PRELIMINARY RESULT: Simultaneous CICL Profiling and Data Matching in Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao

Transcription

1 PRELIMINARY RESULT: Simultaneous CICL Profiling and Data Matching in Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao April 17-19, 2013 Bayview Park Hotel, Manila Crowne Regency Hotel, Cebu Garden Orchid Hotel, Zamboanga

2 Summary of LGUs who submi7ed data on CICL cases handled Number of LGUs with CICL Data Submi7ed to DSWD/ and JJWC MunicipaliVes 137 out of 1491 municipalives (9.18 %) CiVes Regions 42 out of 143 cives (29.37%) 14 Regions (2 out of the 14 have no LGU breakdown) Number of LGUs that will have to submit their CICL Data to DSWD and JJWC 1354 more municipalives 102 more cives

3 Summary of LGUs who submi7ed data on CICL cases handled REGION I II III CAR IV-A NCR V CITIES/MUNICIPALITIES 3 municipalities (San Quintin, Calasiao, Sta. Maria, Pangasinan) Submitted consolidated data and no breakdown of LGUs 1 city (Angeles City) 8 municipalities (Floridablanca, Sta. Rita, Pampanga; Hermosa, Bataan; Paniqui, Tarlac; Subic, Iba, Zambales; Casiguran, Aurora) 1 city (Baguio City) 13 municipalities (Tinglayan, Pudtol, Conner, Luna, Flora, Lagawe, Aguinaldo, Kiangan, Lamut, Banaue, Asipulo, Hungduan, La Trinidad) 3 cities (Cavite City, Calamba City, Lucena City) 4 cities (Valenzuela City, Las Piñas City, Pasay City, Muntinlupa City) 2 cities (Ligao City, Sorsogon City) 14 municipalities (Viga, Panganiban, Bulan, Matnog, Sta. Magdalena, Magallanes, Pioduran, Polangui, Sto. Domingo, Daraga, Sagnay, Minalabac, Jose Panganiban)

4 Summary of LGUs who submi7ed data on CICL cases handled REGION VI CITIES/MUNICIPALITIES 14 cives (Iloilo City, Passi City, Bacolod City, Victorias City, Cadiz City, Roxas City, Himamaylan City, Kabankalan City, Sipalay City, Silay City, Sagay City, San Carlos City, La Carlota City) 52 municipalives (Madalag, Numancia, Buruangan, Balete, Makato, San Jose, Sibalom, Belison, Patnongon, Bugasong, Lauaan, Culasi, Fornier, Valderama, San Remigio, Jordan, Buena Vista, Sibunag, San Lorenzo, Nueva Valencia, Nur Carles, San Enrique, Dumangas, Pototan, Janiuay, Leon, Sara, Cabatuan, Guimbal, Miag- ao, Tubungan, Estancia, Ajuy, Barotac Nueva, Dingle, Tigbauan, Candoni, Pulupandan, Pontevedra, Binalbagan, Murcia, Talisay, Maayon, Ivisan, Cuartero, Dumalag, Panit- an, Pan- ay, Quinagaringan, Pontevedra, Mambusao)

5 Summary of LGUs who submi7ed data on CICL cases handled REGION VII CITIES/MUNICIPALITIES 12 cives (Talisay City, Toledo City, Canlaon City, Tagbilaran City, Danao City, Mandaue City, Lapu- lapu City, Guihulngan City, Bais City, Dumaguete City, Cebu City) 32 municipalives (Baclayon, Pres. Carlos P. Garcia, CaVgbian, Alburquerque, Duero, Guindulman, Panglao, Catmon, Tabogon, Barili, Tuburan, Liloan, Sibonga, Carmen, San Francisco, Bacong, Mabinay, Ayungon, Sta. Catalina, Vallehermoso, Loon, Cortes, Inabanga, Pinamungajan, Alegria, Sambaon, Dumanug, Asturias, Dalaguete)

6 Summary of LGUs who submi7ed data on CICL cases handled REGION IX X XI CITIES/MUNICIPALITIES 1 city (Dipolog City) 1 municipality (Sindangan) 2 municipalities (Sinacaban, Jimenez) 1 city (Davao City) 2 municipalities (Padada, Bansalan) XII CARAGA 3 cities (General Santos City, Koronadal City, Tacurong City) 10 municipalities (Polomolok, Tampakan, Kiamba, Malungon, Malapatan, Maitum, Glan, Bagumbayan, Pres. Quirino, Kalamansig) Submitted consolidated data and no breakdown per LGUs (Cities/Municipalities)

7 LGUs with the most number of CICL cases recorded / documented LUZON 1) Calamba City : 327 cases (CY ) 2) MunVnlupa City : 176 cases (CY 2012) 3) Valenzuela City : 93 cases (CY 2012) 4) Las Piñas City: 70 cases (CY 2012) 5) Cavite City: 30 cases (CY 2012)

8 LGUs with the most number of CICL cases recorded / VISAYAS documented 1. Iloilo City : 402 cases (CY 2012) 2. Cebu : 337 cases (CY 2012) 3. Negros Occidental: 304 cases (CY 2012) 4. Negros Oriental : 184 cases (CY 2012)

