indutrial Engineering and Operation Management Bali, Indoneia, January 7 9, 2014 Model of Integrated Production and Delivery Batch Scheduling Under JIT
More informationINVESTIGATION OF THERMOSTAT-SET CONTROL AS A NEW DIRECT LOAD CONTROL METHOD
INVESTIGATION OF THERMOSTAT-SET CONTROL AS A NEW DIRECT LOAD CONTROL METHOD Canbolat Uçak canbolat@elk.itu.edu.tr Gökçe Dokuyucu gokce776@uperonline.com Department of Electrical Engineering Electrical
More informationKNOWLEDGE MAPPING IN THAI WEAVING INDUSTRY
KNOWLEDGE MAPPING IN THAI WEAVING INDUSTRY Anyanitha Ditanont College of Innovation, Thammaat Univerity, Thailand anyanitha@yahoo.com Abtract: Knowledge i a valuable aet to any organiation epecially, the
More informationBig Data computation for workshop-based planning support
Big Data computation for worhop-baed planning upport Jianguang Tu International School of Software Wuhan Univerity Wuhan, P.R.China Tujg1973@gmail.com Jianquan Cheng * School of Science and the Environment
More informationA model for grain growth based on the novel description of dendrite shape
ARCHIVES of FOUNDRY ENGINEERING Publihed quarterly a the organ of the Foundry Commiion of the Polih Academy of Science ISSN (1897-3310) Volume 7 Iue 4/2007 183 188 36/4 A model for grain growth baed on
More informationInternational Journal of Mathematical Archive-8(6), 2017, Available online through ISSN
International Journal of Mathematical Archive-8(6), 27, 33-38 Available online through www.ijma.info ISSN 2229 546 BAYESIAN SPECIAL TYPE DOUBLE SAMPLING PLAN WITH BETA PRIOR DISTRIBTUTION Dr. S. JEYABHARATHI*
More informationUnit Commitment in Smart Grid Considering Demand Response and Stochastic Wind Generation
J. Energy Power Source Vol. 1, No. 6, 2014, pp. 314-320 Received: September 8, 2014, Publihed: December 30, 2014 Journal of Energy and Power Source www.ethanpublihing.com Unit Commitment in Smart Grid
More informationHeterogeneity in Producer s Marketing Strategy
Heterogeneity in Producer Marketing Strategy Tong Zhang Reearch Aitant Department of Agricultural Economic Oklahoma State Univerity 42C Ag Hall Phone no. 405-744-9797 Email: tong.zhang0@oktate.edu Wade
More informationValue intensity of water used for electrical energy generation in the Western U.S.; an application of embedded resource accounting
Value intenity of water ued for electrical energy generation in the Wetern U.S.; an application of embedded reource accounting Elizabeth A. Martin and Benjamin L. Ruddell Abtract Thi tudy evaluate the
More informationThe Process-Value Model: A Systems View of the IST Value Chain
Aociation for Information Sytem AIS Electronic Library (AISeL) SAIS 2007 Proceeding Southern (SAIS) 3-1-2007 The Proce-Value Model: A Sytem View of the IST Value Chain William L. Lomeron lomeronw@nula.edu
More informationLogistics Service Level Improvement Research and Demonstration Based on Queuing Theory
Management cience and Engineering Vol. 5, No. 3,, pp. -54 DOI:.36/j.me.335X53.z44 IN 3-34[Print] IN 3-35X[Online] www.ccanada.net www.ccanada.org Logitic ervice Level Improvement Reearch and Demontration
More informationNotes on the GoldSim Plume Function
NAC-0036_R1 Note on the GoldSim Plume Function Augut 014 Prepared by John auxe NEPUNE AND COMPANY, INC. 1505 15 th St, Suite B, o Alamo, NM 87544 itle: Decription: hi document calculation detail of the
More informationSimultaneous Synthesis of Multi-Period Heat Exchanger Networks for Multi-Plant Heat Integration
757 A publication of CHEMICAL ENGINEERINGTRANSACTIONS VOL. 61 2017 Guet Editor:PetarSVarbanov Rongxin Su Hon Loong Lam Xia Liu Jiří J Klemeš Copyright 2017 AIDIC ServiziS.r.l. ISBN978-88-95608-51-8; ISSN
More information75th MORSS CD Cover Page UNCLASSIFIED DISCLOSURE FORM CD Presentation
75th MORSS CD Cover Page UNCLASSIFIED DISCLOSURE FORM CD Preentation 712CD For office ue only 41205 12-14 June 2007, at US Naval Academy, Annapoli, MD Pleae complete thi form 712CD a your cover page to
More informationManagement Science Letters
