ESV: Why the Controversy? Everglades Case Studies
|
|
- Meredith Lambert
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 ESV: Why the Controversy? Everglades Case Studies ACES 2012 Workshop John Marshall, Angelique Giraud, James O Connell, Dr. Laila Recevskis, Dr. Leslie Richardson, et al;
2 Workshop Agenda Acronums List Synthesis = summing over details? Purpose: Paradigm Shift to save the Planet Controversy Q&A: Audience Participation Controversy Q&A in the Literature/observations Two Everglades Case Studies by Summer Interns Assessment of ESV for the Central Everglades Conclusions References Panel Discussion Q&A
3 ACRYNUM$ ACES = A Conference on Ecosystem Services ESV = Ecosystem Services Valuation CERP = Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan CEPP = Central Everglades Planning Project Geographic Misnomer AKA Northern Everglades TSP = Tentatively Selected Plan for CEPP NRC = National Research Council CISRERP = NRC CERP/CEPP Peer Review Panel ROI = Return on Investment<=>Benefit:Cost; The Bottom Line is $B:$C
4 Numbers Challenge?? Reduce Environmental Decision-Support to a one number synthesis? B:C = ROI?
5 This ACES Workshop Purpose Shift from ESV = Zero (0) to an ESV Paradigm Use CERP/CEPP as case study to follow Overcome the absurdity of controversy that leaves ecosystems services to be valued at zero by a market that is unsustainable ESV Education to Restore and Protect planetary well-being in a sustainable manner
6 Audience Participation Ecosystem Services Valuation Q&A: Audience Fills in the blanks Controversy? Results/Solution
7 Major Controversy Hard for economists to put a value on goods that are not valued by the Market Result: Tragedy of the Commons Solution: Cap & Trade example Ozone Fix! Carbon Fix?
8 Major Controversy, Continued Economist K. Smith on Costanza Synthesis Should not be used in any form as measures of natural resources to human welfare or yardsticks or roadmap for future research (no, and hell no) Alternative: None visible! Kuhn: Structure for a Scientific Resolution: To reject one paradigm without simultaneously substituting another is to reject science itself.
9 Positions impeding progress? NRC Peer Review in 2012 Biennial Report: It is also notable that the Ecosystem Services summary paints a more optimistic picture of the usefulness of this (ESV) tool than does the NRC 2010 Biennial report. In summary, there is no established formula for the most effective approach to developing ESV synthesis documents. Where is help in getting to the magic formula?
10 NRC Dichotomy? NRC CERP Peer Review 2012 Biennial Report: We are not optimistic ESV can be done for CERP/CEPP 2005 NRC ESV Study Major Point: If the Ecosystem is not given a value, the default value is ZERO (0) More Tragedy of Commons: Agriculture and Development benefits out-compete ESV benefits by treating ESV as zero $$$ value
11 NRC CISRERP Proclamation CERP lacks a systematic approach to analyze the costs and benefits across multiple projects it is not clear how benefits can be optimized. What is NRC CISRERP Calling for? A word search for benefits results in 68 hits A work search for synthesis results in 53 hits REF: Everglades Restoration Progress; NRC Fourth Biennial Review, 2012 (see page 34)
12 ESV: Why shift the paradigm? Planet is in Peril Top Level Predator is in Danger ESV needs to render ecosystems competitive V. Development and Agriculture value White House recommends Feds go in this direction: Sustaining Environmental Capital Protecting Society & the Economy. If we Save the Everglades, we get to keep the Planet (Marjory Stoneman Douglas ~ 1981)
13 Synthesis Simplified CERP (Marshall Plan): Restore sheet flow to max extent feasible from Kissimmee Basin to FL Bay, i.e., Full Decompartmenalization. CEPP: Restore sheet flow from Lake O to rest of Everglades and FL Bay via WCA-3, Everglades National Park, concurrent with meeting water quality standards/seepage mgt SYNTHESIS? What is projected increase of ESV v. costs resulting from these DECOMP actions?
