Comprehensive Asbestos & Lead Base Paint Survey

Transcription

1 Report of Comprehensive Asbestos & Lead Base Paint Survey Prepared for: Freese and Nichols, Inc International Plaza, Suite 200 Fort Worth, TX Building Surveyed: Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Report Date: Monday, August 01, 2016

2 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Comprehensive Asbestos and Lead Base Paint Survey Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction Purpose and Scope Report Organization Field Investigation Sampling Laboratory Analysis Analytical Methods Bulk Sample Results Hazard Assessment Hazard Assessment Ratings Asbestos-Containing Material Assessments Hazard Assessment Summary Response Actions Qualifications 9 Appendices Appendix A: Site Drawings Appendix B: Lab Results Appendix C: Bulk Summary Report Appendix D: Cost Estimates for Abatement Appendix E: Photographs Appendix F: Lead Base Paint Report Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 2 of 9

3 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Introduction This document is a report of a Comprehensive Asbestos Survey performed by Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc.(IHST). IHST is licensed by the Texas Department of State Health Services (DSHS), formerly the Texas Department of Health, as an Asbestos Consultant Agency (DSHS License # Figure 1 provides a description of the assessment described by this report. Figure 1. Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Profile Client Name: Freese and Nichols, Inc. Facility/Campus Hondo Pass Readiness Center Building: Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Survey Date(s): 6/22/2016 Inspector(s): Doug Easley - DSHS Asbestos Inspector License # Purpose and Scope The purpose of this project was to locate, identify, and assess the condition of asbestos containing material (ACM) present at the subject building, and to develop recommendations based on existing and potential asbestos related hazards. The following scope of work was used during the asbestos assessment for the subject property: A. Collecting and analyzing bulk samples of suspected asbestos-containing materials. B. Quantification of the suspected asbestos-containing material. C. Preparing a report discussing the findings and remedial recommendations. 3.0 Report Organization This report is divided into sections which discuss the review of available documentation, field investigation, laboratory analysis, hazard assessments, and recommendations. Illustrations, such as tables and figures follow the text. Other supporting documentation, such as laboratory reports are also included. 4.0 Field Investigation The survey was conducted to determine the amount of asbestos-containing materials present in the subject building. The survey included an observation of accessible areas and unusual conditions; and bulk sampling of suspected asbestos-containing materials. Bulk samples were collected of suspect materials and analyzed by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) with dispersion staining, in accordance with the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Insulation Samples (Method 600/R-93/116). All of the samples that tested greater than 1% by the PLM method for counting asbestos were reanalyzed using the Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) method. This technique characterizes asbestos more precisely than PLM. Laboratory reports containing sample location and results are included with this report. The survey was designed to identify the presence of both friable and non-friable asbestos- containing materials present in the surveyed area. Friable means that the material, when dry, may be crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by hand pressure. Building materials suspected of containing asbestos were grouped into "Homogeneous" sampling areas. The homogeneous areas were defined Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 3 of 9

4 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: based on uniform texture, color, and appearance. Additionally, homogeneous areas were further defined based on building construction date(s). Each of the items sampled were classified into one of three categories: 1.) Surfacing Material: A surfacing material is a building material which has been applied to a surface (i.e., walls or ceilings) or structural members. Examples of surfacing materials which may contain asbestos are: spray-applied fireproofing, spray-applied acoustical texture, and trowel-applied textured ceilings and walls. 2.) Thermal System Insulation: All types of insulation used on a building's mechanical system are classified into the category of thermal system insulation. Examples of thermal system materials which may contain asbestos are: boilers and related piping, or duct insulation. 3.) Miscellaneous: All remaining materials which do not fall into the two above categories are placed in the miscellaneous category. Examples of miscellaneous materials which may contain asbestos are: lay-in ceiling tile, floor tile, mastic adhesives and roofing felt. An assessment was conducted for each building material sampled. The physical assessment consists of evaluating the condition of the suspect material and the potential for future disturbance. Recommendations made for a building material which contains asbestos are based on the assessments made by the inspector during the survey. The data developed during the asbestos survey is presented in the following sections of this report. Table 1 contains the Summary of Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment. This table presents specific locations, results of additional asbestos analysis, time schedules, and quantities of asbestos. 5.0 Sampling Sampling during the field investigation included the collection of bulk samples of suspected asbestos containing materials, as listed in Table 1., Summary of Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment. After sample recovery, samples were placed in secure containers, and the sampling vicinity was cleaned and sealed. Appropriate chain-of-custody protocols were initiated at that time to track handling of bulk samples. 5.1 Laboratory Analysis The samples were transported to and analyzed by the analytical laboratory specified in Figure 2., a successful participant in the Department of Commerce, National Institute of Standards and Technology's (NIST) National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program and licensed by the Texas Department of State Health Services (DSHS), formerly the Texas Department of Health. Ten percent (10%) of the bulk samples were reanalyzed independently as part of the quality assurance and quality control programs. Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 4 of 9

5 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Figure 2. Bulk Sample Laboratory Profile Laboratory Name: Steve Moody Micro Services DSHS License Number: # NVLAP Lab ID: # Expires: 5/31/ Analytical Methods Bulk samples were analyzed by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM). This technique characterizes the materials refractive indices, fiber morphology, birefringence, extinction angle, sign of elongation, and dispersion staining colors to detect asbestos. Percentage estimates are based on approximate area compositions under a stereo-microscope. All of the samples that tested greater than 1% by the PLM method for counting asbestos were reanalyzed using the Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) method. This technique characterizes asbestos more precisely than PLM. 5.3 Bulk Sample Results The results of the sample analysis are presented in Table 1, and the laboratory analysis report is included as Appendix B. Figure 3. Materials with Asbestos Detected at 1% or Greater Mat'l Type Description Location CMU Texture on CMU Block Throughout Except Vaults Caulking Window Glazing Windows Figure 4. Materials with NO Asbestos Detected (Pursuant to EPA and DSHS Definition) Mat'l Type Description Location Sheetrock Sheetrock & Joint Compound Classroom, Administration, Office E-16 Texture Matls Texture on Plaster & Ceiling Men's Shower/Restroom, Women's Restroom, Kitchen Area, Food Storage ACT 2 x 4 Ceiling Tile Throughout Except Storage, Vault & Assembly Hall Cove Base Cove Base & Mastic Office 29, Office E-30, Battery Room TSI White Mastic on Fittings Mechanical Room 20, Maintenance/Storage Room 38 Adhesive Tape on HVAC Battery Room 17, Mechanical Room 20 Flooring Matls Gray 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic Men's Restroom E-42 Texture Matls Texture on Exterior Over Hang Building Exits Flooring Matls Flooring Matls Beige 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic 12 x 12 Black & White Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic See Drawing Office E-33 Caulking Exterior Window Caulk See Drawing TSI Beige Mastic on Pipe Insulation Above Shower E-43 Ceiling Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 5 of 9