Management Science Letter 2 (2012) 3049 3054 Content lit available at GrowingScience Management Science Letter homepage: www.growingscience.com/ml Identification and prioritization of hazardou material
More informationAbstract. 1 Introduction
Automatic conflict detection and reolution in metrorail ytem: evaluation approach for MARCO EU project G.F. D'Addio, M. Mazzucchelli, S. Savio Dipartimento di Ingegneria Elettrica, Univerita di Genova,
More informationManagement Science Letters
Management Science Letter 2 (202) 247 252 Content lit available at GrowingScience Management Science Letter homepage: www.growingscience.com/ml An empirical tudy to meaure the impact of loan aignment for
More information6/6/2012. HR Training and Development. Content. Training: concept. Training: concept. Training: concept. Training and Development: Concept
HR Training and Development UNIT 5 Content Concept and need of HR training and development Training need aement HR training: objective and method (on-the-job and off-the-job). Evaluation of training program
More informationExamining the tradeoff between fixed pay and performance-related pay: A choice experiment approach
Examining the tradeoff between fixed pay and performance-related pay: A choice experiment approach JUNYI SHEN * Reearch Intitute for Economic and Buine Adminitration, Kobe Univerity KAZUHITO OGAWA Faculty
More informationCourse Evaluation Validation using Data Envelopment Analysis. Joseph Sarkis Clark University. Inshik Seol Clark University
THE ACCOUNTING EDUCATORS JOURNAL Volume XX 2010 pp. 21-32 Coure Evaluation Validation uing Data Envelopment Analyi Joeph Sarki Clark Univerity Inhik Seol Clark Univerity Abtract In thi paper we detail
More informationGMACE Pilot #4: Adjusting the National Reliability Input Data
INTERBULL BULLETIN NO. 48. Berlin, Germany, May 20 21, 2014 GMACE Pilot #4: Adjuting the National Reliability Input Data P. G. Sullivan 1 and J. H. Jakoben 2 1 Canadian Dairy Network, Guelph, ON, Canada
More informationCONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATION FOR COMPACTING
ONTARIO PROVINCIAL STANDARD SPECIFICATION OPSS.MUNI 501 NOVEMBER 2017 CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATION FOR COMPACTING TABLE OF CONTENTS 501.01 SCOPE 501.02 REFERENCES 501.03 DEFINITIONS 501.0 DESIGN AND SUBMISSION
More informationEquilibrium Sediment Transport and Evolution Trend Simulation of the Lower Yellow River
Senor & Tranducer, Vol. 21, Special Iue, May 213, pp. 135-141 Senor & Tranducer 213 by IFSA http://www.enorportal.com Equilibrium Sediment Tranport and Evolution Trend Simulation of the Lower Yellow River
More informationModeling Suspended Sediments in Dez Basin (Case Study: The Tale Zang Hydrometric Station)
International Reearch Journal of Applied and Baic Science. Vol., 3 (2), 402-407, 2012 Available online at http://www.irjab.com ISSN 2251-838X 2012 Modeling Supended Sediment in Dez Bain (Cae Study: The
More informationIndicative simplified baseline and monitoring methodologies for selected small-scale CDM project activity categories
III.AU./Verion 01 TYPE III - OTHER PROJECT ACTIVITIES Project participant hall apply the general guideline to SSC CDM methodologie, information on additionality (attachment A to Appendix B) and general
More informationThe research of simplified method of calculating wind and rain loads and its validation
The reearch of implified method of calculating wind and rain load and it validation Xing FU 1) and Hong-Nan LI 2) 1), 2) Faculty of Infratructure Engineering, Dalian Univerity of Technology, Dalian 116024,
More informationWORKING PAPER ITLS-WP INSTITUTE of TRANSPORT and LOGISTICS STUDIES. The Australian Key Centre in Transport and Logistics Management
WORKING PAPER ITLS-WP-15-11 A reilient and utainable upply chain: I it affordable? By Behnam Fahimnia and Armin Jabbarzadeh June 2015 ISSN 1832-570X INSTITUTE of TRANSPORT and LOGISTICS STUDIES The Autralian
More informationDepartment of Production Engineering, Birla Institute of Technology, Mesra, Ranchi, Jharkhand, India.