14 Pre-CERP/CEPP Geography Marshall Plan Flow 1981 USACE Plan 6 Flow
15 Plan 6 provides greatest eco-benefits; but the benefits were not monitized!
16 Missing Link River of Grass Workshop ESV of restoring ROG by 2010 Summer Interns
17 17
18 Central Everglades Planning Project Study Area Storage, Treatment, and Conveyance in the EAA Caloosahatchee Estuary Gulf of Mexico LAKE OKEECHOBEE BIG CYPRESS NATIONAL PRESERVE EAA WCA 3A EVERGLADES NATIONAL PARK 3B Florida Bay WCA 1 WCA 2 St. Lucie Estuary Biscayne Bay Atlantic Ocean Decompartmentalization and Sheetflow Enhancement Seepage Management Operational Changes CERP COMPONENTS UNDER CONSIDERATION CENTRAL EVERGLADES PLANNING PROJECT 18 RESTORING THE HEART OF THE EVERGLADES CENTRAL EVERGLADES
19 CEPP: Events going on real time Five Final Alternatives going viral after Extensive Screening based on Modeling and Discussion USACE Taking the Five Alternatives to Public Meetings beginning Dec 10. Next (January?): Habitat Unit Assessment (HUA) will be used in downsizing 5 alternatives to Tenatively Selected Plan (TSP) Next #2, Date TBD: ESV of TSP For latest info, see:
20 L-30 L-33 L-28 S-8 WCA 2 WCA 1 ALTERNATIVE 1 STORAGE AND TREATMENT A-2 FEB integrated with State Remedies FEB on A-1 DISTRIBUTION/CONVEYANCE HRF: Spreader canal ~ 3 miles east & west of S-8 Backfill Miami Canal from S-8 to I-75 L-28 Triangle gap levee WCA 3A I-75 DISTRIBUTION/CONVEYANCE Increase S-333 capacity to 3000 cfs One 750 cfs gated structure in L-67 A One 6000-ft gaps in L-67C levee Tamiami Trail western 2.6 mile and eastern 1 mile bridge L-29 canal max stage at 9.7 WCA 3B SEEPAGE MANAGEMENT Increase S-356 to 1000 cfs Two 250 cfs pumps on L-31N to return seepage G-211 flood control operations, if needed Utilize coastal canals to convey seepage RESTORING THE HEART OF THE EVERGLADES FEB Pump Gated Structure Canal Operational Backfill Levee Removal 20 CENTRAL EVERGLADES
21 Everglades Case Studies Workshop Introduction (30 minutes) 2010 ESV of a Restored River of Grass (30) Angelique Giraud, UCF, 2010 ARM Summer Intern 2012 ESV of a Restored Everglades (30) James O Connell, UF, 2012 ARM Summer Intern Assessment of ESV for Central Everglades (45) Dr. Laila Racevskis,UF; Dr. Leslie Richardson, USGS Brief Q&A After Each Presentation Panel Discussion/Q&A (45)
22 A Few Good Conclusions Costanza Synthesis: sums over details Is a useable demonstration of a synthesis Use of the Costanza Synthesis provides quicker, better, cheaper approach to ESV Can be done better by detailed approach to local ecosystem; forget quicker & cheaper! In analysis of alternatives, relative ESV of alternatives is better than other approaches.
23 More Conclusions Ecosystem services value of the planetary biomes are not zero. ESV benefits tend to be large, relative to cost of restoring or replacing natural functions. Think Benefits:Costs >> 6:1 It is our job to calculate the benefits as well as the costs, to provide ROI for decision support If we calculate the benefits of CERP/CEPP we may yet get to keep the planet!
24 PRIMARY REFERENCES Costanza, et al, Report on value of the planet s 18 biomes; Google Nature 387; see Valuing Ecosystem Services Towards Better Environmental Decision-making, NRC 2005; See PCAST Report: Sustaining Environmental Capital, Protecting Society and the Economy; See sustaining_environmental_capital_report.pdf Progress Toward Restoring the Everglades Fourth Biennial Review, 2012; See
25 More References The Structure of Scientific Revolutions; T.S. Kuhn; 1970 Perspectives on Biodiversity Valuing its Role in an Everchanging World; NRC 1999 See Education of Public Example at: For additional info, Contact
26 QUESTIONS?
27 ARM SIP 2013 ADVERTISEMENT Arthur R. Marshall Summer Intern Program: Looking for a few hot-shot college students majoring in the environmental sciences, engineering or law to take up ESV approach. REQUIREMENTS: Juniors/Seniors/Grad Students GPA >> 3.0; visible verbal and written comm skills Multiple courses in earth sciences, math, physics. Career vision is in eco-sciences and related fields DETAILS: JAMinfo@aol.com
Sustaining Natural Capital: Protecting Society & the Environment
Sustaining Natural Capital: Protecting Society & the Environment June 7, 2012 John Arthur Marshall, Arthur R. Marshall Foundation GEER / INTECOL Conference Demonstration of an Approach & Methodology for
More informationCENTRAL PROJECT PLANNING. Draft PIR and EIS EVERGLADES CENTRAL EVERGLADES RESTORING THE HEART OF THE EVERGLADES. TSP Project Overview
CENTRAL EVERGLADES PLANNING PROJECT Draft PIR and EIS TSP Project Overview PRESENTED BY Kim Taplin Planning and Policy Division U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Jacksonville District September 16-19 & 25,
More informationPLANNING PROJECT (CEPP)
COMPREHENSIVE EVERGLADES RESTORATION PLAN CENTRAL PRESENTATION EVERGLADES TITLE PLANNING PROJECT (CEPP) AWRA Conference 2016 Presented by: Kim Taplin, Program Manager Jacksonville District US Army Corps
More informationEverglades Restoration Update: Water Quality, Central Everglades and Tamiami Trail Next Steps Project
National Park Service - DOI Everglades Restoration Update: Water Quality, Central Everglades and Tamiami Trail Next Steps Project For the Florida Keys Water Quality Protection Program, February 20, 2013
More informationValuing Ecosystem Services of a Restored River of Grass
Valuing Ecosystem Services of a Restored River of Grass 20th Annual SW FL Water Resources Conference The Next Generation of Water Challenges November 19, 2010 Royal Palm Yacht Club, Fort Myers, FL John