6 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Hazard Assessment Asbestos is an airborne hazard. A hazard assessment refers to the process by which we evaluate a material's potential to release fibers into the air. Fibers may be released spontaneously as part of the aging process, or as a result of sudden impact, vibration, air movement, or localized deterioration. Assessing a material's potential for fiber release, and hence its associated hazard, is based upon evaluating the material's condition and potential for further disturbance, damage, or deterioration. 6.1 Hazard Assessment Rankings Any material identified as asbestos containing that exhibits damage, should be considered a hazard to anyone who works in the area. Typically, damage is classified as minor or significant. Minor damage is characterized by small cuts, tears, scuffs, small openings, or other limited disturbance to asbestos containing materials. Areas with minor damage represent varying degrees of hazards from slight to high depending on: * The nature of the damage; * Proximity to disturbers, such as airstreams; * Location with respect to building occupants; * Activity in the immediate area; and * Frequency of maintenance in the area. Significant damage is characterized by large openings, visible flaking, loose particles, and debris on surfaces below the material. Asbestos containing materials which exhibit significant damage are either high or critical hazards, depending upon accessibility. High hazards exist where significantly damaged materials are generally inaccessible; however, where significant damage is accessible, or in the vicinity of building occupants, there is a critical hazard. The recommended action for addressing asbestos related hazards depends upon the degree of hazard. For example: * An immediate hazard or critical assessment describes a situation in which the material is exposed and friable, accessible to personnel, and is disturbed releasing fibers in the air. In this situation, immediate action should be taken. At a minimum, the area should be isolated and access restricted. * A high assessment describes a situation in which the material is in poor condition, exposed and friable, with a potential for disturbance. In this case, interim controls should be instituted, and the material should be removed when practical. Repairs should be made to the ACM if abatement is not scheduled. * A medium or moderate assessment describes a situation in which a combination of the determining factors vary, such as a material that is in good condition but has a high asbestos content and is generally accessible. In situations like this, abatement can be scheduled with future building renovation or maintenance. * A low or slight assessment describes a situation in which the material is in good condition and has a low potential for disturbance, damage, or deterioration. In this situation, an O&M program is usually all that is needed. In general, those areas that are classified as critical or high damage should be abated. These are areas where a high probability of exposure could occur. Moderately damaged areas would require an Operations and Maintenance (O&M) Program to be instituted. In addition, these areas should be considered for abatement, or at the very least repaired. Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 6 of 9

7 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Asbestos-Containing Material Assessments Figure 5 provides a summary of the asbestos identified during the survey, along with a hazard assessment for each type and condition of asbestos-containing material. Figure 5. Hazard Assessments for Asbestos-Containing Materials Texture on Cinder Block Condition: Good, Friability: NF II, Disturbance Potential: Low The texture is in good condition presents a low potential health hazard to building occupants due to its observed good condition and intact binding matrices. Prior to building demolition, renovation or work activities that would disturb these materials, removal must be performed by a properly trained and licensed abatement contractor. The preceding hazard assessment applies to the asbestos-containing materials listed below: Area Ref# Homogeneous Area Description Quantity Location 04 Texture on CMU Block s.f. Throughout Except Vaults Window Glazing, Caulking and Sealant Condition: Good, Friability: NF II, Disturbance Potential: Low At the time of the survey, this ACM was observed to be non-friable and in good condition. Please refer to the schematic drawings for specific material locations. The window glazing and caulking is in good condition and presents a low potential health hazard to building occupants due to its observed good condition and intact binding matrices. The preceding hazard assessment applies to the asbestos-containing materials listed below: Area Ref# Homogeneous Area Description Quantity Location 07 Window Glazing 856 l.f. Windows Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 7 of 9

8 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Hazard Assessment Summary In the event other building materials are discovered in addition to the materials sampled in this survey, those building materials should be presumed to contain asbestos and treated as such until proven otherwise by PLM laboratory analysis. 7.1 Response Actions Asbestos Containing Materials The identified asbestos in the Hondo Pass Readiness Center should be managed in place until such time that removal is required because of renovation or demolition projects that may disturb the material. 7.2 Explanation of Response Ratings Table 1 includes a response rating based on factors such as friability, accessibility, potential for disturbance, etc. Definitions for the response ratings are listed below: 0 = Material does not contain detectable amounts of asbestos and requires no asbestos-related abatement action. 1 = Material contains asbestos, was non-friable, and requires no abatement action unless sanded, abraded, drilled or otherwise disturbed. 2 = Material contains asbestos and was friable. Damage was not observed; no immediate abatement action is required. 3 = Material contains asbestos, was friable, and shows signs of localized damage with a potential for disturbance. 4 = Material contains friable asbestos and was significantly damaged. Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 8 of 9

9 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Qualifications Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. has attempted to observe the existing conditions within the aforementioned building utilizing generally accepted procedures. Regardless of the thoroughness of a survey, the possibility exists that some areas containing asbestos were overlooked, inaccessible or different from those at specific locations. Furthermore, renovation and/or construction may reveal altered conditions. This report describes only the conditions present at the time of the survey, in the areas surveyed. The recommendations presented apply to the conditions that were observed during the survey. IHST policies are to not perform destructive sampling unless previously authorized by the client. Therefore, IHST does not perform core sampling of roofing materials unless previously authorized and accompanied by the owner and/or his representative. Other conditions may exist in unsurveyed or inaccessible areas such as behind walls and above permanent ceilings. In addition, the conditions of asbestos-containing materials may change gradually or suddenly depending upon use, maintenance or accident. As a result, the recommendations presented should be periodically reviewed and updated. The quantity estimates presented in this report were based upon observations during the survey as well as information from building plans provided by the owner. While it is believed that the estimated quantities are reasonable, unanticipated conditions could be present in inaccessible or unsurveyed areas. Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology, Inc. do not warrant or guarantee the quantity estimates. The use of such estimates shall be at the user's own risk and shall constitute a release and agreement to defend and indemnify Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology, Inc. from and against any liability. If you have any questions or comments regarding the content of this report, I would be glad to discuss them at your convenience. Sincerely, Doug Easley - DSHS Asbestos Inspector License # Tracy K. Bramlett President DSHS Individual Asbestos Consultant License # Comprehensive Asbestos Survey Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Page 9 of 9

10 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Appendix: Appendix A: Site Drawings Asbestos Survey Appendix Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass

11 NORTH L L L L L L L 029 KEY DRAWING TITLE: NEGATIVE ASBESTOS SAMPLE POSITIVE ASBESTOS SAMPLE INACCESSIBLE AREA NEGATIVE LEAD SAMPLE POSITIVE LEAD SAMPLE Freese & Nichols Hondo Pass Readiness Center 9100 Gateway Blvd N, *POSITIVE ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL IS CLASSIFIED AS BEING GREATER THAN 1% ASBESTOS. *POSITIVE LEAD CONTAINING MATERIAL IS CLASSIFIED AS BEING GREATER THAN 0.5% LEAD BY WEIGHT. Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. JOB NUMBER: DRAWN BY: K. Girton DATE: 06/29/2016 CAD File: Readiness Center.TCW Scale: None Sheet: 1 of 2