International Journal of Baic and Applied Science Vol. 4. No. 3 2015. Pp. 118-129 Copyright by CRDEEP. All Right Reerved. Full ength Reearch Paper Supply Chain Optimization Model under Uncertainty Anurag
More informationAdaptive prediction model accuracy in the control of residential energy resources
Delft Univerity of Technology Delft Center for Sytem and Control Technical report 08-013 Adaptive prediction model accuracy in the control of reidential energy reource R.R. Negenborn, M. Houwing, B. De
More informationUp or Out? Economic-Engineering Theory of Flood Levee Height and Setback
Up or Out? Economic-Engineering Theory of Flood Levee Height and Setback Tingju Zhu 1 and Jay R. Lund 2 Abtract: Levee etback location and height are important iue in flood levee ytem deign and modification.
More informationUNIT 2 PROCESS AND FUNCTIONS OF HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING (HRP)
Baic of Human Reource Planning UNIT 2 PROCESS AND FUNCTIONS OF HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING (HRP) Objective After reading thi unit, you hould be able to: l the concept and proce of HRP, l the determination
More informationenvironment of the Poyang Lake of the department of Education, Nanchang University, Nanchang330031, China
doi:10.21311/002.31.10.20 Cot - Benefit Analyi of Green Building Baed on Input - Output Theory Liu Wei 1, 2, 3, Wu zhijiang 1 1 Eat China Jiaotong Univerity, Nanchang330013, China 2 The School of economic
More informationReactive Power Management of a Wind Farm to Prevent Voltage Collapse of an Electric Power System
Reactive Power Management of a Wind Farm to Prevent Voltage Collape of an Electric Power Sytem R. M. Monteiro Pereira Intituto Superior Engenharia de Coimbra, Portugal rmfm@iec.pt C. M. Machado Ferreira
More informationAn Optimal Real-time Pricing Algorithm for the Smart Grid: A Bi-level Programming Approach
An Optimal Real-time Pricing Algorithm for the Smart Grid: A Bi-level Programming Approach Fan-Lin Meng and Xiao-Jun Zeng School of Computer Science, Univerity of Mancheter Mancheter, United Kingdom mengf@c.man.ac.uk,
More informationAn intertemporal decision framework for electrochemical energy storage management
SULEMENTARY INFORMATION Article ttp://doi.org/10.1038/41560-018-0129-9 In te format provided by te autor and unedited. An intertemporal deciion framework for electrocemical energy torage management Guannan
More informationTransportation of Hazardous Wastes in Arizona: Development of a Data Base Management System for Basic Analysis
Tranportation Reearch Record Tranportation of Hazardou Wate in Arizona: Development of a Data Bae Management Sytem for Baic Analyi A. ESSAM RADWAN, K. DAVD PJAWKA, ANDY SOESLO, and FURE-YOW SHEH ABSTRACT
More informationAggregate Supply. MPL i = Y i / L i
Aggregate Supply The upply of output depend on the behavior of producer. roducer' chooe the quantity of input to employ. Thee input produce output and we aume that producer chooe their input to maximize
More informationCO 2 emissions trading planning in combined heat and power production via multi-period stochastic optimization
European Journal of Operational Reearch 176 (2007) 1874 1895 O.R. Application CO 2 emiion trading planning in combined heat and power production via multi-period tochatic optimization Aiying Rong *, Rito
More informationLED IP PRIMER. One World LED 1026 South Road, Edwardstown, SA, 5039 p: (08) e:
LED IP PRIMER Thi brochure provide a quick overview of the patented innovation by and our partner around the world. The ytem and method invented by patent granted to One World LED how our commitment to
More informationPRECIPITATION CALIBRATION TESTS August 12, 2009
BISHOP PAIUTE TRIBE ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT OFFICE PRECIPITATION CALIBRATION TESTS Augut 12, 2009 Thi report decribe the reult of everal precipitation calibration tet carried out in July 2009, following
More informationAfforestation Subsidy under Asymmetric Information and Transaction Cost in Developing Countries: Does rural capital market imperfection matter?
