TALL BUILDINGS IN KUALA LUMPUR - STEEL, CONCRETE OR BOTH?
|
|
- Megan Townsend
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 TALL BUILDINGS IN KUALA LUMPUR - STEEL, CONCRETE OR BOTH? Dr. Juneid Qureshi, Director, Meinhardt Singapore Pte. Ltd. Council on Tall Buildings Kuala Lumpur
2 AGENDA 01 The need for Productivity 02 Key Considerations in the design of Tall Buildings 03 Comparison of Material Choice for Tall Buildings Globally 04 Key Issues in Steel & Concrete Construction 05 Cost Comparison of a Concrete & Composite Tall Building 06 Concluding Remarks
3 TALL BUILDINGS
4 STRUCTURAL DESIGN CHALLENGES FOR TALL BUILDINGS Others? Construction Constraints Architectural Vision Developers Requirements Structural Needs
5 TALL BUILDINGS KEY CHALLENGES Key Design Challenges Efficient structural framing systems Drift control Dynamic behavior Differential shortening between vertical elements Foundation settlements Wind & Seismic Engineering Parametric Modeling & Optimization Source: CTBUH
6 TALL BUILDINGS MATERIAL SELECTION Steel or Concrete or Both? There is no universal answer. The choice is dictated by several considerations such as design requirements building s needs industry know-how market rates and conditions Experience is one of the best guides
7 TALLEST BUILDINGS LOCATION Courtesy CTBUH
8 TALLEST BUILDINGS FUNCTION Courtesy CTBUH
9 TALLEST BUILDINGS MATERIAL Courtesy CTBUH
10 TALLEST BUILDINGS USA One World Trade Centre, 541.3m, 2014, COMPOSITE Willis Tower, 442m, 108flrs, 1974, STEEL 432 Park Avenue, 425.5m, 85flrs, 2015, CONCRETE Trump Tower, 423.2m, 98flrs, 2009, CONCRETE Empire State Building, 381m, 102flrs, 1931, STEEL Bank of America Tower, 365.8m, 55flrs, 2009, COMPOSITE Aon Centre, 346.3m, 83flrs, 1973, STEEL John Hancock Centre, 343.7m, 100flrs, 1969, STEEL Chrysler Building, 318.9m, 77flrs, 1930, STEEL New York Times Tower, 318.8m, 52flrs, 2007, STEEL
11 TALLEST BUILDINGS CHINA Shanghai Tower, 632m, 128flrs, 2015, COMPOSITE Shanghai WFC, 492m, 101flrs, 2008, COMPOSITE International Commerce Centre, 484m, 2010, COMPOSITE Zifeng Tower, 450m, 66flrs, 2010, COMPOSITE KK100, 441.8m, 100flrs, 2011, COMPOSITE Guangzhou IFC, 438.6m, 103flrs, 2010, COMPOSITE Jin Mao Tower, 420.5m, 88flrs, 1999, COMPOSITE Hong Kong Two IFC, 412m, 88flrs, 2003, COMPOSITE CITIC Plaza, 390.2m, 80flrs, 1996, CONCRETE Shun Hing Square, 384m, 69flrs, 1996, COMPOSITE
12 TALLEST BUILDINGS EUROPE OKO Tower, Moscow, 353.6m, 2015, CONCRETE Mercury City Tower, Moscow, 338.8m, 2013, CONCRETE Stalnaya Vershina, Moscow, 308.9m, 2015, COMPOSITE The Shard, London, 306m, 73flrs, Yr2013, COMPOSITE Capital City tower, Moscow, 301.8m, 2010, CONCRETE Naberezhnaya Tower, Moscow, 268.4m, 2007, COMPOSITE Triumph Palace, Moscow, 264.1m, 2005, CONCRETE Sapphire Tower, Istanbul, 261m, 2010, CONCRETE Commerzbank Tower, Frankfurt, 259m, 1997, COMPOSITE Capital City Tower, Moscow, 257.2m,2010, CONCRETE
13 TALLEST BUILDINGS UAE Burj Khalifa, Dubai, 828m, 163flrs, 2010, STEEL / CONCRETE Princess Tower, Dubai, 413.4m, 101flrs, 2012, STEEL / CONCRETE 23 Marina, Dubai, 392.4m, 88flrs, 2012, CONCRETE Elite Residence, Dubai, 380.5m, 87flrs, 2012, CONCRETE Almas Tower, Dubai, 360m, 68flrs, 2008, CONCRETE JW Marriott Dubai, 355.4m, 82flrs, 2012/13, CONCRETE Emirates Tower 1, Dubai, 354.6m, 2000, COMPOSITE The Torch, Dubai, 352m, 86flrs, 2011, CONCRETE Rose Rayhaan, Dubai, 333m, 71flrs, 2007, COMPOSITE Al Yaqoub Tower, Dubai, 328m, 2013, CONCRETE
14 TALLEST BUILDINGS SINGAPORE UOB Bank Plaza One, 280m, 66flrs, 1992, STEEL OUB Centre, 277.8m, 63flrs, 1986, STEEL Republic Plaza, 276.3m, 66flrs, 1996 COMPOSITE Capital Tower, 255.4m, 52flrs, 2000, COMPOSITE Anson, 250m, 2014, CONCRETE Enggor St., 250m, 62flrs, 2014, CONCRETE The Marina Bay, 245m, 70flrs, 2008, CONCRETE MBFC Office Tower II, 245m, 50flrs, 2010, CONCRETE ORQ North Tower, 245m, 50flrs, 2006, COMPOSITE Ocean Financial Centre, 245m, 43flrs, 2011, CONCRETE
15 TALLEST BUILDINGS MATERIAL Reasons for this trend? Concrete is perceived to be cheaper than steel Developing countries have more concrete technological expertise than steel More tall residential and mixed-use developments favor some use of concrete Increased performance requirement can be better addressed by composite construction rather than one material alone
16 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Floor Construction, Spans & Services Integration Range of floor types beam & slab, flat slab, ribbed, banded, coffered with options for insitu, pre-cast, RC and PT. For short to moderate spans of up to 10m, possible to achieve very shallow floors with PT flat plates. PT Banded Beams can span economically up to around 16m. Generally uni-directionally spanning steel beams with concrete slabs on metal decks acting compositely. Rolled Sections are generally most economical for spans up to 15m. Fabricated sections can span economically up to 25m. Castellated, cell-form, truss-girder construction can span even longer & allows integration of building services within the structure to minimize floor to floor depths. One Raffles Link, Singapore
17 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Columns Generally much larger than steel or composite columns. Much smaller column sizes possible. CFT s allow smaller column size & reduced labour & construction time due to simplified connections and elimination of formwork SRC columns offer flexibility a) large steel section to maximize capacity, or b) nominal section for erection only
18 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Seismic Loads Concrete buildings are heavier thereby attracting higher seismic loads, Steel Lower seismic forces due to lesser mass. Steel is also more ductile which is beneficial for seismic force resistance.