12 NORTH ACM Textured CMU Block ACM Window Glazing KEY I HS T DRAWING TITLE: Freese & Nichols Hondo Pass Readiness Center 9100 Gateway Blvd N, *POSITIVE ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL IS CLASSIFIED AS BEING GREATER THAN 1% ASBESTOS. Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. JOB NUMBER: DRAWN BY: K. Girton DATE: 06/29/2016 CAD File: Readiness Center.TCW Scale: None Sheet: 2 of 2

13 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Appendix: Appendix B: Lab Results Asbestos Survey Appendix Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass

14 2051 Valley View Lane Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) PLM Summary Report NVLAP Lab Code TDSHS License No Client : Project : Project # : Identification : Test Method : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Polarized Light Microscopy / Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS) EPA Method 600 / R-93 / 116 Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 Sample Date : 06/22/2016 Page 1 of 4 On 6/27/2016, fifty two (52) bulk material samples were submitted by Doug Easley of Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS. The PLM Detail Report is attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below: Sample Number Client Sample Description / Location Asbestos Content 001 Sheetrock and Joint Compound, Classroom E-45 None Detected - Drywall Material None Detected - Joint Compound 002 Sheetrock and Joint Compound, H.H.B. Administration E- 12 None Detected - Drywall Material None Detected - Joint Compound 003 Sheetrock and Joint Compound, Office E-16 None Detected - Drywall Material None Detected - Joint Compound 004 Texture on Plaster Ceiling, Men's Shower E-42 None Detected - Plaster None Detected - Paint / Texture 005 Texture on Plaster Ceiling, Men's Restroom E-42 None Detected - Plaster None Detected - Paint / Texture 006 Texture on Plaster Ceiling, Women's Restroom 35 None Detected - Plaster None Detected - Paint / Texture 007 Texture on Plaster Ceiling, Kitchen Area 15 None Detected - Plaster None Detected - Paint 008 Texture on Plaster Ceiling, Food Storage 13 None Detected - Plaster None Detected - Paint x 4 Ceiling Tile, Office 18 None Detected - Acoustic Tile x 4 Ceiling Tile, Battery Room 8 None Detected - Acoustic Tile x 4 Ceiling Tile, Locker Room 32 None Detected - Acoustic Tile x 4 Ceiling Tile, Office E-30 None Detected - Acoustic Tile x 4 Ceiling Tile, In Room E-10 None Detected - Acoustic Tile 014 Texture on CMU Block, In Classroom 30 None Detected - CMU None Detected - Texture 015 Texture on CMU Block, In Maintenance/Storage Room 38 None Detected - CMU None Detected - Paint / Texture 016 Texture on CMU Block, In Room E-44 None Detected - CMU 2% Chrysotile - Paint / Texture

15 2051 Valley View Lane Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) PLM Summary Report NVLAP Lab Code TDSHS License No Client : Project : Project # : Identification : Test Method : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Polarized Light Microscopy / Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS) EPA Method 600 / R-93 / 116 Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 Sample Date : 06/22/2016 Page 2 of 4 On 6/27/2016, fifty two (52) bulk material samples were submitted by Doug Easley of Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS. The PLM Detail Report is attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below: Sample Number Client Sample Description / Location Asbestos Content 017 Texture on CMU Block, Outside Vault E-36 None Detected - CMU 2% Chrysotile - Paint / Texture 018 Texture on CMU Block, In Room E-23 Storage None Detected - Mortar 2% Chrysotile - Texture 019 Texture on CMU Block, Corridor outside Room E-15 None Detected - CMU 2% Chrysotile - Texture 020 Texture on CMU Block, Battery Room 5 None Detected - Mortar None Detected - Texture 021 Cove Base and Mastic, Office 29 None Detected - Cove Base None Detected - Tan Mastic 022 Cove Base and Mastic, Office E-30 None Detected - Cove Base None Detected - Tan Mastic 023 Cove Base and Mastic, Battery Room 8 None Detected - Cove Base None Detected - Tan Mastic 024 Mastic (White) on Fittings, Mechanical Room 20 None Detected - Thermal Insulation None Detected - Paper / Foil Wrap None Detected - White Mastic 025 Mastic (White) on Fittings, Maintenance/Storage Room 38 None Detected - Thermal Insulation None Detected - White Mastic 026 Mastic (White) on Fittings, Maintenance/Storage Room 38 None Detected - Thermal Insulation None Detected - White Mastic 027 Window Glazing, Foyer E-31 None Detected - Window Glazing 028 Window Glazing, Exterior Window Office E-7 2% Chrysotile - Window Glazing 029 Window Glazing, Exterior Window Office E-13 2% Chrysotile - Window Glazing 030 Tape on HVAC, Battery Room 17 None Detected - Tape 031 Tape on HVAC, Battery Room 17 None Detected - Tape 032 Tape on HVAC, Mechanical Room 20 None Detected - Tape

16 2051 Valley View Lane Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) PLM Summary Report NVLAP Lab Code TDSHS License No Client : Project : Project # : Identification : Test Method : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Polarized Light Microscopy / Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS) EPA Method 600 / R-93 / 116 Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 Sample Date : 06/22/2016 Page 3 of 4 On 6/27/2016, fifty two (52) bulk material samples were submitted by Doug Easley of Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS. The PLM Detail Report is attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below: Sample Number Client Sample Description / Location Asbestos Content x 12 Floor Tile (Gray) with Mastic (Yellow), Men's Restroom E x 12 Floor Tile (Gray) with Mastic (Yellow), Men's Restroom E x 12 Floor Tile (Gray) with Mastic (Yellow), Men's Restroom E-42 None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic 036 Texture on Exterior Overhang, North Exit Door None Detected - Paint / Texture 037 Texture on Exterior Overhang, East Exit Door None Detected - Paint / Texture 038 Texture on Exterior Overhang, West Exit Door None Detected - Paint / Texture x 12 Floor Tile (Beige) with Mastic (Yellow), In Office x 12 Floor Tile (Beige) with Mastic (Yellow), Corridor outside Battery Room 5 None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - Leveling Compound None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - Leveling Compound x 12 Floor Tile (Beige) with Mastic (Yellow), Corridor 1 outside Battery Room 2 None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - Leveling Compound x 12 Floor Tile (Beige) with Mastic (Yellow), In Room E-23 None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic x 12 Floor Tile (Beige) with Mastic (Yellow), Corridor E- 19 Exit Door None Detected - Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - Leveling Compound x 12 Floor Tile (Black and White) with Mastic (Yellow), E-33 Office None Detected - Black Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - White Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic

17 2051 Valley View Lane Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) PLM Summary Report NVLAP Lab Code TDSHS License No Client : Project : Project # : Identification : Test Method : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Polarized Light Microscopy / Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS) EPA Method 600 / R-93 / 116 Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 Sample Date : 06/22/2016 Page 4 of 4 On 6/27/2016, fifty two (52) bulk material samples were submitted by Doug Easley of Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS. The PLM Detail Report is attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below: Sample Number Client Sample Description / Location Asbestos Content x 12 Floor Tile (Black and White) with Mastic (Yellow), E-33 Office 12 x 12 Floor Tile (Black and White) with Mastic (Yellow), E-33 Office None Detected - Black Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - White Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - Black Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic None Detected - White Floor Tile None Detected - Yellow Mastic 047 Exterior Window Caulk, Outside Office 9 None Detected - Caulking 048 Exterior Window Caulk, Outside Office 7 None Detected - Caulking 049 Exterior Window Caulk, Outside of Battery Room 2 None Detected - Caulking Mastic (Beige) on Pipe Insulation, Above Ceiling Shower RR-E-42 Mastic (Beige) on Pipe Insulation, Above Ceiling Shower RR-E-42 Mastic (Beige) on Pipe Insulation, Above Ceiling Shower RR-E-42 None Detected - Thermal Insulation None Detected - Beige Mastic None Detected - Thermal Insulation None Detected - Beige Mastic None Detected - Thermal Insulation None Detected - Beige Mastic These samples were analyzed by layers. Quantification, unless otherwise noted, is performed by calibrated visual estimate. The test report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without written approval of the laboratory. The results relate only to the items tested. These test results do not imply endorsement by NVLAP or any agency of the U.S. Government. Accredited by the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program for Bulk Asbestos Fiber Analysis under Lab Code Analyst(s): Ashley Chambers, Shaun Wilkerson Lab Manager : Heather Lopez Approved Signatory : Lab Director : Bruce Crabb Approved Signatory : Thank you for choosing Moody Labs

18 Client : Project : Project # : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX PLM Detail Report Moody Labs NVLAP Lab Code Valley View Lane Supplement to PLM Summary Report TDSHS License No Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) % Of Sample Number Layer Components Sample Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 % of Layer Analysis Date Page 1 of Drywall Material (White) 75% Cellulose Fibers 5% 06/28 SW 001 Drywall Material (White) 75% Gypsum / Binders 95% 06/28 SW 001 DW Paper Facing (Tan) 10% Cellulose Fibers 100% 06/28 SW 001 Joint Compound (White) 15% Calcite / Talc / Binders 100% 06/28 SW 002 Drywall Material (White) 75% Cellulose Fibers 5% 06/28 SW 002 Drywall Material (White) 75% Gypsum / Binders 95% 06/28 SW 002 DW Paper Facing (Tan) 10% Cellulose Fibers 100% 06/28 SW 002 Joint Compound (White) 15% Calcite / Talc / Binders 100% 06/28 SW 003 Drywall Material (White) 75% Cellulose Fibers 5% 06/28 SW 003 Drywall Material (White) 75% Gypsum / Binders 95% 06/28 SW 003 DW Paper Facing (Tan) 10% Cellulose Fibers 100% 06/28 SW 003 Joint Compound (White) 15% Calcite / Talc / Binders 100% 06/28 SW 004 Plaster (Grey) 90% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 004 Plaster (Grey) 90% Calcite / Binders 35% 06/28 SW 004 Paint / Texture (Green) 10% Calcite 25% 06/28 SW 004 Paint / Texture (Green) 10% Pigment / Binders 75% 06/28 SW 005 Plaster (Grey) 90% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 005 Plaster (Grey) 90% Calcite / Binders 35% 06/28 SW 005 Paint / Texture (Green) 10% Calcite 25% 06/28 SW 005 Paint / Texture (Green) 10% Pigment / Binders 75% 06/28 SW 006 Plaster (Grey) 90% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 006 Plaster (Grey) 90% Calcite / Binders 35% 06/28 SW 006 Paint / Texture (Green) 10% Calcite 25% 06/28 SW 006 Paint / Texture (Green) 10% Pigment / Binders 75% 06/28 SW 007 Plaster (Grey) 90% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 007 Plaster (Grey) 90% Calcite / Binders 35% 06/28 SW 007 Paint (Off-White) 10% Pigment / Binders 100% 06/28 SW 008 Plaster (Grey) 90% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 008 Plaster (Grey) 90% Calcite / Binders 35% 06/28 SW 008 Paint (Off-White) 10% Pigment / Binders 100% 06/28 SW Analyst

19 Client : Project : Project # : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX PLM Detail Report Moody Labs NVLAP Lab Code Valley View Lane Supplement to PLM Summary Report TDSHS License No Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) % Of Sample Number Layer Components Sample Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 % of Layer Analysis Date Page 2 of Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Cellulose Fibers 50% 06/28 SW 009 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Mineral Wool Fibers 30% 06/28 SW 009 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Perlite 20% 06/28 SW 010 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Cellulose Fibers 50% 06/28 SW 010 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Mineral Wool Fibers 30% 06/28 SW 010 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Perlite 20% 06/28 SW 011 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Cellulose Fibers 50% 06/28 SW 011 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Mineral Wool Fibers 30% 06/28 SW 011 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Perlite 20% 06/28 SW 012 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Cellulose Fibers 50% 06/28 SW 012 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Mineral Wool Fibers 30% 06/28 SW 012 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Perlite 20% 06/28 SW 013 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Cellulose Fibers 50% 06/28 SW 013 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Mineral Wool Fibers 30% 06/28 SW 013 Acoustic Tile (Tan) 100% Perlite 20% 06/28 SW 014 CMU (Grey) 95% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 014 CMU (Grey) 95% Cement Binders 35% 06/28 SW 014 Texture (White) 5% Calcite / Talc / Binders 100% 06/28 SW 015 CMU (Grey) <1% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 015 CMU (Grey) <1% Cement Binders 35% 06/28 SW 015 Paint / Texture (White) 100% Calcite 25% 06/28 SW 015 Paint / Texture (White) 100% Pigment / Binders 75% 06/28 SW 016 CMU (Grey) 98% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 016 CMU (Grey) 98% Cement Binders 35% 06/28 SW 016 Paint / Texture (Green) 2% Chrysotile 2% 06/28 SW 016 Paint / Texture (Green) 2% Calcite / Talc / Binders 98% 06/28 SW 017 CMU (Grey) 98% Aggregate 65% 06/28 SW 017 CMU (Grey) 98% Cement Binders 35% 06/28 SW 017 Paint / Texture (Green) 2% Chrysotile 2% 06/28 SW 017 Paint / Texture (Green) 2% Calcite / Talc / Binders 98% 06/28 SW Analyst