Afforetation Subidy under Aymmetric Information and Tranaction Cot in Developing Countrie: Doe rural capital market imperfection matter? Dambala Gelo, Steven Koch 2 Abtract Thi paper deal with the deign
More informationBusiness-driven decision support for change management: planning and scheduling of changes
Buine-driven deciion upport for change management: planning and cheduling of change Jacque Sauvé 1, Rodrigo Rebouça 1, Antão Moura 1, Claudio Bartolini 2, Abdel Boulmakoul 3, David Tratour 3 1 Departamento
More informationEffect of HFTID Controller on the Stability of Thermal Power Generator
Effect of HFTID Controller on the Stability of Thermal Power Generator Anhuman Sehgal, Japreet Kaur, Parveen Lehana 2 Department of Electrical Engineering, Baba Banda Singh Bahadur Engineering College,
More informationA Method to Risk Analysis in Requirement Engineering Using Tropos Goal Model with Optimized Candidate Solutions K.Venkatesh Sharma 1, Dr P.V.
www.ijcsi.org 250 A Method to Rik Analyi in Requirement Engineering Uing Tropo Goal Model with Optimized Candidate Solution K.Venkateh Sharma 1, Dr P.V.Kumar 2 1 Reearch Scholar in JNTUK Kakinada, Andhra
More informationAvailable online at ScienceDirect. Energy Procedia 48 (2014 )
Available online at www.ciencedirect.com ScienceDirect Energy Procedia 48 (2014 ) 806 812 SHC 2013, International Conference on Solar Heating and Cooling for Building and Indutry September 23-25, 2013,
More informationRESILIENT INFRASTRUCTURE June 1 4, 2016
RESILIENT INFRASTRUCTURE June 1 4, 2016 EXPERIMENTAL STUDY ON THE CAPACITY OF BARRIER DECK ANCHORAGE IN MTQ PL-3 BARRIER REINFORCED WITH HM-GFRP BARS WITH HEADED ENDS Michael Rotami Department of Civil
More informationFuzzy Decision Approach Based on QFD and FWA for Selection of Medical Suppliers
, July 1-3, 2015, ondon,.k. Fuzzy Deciion Approach Baed on QFD and FWA for Selection of Medical Supplier Mehtap Durun and E. Ertugrul Karak Abtract The objective of thi paper i to develop a fuzzy multi-criteria
More informationJOURNAL OF THE. Agricultural Economics Council. L Northeastern 0,/IA-<- '-'-". ~. ' ) VOLUME Ill, NUMBER 2 OCTOBER 1974 NOV
C i.; ' I FOUNDI.\T!ON OF AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS LIBRARY NOV 6 974 JOURNAL OF THE - L Northeatern Agricultural Economic Council ~ 0,/IA-
More informationAN INTEGRATED SIMULATION AND OPTIMIZATION APPROACH FOR SEASIDE TERMINAL OPERATIONS
AN INTEGRATED IMULATION AND OTIMIZATION AROACH FOR EAIDE TERMINAL OERATION Daniela Ambroino Elena Tànfani Department of Economic and Quantitative Method (DIEM) Univerity of Genova Via Vivaldi 5, 16126,
More informationMoST - Business Finland Joint Funding Call
MoST - Buine Finland Joint Funding Call I. AGREEMENT Memorandum of Undertanding for China-Finland Science & Technology Innovation Cooperation between the Department of International Cooperation of the
More informationOpportunity Costs and Non-Scale Free Capabilities: Profit Maximization, Corporate Scope, and Profit Margins
Opportunity Cot and on-scale Free Capabilitie: Profit Maximization, Corporate Scope, and Profit Margin Daniel A. Levinthal* Reginald H. Jone Profeor of Corporate Strategy 309 Steinberg-Dietrich Hall Wharton
More informationAs companies outsource more product design and manufacturing activities to other members of the supply
MANAGEMEN SCIENCE Vol. 55, No. 7, July 2009, pp. 1122 1138 in 0025-1909 ein 1526-5501 09 5507 1122 inform doi 10.1287/mnc.1090.1008 2009 INFORMS Quality Improvement Incentive and Product Recall Cot Sharing