19 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Lateral Load Resistance Concrete buildings generally provide better lateral stiffness & coupled with the extra damping (mass) provides better dynamic performance. Steel The lower lateral stiffness of steel construction is one of the reasons for adoption of composite tall buildings utilizing a concrete core with steel floor framing. Outriggers are added for taller buildings for enhanced stability & stiffness. NDIA, Doha
20 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Foundations Concrete buildings are heavier & therefore require larger foundations. Transfer Structures The low strength-to-area ratio and low shear strength is a significant disadvantage. Foundations can be lighter by 30% to 40% lighter. This is a significant advantage in poor soil conditions or to protect existing below ground structures. Higher strength-to-area ratio makes steel the preferred choice for transfer structures. One Raffles Quay, Singapore
21 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Deflections Variable material properties & time dependent creep & shrinkage effects make precise deflection predictions difficult. Vibrations The mass of concrete construction generally mitigates vibration concerns except for very long spans. No time dependent change in properties making long term movement control simpler. Lighter steel framed construction Dynamic needs to be designed specifically property to limit vibration. Dynamic property Signature Towers, Dubai Floor response Floor response
22 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Fire Protection Provides inherent fire resistance. With enhanced detailing, resistance in excess of four hours can be achieved. Standardization Buildable design & detailing helps but is less critical than steel construction. Bare steel has low fire resistance. Conventional protection provided by intumescent paint, spray coatings or wrappings. CFT s allow moderate fire resistance without protection. Standardisation is key for economy and speed. Particularly in selection of element types and connections.
23 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Adaptability The continuous nature of concrete makes it more challenging to modify or strengthen. Propping during Construction In-situ concrete requires propping constraining fast erection. Precast concrete can eliminate this constraint. Discrete nature facilitates removal, additions or strengthening. No propping required with secondary beams spaced to suit metal deck spanning capability. NDIA, Doha
24 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Construction Accuracy Less accurate because of onsite activities. Sustainability The difference of embodied CO2 of concrete & steel buildings is insignificant compared to a building s operational CO2 emissions. Late Changes More amenable to late changes. More accurate due to off-site controlled manufacturing. Steel has the added benefit of having potential to be reused and recycled repeatedly, Changes are disruptive.
25 STEEL OR CONCRETE KEY ISSUES Concrete Steel Speed Requires less lead-in time (superficial attraction) Is labour-intensive. Cost Requires greater lead-in time & fabrication speed is important. Higher potential for faster construction due to prefabrication. One Raffles Quay, Singapore
26 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Building Description GFA: 85,000 m 2 Height: 130m No. of Floors: 30 Typ. Floor Height: 4.3m Typ. Floor Area: 2800 m 2 Clear Span: up to 15.5m Lateral System: Dual System - RC Core + Frames RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
27 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY 13.5m 12.5m 15.5m Framing 9m Systems Considered Floor Framing Graphics 13.5m 12.5m 15.5m RC Building Typical Parameters Composite Building - Typical Parameters Long Span PT Band Beam: 2400x 600 Deep Long Span Steel Beams: UB610 x 229 x 92 Short Span PT Band Beam: 2400x 550 Deep Short Span Steel Beams: UB610 x 229 x 113 Edge Beam: 500x600 Deep Edge Steel Beams: UB533 x 210 x 66 PT Slab Thickness: 200 Typical Slab: 130 on Re-Entrant Deck Primary Core Wall Thickness: 350 Primary Core Wall Thickness: 300 Secondary Core Wall Thickness: 250 Secondary Core Wall Thickness: 250 Columns : 1.0m x 1.0m Columns : 0.8m dia. CHS 9m
28 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Design Criteria Gravity Loading: Dead Load (DL) Superimposed Dead Load (SDL) Live Load (LL) Cladding (SDL) Lateral Loading: Wind Speed Wind Load Pressure Seismic : Self-weight of elements : 1.5 kpa : 3.5 kpa + 1 kpa for Partitions : 1.0 kpa (on elevation) : 22m/s Mean Hourly, 50-year Return Period : Max Pressure ~ 1.3 kpa : SS-EN , BC3, q=1.5, Ground Type D Deflections & Drift Parameters: Interior Beams, Live Load : L / 250, 20 mm maximum Interior Beams, Incremental Deflection : L / 350 Perimeter Beams, Live Load : L /500, 10 mm maximum Wind Inter-story Drift : H / 500 Floor Vibrations and Acceleration: : Acceleration 0.5%g
29 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Building Dynamic Characteristics T 1 = 3.5 s RC Building T 2 = 3.1 s T 1 = 3.2 s Composite Building T 2 = 2.9 s