20 Client : Project : Project # : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX PLM Detail Report Moody Labs NVLAP Lab Code Valley View Lane Supplement to PLM Summary Report TDSHS License No Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) % Of Sample Number Layer Components Sample Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 % of Layer Analysis Date Page 3 of Mortar (Grey) 99% Aggregate 65% 06/29 AC 018 Mortar (Grey) 99% Cement Binders 35% 06/29 AC 018 Texture (White) 1% Chrysotile 2% 06/29 AC 018 Texture (White) 1% Calcite / Talc / Binders 98% 06/29 AC 019 CMU (Grey) 99% Aggregate 65% 06/29 AC 019 CMU (Grey) 99% Cement Binders 35% 06/29 AC 019 Texture (White) 1% Chrysotile 2% 06/29 AC 019 Texture (White) 1% Calcite / Talc / Binders 98% 06/29 AC 020 Mortar (Grey) 99% Aggregate 65% 06/29 AC 020 Mortar (Grey) 99% Cement Binders 35% 06/29 AC 020 Texture (White) 1% Calcite / Talc / Binders 100% 06/29 AC 021 Cove Base (Brown) 97% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 021 Tan Mastic (Tan) 3% Calcite 40% 06/29 AC 021 Tan Mastic (Tan) 3% Glue Binders 60% 06/29 AC 022 Cove Base (Brown) 97% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 022 Tan Mastic (Tan) 3% Calcite 40% 06/29 AC 022 Tan Mastic (Tan) 3% Glue Binders 60% 06/29 AC 023 Cove Base (Brown) 97% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 023 Tan Mastic (Tan) 3% Calcite 40% 06/29 AC 023 Tan Mastic (Tan) 3% Glue Binders 60% 06/29 AC 024 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 60% Mineral Wool Fibers 95% 06/29 AC 024 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 60% Resin Binders 5% 06/29 AC 024 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 15% Cellulose Fibers 60% 06/29 AC 024 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 15% Glass Wool Fibers 20% 06/29 AC 024 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 15% Metal Foil 20% 06/29 AC 024 White Mastic (Off-White) 25% Pigment / Binders 100% 06/29 AC 025 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 75% Mineral Wool Fibers 95% 06/29 AC 025 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 75% Resin Binders 5% 06/29 AC 025 White Mastic (Off-White) 25% Pigment / Binders 100% 06/29 AC Analyst

21 Client : Project : Project # : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX PLM Detail Report Moody Labs NVLAP Lab Code Valley View Lane Supplement to PLM Summary Report TDSHS License No Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) % Of Sample Number Layer Components Sample Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 % of Layer Analysis Date Page 4 of Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 75% Mineral Wool Fibers 95% 06/29 AC 026 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 75% Resin Binders 5% 06/29 AC 026 White Mastic (Off-White) 25% Pigment / Binders 100% 06/29 AC 027 Window Glazing (Grey) 100% Calcite 60% 06/29 AC 027 Window Glazing (Grey) 100% Binders / Fillers 40% 06/29 AC 028 Window Glazing (Light Grey) 100% Chrysotile 2% 06/29 AC 028 Window Glazing (Light Grey) 100% Calcite 98% 06/29 AC 028 Window Glazing (Light Grey) 100% Binders / Fillers 40% 06/29 AC 029 Window Glazing (Light Grey) 100% Chrysotile 2% 06/29 AC 029 Window Glazing (Light Grey) 100% Calcite 98% 06/29 AC 029 Window Glazing (Light Grey) 100% Binders / Fillers 40% 06/29 AC 030 Tape (White) 100% Cotton Fibers 90% 06/29 AC 030 Tape (White) 100% Binders / Fillers 10% 06/29 AC 031 Tape (White) 100% Cotton Fibers 90% 06/29 AC 031 Tape (White) 100% Binders / Fillers 10% 06/29 AC 032 Tape (White) 100% Cotton Fibers 90% 06/29 AC 032 Tape (White) 100% Binders / Fillers 10% 06/29 AC 033 Floor Tile (Gray) 98% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 033 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 034 Floor Tile (Gray) 98% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 034 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 035 Floor Tile (Gray) 98% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 035 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 036 Paint / Texture (Off-White) 100% Calcite 25% 06/29 AC 036 Paint / Texture (Off-White) 100% Pigment / Binders 75% 06/29 AC 037 Paint / Texture (Off-White) 100% Calcite 25% 06/29 AC 037 Paint / Texture (Off-White) 100% Pigment / Binders 75% 06/29 AC 038 Paint / Texture (Off-White) 100% Calcite 25% 06/29 AC 038 Paint / Texture (Off-White) 100% Pigment / Binders 75% 06/29 AC Analyst

22 Client : Project : Project # : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX PLM Detail Report Moody Labs NVLAP Lab Code Valley View Lane Supplement to PLM Summary Report TDSHS License No Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) % Of Sample Number Layer Components Sample Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 % of Layer Analysis Date Page 5 of Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Cellulose Fibers 2% 06/29 AC 039 Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 98% 06/29 AC 039 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 039 Leveling Compound (Off-White) 5% Calcite / Binders 100% 06/29 AC 040 Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Cellulose Fibers 2% 06/29 AC 040 Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 98% 06/29 AC 040 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 040 Leveling Compound (Off-White) 5% Calcite / Binders 100% 06/29 AC 041 Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Cellulose Fibers 2% 06/29 AC 041 Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 98% 06/29 AC 041 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 041 Leveling Compound (Off-White) 5% Calcite / Binders 100% 06/29 AC 042 Floor Tile (Beige) 100% Cellulose Fibers 2% 06/29 AC 042 Floor Tile (Beige) 100% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 98% 06/29 AC 042 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) <1% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 043 Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Cellulose Fibers 2% 06/29 AC 043 Floor Tile (Beige) 93% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 98% 06/29 AC 043 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 043 Leveling Compound (Off-White) 5% Calcite / Binders 100% 06/29 AC 044 Black Floor Tile (Black) 48% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 044 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 044 White Floor Tile (White) 48% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 044 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 045 Black Floor Tile (Black) 48% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 045 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 045 White Floor Tile (White) 48% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 045 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC Analyst