More informationToP Strategic Planning Design Pattern Application Level
The Big Picture ToP Strategic Planning Deign Pattern Application Level ToP Strategic Planning Overview The ToP Strategic Planning method enable a group to create a et of trategie and practical action plan
More informationStudy of Enhanced Bioremediation in Treatment of Gas Condensates Contaminated Soil
Iranian Journal of Chemical Engineering Vol. 9, No. 4 (Autumn), 2012, IAChE Study of Enhanced Bioremediation in Treatment of Ga Condenate Contaminated Soil J. Shayegan, A. Babaee School of Chemical and
More informationExperimental Investigation of Sediment Trap Efficiency in Reservoirs
ENGINEER - Vol. XLVII, No. 0, pp. [1-8], 014 The Intitution of Engineer, Sri Lanka Experimental Invetigation of Sediment Trap Efficiency in Reervoir N.M.T.K. Revel, L.P.G.R. Ranairi, R.M.C.R.K. Rathnayake
More informationVEHICLE DISPATCHING PROBLEM AT THE CONTAINER TERMINAL WITH TANDEM LIFT QUAY CRANES. A Dissertation YAO XING
VEHICLE DISPATCHING PROBLEM AT THE CONTAINER TERMINAL WITH TANDEM LIFT QUAY CRANES A Diertation by YAO XING Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studie of Texa A&M Univerity in partial fulfillment of the
More informationMicrogrid Load Management Control Application
Microgrid Load Management Control Application T. Madiba Dept. Electrical, Electronic and Computer Engineering Univerity of Pretoria Pretoria, Republic of South Africa ymphomadiba@gmail.com Abtract Thi
More informationTHE POTENTIAL AND COST OF CARBON SEQUESTRATION IN AGRICULTURAL SOIL; EMPIRICAL STUDY OF DYNAMIC MODEL IN THE MIDWESTERN U.S.
THE POTENTIAL AND COST OF CARBON SEQUESTRATION IN AGRICULTURAL SOIL; EMPIRICAL STUDY OF DYNAMIC MODEL IN THE MIDWESTERN U.S. DISSERTATION Preented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Degree
More informationEuropean Advertising Consumer Research Report 2015
RESEARCH REPORT European Advertiing Conumer Reearch Report 2015 Conumer Awarene & Impact of European Self-Regulatory Programme for OBA Independent reearch conducted by Ipo MORI on behalf of TRUSTe and
More informationJJEES Jordan Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences
JJEES Jordan Journal of Earth and Environmental Science Volume 1, Number 1, Mar. 2008 ISSN 1995-6681 Page 33-44 Developing Reference Crop Evapotranpiration Time Serie Simulation Model Uing Cla a Pan: A
More informationFINITE ELEMENT INVESTIGATION ON THE INTERACTION BETWEEN SHALLOW AND DEEP EXCAVATED TWIN TUNNELS
VOL. 13, NO. 1, JANUARY 18 ISSN 1819-668 6-18 Aian Reearch Publihing Network (ARPN). All right reerved. FINITE ELEMENT INVESTIGATION ON THE INTERACTION BETWEEN SHALLOW AND DEEP EXCAVATED TWIN TUNNELS Adel
More informationPollution prevention with chemical process simulators: the generalized waste reduction (WAR) algorithm full version
Computer and Chemical Engineering 23 (1999) 623 634 Pollution prevention with chemical proce imulator: the generalized wate reduction (WAR) algorithm full verion Heriberto Cabeza *, Jane C. Bare, Subir
More informationWorking Party on Agricultural Policies and Markets
Unclaified AGR/CA/APM(2001)24/FINAL AGR/CA/APM(2001)24/FINAL Unclaified Organiation de Coopération et de Développement Economique Organiation for Economic Co-operation and Development 22-Jul-2002 Englih
More informationEnabling Collaborative Data Sharing in Google+
Enabling Collaborative Data Sharing in Google+ Hongxin Hu Delaware State Univerity, Dover, Delaware, 19901 hxhu@au.edu Gail-Joon Ahn and Jan Jorgenen Arizona State Univerity, Tempe, Arizona, 85287 {gahn,jan.jorgenen}@au.edu