More informationREFINING FLOW RESTORATION TO WORK WITH THE LANDSCAPE
REFINING FLOW RESTORATION TO WORK WITH THE LANDSCAPE Walter Wilcox, Fahmida Khatun, Wasantha Lal, M. Clay Brown and Colin Saunders Greater Everglades Ecosystem Restoration Conference April 18-20, 2017
More informationAPPENDIX I CENTRAL EVERGLADES PLANNING PROCESS ISSUE RESOLUTION
APPENDIX I PLANNING PROCESS ISSUE RESOLUTION This page intentionally left blank Central Everglades Planning Project EAA Formulation Issue Resolution Conference July 20, 2012 MEETING PURPOSE Issue Resolution
More informationEverglades Restoration Update. Melissa Meeker, Executive Director
Everglades Restoration Update Melissa Meeker, Executive Director Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council September 21, 2012 The Challenge: Reevaluating Water Flows 3 The Solution: Three-Part Strategy
More informationEverglades Restoration. Incremental Analysis and Justification of a Comprehensive Plan
Everglades Restoration Incremental Analysis and Justification of a Comprehensive Plan Analytical and Policy Issues Lessons Learned Recommendations Eric Bush, USACE, Jacksonville District Eric.L.Bush@usace.army.mil
More informationThe South Florida Ecosystem Restoration Initiative
The Role of Science in Ecosystem Restoration and Management: The South Florida Ecosystem Restoration Initiative Frank J. Mazzotti University of Florida Fort Lauderdale Research and Education Center There
More informationThis activity will prepare participants for an interactive activity later in the meeting. This may speed up the role call or take the same amount of
1 2 3 4 This activity will prepare participants for an interactive activity later in the meeting. This may speed up the role call or take the same amount of time. In previous meetings role call required
More informationWater Management Under Severe Storm Conditions in Central and South Florida
Water Management Under Severe Storm Conditions in Central and South Florida Chandra S. S. Pathak, Ph.D., P.E. Severe Storm Prediction and Global Climate Impact in the Gulf Coast Conference October 29 to
More informationCENTRAL EVERGLADES GETTING TO THE HEART OF THE EVERGLADES. PRESENTED BY Kim Taplin, Chief Central Everglades Study Branch. Gina Paduano Ralph, Ph.D.
PRESENTED BY Kim Taplin, Chief Central Everglades Study Branch Gina Paduano Ralph, Ph.D. DECEMBER 14, 2011 PLANTATION, FLORIDA U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Jacksonville District Introduction Where we are
More informationCrisis at the Indian River Lagoon and Everglades Planning An Ongoing Crisis, An Emerging Solution August 28, 2013
1 Crisis at the Indian River Lagoon and Everglades Planning An Ongoing Crisis, An Emerging Solution August 28, 2013 Audio Options TO USE YOUR COMPUTER'S AUDIO: When the Webinar begins, you will be connected
More informationEverglades Restoration Definitions
Everglades Restoration Definitions - CERP - CEPP - C-44, C-43 - EAA - IRL South - Plan 6 - SLE - STA - Water Farming - WCA - WRDA Pre-drainage Flow Present Flow Restored Flow Source: The National Academies
More informationProject Delivery Team Meeting
LOXAHATCHEE RIVER WATERSHED RESTORATION PROJECT Project Delivery Team Meeting December 15, 2014 One of the Last Old Growth Cypress Floodplains in the SE Florida Last Large Freshwater Wetland Corridor in
More informationCITY OF SANIBEL, FLORIDA
CITY OF SANIBEL, FLORIDA 2018 WATER QUALITY PRIORITIES Introduction Ongoing water quality issues associated with freshwater discharges from Lake Okeechobee and stormwater runoff from the Caloosahatchee
More informationC-111 Spreader Canal Project: A Unique Example of Public Involvement and Adaptive Management in Everglades Restoration
C-111 Spreader Canal Project: A Unique Example of Public Involvement and Adaptive Management in Everglades Restoration INTERCOL 9 June 7, 2012 Kenneth G. Ammon, P.E. Senior Vice President Overview South
More informationOptions for Reducing Harmful Lake Okeechobee Discharges and Everglades Restoration
Options for Reducing Harmful Lake Okeechobee Discharges and Everglades Restoration The Florida Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on the Environment and Natural Resources January 11, 2017 Gary Goforth,
More informationSt. Lucie Estuary/ Southern Indian River Lagoon Water Resource Summary
St. Lucie Estuary/ Southern Indian River Lagoon Water Resource Summary Kathy LaMartina Regional Representative, Martin/St. Lucie Counties South Florida Water Management District Water Resource Modifications
More informationC-111 SPREADER CANAL Western Project and Design Test
C-111 SPREADER CANAL Western Project and Design Test Integration of Science and Engineering into Innovative Ecosystem Restoration Concepts National Conference on Ecosystem Restoration August 2011 Ray Wimbrough
More informationWESTERN EVERGLADES RESTORATION PROJECT
WESTERN EVERGLADES RESTORATION PROJECT PROJECT DELIVERY TEAM (PDT) MEETING SEPTEMBER 16, 2016 August 16, 2016 Trusted Partners Delivering Value Today for a Better Tomorrow US Army Corps of Engineers MEETING
More informationCENTRAL EVERGLADES PLANNING PROJECT ANNEX C DRAFT PROJECT OPERATING MANUAL
CENTRAL EVERGLADES PLANNING PROJECT ANNEX C DRAFT PROJECT OPERATING MANUAL Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction... 1 2.0 General Project Purposes, Goals, Objectives, and Benefits... 2 3.0 Project Features...