23 Client : Project : Project # : Industrial Hygiene & Safety Technology Readiness Center, Hondo Pass, El Paso, TX PLM Detail Report Moody Labs NVLAP Lab Code Valley View Lane Supplement to PLM Summary Report TDSHS License No Farmers Branch, TX Phone: (972) % Of Sample Number Layer Components Sample Lab Job No. : 16B Report Date : 06/29/2016 % of Layer Analysis Date Page 6 of Black Floor Tile (Black) 48% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 046 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 046 White Floor Tile (White) 48% Calcite / Vinyl Binders 100% 06/29 AC 046 Yellow Mastic (Yellow) 2% Glue Binders 100% 06/29 AC 047 Caulking (Grey) 100% Binders / Fillers 100% 06/29 AC 048 Caulking (Grey) 100% Binders / Fillers 100% 06/29 AC 049 Caulking (Grey) 100% Binders / Fillers 100% 06/29 AC 050 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 85% Mineral Wool Fibers 95% 06/29 AC 050 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 85% Resin Binders 5% 06/29 AC 050 Beige Mastic (Beige) 15% Calcite 50% 06/29 AC 050 Beige Mastic (Beige) 15% Binders / Fillers 50% 06/29 AC 051 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 85% Mineral Wool Fibers 95% 06/29 AC 051 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 85% Resin Binders 5% 06/29 AC 051 Beige Mastic (Beige) 15% Calcite 50% 06/29 AC 051 Beige Mastic (Beige) 15% Binders / Fillers 50% 06/29 AC 052 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 85% Mineral Wool Fibers 95% 06/29 AC 052 Thermal Insulation (Yellow) 85% Resin Binders 5% 06/29 AC 052 Beige Mastic (Beige) 15% Calcite 50% 06/29 AC 052 Beige Mastic (Beige) 15% Binders / Fillers 50% 06/29 AC Analyst

24

25

26

27

28 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Appendix: Appendix C: Bulk Summary Report Asbestos Survey Appendix Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass

29 Table 1. Summary of Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Freese and Nichols, Inc. Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Survey Date(s): 6/22/2016 through 6/22/2016 Sample ID# Sample Description Material Location Percent & Type of Asbestos Detected (a) Estimated Quantity Type of ACM (b) Friability (c) Physical Condition Potential for Disturbance Response Rating 001 Sheetrock & Joint Compound (homogeneous area # 01) Classroom, Administration, Office E-16 NAD - Dyrwall Material NAD - Joint Compound 870 s.f. Surfacing NF II Good Low Sheetrock & Joint Compound (homogeneous area # 01) Classroom, Administration, Office E-16 NAD - Dyrwall Material NAD - Joint Compound see 001 Surfacing NF II Good Low Sheetrock & Joint Compound (homogeneous area # 01) Classroom, Administration, Office E-16 NAD - Dyrwall Material NAD - Joint Compound see 001 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on Plaster & Ceiling (homogeneous area # 02) Men's Shower/Restroom, Women's Restroom, Kitchen Area, Food Storage NAD - Plaster NAD - Paint/Texture 1887 s.f. Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on Plaster & Ceiling (homogeneous area # 02) Men's Shower/Restroom, Women's Restroom, Kitchen Area, Food Storage NAD - Plaster NAD - Paint/Texture see 004 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on Plaster & Ceiling (homogeneous area # 02) Men's Shower/Restroom, Women's Restroom, Kitchen Area, Food Storage NAD - Plaster NAD - Paint/Texture see 004 Surfacing NF II Good Low 0 Asbestos Survey - IHST Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Summary Page 1 of 7

30 Sample ID# Sample Description Material Location Percent & Type of Asbestos Detected (a) Estimated Quantity Type of ACM (b) Friability (c) Physical Condition Potential for Disturbance Response Rating 007 Texture on Plaster & Ceiling (homogeneous area # 02) Men's Shower/Restroom, Women's Restroom, Kitchen Area, Food Storage NAD - Plaster NAD - Paint see 004 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on Plaster & Ceiling (homogeneous area # 02) Men's Shower/Restroom, Women's Restroom, Kitchen Area, Food Storage NAD - Plaster NAD - Paint see 004 Surfacing NF II Good Low x 4 Ceiling Tile (homogeneous area # 03) Throughout Except Storage, Vault & Assembly Hall NAD - Acoustic Tile s.f. Misc F Good Low x 4 Ceiling Tile (homogeneous area # 03) Throughout Except Storage, Vault & Assembly Hall NAD - Acoustic Tile see 009 Misc F Good Low x 4 Ceiling Tile (homogeneous area # 03) Throughout Except Storage, Vault & Assembly Hall NAD - Acoustic Tile see 009 Misc F Good Low x 4 Ceiling Tile (homogeneous area # 03) Throughout Except Storage, Vault & Assembly Hall NAD - Acoustic Tile see 009 Misc F Good Low x 4 Ceiling Tile (homogeneous area # 03) Throughout Except Storage, Vault & Assembly Hall NAD - Acoustic Tile see 009 Misc F Good Low Texture on CMU Block (homogeneous area # 04) Throughout Except Vaults NAD - CMU NAD - Paint/Texture s.f. Surfacing NF II Good Low 1 Asbestos Survey - IHST Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Summary Page 2 of 7

31 Sample ID# Sample Description Material Location Percent & Type of Asbestos Detected (a) Estimated Quantity Type of ACM (b) Friability (c) Physical Condition Potential for Disturbance Response Rating 015 Texture on CMU Block (homogeneous area # 04) Throughout Except Vaults NAD - CMU NAD - Paint/Texture see 014 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on CMU Block (homogeneous area # 04) Throughout Except Vaults NAD - CMU 2% CH - Paint/Texture see 014 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on CMU Block (homogeneous area # 04) Throughout Except Vaults NAD - CMU 2% CH - Paint/Texture see 014 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on CMU Block (homogeneous area # 04) Throughout Except Vaults NAD - CMU 2% CH - Paint/Texture see 014 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on CMU Block (homogeneous area # 04) Throughout Except Vaults NAD - CMU 2% CH - Paint/Texture see 014 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on CMU Block (homogeneous area # 04) Throughout Except Vaults NAD - Mortar NAD - Texture see 014 Surfacing NF II Good Low Cove Base & Mastic (homogeneous area # 05) Office 29, Office E-30, Battery Room NAD - Cove Base NAD - Tan Mastic 1344 s.f. Misc NF II Good Low Cove Base & Mastic (homogeneous area # 05) Office 29, Office E-30, Battery Room NAD - Cove Base NAD - Tan Mastic see 021 Misc NF II Good Low 0 Asbestos Survey - IHST Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Summary Page 3 of 7

32 Sample ID# Sample Description Material Location Percent & Type of Asbestos Detected (a) Estimated Quantity Type of ACM (b) Friability (c) Physical Condition Potential for Disturbance Response Rating 023 Cove Base & Mastic (homogeneous area # 05) Office 29, Office E-30, Battery Room NAD - Cove Base NAD - Tan Mastic see 021 Misc NF II Good Low White Mastic on Fittings (homogeneous area # 06) Mechanical Room 20, Maintenance/Storage Room 38 NAD - Thermal Insulation NAD - Paper/Foil Wrap NAD - White Mastic 12 fittings TSI NF II Good Low White Mastic on Fittings (homogeneous area # 06) Mechanical Room 20, Maintenance/Storage Room 38 NAD - Thermal Insulation NAD - White Mastic see 024 TSI NF II Good Low White Mastic on Fittings (homogeneous area # 06) Mechanical Room 20, Maintenance/Storage Room 38 NAD - Thermal Insulation NAD - White Mastic see 024 TSI NF II Good Low Window Glazing (homogeneous area # 07) Windows NAD - Window Glazing 856 l.f. Misc NF II Good Low Window Glazing (homogeneous area # 07) Windows 2% CH - Window Glazing see 027 Misc NF II Good Low Window Glazing (homogeneous area # 07) Windows 2% CH - Window Glazing see 027 Misc NF II Good Low Tape on HVAC (homogeneous area # 08) Battery Room 17, Mechanical Room 20 NAD - Tape 436 l.f. Misc NF II Good Low 0 Asbestos Survey - IHST Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Summary Page 4 of 7