More informationAdaptation benefits and costs measurement and policy issues
WORKING PARTY ON GLOBAL AND STRUCTURAL POLICIES OECD Workhop on the Benefit of Climate Policy: Improving Information for Policy Maker Adaptation benefit and cot meaurement and policy iue by John M. Callaway
More information4 Farmer Perceptions of the Biophysical
4 Farmer Perception of the Biophyical Contraint to Rice Production in Sub-Saharan Africa, and Potential Impact of Reearch Aliou Diagne,* Didier Y. Alia, Eyram Amovin-Aagba, Marco C.S. Woperei, Kazuki Saito
More informationMaintaining ISO Compliance in Automated Procedures
Maintaining ISO 1705 Compliance in Automated Procedure Preenter & Author: Jorge Martin Fluke Corporation PO 9090 M/S 6-30 Everett, WA, USA 9806 Phone: (45) 446 6477; Fax: (45) 446 6390 Email: jmartin@flukecom
More informationAbout the Authors. Your Shortcuts Might Become Expensive Detours. Dr. Andreas Krueger. Felipe Nogueira
L ea eadmi ni t r a onbynaki a MakeYourDeadl i newi t houtcompr omi i ngqual i t y I FRS16Rapi ddepl oymentgui de naki a. c om About the Author Dr. Andrea Krueger Andrea i a Senior Solution Expert for
More informationINTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ENGINEERING DESIGN ICED 03 STOCKHOLM, AUGUST 19-21, 2003 EVALUATION OF SOFT REQUIREMENTS DURING PRODUCT DESIGN
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ENGINEERING DESIGN ICED 3 STOCKHOLM, AUGUST 9-, 3 EVALUATION OF SOFT REQUIREMENTS DURING PRODUCT DESIGN Kjell Anderon Abtract Ti paper preent an approac to improve current metod
More informationMARINE HEALTH, SAFETY, QUALITY, AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
Guide for Marine Health, Safety, Quality and Environmental Management GUIDE FOR MARINE HEALTH, SAFETY, QUALITY, AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT AUGUST 2009 (Updated November 2010 ee next page) American Bureau
More informationThe Use of Swimmer Bars as Shear Reinforcement in Reinforced Concrete Beam
American Journal of Engineering and Applied Science, 6 (1): 87-94, 2013 ISSN: 1941-7020 2014 M. Al-Nara et al., Thi open acce article i ditributed under a Creative Common Attribution (CC-BY) 3.0 licene
More informationIncentivizing the Use of Bike Trailers for Dynamic Repositioning in Bike Sharing Systems
Incentivizing the Ue of Bike for Dynamic Repoitioning in Bike Sharing Sytem Supriyo Ghoh School of Information Sytem Singapore Management Univerity upriyog.2013@phdi.mu.edu.g Pradeep Varakantham School
More informationOnline Monitoring of Exhaust Gas Emissions of a Boiler with Diesel/Biodiesel Fuel Blends
Online Monitoring of Exhaut Ga Emiion of a Boiler with Dieel/Biodieel Fuel Blend Andrea Valdman *1, Maurício Bezerra de Souza Jr. 1, Roana Folly 1, Belki Valdman 1 1 School of Chemitry, Chemical Engineering
More informationNumerical simulation of the seismic behavior of steel storage pallet racking systems
1 Numerical imulation of the eimic behavior of teel torage pallet racking ytem Gonçalo E. Novai Ribeiro Coutinho a a Intituto Superior Técnico, Liboa, Portugal 1. Introduction 1.1. Overview Depite their
More informationModeling Liquid Phase Sintering of Hard metal powder compacts
ing Liquid Phae Sintering of Hard metal powder compact Shama Shamaundar *, Maheha Siddegowda*, Pavanachand Chigurupati**, Rengarajan Raghavan***, Rameh Rao. S. *** * ProSIM AFTC # 326, 8th Main, III Stage,
More informationEnhanced Biofilter Treatment of Urban Stormwater by Optimizing the Hydraulic Residence Time in the Media