More information12 YEARS OF EVERGLADES RESTORATION
12 YEARS OF EVERGLADES RESTORATION Idealism, Realism, War, Elections, Recession and Reform Where are We Going Now? Presented by Barbara Cintron Planning Division, Jacksonville District U.S. Army Corps
More informationCESAJ-PM (Cong) March 2016
CESAJ-PM (Cong) March 2016 FACT SHEET SOUTH FLORIDA ECOSYSTEM RESTORATION (SFER) Overview Congressional Districts: 5, 7, 9, 10, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 1. DESCRIPTION The Central and
More informationPermitting Process Regarding Mining Impacts within the EAA
Arthur R. Marshall Foundation and Florida Environmental Institute, Inc. Public Comment on: Permitting Process Regarding Mining Impacts within the EAA The absence of a clear long-term plan for the EAA places
More informationSettlement Agreement Report
Settlement Agreement Report Fourth Quarter October December 2010 Prepared for the Technical Oversight Committee February 15, 2011 Prepared by: Cheol Mo, Violeta Ciuca, and Stuart Van Horn Restoration Sciences
More informationRiver of Grass Saving the Everglades: Management and Restoration
River of Grass Saving the Everglades: Management and Restoration K. R. Reddy and R G. Best Wetland Biogeochemistry Laboratory Soil and Water Science Department University of Florida and U. S. Geological
More informationAdventures in Ecosystem Restoration Everglades Case Study
Adventures in Ecosystem Restoration Everglades Case Study Andrew LoSchiavo U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Background Restoration Problem Nutrient Implications Timeline Solutions, Progress, and Challenges
More informationC-111 West Spreader Canal: An Everglades Restoration Success Story
C-111 West Spreader Canal: An Everglades Restoration Success Story National Ecosystem Restoration Conference: July 30, 2013 Tom Teets, Federal Policy Chief, South Florida Water Management District The
More informationAssessment of Ecosystem Services Values for the Central Everglades
Assessment of Ecosystem Services Values for the Central Everglades Leslie Richardson, Lynne Koontz, Chris Huber - USGS Fort Collins Science Center Laila Racevskis - University of Florida Kelly Keefe U.S.
More informationHydrology & Hydraulics Bureau and Interagency Modeling Center
Hydrology & Hydraulics Bureau and Interagency Modeling Center Regional Simulation Model Basins (RSMBN) Lake Okeechobee Watershed Project Future Without Project Baseline (FWOP) Table of Assumptions Climate
More informationLAKE OKEECHOBEE WATERSHED RESTORATION
COMPREHENSIVE EVERGLADES RESTORATION PLAN LAKE OKEECHOBEE WATERSHED RESTORATION INTEGRATED PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION REPORT & ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT 17-May-2017 Trusted Partners Delivering Value Today
More informationScoping Level Evaluation of Everglades Water Quality Compliance Using a Central Flow Way Hydrated With Lake Okeechobee Water
Scoping Level Evaluation of Everglades Water Quality Compliance Using a Central Flow Way Hydrated With Lake Okeechobee Water by Larry E. Fink, M.S. Waterwise Consulting, LLC 04/22/15 W WC Need Introduction
More informationSUSTAINABILITY OF LONG-TERM MONITORING FOR LARGE SCALE ECOSYSTEM RESTORATION
SUSTAINABILITY OF LONG-TERM MONITORING FOR LARGE SCALE ECOSYSTEM RESTORATION Gretchen Ehlinger, Eliza Hines, Tom St. Clair, and Dave Tipple INTECOL June 6, 2012 Long-term System-wide Monitoring Critical
More informationPrepared by The Florida Senate Committee on Environmental Preservation and Conservation
Prepared by The Florida Senate Committee on Environmental Preservation and Conservation What causes algae blooms cyanobacteria or blue-green algae is naturally occurring freshwater algae that can grow
More informationREVIEW PLAN. Central Everglades Planning Project, Florida Project Implementation Report. Jacksonville District
REVIEW PLAN Central Everglades Planning Project, Florida Project Implementation Report Jacksonville District MSC Approval Date: 9/24/12 Last Revision Date: None REVIEW PLAN Central Everglades Planning
More informationWESTERN EVERGLADES RESTORATION PROJECT