33 Sample ID# Sample Description Material Location Percent & Type of Asbestos Detected (a) Estimated Quantity Type of ACM (b) Friability (c) Physical Condition Potential for Disturbance Response Rating 031 Tape on HVAC (homogeneous area # 08) Battery Room 17, Mechanical Room 20 NAD - Tape see 030 Misc NF II Good Low Tape on HVAC (homogeneous area # 08) Battery Room 17, Mechanical Room 20 NAD - Tape see 030 Misc NF II Good Low Gray 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 09) Men's Restroom E-42 NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic 42 s.f. Misc NF I Good Low Gray 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 09) Men's Restroom E-42 NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic see 033 Misc NF I Good Low Gray 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 09) Men's Restroom E-42 NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic see 033 Misc NF I Good Low Texture on Exterior Over Hang (homogeneous area # 10) Building Exits NAD - Paint/Texture 175 s.f. Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on Exterior Over Hang (homogeneous area # 10) Building Exits NAD - Paint/Texture see 036 Surfacing NF II Good Low Texture on Exterior Over Hang (homogeneous area # 10) Building Exits NAD - Paint/Texture see 036 Surfacing NF II Good Low 0 Asbestos Survey - IHST Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Summary Page 5 of 7

34 Sample ID# Sample Description Material Location Percent & Type of Asbestos Detected (a) Estimated Quantity Type of ACM (b) Friability (c) Physical Condition Potential for Disturbance Response Rating 039 Beige 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 11) See Drawing NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic NAD - Leveling Compound s.f. Misc NF I Good Low Beige 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 11) See Drawing NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic NAD - Leveling Compound see 039 Misc NF I Good Low Beige 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 11) See Drawing NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic NAD - Leveling Compound see 039 Misc NF I Good Low Beige 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 11) See Drawing NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic see 039 Misc NF I Good Low Beige 12 x 12 Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 11) See Drawing NAD - Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic NAD - Leveling Compound see 039 Misc NF I Good Low x 12 Black & White Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 12) Office E-33 NAD - Black Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic NAD - White Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic 189 s.f. Misc NF I Good Low x 12 Black & White Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 12) Office E-33 NAD - Black Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic NAD - White Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic see 044 Misc NF I Good Low x 12 Black & White Floor Tile with Yellow Mastic (homogeneous area # 12) Office E-33 NAD - Black Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic NAD - White Floor Tile NAD - Yellow Mastic see 044. Misc NF I Good Low 0 Asbestos Survey - IHST Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Summary Page 6 of 7

35 Sample ID# Sample Description Material Location Percent & Type of Asbestos Detected (a) Estimated Quantity Type of ACM (b) Friability (c) Physical Condition Potential for Disturbance Response Rating 047 Exterior Window Caulk (homogeneous area # 13) See Drawing NAD - Caulking 288 l.f. Misc NF II Good Low Exterior Window Caulk (homogeneous area # 13) See Drawing NAD - Caulking see 047 Misc NF II Good Low Exterior Window Caulk (homogeneous area # 13) See Drawing NAD - Caulking see 047 Misc NF II Good Low Beige Mastic on Pipe Insulation (homogeneous area # 14) Above Shower E-43 Ceiling NAD - Thermal Insulation NAD - Beige Mastic 23 l.f. TSI NF II Good Low Beige Mastic on Pipe Insulation (homogeneous area # 14) Above Shower E-43 Ceiling NAD - Thermal Insulation NAD - Beige Mastic see 047 TSI NF II Good Low Beige Mastic on Pipe Insulation (homogeneous area # 14) Above Shower E-43 Ceiling NAD - Thermal Insulation NAD - Beige Mastic see 047 TSI NF II Good Low 0 Table Key: (a) CH = Chrysotile; AM = Amosite; CR = Crocidolite; AN = Anthophyllite; AC = Actinolite; NAD = NAD = No Asbestos Detected (b) Misc = Miscellaneous; TSI = Thermal Systems Insulation (c) F = Friable; NF I = Non-Friable Category I; NF II = Non-Friable Category II Asbestos Survey - IHST Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Bulk Sample Analysis and Assessment Summary Page 7 of 7

36 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Appendix: Appendix D: Cost Estimate for Abatement Asbestos Survey Appendix Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass

37 Table 2. Approximate Cost to Remove Asbestos Freese and Nichols, Inc. Readiness Center - Hondo Pass Survey Date(s): 6/22/2016 through 6/22/2016 Material Description Location(s) Approx. Quantity Unit Cost # Days to Abate Removal Cost Air Monitoring (per day) Line Item Subtotal Texture on CMU Block Walls Throughout Structure s.f. $ $230, $ $272, Window Caulk Exterior Windows 856 l.f. $ $4, $ $6, Removal Costs Subtotal: $279, Abatement Specifications: $1, Total Abatement Cost: $280, The price estimates were derived from current estimates from asbestos abatement contractors. 2. Price does not include replacement costs with non-asbestos materials. 3. Air monitoring costs do not include final air clearance by Transmission Electron Microscopy. 4. Price estimates listed above are intended as a guide for budget estimating only. To determine the total abatement costs for the project, asbestos removal specifications should be prepared and the project bid by professional asbestos abatement contractors. 5. Prices could be reduced if all abatement activities are performed at one time. 6. Prices may be slightly higher for small abatement projects due to mobilization costs. 7. Prices do not include the Texas Department of State Health Services (DSHS) fee for asbestos regulated units generated for the removal of ACM quantified in Table Time schedule includes air clearance monitoring and contractor demobilization from site. Time schedule for abatement will also vary depending on the size of the contractor's work force and the specified scope of work. Approximate Cost to Remove Asbestos Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass El Paso, TX79924 Page 1 of 1

38 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Appendix: Appendix E: Photographs Asbestos Survey Appendix Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass

39 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Photo of Structure Samples

40 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Samples Samples

41 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Samples Samples

42 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Samples Samples

43 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Samples Samples

44 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Samples Samples

45 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Samples Samples

46 Hondo Pass Readiness Center El Paso, Texas Samples

47 Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. IHST Project Number: Appendix: Appendix F: Lead Base Paint Report Asbestos Survey Appendix Freese and Nichols, Inc. - Readiness Center - Hondo Pass