Enhanced Biofilter Treatment of Urban Stormwater by Optimizing the Hydraulic Reidence Time in the Media Redahegn Silehi 1, Robert Pitt 2 and Shirley Clark 3 1 Graduate tudent, Dept. of Civil, Contruction,
More informationPlugging Ontario Into A Green Future
Plugging Ontario Into A Green Future A Renewable i Doable Action Plan Cherie Burda, THE PEMBINA INSTITUTE and Roger Peter NOVEMBER 2008 CANADIAN ENVIRONMENTAL LAW ASSOCIATION L ASSOCIATION CANADIENNE DU
More informationOptimal Distributed Energy Resources Sizing for Commercial Building Hybrid Microgrids
Optimal Ditributed Energy Reource Sizing for Commercial Building Hybrid Microgrid Yihen Wang, Zhehan Yi, Di Shi, Zhe Yu, Bibin Huang, Zhiwei Wang GEIRI North America, San Joe, CA, USA State Grid Energy
More informationULTRASENSITIVE MAGNETOMETERS BASED ON ROTATIONAL MAGNETIC EXCITATION. Evangelos Hristoforou 1, Peter Svec Sr. 2
ULTRASENSITIVE MAGNETOMETERS BASED ON ROTATIONAL MAGNETIC EXCITATION Evangelo Hritoforou, Peter Svec Sr. National TU of Athen, Greece, Slovak Academy of Science, Bratilava Received 7 April 04; accepted
More informationAccommodating Transit in TRANSYT
68 TRANSPORTATON RESEARCH RECORD 1181 Accommodating Tranit in TRANSYT SAM YAGAR Although the TRANSYT traffic model imulate tranit vehicle in mixed traffic operation, it doe not adequately conider the effect
More informationStudy on Mechanical Behavior of Thin-walled Member during Precision Straightening Process
2014 by IFSA Publihing, S. L. http://www.enorportal.com Study on Mechanical Behavior of Thin-walled Member during Preciion Straightening Proce Ben Guan, Yong Zang, Diping Wu, Qin Qin School of Mechanical
More informationAgrifood safety standards, market power and consumer misperceptions
Agrifood afety tandard, market power and conumer miperception Eric Giraud-Héraud, Critina Grazia, Abdelhakim Hammoudi INRA and Ecole Polytechnique France; Univerity of Bologna, Italy c.grazia@unibo.it
More informationImprovement of Inventory Control for Defective Goods Supply Chain with Imperfect Quality of Commodity Components in Uncertain State
Reearch Journal of Applied Science, Engineering and Technology 6(): 920-927, 203 SSN: 2040-7459; e-ssn: 2040-7467 Maxwell Scientific Organization, 203 Submitted: October 22, 202 Accepted: February 0, 203
More informationConsumers often purchase goods that are hard to find to conspicuously display their exclusivity and social
Publihed online ahead of print July 3, 212 MANAGEMENT SCIENCE Article in Advance, pp. 1 22 ISSN 25-199 (print ISSN 1526-551 (online http://dx.doi.org/1.1287/mnc.112.1545 212 INFORMS Selling to Conpicuou
More informationConsidering Production Limits in Greenhouse Gas Emission Trading using the Data Envelopment Analysis Approach
2012 45th Haaii International Conference on Sytem Science Conidering Production Limit in Greenhoue Ga Emiion Trading uing the Data Envelopment Analyi Approach Bo Hiao ational Taian Univerity d96725002@ntu.edu.t
More informationR&D Cost Allocation and Income Sharing for Industry-University Cooperation in Open Innovation Context
[016] Vol.5 NTUT J. of Intell. Prop. L. & Mgmt. R&D Cot Allocation and Income Sharing for Indutry-Univerity Cooperation in Open Innovation Context Bao xinzhong, Dong yuhuan & Wang yan ABSTRACT Open innovation
More informationEstablishment and evaluation of operation function model for cascade hydropower station
Water Science and Engineering, 2010, 3(4):443-453 doi:10.3882/j.in.1674-2370.2010.04.007 http://www.waterjournal.cn e-mail: we2008@vip.163.com Etablihment and evaluation o operation unction model or cacade