WESTERN EVERGLADES RESTORATION PROJECT PROJECT DELIVERY TEAM (PDT) MEETING May 30, 2017 August 16, 2016 Trusted Partners Delivering Value Today for a Better Tomorrow US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING
More informationClimate Sensitivity Runs (DRAFT)
Climate Sensitivity Runs (DRAFT) South Florida Water Management Model SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT February 13, 2013 Authored by: Hydrologic & Environmental Systems Modeling (HESM) Contributors:
More informationEverglades Restoration Goals
Everglades Restoration Goals Restore natural hydrologic conditions in the remaining 50% of historic Everglades Water quantity, quality, timing and distribution Maintain existing services in developed areas
More informationEverglades Restoration Climate Program
Sea Level Change and Long Range Water Resources Planning for Florida Everglades Restoration Climate Program Change Application Concerns of USACE and Guidance Draft Sea Level on Sea Rise Level Planning
More informationComprehensive Everglades Restoration Project. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers South Florida Water Management District Other Agencies and NGOs
Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Project U.S. Army Corps of Engineers South Florida Water Management District Other Agencies and NGOs Everglades Restoration Overview Past, Present, and Future South
More informationProgress Report on SFWMD Implementation of Senate Bill 10 (Section Florida Statutes)
Progress Report on SFWMD Implementation of Senate Bill 10 (Section 373.4598 Florida Statutes) INTRODUCTION Senate Bill 10, approved by the Florida Legislature and signed into law by Governor Rick Scott
More informationKim DeLaney, Ph.D. Strategic Development Coordinator. Overview & Project Approach 1/30/2014. Waterways Forum 3 - Regulation (1/29/2014) 1
Waterways Forum #3: Regulation & Management of the Waterways Kim DeLaney, Ph.D. Strategic Development Coordinator Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council January 29, 2014 120+ Miles of Waterways St. Lucie
More informationA BRIEF HISTORY OF FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT PONCE TO CERP
A BRIEF HISTORY OF FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT PONCE TO CERP 1800 2000 A little bit earlier Ponce de Leon 2 1803 - Louisiana Purchase 1821 Spanish Deeds Florida to U.S. ($5M) 1845 - Statehood 1851 Florida
More informationANNEX E REPORTS PROVIDED BY RECOVER TO SUPPORT THE CENTRAL EVERGLADES PLANNING PROJECT PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION REPORT
ANNEX E REPORTS PROVIDED BY RECOVER TO SUPPORT THE CENTRAL EVERGLADES PLANNING PROJECT PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION REPORT Annex E.i This page intentionally left blank Annex E.ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Annex E contains
More informationCERP System Status Reports The Evolution from
CERP System Status Reports The Evolution from 2006-2009 Eliza Hines 22 July 2009 Everglades Restoration Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan (CERP) 18,000 sq mile ecosystem Everglades & South Florida
More informationAPPENDIX G BENEFIT MODEL
APPENDIX G BENEFIT MODEL Appendix G-i This page intentionally left blank Appendix G-ii TABLE OF CONTENTS APPENDIX G... G-i G... G-1 G.1 Model Documentation... G-1 G.1.1 Description of the CEPP Planning
More informationLAKE OKEECHOBEE WATERSHED PROJECT
LAKE OKEECHOBEE WATERSHED PROJECT Modeling Sub-Team Storage Screening September 21, 2016 Trusted Partners Delivering Value Today for a Better Tomorrow US Army Corps of Engineers TOPICS Screening Tools
More informationLong-term Water Quality Trends and BMPs in the Everglades Agricultural Area
Long-term Water Quality Trends and BMPs in the Everglades Agricultural Area Samira Daroub 1, Tim Lang 1, Orlando Diaz 2, and Stuart VanHorn 2 July 2008 INTRODUCTION The Everglades Agricultural Area (EAA):
More informationThe area has been greatly altered by engineered flood control and water storage and distribution for agriculture and urban development.