30 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Storey Building Performance Comparison S d (T) = S e (T). γ l q [ γ l = 1.0, q=1.5] Wind RC/Composite Seismic Composite Seismic RC RC Building: V eq1 = 3.41%*W = 35.9 MN V eq2 = 3.95%*W = 41.6 MN Lateral Storey Forces Wind 5 RC/Composite Seismic- Composite Overturning Moment Composite Building: V eq1 = 3.81%*W = 24.9 MN V eq2 = 4.05%*W = 26.5 MN Seismic-RC Storey 35 Wind-RC Wind Composite 5 Δ = h / 500 Seismic-RC Seismic Composite Inter-storey Drift Δ = h / (200.v.q)
31 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Member Force Envelopes RC Building Composite Building
32 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Costing Data Pricing information was obtained from Langdon & Seah & verified through a combination of local sources Baseline Unit Costs ( All-in, incl. labour) Concrete Grade (f cu ) Cost (S$/m3) 40 S$ S$ S$ 165 Rebar Cost (S$/T) S$ 1,350 Post-tensioning (S$/T) S$ 6,250 Formwork (S$/m2) S$ 45 Structural Steel incl. studs (S$/T) S$ 5,000 Metal Deck (S$/m2) S$ 50 Steel Fireproofing (S$/m2) S$ 25 Foundation Costs (S$/ ton / m ) S$ 0.60
33 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Building Weight (normalized) Normalized Building Weight RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
34 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Concrete Costs (normalized; excluding rebar & PT) Normalized Concrete Costs RC Building 0.5 Steel-Concrete Composite Building
35 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Rebar & PT Costs (normalized) Normalized Rebar & PT Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
36 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Structural Steel Costs (normalized; including decking & FP) Normalized Steel Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
37 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Foundation Costs (normalized) Foundation Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
38 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Total Structural Material Costs (normalized) Normalized Structural Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
39 COMPARATIVE COST STUDY THE BIG PICTURE
40 COMPARATIVE COST STUDY THE BIG PICTURE
41 TYPICAL TALL BUILDING COMPARATIVE COST STUDY Total Project Construction Costs (normalized) Normalized Structural Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
42 COMPARATIVE COST STUDY THE BIG PICTURE Other Costs & Revenues Project Costs GFA = 85,000 sq-m Land Cost = $19,000 per sq-m of GFA Legal Fee & Stamp Duty = 4% of land cost Total Project Duration= 33 months Property Tax = 0.5% x land cost x duration Associated Costs (Prof. & Site Supervision Fee) = ~ 8% of Total Construction Cost Marketing & Advertisement = ~ 5% of Total Construction Cost GST = 7% of Construction & Assoc. Costs Interest of Financing Cost for Land = 5% of Land Cost, Legal Fee & Property Tax Interest of Financing During Construction = 5% of Construction & Associated Costs x 0.5 Rental Return + Preliminaries Net Efficiency= 80% Occupancy Rate= 80% Rental Rate $$/sq-ft/month= $10 per sq-ft per month (net floor area) Preliminaries / month = 10% of Total Construction Cost
43 COMPARATIVE COST STUDY THE BIG PICTURE Total Development Construction Costs (normalized) Normalized Structural Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
44 COMPARATIVE COST STUDY THE BIG PICTURE
45 COMPARATIVE COST STUDY THE BIG PICTURE Total Project Construction Costs with One Month Lesser Construction Time for Composite Building (normalized) Normalized Structural Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
46 COMPARATIVE COST STUDY THE BIG PICTURE Total Project Construction Costs with Two Month Lesser Construction Time for Composite Building (normalized) Normalized Structural Costs RC Building Steel-Concrete Composite Building
47 CONCLUDING REMARKS FUTURE TRENDS As Singapore develops, labour costs will continue to rise. Productivity will continue to be the key driver Project cost is dictated by completion period not material cost. The perception that steel means higher cost must be seen in perspective In addition to performance benefits, composite buildings offer far higher potential for greater productivity & hence lower costs What do you think will be the material of choice for these future buildings?
Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems
Andrew Covely Structural Dr. Linda Hanagan The Helena New York City, NY October 27, 2004 Pictures courtesy of Fox & Fowle Architects Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems Executive Summary
More informationTHE FORENSIC MEDICAL CENTER
THE FORENSIC MEDICAL CENTER Image courtesy of Gaudreau, Inc. TECHNICAL REPORT #2 OCTOBER 26, 2007 KEENAN YOHE STRUCTURAL OPTION DR. MEMARI FACULTY ADVISOR EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Image courtesy of Gaudreau,
More informationErie on the Park. Timothy Moore Penn State University Architectural Engineering Structural Emphasis Advisor: Prof. Ali Memari
Timothy Moore Penn State University Architectural Engineering Structural Emphasis Advisor: Prof. Ali Memari Thesis Presentation - Spring 2006 Contents Introduction Building Professionals Existing Structure
More informationPro-Con Structural Study for Alternative Floor Systems October 27, 2004
Ismail Al-Hadhrami Structural Option Faculty Consultant: Dr. Thomas Boothby Agricultural Hall and Annex East Lansing, MI Pro-Con Structural Study for Alternative Floor Systems October 27, 2004 Executive
More informationSimplified Building Schematic for Typical Floor (Levels 9 through 22):