More informationHOW A REDUCTION OF STANDARD WORKING HOURS AFFECTS EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS. Summary
De Economit (2010) 158:193 207 The Author() 2010 DOI 10.1007/10645-010-9142-5 Thi article i publihed with open acce at Springerlink.com DE ECONOMIST 158, NO. 2, 2010 HOW A REDUCTION OF STANDARD WORKING
More informationTowards Planning and Execution for Information Retrieval
Toward Planning and Execution for Information Retrieval Laurie S. Hiyakumoto and Manuela M. Veloo Computer Science Department Carnegie Mellon Univerity Pittburgh, PA, USA 523 hyaku, mmv @c.cmu.edu Abtract
More informationThe Role of Skills Development in Competitiveness in Asia
The Role of Skill Development in Competitivene in Aia Profeor Michael J. Enright Univerity of Hong Kong Hong Kong Intitute for Economic and Buine Strategy Enright, Scott & Aociate ADB Copyright Michael
More informationJournal of Operation and Automation in Power Engineering. Vol. 5, No. 2, Dec. 2017, Pages:
Journal of Operation and Automation in ower Engineering Vol., No. 2, Dec. 27, age: 2-24 http://joape.uma.ac.ir Optimal Sizing of Energy Storage Sytem in A Renewable-Baed Microgrid Under Flexible Demand
More informationThe Regional Economics Applications Laboratory (REAL) of the University of Illinois focuses on the development and use of analytical models for urban
The Regional Economic Application Laboratory (REAL) of the Univerity of Illinoi focue on the development and ue of analytical model for urban and regional economic development. The purpoe of the Dicuion
More informationM A S O N R Y. Revised Spring Engineering Notes For Design With Concrete Block Masonry
A S O N R Y Revied Spring 007 Engineering Note For Deign With Concrete Block aonry C H R O N I C L E S To rectify the ituation, the Spring 007 article i being reiued. We apologize for any inconvenience
More informationTom-Reiel Heggedal and Karl Jacobsen
Dicuion Paper No. 536, April 2008 Statitic Norway, Reearch Department Tom-Reiel eggedal and Karl Jacoben Timing of innovation policie when carbon emiion are retricted: an applied general equilibrium analyi
More informationModeling Reveals Bistability and Low-Pass Filtering in the Network Module Determining Blood Stem Cell Fate
Modeling Reveal Bitability and Low-Pa Filtering in the Network Module Determining Blood Stem Cell Fate Jatin Narula, Aileen M. Smith 2, Berthold Gottgen 2, Oleg A. Igohin * Department of Bioengineering,
More informationA mining perspective on the potential of renewable electricity sources for operations in South Africa
http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/2411-9717/2017/v117n3a10 A mining perpective on the potential of renewable electricity ource for operation in South Africa Part I The reearch approach and internal evaluation
More informationHabitat Evaluation Procedures. Habitat Evaluation Procedures. Habitat Evaluation Procedures. Habitat Evaluation Procedures
969-976 an enlightened Congre pae conervation legilation Affecting management of fih & ldlife reource NEPA (National Environmental Policy Act ESA Foret & Rangeland Renewable Reource Planning Act Federal
More informationSIMULATION OF CONTAMINATED SEDIMENT TRANSPORT IN WHITE OAK CREEK BASIN
SMULATON OF CONTAMNATED SEDMENT TRANSPORT N WHTE OAK CREEK BASN Yixing Bao, Reearch Scientit, Roger B. Clapp, Reearch Scientit, and Antoinette L. Brenkert, Reearch Scientit, Environmental Science Diviion,
More information