Today s presentation to the Commission is an update on Everglades Restoration, including current and future decisions that will guide implementation of these restoration activities. These decisions will
More informationDEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY CHIEF OF ENGINEERS 2600 ARMY PENTAGON WASHINGTON, D.C
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY CHIEF OF ENGINEERS 2600 ARMY PENTAGON WASHINGTON, D.C. 20310-2600 DAEN.f 3 DEC 2014 THE SECRETARY OF THE ARMY SUBJECT: Central Everglades Planning Project, Comprehensive Everglades
More informationClimate Change Considerations for Surface Water and Groundwater Flows in the Everglades
Climate Change Considerations for Surface Water and Groundwater Flows in the Everglades Robert Johnson National Park Service/ENP Hydrology of the Everglades in the Context of Climate Change March 30, 2012
More informationThe State of Everglades Restoration
FCE-LTER All Scientist Meeting The State of Everglades Restoration Fred H. Sklar 14 March 2016 Deering Estate Restoration Update Outline 1. Reservoirs, STAs & FEBs 2. Broward WPA s 3. DPM 4. MFL & Seagrass
More informationHighlights. Environmental Report SOUTH FLORIDA. Pine Lake, Everglades National Park
S O U T H F L O R I D A 2016 W A T E R M A N A G E M E N T D I S T R I C T SOUTH FLORIDA Environmental Report Highlights Pine Lake, Everglades National Park With Everglades water cleaner than it has been
More informationStormwater Treatment Areas & Everglades Restoration. 3 rd University of Florida Water Institute Symposium
Stormwater Treatment Areas & Everglades Restoration 3 rd University of Florida Water Institute Symposium February 15, 2012 Jennifer Leeds, PMP Senior Project Manager Office of Everglades Policy and Coordination
More informationCHAPTER 1 PURPOSE OF AND NEED FOR ACTION
CHAPTER 1 PURPOSE OF AND NEED FOR ACTION This page intentionally left blank. 1.0 PURPOSE OF AND NEED FOR ACTION 1.1 INTRODUCTION The South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) has submitted an application
More informationInvestigating the Causes and Mitigation of Harm Algal Blooms, Including Red Tide, in South Flor William J. Mitsch, Ph.D.
Investigating the Causes and Mitigation of Harm Algal Blooms, Including Red Tide, in South Flor William J. Mitsch, Ph.D. Eminent Scholar, Endowed Chair, and Director, Everglades Wetland Research Park,
More informationModified Water Deliveries G-3273/S-356 Increment 2 Field Test
Modified Water Deliveries G-3273/S-356 Increment 2 Field Test Kick Off Meeting Teleconference/WebMeeting Jacksonville District, Everglades National Park South Florida Water Management District June 21,
More informationMoving Forward Suggestions for Reducing the Destructive Lake Discharges to the Estuaries
Moving Forward Suggestions for Reducing the Destructive Lake Discharges to the Estuaries Gary Goforth April 2014 Moving Forward Commend Corps and District for holding Lessons Learned workshops to identify
More informationSouth Florida Water Management District Future Directions. Melissa Meeker, Executive Director
South Florida Water Management District Future Directions Melissa Meeker, Executive Director September 15, 2011 District Overview Oldest and largest of five water management districts Covers 18,000 square
More informationCHAPTER 2 ALTERNATIVES
CHAPTER 2 ALTERNATIVES This page intentionally left blank. 2.0 ALTERNATIVES This chapter outlines the process used to determine the range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed action and presents
More informationRicardo A. Alvarez 1
Ricardo A. Alvarez 1 Ricardo A. Alvarez Florida Center for Environmental Studies Ricardo A. Alvarez Florida Atlantic University 2 Ricardo A. Alvarez 3 CENTRAL FLORIDA LAKES KISSIMMEE RIVER LAKE OKEECHOBEE
More informationEverglades Restoration. Ernie Barnett Assistant Executive Director
Everglades Restoration Ernie Barnett Assistant Executive Director Lake Worth Lagoon Symposium 2013 S O U T H F L O R I D A W A T E R M A N A G E M E N T D I S T R I C T Planning Everglades Restoration
More informationApplication of Adaptive Management for Wetland Restoration
Application of Adaptive Management for Wetland Restoration An Overview of a Large-Scale Everglades Physical Model Fred Sklar, Ph.D Director Everglades Systems Assessment International Wetlands Conference
More informationMODELING THE HYDRODYNAMIC AND WATER QUALITY IMPACTS OF PROPOSED TAMIAMI TRAIL BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION USING THE M3ENP NUMERICAL MODEL
MODELING THE HYDRODYNAMIC AND WATER QUALITY IMPACTS OF PROPOSED TAMIAMI TRAIL BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION USING THE M3ENP NUMERICAL MODEL Stephanie Long 1, Georgio Tachiev 2, Amy Cook 1,2, Robert Fenema 3, Jordan
More informationLAKE OKEECHOBEE WATERSHED RESTORATION
LAKE OKEECHOBEE WATERSHED RESTORATION INTEGRATED PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION REPORT & ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT Initial Array of Alternatives Overview October 25, 2016 Trusted Partners Delivering Value