Introduction to Structural System Simplified Building Schematic for Typical Floor (Levels 9 through 22): Key: - Tower Columns - Tower Shear Walls - Parking Garage Columns - Parking Garage Shear Walls Solid
More informationTechnical Report 3. Alyssa Stangl Structural Option Advisor Dr. Linda Hanagan L A J O L L A C O M M O N S P H A S E I I O F F I C E T O W E R
Technical Report 3 Alyssa Stangl Structural Option Advisor Dr. Linda Hanagan L A J O L L A C O M M O N S P H A S E I I O F F I C E T O W E R Site and Location La Jolla Commons, San Diego, California General
More informationCouncil on Tall Buildings. and Urban Habitat
3D View- Courtesy of Gensler Tallest building when built West of Jinji Lake in Suzhou CBD 137- story, 729m tall Total site area : ~ 16,573 m 2 Total GA: 498,795 m 2 o Above Ground: 375,453 m 2 o Basement
More informationDesign of Slender Tall Buildings for Wind & Earthquake
SMCES Civil Engineering Seminar YTU, Yangon 27 September 2015 Design of Slender Tall Buildings for Wind & Earthquake Presented by Dr. Juneid Qureshi Director (Group Design Division) Meinhardt Singapore
More informationSTEEL STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS
STEEL STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS Steel elements are of two basic types: Structural steel shapes are formed into their final shapes by hot-rolling. This method produces such common elements as wide flange sections,
More informationWANCHAI,HONG KONG. Submitted By Nidhi Setya Prachi Patwardhan Priyanka Dherange
WANCHAI,HONG KONG Submitted By Nidhi Setya Prachi Patwardhan Priyanka Dherange CENTRAL PLAZA 1) 78-storey: 374m tower 2) World's fourth tallest building at the time of construction 3) Tallest reinforced-concrete
More informationHIGH RISE CONDO SOHO, NEW YORK, NY
HIGH RISE CONDO SOHO, NEW YORK, NY TECHNICAL ASSIGNMENT 1 October 5, 2006 Joseph The Pennsylvania State University Structural Option Faculty Advisor: Andres Lepage TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS 2
More informationA Challenging Journey for the Third CTF Finance Centre. Derry Yu De Ming, Project Director, New World China Land
A Challenging Journey for the Third CTF Finance Centre Derry Yu De Ming, Project Director, New World China Land Derry YU De Ming Project Director PhD CEng IntPE New World China Land Co Ltd, Hong Kong,
More informationJohn Jay College Expansion Project
Technical Report #3 Michael Hopper Mike AE Consultant: Dr. Lepage [Type the company name] November 21 st, 2008 Technical Report #3 Table of Contents Executive Summary.3 Introduction.4 Existing Composite
More informationThe Structural Redesign of Boyds Bear Country and its Related Systems. Boyds Bear Country, Pigeon Forge, Tennessee
The Structural Redesign of Boyds Bear Country and its Related Systems Included in this Presentation: Background and Existing System Proposal Problem / Solution Structural System Redesigns Pre-cast Concrete
More informationRETHINKING MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL
RETHINKING MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL Presented by: Neil Wexler, PhD PE Ali Maher, PE ABOUT US- WEXLER ASSOCIATES Founded 35 years ago NYC Structural Engineers Forensic Work Active in various markets BIM
More informationStructural Technical Report #2 Pro/Con Study of Alternate Floor Systems
Christopher McCune Structural Option Eight Tower Bridge Faculty Advisor: Dr. Hanagan October 31 st, 2005 Structural Technical Report #2 Pro/Con Study of Alternate Floor Systems Executive Summary This technical
More informationJonathan R. Torch Technical Report 2 Columbia University. Technical Report 2. Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems
Technical Report 2 Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems Columbia University Broadway & 120 th Street, New York, NY Jonathan R. Torch Pennsylvania State University Architectural Engineering
More informationMulti-storey buildings
Doc. Ing. Hana Gattermayerova,CSc gatter@fsv.cvut.cz Contents Multi strorey buildings Sources, literature Definition Features Statical systems Interior Extrior Materials Hájek P. a kol.: Konstrukce pozemních
More informationmidas Gen Advanced Webinar Column Shortening for High-rise Building
midas Gen midas Gen Advanced Webinar for High-rise Building for High-rise Building Introduction in Project Applications Procedure for Construction Stage Analysis Useful features for Construction Stage
More informationTechnical Report #1. Indiana Regional Medical Center Indiana, PA. Cody A. Scheller. Structural Concepts & Existing Conditions Report
Technical Report #1 Technical Report #1 Structural Concepts & Existing Conditions Report Indiana Regional Medical Center Cody A. Scheller The Pennsylvania State University Architectural Engineering Faculty
More informationMahaNakhon Tower History of a Design & Build. Dr. Kanokpat Chanvaivit, Senior Design Manger, Bouygues-Thai Ltd.
MahaNakhon Tower History of a Design & Build Dr. Kanokpat Chanvaivit, Senior Design Manger, Bouygues-Thai Ltd. MahaNakhon Tower History of a Design & Build Ī Source image courtesy of Bouygues-Thai TOPICS
More informationDanielle Shetler - Structural option Courtyard by Marriott Lancaster, PA
Structural Analysis Overview: During the structural analysis of the in Lancaster, Pa, a redesign of the lateral and gravity system from masonry bearing and shear walls to a staggered truss system was performed.