9 LGUs with the most number of CICL cases recorded / documented MINDANAO 1. Gen. Santos City, South Cotabato: 964 cases (CY 2008 to 2012) 2. Polomolok, Saranggani: 302 cases (CY 2002 to 2012) 3. Sindangan, Zamboanga del Norte: 264 cases (CY 2002 to 2012) 4. Dapitan City, Zamboanga del Norte: 165 cases (CY 2006 to 2012) 5. Tampakan, South Cotabato: 158 cases (CY 2007 to 2012)

10 TOP 5 OFFENSES/CRIMES ALLEGEDLY COMMITTED BY CHILDREN LUZON (696 cases) VISAYAS (1227 cases) 1) TheR 37.64% 2) Serious Physical Injuries 5.03% 3) Vagrancy 3.88% 4) Misbehavior/ Stowaway/ Disobedience to Parents 3.45% 5) Sexual Abuse 2.73% 1) TheR 48.82% 2) Physical Injuries 11.41% 3) Robbery 5.54% 4) Alarm and Scandal 3.50% 5) Malicious Mischief 2.36% MINDANAO (2508 cases) 1) TheR 52.79% 2) ViolaVon of PD 1619 / Sniffing of Rugby 5.26% 3) Physical Injuries 5.06% 4) Street child 3.39% 5) ViolaVon of RA %

11 HEINOUS CRIMES ALLEGEDLY COMMITTED BY CHILDREN LUZON VISAYAS MINDANAO 1) Rape 1.15% 2) Robbery 0.57% 3) ViolaVon of RA % 4) Carnapping ; Murder; Carnapping 0.29% 1) Robbery 1.39% 2) Rape 0.90% 3) ViolaVon of RA % 4) Homicide 0.33% 5) Murder 0.16% 1) Robbery 3.87% 2) ViolaVon of RA % 3) Rape 1.95% 4) Murder 1.16% 5) Carnapping 0.68%

12 PROFILE OF CICL LUZON GENDER Male: 81.61% Female: 10.78% Unknown: 7.61% AGE 15 and below: 22.70% Above 15yo: 69.68% No data: 7.61%

13 PROFILE OF CICL LUZON EducaVonal Akainment: Elementary: 32.47% High School: 27.30% Have not akended school: 1.15% No data: 39.08%

14 PROFILE OF CICL VISAYAS GENDER Male: 47.51% Female: 37.49% Unknown: 15% AGE 15 and below: 46.94% Above 15yo: 38.06% No data: 15%

15 PROFILE OF CICL VISAYAS EducaVonal Akainment: Elementary: 6.68% High School: 24.78% No data: %

16 PROFILE OF CICL MINDANAO GENDER Male: 87.32% Female: 12.12% Unknown: 0.56% AGE 15 and below: 36.60% Above 15yo: 17.03% No data: 46.37%

17 PROFILE OF CICL MINDANAO EducaVonal Akainment: Kinder: 0.04% Elementary: 18.42% High School: 10.53% College: 0.36% No data: 70.65%

18 STATUS OF CASES LUZON 1) No data: 46.12% 2) Undergoing Diversion/ IntervenVon Program: 20.26% 3) Referred to Prosecutor for Inquest: 16.09% 4) Released to Parents: 13.22% 5) Referred to LSWDO: 4.31%

19 STATUS OF CASES VISAYAS 1) No data on status: 42.46% 2) Referred to Youth Homes: 25.12% 3) Undergoing IntervenVon Program : 12.64% 4) Released to Parents: 11.17%

20 STATUS OF CASES MINDANAO 1) No data on status: 43.42% 2) Released to Parents: 43.3% 3) Undergoing Diversion Program: 6.34% 4) Undergoing IntervenVon Program : 3.51% 5) Referred to Youth Homes: 0.96% 6) Placed in RRCYs: 0.68% 7) ROR: 0.48%

21 Challenges Encountered During the CICL Profiling and Data Matching Workshop No data on very basic and crivcal informavon such as age of the child at the Vme of the commission of the offense and the actual offense/crime commiked. Children are not properly idenvfied and recorded (idenvficavon as to whether the child is a child at risk or a child in conflict with the law) Lack of relevant data or informavon about a child; Lack of documentavon of cases handled and of services rendered

22 Challenges Encountered During the CICL Profiling and Data Matching Workshop LSWDO and LEO were able to match a very small number of cases from their respecvve records No standard forms and tools for regular inventory of cases, for data matching (law enforcers, BCPC, LSWDO) and for tracking of status of cases managed. No endorsed records or data from former case managers; no back- up (unavailable data)

23 RecommendaVons for Data Management, Sharing and Referral System A standard policy for data collecvon, transfer, management and security should be implemented Technical assistance through capability- building and orientavon acvvives should be regularly conducted for the LGU implementers (guidelines, protocols, data collecvon and management) A separate record for children at- risk (CAR) and children in conflict with the law (CICL) should be established and maintained by duty bearers

24 RecommendaVons for Data Management, Sharing and Referral System LGUs should invest in their local informavon system that will capture and help them manage and analyze the data from the barangay up to the provincial level System of referral and feedback should be standardized and integrated in the informavon management system which will be designed JJWC data collecvon and informavon system should be automated and user- friendly