More informationWatersheds Functions and Management 1
Fact Sheet ABE350 Watersheds Functions and Management 1 S. Shukla 2 What Is a Watershed? The term watershed is often used in discussions about water quality or flood prevention, but most people do not
More informationHydrologic and Ecologic Impacts from the CERP Indian River Lagoon South Project
Hydrologic and Ecologic Impacts from the CERP Indian River Lagoon South Project Dr. Gretchen Ehlinger Senior Biologist US Army Corps of Engineers Jacksonville District November 15, 2016 AWRA Conference
More informationEverglades Landscape Sulfate Dynamics: Final Summary Evaluation of CERP ASR Alternatives
Everglades Landscape Sulfate Dynamics: Final Summary Evaluation of CERP ASR Alternatives http://ecolandmod.ifas.ufl.edu/projects/elmreg500masr In partial fullfillment of U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Cooperative
More informationRESOLUTION NO
RESOLUTION NO. 135-2016 A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA IN SUPPORT OF EXPEDITING AUTHORIZATON, APPROPRIATION, IMPLEMENTATION, AND COMPLETION OF EVERGLADES RESTORATION
More information1999 Base Line Report for the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan. Table of Contents. Introduction... 1
Table of Contents Introduction... 1 1. Lake Okeechobee Phosphorus Levels... 4 2. St. Lucie Estuary Oyster Beds... 6 3. St. Lucie Estuary Phosphorus Levels... 8 4. Lake Okeechobee and East Coast Water Supply
More informationA Relook at CERP Interim Goals and Interim Targets GEER 2017, Coral Springs FL
A Relook at CERP Interim Goals and Interim Targets GEER 2017, Coral Springs FL Agnes R. McLean, Everglades National Park Rebecca Elliott, Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services Presentation
More informationEUROPE AND NORTH AMERICA. 14. Everglades National Park (United States of America) (N 76)
EUROPE AND NORTH AMERICA 14. Everglades National Park (United States of America) (N 76) Year of inscription on the World Heritage List 1979 Criteria (viii) (ix) (x) Year(s) of inscription on the List of
More informationHydrologic and Ecologic Analysis and Targets. Water Quality Targets and Feature Performance
WRAC Issues Workshop - Phase I Planning September 2, 2009 Temperince Morgan, River of Grass Project Liaison/Northern Everglades Program Implementation Manager Recap from August Workshop Restoration Concepts
More informationMODELING AT SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT (SFWMD)
MODELING AT SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT (SFWMD) UNESCO IHE LECTURES - 2017 5/25/2017 Akintunde Owosina P.E. Chief, Hydrology and Hydraulics Bureau Operations, Engineering & Construction Division
More informationNEW CLIMATE CHANGE INFORMATION FOR ENHANCING EVERGLADES RESTORATION CLIMATE PREPAREDNESS AND RESILIENCE
NEW CLIMATE CHANGE INFORMATION FOR ENHANCING EVERGLADES RESTORATION CLIMATE PREPAREDNESS AND RESILIENCE Glenn B. Landers, P.E. USACE Jacksonville District GEER Conference, Coral Springs, FL April 19, 2017
More informationRestoration Rally Cry for the Big Cypress Swamp. Robert V. Sobczak, Hydrologist Big Cypress National Preserve
Restoration Rally Cry for the Big Cypress Swamp Robert V. Sobczak, Hydrologist Big Cypress National Preserve Restoration Rally Cry for the Big Cypress Swamp Robert V. Sobczak, Hydrologist Big Cypress National
More informationThe Lake Okeechobee Fast Track (LOFT) Project
3 rd UF Water Institute Symposium Sustainable Water Resources The Lake Okeechobee Fast Track (LOFT) Project A Watershed Approach to Phosphorus Removal for a Complex System February 15, 2012 Michael F.
More informationRoland Ottolini, P.E. Director, Natural Resources Division. Lee County Board of County Commissioners March 15, 2016
Roland Ottolini, P.E. Director, Natural Resources Division Lee County Board of County Commissioners March 15, 2016 1 Presentation Overview Lee County Water Quality/Storage Initiatives Regional Initiatives
More informationInteragency CERP AM Disclaimer
Lessons Learned from the Everglades Collaborative Adaptive Management Program Interagency CERP AM Andrew LoSchiavo, USACE Ronnie Best, USGS, retired Rebecca Burns, Atkins Global Susan Gray, SFWMD Matthew
More informationCENTRAL AND SOUTHERN FLORIDA PROJECT COMPREHENSIVE EVERGLADES RESTORATION PLAN SITE 1 IMPOUNDMENT PROJECT FINAL SUPPLEMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
CENTRAL AND SOUTHERN FLORIDA PROJECT COMPREHENSIVE EVERGLADES RESTORATION PLAN SITE 1 IMPOUNDMENT PROJECT FINAL SUPPLEMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT June 2010 CENTRAL AND SOUTHERN FLORIDA PROJECT SITE
More informationEverglades Restoration Strategies August 24, 2016
Everglades Restoration Strategies August 24, 2016 The views in this presentation are those of the author and do not represent the views of the US EPA. South Florida Ecosystem at a Glance 2016 Greater Everglades
More informationWilliam J. Mitsch, Ph.D.