More informationTable of Contents.2. Introduction...3 Gravity Loading and Deflections..4. Existing Structural System..8
WISCONSIN PLACE RESIDENTIAL TECHNICAL ASSIGNMENT 2 OCTOBER 29, 2007 KURT KRASAVAGE THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY STRUCTURAL OPTION FACULTY ADVISOR: DR. ALI MEMARI 1 Table of Contents Table of Contents.2
More informationTHE PARKING STRUCTURE PROTOTYPE II
THE PARKING STRUCTURE PROTOTYPE II 866.ask.aisc solutions@aisc.org THE PARKING STRUCTURE PROTOTYPE II Prepared by: AISC Steel Solutions Center What's this? This package contains a fictitious project with
More informationCouncil on Tall Buildings. and Urban Habitat CAYAN TOWER CTBUH BEST TALL BUILDING MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA
CAYAN TOWER CTBUH BEST TALL BUILDING MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA CTBUH AWARDS 2014 13 TH ANNUAL AWARDS NOVEMBER 6, 2014 SKIDMORE, OWINGS & MERRILL LLP CAYAN GROUP REAL ESTATE & INVESTMENT GEORGE J. EFSTATHIOU
More informationStructural Tech Report #2 Pro Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems
Structural Tech Report #2 Pro Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems Table of Contents 1. Executive Summary.....Page 2 2. Existing Floor System....Page 4 2.1. Composite steel beams with composite
More informationSimplified Building Schematic for Typical Floor (Levels 9 through 22):
Introduction to Structural System Simplified Building Schematic for Typical Floor (Levels 9 through 22): Key: - Tower Columns - Tower Shear Walls - Parking Garage Columns - Parking Garage Shear Walls Solid
More informationLa Jolla Commons Phase II Office Tower
La Jolla Commons Phase II Office Tower San Diego, California Photos Provided Courtesy of HINES Alyssa Stangl Structural Option Faculty Advisor Dr. Hanagan Preliminary Vibrations and Layout Building Introduction
More informationTechnical Report #2 10/26/06
Photo courtesy of OTO Development, http://www.otodevelopment.com/ Dr. Memari Thesis Advisor Technical Report #2 10/26/06 Executive Summary Systems Overview Hollow Core Plank (precast) Solid Flat Slab (precast)
More informationStructural Performance Assessment and Control of Super Tall Buildings During Construction
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com Procedia Engineering 14 (211) 253 251 The Twelfth East Asia-Pacific Conference on Structural Engineering and Construction Structural Performance Assessment and
More informationStructural Design and Optimization of Long-Span Ultra-Slim Composite Floor for Super Tall Residence
Structural Design and Optimization of Long-Span Ultra-Slim Composite Floor for Super Tall Residence *Rong He 1), Guo Ding 2), Yue Yang 3) and Liwei Ye 4) 1), 2), 3) Tongji Architectural Design (Group)
More informationMOUNTAIN STATE BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD HEADQUARTERS
MOUNTAIN STATE BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD HEADQUARTERS PARKERSBURG, WEST VIRGINIA DOMINIC MANNO STRUCTURAL OPTION FACULTY CONSULTANT: DR. ANDRES LEPAGE Technical Report 3 11-21-08 TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF
More informationTECHNICAL REPORT II STRUCTURAL STUDY OF ALTERNATE FLOOR SYSTEMS
TECHNICAL REPORT II STRUCTURAL STUDY OF ALTERNATE FLOOR SYSTEMS Chris Vanaskie Structural Peninsula Regional Medical Center Salisbury, MD December 22, 2008 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary... 3 Introduction...
More informationARCHITECTURAL ENGINEERING THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERISITY THESIS PROJECT
ARCHITECTURAL ENGINEERING THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERISITY THESIS PROJECT PASEO CARIBE CONDOMINIUM TOWER & PARKING Coupled Shear Wall Systems in High Seismic Zones PASEO CARIBE CONDOMINIUM TOWER & PARKING
More information151 First Side. Technical Assignment 2 November 16 th, William J. Buchko. AE 481w Senior Thesis The Pennsylvania State University
November 16 th, 2007 William J. Buchko AE 481w Senior Thesis The Pennsylvania State University Thesis Advisor: Kevin Parfitt Table of Contents Executive Summary... 3 Structural System Overview Foundation...
More informationChristopher McCune Structural Option 2006 Senior Thesis Penn State Architectural Engineering. Eight Tower Bridge Conshohocken, Pennsylvania
Christopher McCune Structural Option 2006 Senior Thesis Penn State Architectural Engineering Outline Project Original Proposal Structural Design Proposal Design Objectives Design Criteria Presentation
More informationStructural Engineering, Mechanics, and Materials. Preliminary Exam - Structural Design
Fall Semester 2018 Preliminary Exam - Structural Design A small building is located in downtown Berkeley. The structural system, either structural steel or reinforced concrete, comprises gravity framing
More informationPricewaterhouseCoopers Building Oslo, Norway
PricewaterhouseCoopers Building Oslo, Norway James Wilson Structural Option Senior Thesis Presentation 2009 The Pennsylvania State University Location Bjørvika B10 A Oslo, Norway BARCODE Building Data
More informationCrossroads at Westfields Building II
Crossroads at Westfields Building II Chantilly, Va STEPHEN LUMPP Structural option Faculty Consultant: Dr. Andres Lepage Technical Report 2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report is a study of alternate floor systems
More informationIntroduction. Structures may be classified on the basis of materials used for construction, as follows: Steel structures. Aluminium structures
Steel Structures 1 Introduction Structures may be classified on the basis of materials used for construction, as follows: Steel structures Aluminium structures Concrete structures Composite structures
More informationOffice Building-G. Thesis Proposal. Carl Hubben. Structural Option. Advisor: Dr. Ali Memari
Office Building-G Thesis Proposal Structural Option December 10, 2010 Table of Contents Executive Summary... 3 Introduction... 4 Gravity System...4 Lateral System:...6 Foundation System:...6 Problem Statement...