48 INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE AND SAFETY TECHNOLOGY, INC. August 1, 2016 Mr. Vimal Nair Freese and Nichols, Inc International Plaza, Suite 200 Fort Worth, Texas RE: Lead Base Paint Building Materials Survey Location: Hondo Pass Readiness Center,, El Paso, Texas Sample Date: June 22, 2016 IHST Job #: Dear Mr. Nair, Mr. Doug Easley representing Industrial Hygiene and Safety Technology, Inc. performed a visual inspection and collected bulk samples of suspect lead based paint at address listed above. Seven (7) suspect lead based painted materials were identified during the visual inspection of the structure. Table 1 list the materials sampled and the results of the lead based paint analysis. Fiberquant Analytical Services was contracted to perform the laboratory analysis. A copy of the original laboratory report is included as Appendix A to this report. The samples were analyzed utilizing EPA 7420 method for lead analysis. Table 1, Results of Lead Based Paint Testing Sample ID Material Tested Location Results L Beige Paint Interior CMU Block Walls <40 ppm L Blue Paint Interior CMU Block Walls 15 ppm L Red Paint Exterior Entrance to Facility 950 ppm L Light Brown Paint Interior CMU Block Walls <13 ppm L Brown Paint Doors and Trim 47 ppm L Off White Paint Interior CMU Block Walls <27 ppm L Green Paint Interior CMU Block Walls 310 ppm In reviewing the results of the lead based paint sampling, all of the samples are less than the HUD guidelines of 5,000 ppm. Lead base paint is not a hazard in the facility Should you or your staff have any questions regarding the content of this report, please do not hesitate to contact our office at your convenience. Cordially, Tracy Bramlett, CIH, CSP President Appendix A Laboratory Report 2235 Keller Way Carrollton, Texas (972) FAX (972)

49 Appendix A Laboratory Report

50 Atomic Absorption Spectrometer (AAS) Analysis of Paint JobNumber: Client: IHST 2235 KELLER WY CARROLLTON, TX Office Phone: (972) FAX: (972) # Samples: 7 AA Client Job: Building Readiness Center PO Number: Method and Analysis Information: Rec: 6/28/2016 Report Date: 6/29/2016 Date Analyzed: 6/29/2016 Method: Modified SW b/7420 AApw Pb in paint by weight AA Analysis Routing Number: - The received samples were analyzed for Pb (total) using "Test Methods for Evaluating Solid Waste" (SW 846, December 1996 updates). The extraction/digestion method was SW 3050b. The analytical method is "flame atomic absorption, direct aspiration", SW Briefly the procedures are as follows. The incoming paint samples are first homogenized by mixing and crushing. A sub-sample is weighed to gm into a 50ml centrifuge tube. To the run stream are added the quality assurance samples described below. Six mls of concentrated HNO3 and one ml of 30% H2O2 are added to each container. The tubes are caped and heated for 1 hour at 95 deg. C. After cooling, the contents of the centrifuge tube are brought up to exactly 25 mls, completing the digestion/extraction. The sample and quality assurance extractions are then analyzed on a TJA M5 flame atomic absorption spectrometer. The wavelengths and other instrumental settings are set according to the manufacturer's recommendations, or as otherwise specified in the published method. Absorptions are recorded from sample and standard solutions. A calibration curve is fitted to at least three standard solutions, and the concentrations of the sample extracts are calculated from the curve. The ppm (ug/gm) and weight percent for each sample is calculated from the sub-sample weight, extract volume, and extract concentration. The results from this analysis is generally compared to either the HUD guidelines, in which a sample is positive if it contains >0.5% (5000 ppm) Pb, or the Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) limit, in which a paint or surface coating containing greater than 90 ppm is defined as leadcontaining. The expected coefficient of variation for this method is approximately 20-30%. The results are reported to two significant figures. The Sample Reporting Limit (RL) listed below is twice the Sample Detection Limit, which is calculated for each sample from the experimentally determined Method Detection Limit. The limit of reliable quantitatiion is generally regarded as five to ten times the limit of detection. Therefore, samples smaller than 0.1 gm may give results too near the CPSC standard to be reliable. Problems in analysis or other information is provided in the "Analytical Notes" below. Blanks, if analyzed, are treated the same as samples and are not used for correcting non-blank results. The following on-going quality assurance program was followed to ensure reproducible and dependable results: All analysts are degreed chemists trained extensively in-house for at least six months prior to un-supervised runs. Blank matrix samples are analyzed at a rate of 5% (at least one per run). Reference standards are analyzed at a rate of 5% (at least one per run), and compared to statistical records via control charts. Spiked matrix samples are analyzed at a rate of 5% (at least one per run), and compared to statistical records via control charts. Duplicate samples are analyzed at a rate of 5% (at least one per run), and compared to statistical records via control charts. For each instrumental run, the spectrometer is checked for sensitivity and stability. The calibration standards are made fresh weekly, and checked each run against a calibration verification standard from another source. All calculations are performed twice - once in a calibration spreadsheet, and once during the report generation, and also checked by hand. All quality checks performed for these samples were in control except as detailed in the "Analytical Notes" below. Fiberquant participates in the Environmental Lead Proficiency Analytical Testing (ELPAT) program, is accredited by AIHA-LAP, LLC for environmental lead in paint (Lab # ), and is recognized by the National Lead Laboratory Accreditation Program (NLLAP) for the analysis of Pb in paint. Accreditation does not imply endorsement by the EPA, any other United States governmental agency or any private agency or association. Each lab analysis refers only to the sample tested, and may not, due to the sampling process, be representative of the material sampled. This report may not be reproduced except in full, without the approval of Fiberquant Analytical Services. Job Analysis Notes: Fiberquant Internal SOP: Some results may have been calculated using client supplied data, such as volume or area sampled, for which Fiberquant assumes no liability for accuracy. Page 1 of S. 33rd Street Phoenix, Arizona Phone: FAX: Fiberquant, Inc.

51 Calibration Curve: Pb Run # Instrument: M5-2 Standards: /28/2016 ppm avg. mabs ax bx c R ppm AA Calibration Curve abs Analysis Results: Job Number: AApw Lab Number Client Number Date Condition Weight (gm) ug/ml ml Dil Analyte wt % ppm RL(ppm) L 6/22/2016 acceptable Pb <0.004 < L 6/22/2016 acceptable Pb L 6/22/2016 acceptable Pb L 6/22/2016 acceptable Pb < < L 6/22/2016 acceptable Pb L 6/22/2016 acceptable Pb < < L 6/22/2016 acceptable Pb Analyst: MARTIN A. ESQUER Printed: 29-Jun-16 Original Print Date: 29-Jun-16 Larry S. Pierce, Approved Accreditation Signatory Page 2 of S. 33rd Street Phoenix, Arizona Phone: FAX: Fiberquant, Inc.

52