Ecological engineering and restoration of wetlands, rivers, and coastlines for their ecosystem services William J. Mitsch, Ph.D. Eminent Scholar and Director, Everglades Wetland Research Park Florida Gulf
More informationThank you for your comment. We understand the MOU and will coordinate as required.
A NEPA scoping letter dated June 28, 2016 was mailed to stakeholders soliciting comments for this action. The scoping letter was used to invite comments from Federal, State, and local agencies, affected
More informationRoland Ottolini, P.E. Director, Natural Resources Division. Presented to the Lee County Tourist Development Council. May 11, 2017
Roland Ottolini, P.E. Director, Natural Resources Division Presented to the Lee County Tourist Development Council May 11, 2017 1 Presentation Overview Regional Water Management Caloosahatchee Issues Lee
More informationCaloosahatchee - Everglades Restoration
Caloosahatchee - Everglades Restoration Captiva Community Panel December 13, 2016 Orlando Upper Chain of Lakes Lake Kissimmee Kissimmee River Lake Okeechobee Caloosahatchee St. Lucie River Everglades Florida
More informationOctober 10, Prepared by Battelle Memorial Institute
October 10, 2013 Final Independent External Peer Review Report Central Everglades Planning Project Draft Project Implementation Report and Environmental Impact Statement Prepared by Battelle Memorial Institute
More informationSTUDY GUIDE SECTION 22-1 An Interconnected Planet
STUDY GUIDE SECTION 22-1 An Interconnected Planet Name Period Date Multiple Choice-Write the correct letter in the blank 1. Which of the following is NOT a measure of biodiversity? a. species evenness
More informationProgress on South Florida Estuaries Restoration: C-111 Western Spreader Canal and Biscayne Bay Coastal Wetland CERP Project
Progress on South Florida Estuaries Restoration: C-111 Western Spreader Canal and Biscayne Bay Coastal Wetland CERP Project American Water Resources Association 2016 ANNUAL WATER RESOURCES CONFERECNCE
More informationwise use of water, wetlands, and watersheds : Everglades restoration using large treatment wetlands
wise use of water, wetlands, and watersheds : Everglades restoration using large treatment wetlands Gary Goforth, P.E., Ph.D. Overview Everglades Restoration Background Stormwater Treatment Areas Design
More informationAN INTERCONNECTED PLANET
SECTION 22-1 REVIEW AN INTERCONNECTED PLANET VOCABULARY REVIEW Define the following terms. 1. biodiversity 2. species evenness 3. genetic diversity MULTIPLE CHOICE Write the correct letter in the blank.
More informationINTRODUCTION. Trusted Partners Delivering Value Today for a Better Tomorrow BUILDING STRONG
INTRODUCTION BUILDING STRONG Welcome to the 1 st PDT meeting of 2017 for the Lake Okeechobee Watershed Project Attendance CERP Team and Public Housekeeping Items: Please keep phones on mute unless you
More informationChallenges in Benefit Analysis
Challenges in Benefit Analysis Topics Fundamental Challenges Observations Research Ongoing for Benefit Analysis Accomplishments despite the challenges Don t Forget the Why s Fundamental Challenges of Ecosystem
More informationSUNSHINE STATE STANDARD VOCABULARY REQUIRED MATERIALS
SECTION-TOPIC SUNSHINE STATE STANDARD VOCABULARY REQUIRED MATERIALS GEOGRAPHY EVERGLADES Standard 5: Understand how human actions can impact the environment. SS.912.G.5.4: Analyze case studies of how humans
More informationDesign and Construction of a Flow Equalization Basin (FEB) to Optimize Performance of Everglades Stormwater Treatment Areas (STAs)
Design and Construction of a Flow Equalization Basin (FEB) to Optimize Performance of Everglades Stormwater Treatment Areas (STAs) American Water Resources Association 2016 Annual Water Resources Conference
More informationHydrologic and Environmental Systems Modeling
Hydrologic and Environmental Systems Modeling Model Documentation Report (DRAFT) RSM Glades-LECSA 2015 Future without CERP Baseline V2.1 April 29, 2011 1.0 Overview Identification This report documents
More informationAGENCY. Letters AGENCY. Letters
AGENCY Letters AGENCY Letters Section 601 of the Water Resources Development Act (WRDA) of 2000 approved the Final Integrated Feasibility Report and Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement (the Plan),
More informationSTATE OF FLORIDA. OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR EXECUTIVE ORDER NUMBER (Achieving More Now For Florida's Environment)
STATE OF FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR EXECUTIVE ORDER NUMBER 19-12 (Achieving More Now For Florida's Environment) WHEREAS, water and natural resources are the foundation of Florida's communities, economy
More informationDesigning STAs to Achieve Treatment and Restoration Objectives. Briefing information prepared for
Designing STAs to Achieve Treatment and Restoration Objectives Briefing information prepared for Committee on Independent Scientific Review of Everglades Restoration Progress Meeting # 23 Questions and
More information