More informationPEER Tall Building Seismic Design Guidelines
PEER Tall Building Seismic Design Guidelines Preliminary Design Recommendations & Performance Studies John Hooper Principal & Director of Earthquake Engineering Magnusson Klemencic Associates SEAW November
More informationLa Jolla Commons Phase II Office Tower
La Jolla Commons Phase II Office Tower San Diego, California Alyssa Stangl Structural Option Faculty Advisor Dr. Hanagan Preliminary Vibrations and Layout Building Introduction Location San Diego, California
More informationChallenges and Opportunities for the Structural Design of the Jamsil Lotte World Tower
Challenges and Opportunities for the Structural Design of the Jamsil Lotte World Tower Jong-Ho Kim, P.E., CEO & Chairman, LOTTE WORLD TOWER Height 555 m (1,821 ft) Floor Count 123 above ground 6 below
More informationCaitlin Ferrell Structural Option Dr. Boothby, AE Faculty Consultant. Erie Convention Center and Sheraton Hotel
Caitlin Ferrell Structural Option Dr. Boothby, AE Faculty Consultant Erie Convention Center and Sheraton Hotel Erie, Pennsylvania Technical Report #2: Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems
More informationStructural Comparison between Pan Joist Concrete and Steel Frame Systems for UMCP Student Housing Building B
Structural Comparison between Pan Joist Concrete and Steel Frame Systems for UMCP Student Housing Executive Summary The proposed thesis will include an investigation of two different alternative structural
More informationComparative Study of R.C.C and Steel Concrete Composite Structures
RESEARCH ARTICLE OPEN ACCESS Comparative Study of R.C.C and Steel Concrete Composite Structures Shweta A. Wagh*, Dr. U. P. Waghe** *(Post Graduate Student in Structural Engineering, Y.C.C.E, Nagpur 441
More informationComparative Study on Post - Tensioned and Reinforced Concrete flat Slab Systems for a Multistory Building
Comparative Study on Post - Tensioned and Reinforced Concrete flat Slab Systems for a Multistory Building Thayapraba M Civil Department, NIT Trichy, (India) ABSTRACT Designers have a huge number of choices
More informationTable of Contents 2. Structural Systems.4 Foundations.4 Floor System...4 Columns..5 Lateral System...5
WISCONSIN PLACE RESIDENTIAL TECHNICAL ASSIGNMENT 1 OCTOBER 5, 2007 KURT KRASAVAGE THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY STRUCTURAL OPTION FACULTY ADVISOR: DR. ALI MEMARI Table of Contents Table of Contents
More informationPAUL PARFITT. BAE/MAE Structural Option Senior Thesis Tower 333 May 4 th 2007
PAUL PARFITT BAE/MAE Structural Option Senior Thesis Tower 333 May 4 th 2007 Tower 333 Introduction Proposal Lateral System Redesign Elimination of Moment Frames Core-Only Solution Cost Analysis & Schedule
More informationDavid A. Walenga Technical Assignment #2
Executive Summary This report explores multiple structural design alternatives for the Residence Inn by Marriott. The existing system, precast concrete plank on steel, is the basis for comparison with
More informationPOST-TENSIONING APPLICATION AND TECHNOLOGY. Moe Kyaw Aung
POST-TENSIONING APPLICATION AND TECHNOLOGY Moe Kyaw Aung Overview 1. Background 2. Basic Design Concept 3. Application and Benefits 4. Components of Post-tensioning System 5. Installation Process 6. Construction
More informationComparative Study on Analysis and Cost of R.C.C. and Steel-Composite Structure
Comparative Study on Analysis and Cost of R.C.C. and Steel-Composite Structure Renavikar Aniket V. 1, Suryawanshi Yogesh 2 1 Dept. of Civil Engineering ICOER Wagholi Pune 2 Professor, Department of Civil
More informationCouncil on Tall Buildings. and Urban Habitat BACKGROUND SECTION STEEL REINFORCED CONCRETE SHEAR WALL STEEL PLATE COMPOSITE SHEAR WALL
BACKGROUND CATALOG SECTION STEEL REINFORCED CONCRETE SHEAR WALL STEEL PLATE COMPOSITE SHEAR WALL STEEL PLATE SHEAR WALL CONCLUSION BACKGROUND With the rapid development of our economy and advancement of
More informationAISC Steel & Timber Research for High-Rise Residential Buildings
AISC Steel & Timber Research for High-Rise Residential Buildings Final Report December 4 th, 2017 SOM Designed Benchmark Concrete Building Skidmore, Owings, and Merrill, LLP 2017 224s Michigan Avenue Suite
More informationThese systems are evaluated on the basis of serviceability issues such as:
1 Traci Peterson Option: Structural Faculty Consultant: Memari The Del Monte Center at The North Shore Pittsburgh, PA Structural Technical Report 2 Pro Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems Date
More informationThesis Proposal 12/13/06
Photo courtesy of OTO Development, http://www.otodevelopment.com/ Dr. Memari Thesis Advisor Thesis Proposal 12/13/06 Executive Summary Structural System The in, is an eleven story hotel complex which reaches
More informationJanuary 14, 2006 Structural Thesis Proposal: Structural and Breadth Redesign Options
River Tower at Christina Landing Wilmington, DE Joseph Bednarz Structural Option Faculty Advisor: Dr. Boothby Executive Summary January 14, 2006 Structural Thesis Proposal: Structural and Breadth Redesign
More informationLateral System Analysis and Confirmation Design
Andrew Covely Structural Dr. Linda Hanagan The Helena New York City, NY November 15, 2004 Pictures courtesy of Fox & Fowle Architects Lateral System Analysis and Confirmation Design Executive Summary This
More informationAlexis Pacella Structural Option Dr. Schneider Lexington II, Washington D.C. Technical Report #2 October 31,
1 Executive Summary: Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems is an investigation into possible alternative structural systems for Lexington II in Washington, D.C. For this report, several structural
More informationDesign of Tall RC Buildings: Core Supported Structures and Outrigger Braced Systems
Design of Tall RC Buildings: Core Supported Structures and Outrigger Braced Systems Example Writing Project from: CE 764 Advanced Design of Reinforced Concrete Structures Fall Semester of 2014 Introduction
More informationHouse of Sweden. Structural Study of Alternative Floor Systems K St. NW Washington, DC 20007
Structural Study of Alternative Floor Systems 2900 K St. NW 20007 The Pennsylvania State University Department of Architectural Engineering Senior Thesis 2008-2009 October 24, 20008 Prepared by: Prepared
More informationBOAST. West Coast. Set to open this spring, the tallest building on the West Coast resists wind and seismic drifts with massive braces.
Set to open this spring, the tallest building on the West Coast resists wind and seismic drifts with massive braces. AC Martin West Coast BOAST BY GERARD M. NIEBLAS, SE AC Martin Wilshire Grand is expected
More informationCTBUH Height Criteria
for Measuring & Defining Tall Buildings The Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat (CTBUH) developed the international standards for measuring and defining tall buildings, as outlined below, and is
More informationtwo structural systems, planning and design Structural Organization Bearing Walls Structural Components
ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES: FORM, BEHAVIOR, AND DESIGN DR. ANNE NICHOLS FALL 2013 lecture two structural systems, planning and design AISC teaching aids: Courtesy of John Hooper, MKA Seattle Structural Organization
More informationtwo structural systems, planning and design Structural Organization Structural Components Bearing Walls
ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES: FORM, BEHAVIOR, AND DESIGN DR. ANNE NICHOLS FALL 2017 lecture two structural systems, planning and design AISC teaching aids: Courtesy of John Hooper, MKA Seattle Structural Organization
More informationStructural Redesign Gravity System
Redesign Gravity System Design Considerations A composite floor system was used for this design to maximize the efficiency of the material being used. This type of system requires less material and provides
More informationSite Analysis. Site Conditions: Seismic Challenges Strong Winds Average Temperature 69. San Francisco
A Site Analysis Site Conditions: Seismic Challenges Strong Winds Average Temperature 69 San Francisco A Site Analysis A Engineering School of San Francisco Requirements 2015 Innovative Design Gold LEED
More informationXyston Inn. NY. Proposal. Xiaodong Jiang. Structure Option. Advisor: Dr. Linda Hanagan
Proposal Xiaodong Jiang Structure Option Advisor: Dr. Linda Hanagan December 12, 2014 Executive Summary Xyston Inn is a 17-story hotel building that will be located in Brooklyn, New York. The design of
More informationCampus Square Buildings C & D Lehigh University, Bethlehem, PA
Depth Study: Structural Redesign As noted previously, Building C is the focus of the spring semester redesign, though the proposed alternatives could be applied to the other buildings in the complex, including
More informationmidas Gen Advanced Webinar on Construction Stage Analysis with Special Emphasis on Column Shortening
midas Gen Advanced Webinar on Construction Stage Analysis with Special Emphasis on Column Shortening Webinar Objective Construction Stage Analysis Column Shortening Procedure for Construction Stage Analysis
More information3.4.2 DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
3.4.2 DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS Formwork Where Flatdeck sheet is used as formwork, the profile provides resistance to wet concrete (G) and construction loads (Q). Maximum formwork spans given in Section 3.4.4.1
More informationPresentation Overview
Presentation Overview Structural System Overview Dr. J. Bracci Spring 2008 Semester 1. Building system primary functions 2. Types of load 3. RC structural systems 4. RC structural members 2 1. Basic Building
More informationSabah Shawkat Cabinet of Structural Engineering 2017
3.1-1 Continuous beams Every building, whether it is large or small, must have a structural system capable of carrying all kinds of loads - vertical, horizontal, temperature, etc. In principle, the entire
More informationXyston Inn. NY. Proposal. Xiaodong Jiang. Structure Option. Advisor: Dr. Linda Hanagan
Proposal Xiaodong Jiang Structure Option Advisor: Dr. Linda Hanagan December 12, 2014 Executive Summary Xyston Inn is a 17-story hotel building that will be located in Brooklyn, New York. The design of
More informationTECHNICAL REPORT 1. Structural Concepts / Structural Existing Conditions. Penn State Hershey Medical Center Children s Hospital. Hershey, Pennsylvania
TECHNICAL REPORT 1 Structural Concepts / Structural Existing Conditions Penn State Hershey Medical Center Children s Hospital Matthew V Vandersall The Pennsylvania State University Architectural Engineering
More informationJohn Jay College Expansion Project
Technical Report #1 Michael Hopper Mike AE Consultant: Dr. Lepage [Type the company name] September 29 th, 2008 Technical Report #1 Table of Contents Executive Summary.3 Introduction.4 Structural System.6
More informationPAT Construction Technology of High rise Building. Lateral System: Steel Building
PAT 409 - Construction Technology of High rise Building Lateral System: Steel Building Topic Learning Outcome UNDERSTAND the lateral systems for steel buildings. IDENTIFY the structural form/system including
More informationTrump Taj Mahal Hotel
Trump Taj Mahal Hotel Atlantic City, New Jersey Thesis Proposal Prepared By: Stephen Reichwein, Structural Option Faculty Advisor: Dr. Andres Lepage The Pennsylvania State University Department of Architectural
More informationSpring Hill Suites Marriott
Spring Hill Suites Marriott Project Location: Amarillo, TX Prepared for: Girder Slab Technologies Contact: Daniel Fisher, Sr. January 15, 2008 Prepared by: Monica Stockmann Regional Engineer: Erika Winters-Downey
More informationTechnical Report #1. Matthew R Peyton
Technical Report #1 This Document is Technical Report #1 for 5th year senior thesis in the Architectural Engineering Departments at The Pennsylvania State University. This Report will include structural
More informationTALL BUILDINGS. The 2010 CTBUH Reference Guide of the what, when and where of tall and urban
TALL BUILDINGS The 2010 CTBUH Reference Guide of the what, when and where of tall and urban TALL BUILDINGS The 2010 CTBUH Reference Guide of the what, when and where of tall and urban www.ctbuh.org Editor
More informationFairfield Inn and Suites Pittsburgh, PA
Existing Building Information Presentation Outline Construction Management Breadth Study Existing Building Information Location: Downtown Pittsburgh 228 Federal St, Building Statistics: Occupancy - Hotel
More informationDYNAMICPERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF OUTRIGGER AND OUTRIGGER WITH BELT TRUSS SYSTEM IN COMPOSITE HIGH RISE BUILDING
DYNAMICPERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF OUTRIGGER AND OUTRIGGER WITH BELT TRUSS SYSTEM IN COMPOSITE HIGH RISE BUILDING Nandeesh M 1, Suma Devi 2 1Asstprofessor,Dept of civil Engineering, BITS, Warangal, Telangana,
More informationMarina Bay Sands Hotel Arch 631 Kayla Brittany Maria Michelle
Marina Bay Sands Hotel Arch 631 Kayla Brittany Maria Michelle Overall Information Location: Singapore Date of Completion: 2010 Cost: $5.7 billion Architect: Moshe Safdie Executive Architect: Aedas, Pte
More informationThesis Proposal. Matthew R Peyton
This Document is for 5th year senior thesis in the Architectural Engineering Departments at The Pennsylvania State University. S t r u c t u r a l O p t i o n P r o f e s s o r B e h r H o s p i t a l
More informationKeywords: Discrete Staggered Shear Wall, High-Rise Building, Response Spectrum Analysis, Storey Drift.
www.semargroup.org, www.ijsetr.com ISSN 2319-8885 Vol.03,Issue.09 May-2014, Pages:1830-1835 Seismic Response of High-Rise Structure with Staggered Shear Wall AUNG MON 1, TIN TIN HTWE 2 1 Dept of Civil
More informationTechnical Report 2: Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems
Gateway Plaza Wilmington, DE October 31, 2005 Elizabeth Hostutler Structural Option Advisor: Linda Hanagan Technical Report 2: Pro-Con Structural Study of Alternate Floor Systems EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The
More informationTemecula Medical Center Temecula, CA
Temecula Medical Center Temecula, CA Technical Assignment #2 Sean F. Beville The Pennsylvania State University Architectural Engineering Structural Option Senior Thesis Project Student Advisor: Thomas
More informationone structural behavior, systems, and design ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES: FORM, BEHAVIOR, AND DESIGN DR. ANNE NICHOLS SUMMER 2015 lecture
ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES: FORM, BEHAVIOR, AND DESIGN DR. ANNE NICHOLS SUMMER 2015 lecture one structural behavior, systems, and design Introduction 1 www.greatbuildings.com Syllabus & Student Understandings
More informationBrent Ellmann Structural Option 200 Minuteman Park, Andover, MA Structural Consultant: Dr. Hanagan
Executive Summary: 200 Minuteman Park currently stands as a three story commercial building. The original design was limited to three stories by an industrial zoning law in Andover, Massachusetts. If this
More informationEric Alwine Structural Option George Read Hall The University of Delaware Dr. Boothby Technical Assignment #2 October 31, 2005 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: THIS REPORT IS A COMPARISON OF ALTERNATE FLOOR SYSTEMS FOR GEORGE READ HALL. FOUR DIFFERENT SYSTEMS WERE DESIGNED AND COMPARED TO THE EXISTING HAMBRO FLOOR SYSTEM. THE FOUR SYSTEMS WERE
More informationone structural behavior, systems and design Course Description Course Description Syllabus & Student Understandings statics mechanics of materials
ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES: FORM, BEHAVIOR, AND DESIGN DR. ANNE NICHOLS SUMMER 2014 lecture one Syllabus & Student Understandings structural behavior, systems and design Introduction 1 Architectural Structures
More informationDIAGRID STRUCTURAL SYSTEM: STRATEGIES TO REDUCE LATERAL FORCES ON HIGH-RISE BUILDINGS
DIAGRID STRUCTURAL SSTEM: STRATEGIES TO REDUCE LATERAL FORCES ON HIGH-RISE BUILDINGS Nishith B. Panchal 1, Vinubhai R. Patel 2 1 PG student, Applied Mechanics & Structural Engineering Department, Faculty
More informationUNIT IVCOMPOSITE CONSTRUCTION PART A
UNIT IVCOMPOSITE CONSTRUCTION PART A 1. What is composite section of pestressed concrete? [A/M 16] A composite section in context of prestressed concrete members refers to a section with a precast member
More informationTechnical Report #2. Matthew R Peyton
Technical Report #2 This Document is Technical Report #2 for 5th year senior thesis in the Architectural Engineering Departments at The Pennsylvania State University. This Report is to prepare a study
More informationPark Potomac Office Building E
Technical Assignment 1 Kyle Wagner (IP) AE Consultant: Professor Kevin Parfitt October 05, 2009 Table of Contents I. Executive Summary 3 II. Introduction... 4 III. Structural System Overview..... 4 Foundation
More informationU.S. Pharmacopeia Headquarters Consolidation. Rockville, MD
Consolidation Jeff Rothermel Structural Option Advisor: Dr. Ali Memari Technical Report 2 Submitted: Oct. 24 th, 2008 Table of Contents Executive Summary.1 Floor Systems Existing Two Way Slab with Drop
More informationTechnical Report 1 Bed Tower Addition at Appleton Medical Center Appleton, WI
Courtesy of HGA Technical Report 1 Bed Tower Addition at Appleton Medical Center Appleton, WI Jessel Elliott Structural 2011 Architectural Engineering Senior Thesis Studio Advisor: Dr. Richard Behr Date:
More informationCouncil on Tall Buildings
Structure Design of Sino Steel (Tianjin) International Plaza Xueyi Fu, Group Chief Engineer, China Construction Design International 1 1 Brief of Project 2 Location: Tianjin Xiangluowan Business District
More information